Thread for Marc39: Jordanians and Torture

Argument by Google doesn't work. For a start many of the sites returned are sites you don't consider to be reliable sources. Then consider that the phrase "Everyone agrees there's no torture in Jordan" would be retured in your search. Finally I searched for "Torture in Narnia", it returned 275,000 results, perhaps HRW could start work there too ;)

A visit to Jordan, then, would be another, even better, option. Or, try talking with a Jordanian, or, with someone from the Middle East region. I agree that the Internet has limitations.
 
A visit to Jordan, then, would be another, even better, option. Or, try talking with a Jordanian, or, with someone from the Middle East region. I agree that the Internet has limitations.

Maybe you could enlighten us by describing your time there, clearly it left a deep impression. Were you primarily in the cities or were you able to go "back country". Were you able to shake off your tourist "minders" and talk to dissidents ?
 
Pot meet kettle.

Tell us, Marc, have you come up with a source for the "torture" argument yet? Still trying to deny that the article in Salon written by HRW's director isn't an HRW article?Evidence that waterboarding isn't torture?

Didn't think so....
 
Your posts inspire confidence? A Google search of torture in Jordan generates nearly 3,000,000 articles.

Argument by Google count? Heh.

Torture in Jordan...About 3 million results, as you say.
Torture in North Korea...3.4 million.
Torture in Israel....9 million.
Torture in the United States...21 million
 
To put this in perspective, "are leprechauns real?" generates over a million.
 
Argument by Google count? Heh.

Torture in Jordan...About 3 million results, as you say.
Torture in North Korea...3.4 million.
Torture in Israel....9 million.
Torture in the United States...21 million

Israel banned torture in 2000.
 
Well, Marc, they had good reason to:

http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/world/middle_east/637293.stm

Hey, but they stopped it......didn't they?

http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/world/middle_east/7345025.stm

Well, well, well. Tell me, have you actually considered reading what you write, or perhaps carrying out some research?

Sherlock, as I said, torture was banned in Israel 9 years ago. People will still violate the law. Murder is a criminal offense in the US, but, people still commit murder.
 
So, you have nothing to add, at least not of a substantive nature, to the discussion of torture in Jordan, I see.

You were the one suggesting that I visit Jordan or talk to my friend about torture in Jordan. I was attempting to establish whether YOU had attempted to do any research in person (by visiting Jordan) or talking to any Jordanians.

I presume from your lack of a direct answer that you have not done either.
 
Firstly, let's look at what expert sources say about waterboarding:
.. snip ..

Great bit of critical thinking there, Marc. Absolutely fantastic.
It does not take critical thinking to understand that being waterboarded sucks.

You're not liable to be waterboarded if you come across the pond. Thus, I wonder at your obsession with this thing. Why is it so important to you? What does it symbolize to you, and why is that important?

What is still somewhat muddy to me is whether or not General Hayden was being completely candid about how many and whom were so boarded. If it was them three, for the reasons cited at the time, I lose no sleep. In time, the policy was rescinded for the variety of reasons discussed into the dirt here, and elsewhere. About 2004 or 2005, not sure who to believe on that one.

If, however, the fact of the matter is that it was a habitual practice, sort of a standard "Check into Gitmo, and if you won't cooperate, off to the aqueous room with you" then something most rotten in the state of Denmark was up, and IMO it's a darker matter.

That KSM is still drawing breath pisses me off. His alleged intelligence value is nil.

He's now using up perfectly good people's air. No reason he should continue to do so.

As to thepenchant for torture in a despotic regime, in this case Jordan, perhaps only semi despotic, how is this news to you?

DR
 
Last edited:
I

That KSM is still drawing breath pisses me off. His alleged intelligence value is nil.

He's now using up perfectly good people's air. No reason he should continue to do so.


DR

There' a whole batch of neocons and their supporters like Bush, Blair, Rice and Cheney, etc who are also using up valuable air. All these have killed a huge magnitude of more people than KSM. There's no need for torture to make a case for it either.

However I don't believe in that kind of capital punishment. I believe in incarcerating them for life
 
There' a whole batch of neocons and their supporters like Bush, Blair, Rice and Cheney, etc who are also using up valuable air.

All these have killed a huge magnitude of more people than KSM. There's no need for torture to make a case for it either.

However I don't believe in that kind of capital punishment. I believe in incarcerating them for life
You are welcomed to proceed with your plan.

What is your first step?

DR
 
There' a whole batch of neocons and their supporters like Bush, Blair, Rice and Cheney, etc who are also using up valuable air. All these have killed a huge magnitude of more people than KSM. There's no need for torture to make a case for it either.

However I don't believe in that kind of capital punishment. I believe in incarcerating them for life

Don't you mean crypto-neocons? :D
 
Thus, I wonder at your obsession with this thing. Why is it so important to you? What does it symbolize to you, and why is that important?

I think you're missing the point of the thread. Marcus made a number of unsubstantiated claims including, inter alia, that waterboarding wasn't all that bad a thing. He's the one that's been asked to support his claim.

Of course, he's done no such thing.
 
Last edited:
I think you're missing the point of the thread. Marcus made a number of unsubstantiated claims including, inter alia, that waterboarding wasn't all that bad a thing. He's the one that's been asked to support his claim.

Of course, he's done no such thing.
1. Marc makes a lot of crap arguments, I've busted his chops over that in the threads where he makes them. Why this needs another thread is due to ... what, mods asking you to split or not bicker?

2. Common knowledge, or conventional wisdom, and the support for it? I understand where you are playing pedantic skeptic, as a role, but don't get why this is of any value. The observation Marc makes is hardly an extraordinary claim, and as noted by a number of posters in this thread, extraordinary evidence is hardly needed, nor is more mundane "evidence" or supporting links (more accurate descriptive) in short supply.

So, again, not sure why you see this thread, nor this attempt to make a major deal

In The Politics Forum where Skepticism and Critical Thinking go to die (IIRC, either Cleon or RandFan was the first to use that construction, may have been someone else)

as being of any value. If you intent is to take the piss out of Marc, or bust his chops, or poke him in the eye, OK, fine. No E being put into JREF here.

As a member of the audience, you score no points. Marc makes a lot of weak and lame arguments. He also scores no point.

For this we spend five pages of bandwidth?

DR
 
Last edited:
:rolleyes:

Yea, right. Got any evidence of torture from a source you trust yet? Got any proof that - contrary to expert opinion - waterboarding ain't torture?

Thought not.

You're no Mike Wallace. I have my own sources of evidence for torture. I don't need anyone to tell me torture is occurring. Nor, where. Water-boarding is unpleasant. It doesn't constitute torture. Not in my opinion. Your mileage may vary.
 
The observation Marc makes is hardly an extraordinary claim,

Well, he claimed that he was personally waterboarded and didn't find it to be particularly bothersome. I'd say that was a fairly extraordinary claim.

But as he said it was part of a hazing ritual at whatever posh school he went to, maybe you as a fellow-American (?) know more about this than I do.
 
Well, he claimed that he was personally waterboarded and didn't find it to be particularly bothersome. I'd say that was a fairly extraordinary claim.

But as he said it was part of a hazing ritual at whatever posh school he went to, maybe you as a fellow-American (?) know more about this than I do.

I am not sure if it got coveage in the UK but a local radio personality decided to be water boarderd, thinking it also not to be any big deal. He lasted 6 seconds, and although a conservative broadcaster, he freely admitted it shook him up, and it indeed was torture

For reference it was mentioned that trained servicemen could take 11 seconds before submitting
 
Irony of the Month Award. :cool:

DR

Oh dear. :rolleyes:

Actually Buddy if you can find evidence of me trolling then bring it on. I won't hold my breath.

I don't troll I speak the truth about Israel's Racist behavior. All proven by what is actually happening in the Middle East.

Shame you had to discredit yourself by resorting to such comments which are easily proven to be nonsense.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom