The vulnerability of the Truth Movement.

Here is the paragraph you question:



Please state, and back up with legitimate evidence, what part of the above paragraph is false, and why. Thanks.

TAM:)

It is simply not believable the Otis fighters did not know to go to New York City.

Profile: Otis Air National Guard Base," cooperativeresearch.org
http://www.cooperativeresearch.org/entity....onal_guard_base
"Otis Fighters Scramble to New York; Conflicting Accounts of Urgency and Destination," cooperativeresearch.org
http://www.cooperativeresearch.org/context...a852otistakeoff
 
That paragraph does not state they did not know to go to NYC. This is what you can deduce from the paragraph.

1. They lacked a target (ie. had not officially been given one)
2. As a result they were sent to an area off Long Island and to "hold as needed"
3. They were uncertain what to do, because they had not been fully informed of the situation, and had been given no other orders than to head toward Long Island.
4. From 9:09 until 9:13 they remained in the holding pattern.

Anything else you say about the paragraph is pure speculation and conjecture, which is far from evidence.

Try again.

TAM:)

Edit: Oh, and by the way, your "not believing" something does not make it untrue.

TAM
 
That paragraph does not state they did not know to go to NYC. This is what you can deduce from the paragraph.

1. They lacked a target (ie. had not officially been given one)
2. As a result they were sent to an area off Long Island and to "hold as needed"
3. They were uncertain what to do, because they had not been fully informed of the situation, and had been given no other orders than to head toward Long Island.
4. From 9:09 until 9:13 they remained in the holding pattern.

Anything else you say about the paragraph is pure speculation and conjecture, which is far from evidence.

Try again.

TAM:)

Edit: Oh, and by the way, your "not believing" something does not make it untrue.

TAM

If you read the links provided you can see the conflict in the reporting. Going supersonic speed to a holding pattern does not make sense. They flew directly to NYC because they knew flight 11 was heading in that direction. They arrived moments after 9:03 too late to shoot down the second plane. In a word, the paragraph on page 20 is a lie.
 
1. Your links are to a site with a clear "truth" agenda.
2. Your links make their points based purely on other journal articles.
3. the 9/11 Commission Report paragraph you question was created based on the NORAD/FAA/NEADS audio recordings from that day.

Now I think I know which I'm gonna believe.

TAM:)

Edit: Page 459 - Notes on Chapter 1: Note 120. FAA Audio File Boston center....

TAM
 
Last edited:
If you read the links provided you can see the conflict in the reporting. Going supersonic speed to a holding pattern does not make sense. They flew directly to NYC because they knew flight 11 was heading in that direction. They arrived moments after 9:03 too late to shoot down the second plane. In a word, the paragraph on page 20 is a lie.
(bolding mine)

That's 8 words.

You mentioned NORAD. Our own gumboot has really done some fine work in this area, please have a good long look:
http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?t=70300&highlight=norad
 
I'm sort of puzzled that the conspiracy theories get more and more bizarre as time goes on. I would think that True Believers would weed out the plain-crazy stuff for things that are ever so slightly more plausible. For example, a very loose LIHOP scenario based on the intelligence apparatus' apparent incompetence and failure to act. They might posit that United 93 was shot down.

But over 5 years later we have death rays, cartoon/holographic planes, fires that were barely hot enough to cook a turkey, and planted lightpoles at the pentagon.

It's almost as bad as if the majority of JFK conspiracy theorists asserted that Jackie was the shooter, or that JFK committed suicide by holding his mouth and nose closed while sneezing.
 
1. Your links are to a site with a clear "truth" agenda.
2. Your links make their points based purely on other journal articles.
3. the 9/11 Commission Report paragraph you question was created based on the NORAD/FAA/NEADS audio recordings from that day.

Now I think I know which I'm gonna believe.

TAM:)

Edit: Page 459 - Notes on Chapter 1: Note 120. FAA Audio File Boston center....

TAM


Newark NJ air traffic controller, Bob Varcapade, said the fighters were over New York City moments after the second plane crashed in to WTC 2.
http://www.msnbc.msn.com/id/14754701/

The paragraph on page 20 of the 9/11 Report is a lie.
 
So are you saying:

1. The commission lied about what was on the tapes
2. the commission misinterpreted what was on the tapes.
3. The tapes were fabricated.

Like I said, your not believing the paragraph does not make it untrue, so you should be saying:

"In my opinion, the paragraph is a lie." as it is only your opinion, and you have proven nothing more.

TAM
 
What?

I don't take any particular side when it comes to these topics but how do you have a monopoly on "truth and logic"?

:boggled:

The fact that you "don't take any particular side" shows why you don't understand.

Truth is not decided by poll numbers. Reason is the only way we can understand truth- and your peeps don't got it. We've got the keys, and friends don't let conspiracists drive... ever.
 
I'm sort of puzzled that the conspiracy theories get more and more bizarre as time goes on. I would think that True Believers would weed out the plain-crazy stuff for things that are ever so slightly more plausible. For example, a very loose LIHOP scenario based on the intelligence apparatus' apparent incompetence and failure to act. They might posit that United 93 was shot down.

But over 5 years later we have death rays, cartoon/holographic planes, fires that were barely hot enough to cook a turkey, and planted lightpoles at the pentagon.

It's almost as bad as if the majority of JFK conspiracy theorists asserted that Jackie was the shooter, or that JFK committed suicide by holding his mouth and nose closed while sneezing.

They have to enter the realm of the "unknowable"- the utterly bizarre, because no one will follow them there. The scientists who have been vocal against the "Truth Movement" won't waste their time on death rays from outer space- and even skeptics will just giggle and turn their backs.

Hopefully- the general public will do the same. That grey stuff in the middle that they considered an argument has been cleaned up with some simple soap and water. When the general public looks for a conspiracy, they'll be happy to find simple truth in its place or complete wackjobs of the tinfoil hat brand.
 
So on reality, The Truth Movement is extremely vulnerable and hangs on the shoulders of only a couple of people who feed the whole CT world. Without them the whole movement would shrink to a hardly noticed branch with outlandish speculations. Speculations that would not raise interest.

I say again... "truthers" are not "CT's" (conspiracy theorists). They are activists who have latched onto popularized conspiracy mythology as a catalyst for their anger, and excuse for their divisive behavior. If not for 9/11, they'd be trowing eggs at GAP storefronts or choking tear-gas fumes at world bank protests.

The "movement" is a dysfunctional leaderless mess. They aspire to Vietnam-era greatness, but there's absolutely no cultural resonance they can rely upon.

Any small glimmer of hope of exposing lies, corruption, malfeasance, or cover-ups related to 9/11 has been sabotaged by their own inability to control their ranks, moderate their language, and manage laughable theories.

If there are conspiracies related to the events of 9/11 (which I think there are), the "Truth Movement" has successfully sabotaged the investigation better than any "infiltration" or "COINTELPRO" could ever do.

There. Oh, man... am I ever in trouble now! :p
 
I think the die-hard CTists will never give up but the movement itself is flaming out.

I spoke to a "truther" a few weeks back and asked him the standard, "If you really believe all of this stuff, why are you just sitting back on your computer posting to message boards" line. His response was that the first step was "education" but "we're really not doing a very good job."

Of all my possible responses, I settled for "So much for everybody 'waking up' then, huh?"
 
The Otis fighters thing...

Some things to consider. At 0844, when NEADS decided to launch the Otis F-15s, they had not been given a position for AA11 from Boston Centre.

08:44:59
FOX: M.C.C. [Mission Crew Commander], I don’t know where I’m scrambling these guys to. I need a direction, a destination—
NASYPANY: O.K., I’m gonna give you the Z point [coordinate]. It’s just north of—New York City.
FOX: I got this lat long, 41-15, 74-36, or 73-46.
NASYPANY: Head ‘em in that direction.
FOX: Copy that.

We can have a quick look at these coordinates to determine where they actually are.

The first (41°15’0.00”N 74°36’0.00”W) is just north of Sussex NJ, 48 miles from the WTC due NW. The second (41°15’0.00”N 73°46’0.00”W) is just south of Yorktown Heights NY, 39 miles from the WTC due NNE.

So far so good. Except of course, the fighters don't just fly there in a straight line. You can't have a couple of F-15's just barrelling their way through civilian airspace at 1000MPH+, over urban areas. So they head east, out over the Atlantic, and follow the coast, flying through the ADIZ which is military controlled airspace.

Once they reached the coast of Long Island, to pass through to the Z-Point they then have to get FAA permission. Which they weren't given. The FAA didn't want two F-15's flying smack through the middle of New York, potentially colliding with airliners in the tightly packed airspace. It was the FAA controllers that put the F-15s in a holding pattern over Long Island. That was at 0907. And then, at 0921, the phantom A11 report came in, and the Otis fighters were directed towards Washington DC.

Bear in mind, the FAA control airspace over the USA, not the military. For NORAD to take command, first the government would need to declare an Air Defense Emergency. This would activate the Security Control of Air Traffic and Air Navigation Aids (SCATANA) Plan and give NORAD total control of airspace.

-Gumboot
 
You guys think you are winning...

Actually, I don't think we're "winning," for the simple reason that I never considered this a contest or game. It's about countering the lies and slander and nonsense of those who proclaim themselves "truthers." It's more a moral obligation, a responsibility to 9/11 victims, their families, and ultimately the truth itself. I've never derived a scintilla of pleasure or satisfaction from dealing with you guys. It's like an unpleasant chore, something that unfortunately has to be done by someone.

The whole 9/11 CT thing has basically devolved along the lines of the UFO and Bigfoot movements. It had its brief little heyday, but now no one takes it very seriously anymore, except the hard-core few who believe because it fulfills some personal inner need. And like the UFO movement, you're sustained by the belief that you're always right on the verge of that long-awaited breakthrough, the watershed event that will finally make the rest of us see the light and proclaim you as visionary heroes. But it never comes.
 
Thank you sir! :)

Instead of a pyramid, it's actually supposed to simulate the Star Wars crawl of receding words that kicked off those flicks (incidentally not a Lucas original, that had been done before).

But I guess a pyramid works too, good eyes. The NWO all-seeing pyramid and all...

Oh, stupid me. All I see is NWO pyramids :D Star Wars is better.

And in any case, the text was very good :)
 
So are you saying:

1. The commission lied about what was on the tapes
2. the commission misinterpreted what was on the tapes.
3. The tapes were fabricated.

Like I said, your not believing the paragraph does not make it untrue, so you should be saying:

"In my opinion, the paragraph is a lie." as it is only your opinion, and you have proven nothing more.

TAM

The different accounts don’t seem to bother you.

What have you proven other than your blind faith in the Commission?
 
The fact that you "don't take any particular side" shows why you don't understand.

Truth is not decided by poll numbers. Reason is the only way we can understand truth- and your peeps don't got it. We've got the keys, and friends don't let conspiracists drive... ever.

What is true today may not be true tomorrow. New facts and information brings about new truth.

The conventional thinkers here in this forum (note, not critical thinkers) base their truth on authority and not reason, example the 9/11 Commission Report.

I have presented many examples which conflicts with the known truth in this forum: i.e. The Missiles at Ground Zero. Conventional thinkers find it easier to rely upon authority than reason. To reconcile conflicting information requires a person to actually think. It appears that most people here find that a bit difficult.

The Missiles at Ground Zero
http://www.nationalvanguard.org/printer.php?id=10058
 
I say again... "truthers" are not "CT's" (conspiracy theorists). They are activists who have latched onto popularized conspiracy mythology as a catalyst for their anger, and excuse for their divisive behavior. If not for 9/11, they'd be trowing eggs at GAP storefronts or choking tear-gas fumes at world bank protests.

The "movement" is a dysfunctional leaderless mess. They aspire to Vietnam-era greatness, but there's absolutely no cultural resonance they can rely upon.

Any small glimmer of hope of exposing lies, corruption, malfeasance, or cover-ups related to 9/11 has been sabotaged by their own inability to control their ranks, moderate their language, and manage laughable theories.

If there are conspiracies related to the events of 9/11 (which I think there are), the "Truth Movement" has successfully sabotaged the investigation better than any "infiltration" or "COINTELPRO" could ever do.

There. Oh, man... am I ever in trouble now! :p

Not at all, well said.
 
What is true today may not be true tomorrow. New facts and information brings about new truth.
Really, Mr. Wizard? (or is that Grand Wizard? I can't keep up with you guys)
Our understanding of what facts are may change, but the truth remains the truth regardless. Even when we "knew" the Earth was flat didn't change the truth that it is a sphere.
You need to go back to grade school. Obviously didn't take the first time.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom