The Truth of Christianity vs. All Other Belief Systems

Your living organism is too complex to just happen by itself. There has to be the now-infamous intelligent design to have come about. Something, and I am not defining what that is because the creator is infinite and not to be put in a box.


Actually, the theories of abiogenesis and evolution work pretty well to explain that, and it has the advantage to make scientifically testable prediction, something that intelligent design has yet to produce.
 
That is a problem. I did not write Revelation, so it is not my mistake. You have to keep in mind that in the new Testament, you can not take the more esoteric parts as being so strictly literal. You have to go back to the Men of Renown of Long Ago, of Genesis who were the Nephilim. (Another thing I did not write) The fact that they were of renown must be because some of the people who came out of Noah's Ark brought with them the stories of these "gods".

Or perhaps they were just another story, like Noah's Ark?
 
Originally Posted by Ethnikos
Some thoughts go so far as to personify it, as a goddess of wisdom, almost.
No, never. Words are words. They are symbolic. They hold no meaning in and of themselves. Meaning must be given to them.
I mean that there are concepts associated with the words. I do not mean the word itself has any special qualities.
If you had never read Aristotle or Philo, or anyone influenced by them, how would you know what to make of "The Word" when you found this lying about as a Greek text?
Ummm . . . what makes you think I haven't? I'll admit to never having read them in Greek, but that's hardly the point. The way the two use the word is not interchangeable at all.
I was trying to give a hypothetical about what someone might think about the New Testament, if they had no knowledge of Greek culture, whatsoever. I did not mean you, personally.
That's my point, you can not understand it without a context, that might be rather extensive.
Which is part of my point as well, except I take it further. Words don't mean. People mean.
What I guess I mean, as what my bigger point was supposed to be, was that Greek is not a suitable language for translating ancient Hebrew into because you can take the translation as if it really was meant to be understood in the same sort of way as if it was Greek, to start with.
The New Testament was written for its time without regard to future use because they expected the end to come at any moment.
Thus rendering it completely and utterly useless to anyone outside of that original context.
Not without some education. There are attempts to make it understandable in a modern translation, like the New International version. It ends up representing the opinions of the translators, in my opinion. I am in favor of an open translation like NetBible where they show how they made their decisions on how to make a particular translation.
Hebrew is not like Greek.
Sure it is. They are both languages, using visual or verbal symbols to convey meaning. Meaning that is assigned by people.
Ok, it is human. So what is your point? that god has nothing to do with it being written?
I just think it is funny how some people somehow know exactly when prophecy switches from literal to symbolic.
Yeah, exactly my point (except you should have written "from literal to figurative" since all words are already symbolic). So your interpretation bears no better weight than anyone else's. In the end, its a zero-sum game.
Right, right, and right. I encourage people to do your own. God is not some thing you just say, ok i can go with that, and that is the end of it. You have to own it, otherwise it is useless.
Any interpretation is useful (unless it is to actually carry out some law that only applies to kings or Levitical priests) to that person but may not be to anyone else. Inventing your own religion is great as long as it is a one person religion.
This concept renders the Bible completely useless. If anyone can interpret it to be anything they want and then invent their own religion, there's no basis for "truth" or "righteousness" at all.
Everyone has an opinion, or at least they should always be making opinions if their mind is alive. That is just going to happen, whether anyone wants that to be true or not. Really it is just an illustration, the creating a religion thing. I have a brother who is an expert Bible translator and he says he is now practically an atheist, so understanding the Bible is not the same thing as believing in the Bible. Someone could translate the whole Bible and do a good job of it and have no interest in making any kind of religion, or even having a religion.
 
I mean that there are concepts associated with the words. I do not mean the word itself has any special qualities.
I was trying to give a hypothetical about what someone might think about the New Testament, if they had no knowledge of Greek culture, whatsoever. I did not mean you, personally.

Great. Then we're in complete agreement, and Rush Limbaugh is an idiot. Word don't mean. People do.

What I guess I mean, as what my bigger point was supposed to be, was that Greek is not a suitable language for translating ancient Hebrew into because you can take the translation as if it really was meant to be understood in the same sort of way as if it was Greek, to start with.

And English (a language based on Latin, Greek, French, etc.) is more suitable because . . . ?

Not without some education. There are attempts to make it understandable in a modern translation, like the New International version. It ends up representing the opinions of the translators, in my opinion. I am in favor of an open translation like NetBible where they show how they made their decisions on how to make a particular translation.

Not my point. I have no idea what you're arguing here, but this has nothing to do with what I was saying.

Ok, it is human. So what is your point? that god has nothing to do with it being written?

Language is symbolic. Meaning is assigned. It doesn't matter if you use Greek, Hebrew or Klingon. Saying one language is more or less adequate than another for translating is like saying one 6oz glass is more or less adequate than another for holding water.

Right, right, and right. I encourage people to do your own. God is not some thing you just say, ok i can go with that, and that is the end of it. You have to own it, otherwise it is useless.

Sure you can. People do it all the time.

Really it is just an illustration, the creating a religion thing.

An illustration of what?
 
.
Yes you are.
You know nothing of "blood debt".
Slavery.
The sources of the OT.
The course of civilization.
You parrot whatever your preacher beat into you as a child, with no questions asked, it seems, from your continual blunders about theology and fact.
Do you mean the "Scandinavian common law" or whatever? Go ahead and fill me in on that.
And someone does know the source of the Old Testament? I think it was Daniel over in Babylon who took whatever survived the destruction of Jerusalem and made some sort of compilation. You can find references in the Bible that says, "And so it says in the book of the wars." or whatever.
"Also he bade them teach the children of Judah the use of the bow: behold, it is written in the book of Jasher."
I made a list of them tears ago and there are a bunch of them.
I never had any violent preachers an I learned most from what I read, and I have no problem asking questions of preachers or even being very condemning of their doctrines to their face, if necessary.
I have read piles of books on history. That does not make me an expert on history outside of whatever I specialized in.
 
According to the bible. But what does that have to do with the post you were responding to?
Please, stop preaching at us and explain why your God is better than any other God (and don't use anything from the bible)...
God is the God of promises, as in the God of Abraham, Who makes promises and keeps them.
 
That would be because there is no other version. The hebrew is a translation from the greek. If you wish to go to the source and retranslate you must go to the greek.
Wikipedia will tell you that the oldest surviving manuscript containing verses of the Old Testament is a Greek papyrus but that does not mean it is the oldest version that ever existed.
 
Wikipedia will tell you that the oldest surviving manuscript containing verses of the Old Testament is a Greek papyrus but that does not mean it is the oldest version that ever existed.


That actually depends of which book of the Bible you are referring to, anyway, as none of these ancient manuscripts were even a complete book, let alone the whole OT.
For some books, the oldest version known is part of the dead sea scrolls, for example, in Hebrew.
But that does not solve the problem one bit as none of the redundant parts we can find agree with each other so, before you go and start translating, you'd first need to define which one version (if any) is the correct one tor translate.
 
You do? Which religions are those please?
People. There are all sorts of people who will go to a lot of trouble not saying or writing yahweh of even the word god. Hashem or something, and G-d.
Oh, which day is the holy one then?
The one in the famous Ten Commandments that all Christians say they follow but conveniently ignore the seventh day clause, while they worship the day Constantine kept, in honor of the sun.
Except names are just words, and we've already discussed how they don't mean. People mean. So what does in our interaction with the divine what we call Him?
The popular thing right now in churches is, Father God. I think it is a little odd, and do not use it myself. I just say God. God will make us sons at some time but for right now, I think the Father is a communal concept and not an individual thing until we are transformed. I feel it is presumptuous to assume we are already worthy to call ourselves such while we are in our current sinful condition. We are adopted through Christ who is our brother. We have to go through a probationary period before the full adoption goes into affect.
 
People. There are all sorts of people who will go to a lot of trouble not saying or writing yahweh of even the word god. Hashem or something, and G-d.

So no religions then?

The one in the famous Ten Commandments that all Christians say they follow but conveniently ignore the seventh day clause, while they worship the day Constantine kept, in honor of the sun.

Again, which day?

The popular thing right now in churches is, Father God.

Which churches?

We are adopted through Christ who is our brother. We have to go through a probationary period before the full adoption goes into affect.

So are we, or aren't we adopted. Your statements are contradictory.
 
Hmmmm: I asked KK about this too but did not get an answer. So who is the audience? I really want to know
Do you mean the preaching? I suppose I imagine someone might be sitting on the fence and could be persuaded.
I was reading this story last night on a "Christianity is right" web site and this writer was saying this person was looking at the ground as he went into his pro-Jesus spiel. For some reason he thought this was him "getting through". The poor guy was probably wishing he would just stop talking.
Maybe writing on a forum is a way to deal with guilt about not carrying out Jesus' commission to spread the Gospel. My thing is I get bothered with the fact that there is this great big thing called the internet where no one is telling the truth. To me, the truth is that this mirage with the flashing neon light saying "Here is religion. Just pick one that suites you" is Babylon, destined for Hell.
 
The irony being, from where I am sitting, that you are not merely satisfied by this hell-bent cafeteria Religion and want to write your own menu through translating the text as you see fit.
 
That's a can of worms you probably don't really want to open on this forum.
Right. I am not prepared to get into an argument about that.
There is no scientific dispute about whether evolution (well, the general theory thereof. There are, of course, disputes regarding specifics.) is able to create complex organisms...
There was a guy,Stephen C. Meyer, on Coast to Coast the other night who seemed to have some very good arguments for I.D. He said he was able to have his paper published in Smithsonian.
 
Actually, the theories of abiogenesis and evolution work pretty well to explain that, and it has the advantage to make scientifically testable prediction, something that intelligent design has yet to produce.
Thanks for that bit of info. I was just stating my opinion.
 
Or perhaps they were just another story, like Noah's Ark?
The gods? You mean you do not believe they really existed? What would you think if they all of a sudden appeared and said, "We are immortal and we are back."? Seeing is believing, right? There you go. Want a war? Have the ultimate warriors. How would you like Achilles, as in Brad Pit in Troy, on your side? Armageddon, here we come.
 
Do you mean the preaching? I suppose I imagine someone might be sitting on the fence and could be persuaded.
I was reading this story last night on a "Christianity is right" web site and this writer was saying this person was looking at the ground as he went into his pro-Jesus spiel. For some reason he thought this was him "getting through". The poor guy was probably wishing he would just stop talking.
Maybe writing on a forum is a way to deal with guilt about not carrying out Jesus' commission to spread the Gospel. My thing is I get bothered with the fact that there is this great big thing called the internet where no one is telling the truth. To me, the truth is that this mirage with the flashing neon light saying "Here is religion. Just pick one that suites you" is Babylon, destined for Hell.

You have a real knack of not answering what you are asked. No I did not mean the preaching

you said

One way of looking at the judgment is the doomsday scenario, where Jesus returns to execute judgement against the wicked. The "day" may not be a literal day but a series of events where the most powerful entities for evil are unleashed to gather the nations for Armageddon. They need to be destroyed, so they are allowed to work their worst, so to make it known to whoever is looking on, that they really deserved what they get. You have to realize people worshipped them as gods and were held in high esteem by many and their destruction may not be looked on kindly if it appears it was done without just cause.

We are talking about the end times and we are talking about god. Who is the audience he needs to convince? That makes no sense to me. Do you argue that after the final judgement there will be a whole bunch of people standing around saying "see that god? he went and done in my <insert preferred deity here> and he hadn't done anything to deserve it. So I am just not going to be judged and I will carry on as before." ?
 
There was a guy,Stephen C. Meyer, on Coast to Coast the other night who seemed to have some very good arguments for I.D. He said he was able to have his paper published in Smithsonian.

There are no good arguments for ID. If Meyer was published in the Smithsonian, I'm unaware of it. Can you provide a citation?

Last I heard, his big article on ID was retracted due to conflict of interest with the editor and a complete lack of peer review.
 
Right. I am not prepared to get into an argument about that.
There was a guy,Stephen C. Meyer, on Coast to Coast the other night who seemed to have some very good arguments for I.D. He said he was able to have his paper published in Smithsonian.

I believe you are referring to this Stephen C. Meyer, of the "Discovery Institute", correct?
 
Great. Then we're in complete agreement, and Rush Limbaugh is an idiot. Word don't mean. People do.
And English (a language based on Latin, Greek, French, etc.) is more suitable because . . . ?
What I mean is it's almost as if they said, "now that we have this nice translation into something we can understand,Greek, we no longer ever have to look at the Hebrew again." The thing is, it would have had to have been kept constantly up to date by continually going back to the Hebrew in order to keep the meaning more accurate. After a while, even the Greek was ignored and treated as unclean, in favor of the "holy" Latin texts.
Not my point. I have no idea what you're arguing here, but this has nothing to do with what I was saying.
If someone, or a group of people, were super experts on Greek culture and history, they could look at the New Testament Greek and have a clear view on what the implications of these words were. Knowing all that, should they go ahead and make a new Translation? Well yes, but it would still be an opinion and can not be expected to be perfectly accurate.
Language is symbolic. Meaning is assigned. It doesn't matter if you use Greek, Hebrew or Klingon. Saying one language is more or less adequate than another for translating is like saying one 6oz glass is more or less adequate than another for holding water.
The Septuagint Greek Old testament had all sorts of ridiculous claims about the miraculous nature of its being made, plus a claim the for another miraculous reason, Greek happens to be the only perfect language in the world to translate the Hebrew into. This has been accepted without question for a large chunk of history.
I think the best language is whatever it is that you speak, for you. My opinion is that translation should be made from the Hebrew instead of the Greek.
Sure you can. People do it all the time.
Maybe but it is not right.
An illustration of what?
Possibilities. People have done it and those are the true Christians, the ones who made their own translations, back when having a bible in your own language was punishable by death.
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom