The Trials of Amanda Knox and Raffaele Sollecito: Part 28

Status
Not open for further replies.
So you base your opinion of her on the amount of money she makes, heh? Do you have a source for this $8m pa?

Do you really think that those she represents, who are in prison, or their families have $8m to pay her? Get real.





https://www.reddit.com/r/TickTockMa...avery_family_has_paid_kathleen_t_zellner_and/


A reputable nwspaper article stated she had earned US$2m already in the first quarter, a couple of years ago. I merely extrapolated from that to get the US$8m pa.

She is a good old-fashioned vulturous blood-sucking lawyer, not Mother Theresa.
 
Zellner's law firm does a lot of pro bono work and if they don't win the case and their client does not receive a hefty monetary judgment, the firm loses that money. It costs a lot to do research and hire experts and these cases often go on for years.


https://www.chicagolawbulletin.com/archives/2014/04/22/kathleen-zellner-4-22

She earns every dollar she makes. You instantly demonize her because she's associated with Innocence Projects which supported Amanda Knox and with which she is now associated. That is why you attack it and Zellner.

She only does pro-bono work because lawyers in the US are expected to do a certain amount per year.

You are mistaking what she did for Avery as pro-bono, when in fact, by your own description it was on a contingency basis, more commonly known as 'No Win, No Fee'.
 
A reputable nwspaper article stated she had earned US$2m already in the first quarter, a couple of years ago. I merely extrapolated from that to get the US$8m pa.

She is a good old-fashioned vulturous blood-sucking lawyer, not Mother Theresa.

A newspaper article you cannot provide. I see. You "extrapolated". I see.

You are again resorting to a straw man argument as no one has stated, or even implied, that she is a "Mother Theresa". She's just a damn good lawyer.


She only does pro-bono work because lawyers in the US are expected to do a certain amount per year.

You are mistaking what she did for Avery as pro-bono, when in fact, by your own description it was on a contingency basis, more commonly known as 'No Win, No Fee'.

Lawyers are encouraged to do pro bono work but there is no requirement to do so. You don't know how much she does or how much she makes. You just make it up.

Exactly where did I claim she was doing pro bono work for Avery? I only quoted from the link. I didn't write it.

Zellner is one of the worst kinds of unscrupulous blood-sucking vultures. Goes to the death beds of notorious serial killers and gets them to sign a statement that they were responsible for the murder her client was convicted of. As the guy snuffs it shortly after, no-one gets to (a) cross examine him, and (b) gets to find out it is all fraudulent. Outcome? A likely killer is freed on the basis of Zellner's crafty skullduggery.

That's what lawyers do, but don't beatify them. They do it to line their pockets.

Full stop.

She is held in high regard by the legal world and is an award winning lawyer.

What case are you referring to where she got a death bed confession that freed her client? I can find no such case. The only case that I can find is where she solicited the death bed confession of Larry Eyler, who was her client.

Look in the mirror. Just yesterday you made the fraudulent claim that 530,1 meant 'proven innocent', then tried to pretend you had not been lying.

Oh, good lord. Why would I lie about something so easily googled and about which this very group has had frequent and extensive conversations? Do you think I thought I wouldn't be corrected? Come on, use some common sense instead of just lobbing more insults. And I WAS corrected by, IIRC, Numbers and acknowledged my mistake. Which is more than you ever do. You couldn't even admit your incorrect use of "mother-in-lawS", for Pete's sake. Sheesh.
 
Last edited:
She only does pro-bono work because lawyers in the US are expected to do a certain amount per year.

You are mistaking what she did for Avery as pro-bono, when in fact, by your own description it was on a contingency basis, more commonly known as 'No Win, No Fee'.

nv3TqEb.jpg
 
Zellner is one of the worst kinds of unscrupulous blood-sucking vultures. Goes to the death beds of notorious serial killers and gets them to sign a statement that they were responsible for the murder her client was convicted of. As the guy snuffs it shortly after, no-one gets to (a) cross examine him, and (b) gets to find out it is all fraudulent. Outcome? A likely killer is freed on the basis of Zellner's crafty skullduggery.

That's what lawyers do, but don't beatify them. They do it to line their pockets.

Full stop.

Read my post again, read your reply again, and then answer this question:

What's wrong with you?
 
See what I mean? 99.9% of 'not guilty' verdicts fall under the ambit of Art 530 Paragraph 1.

Total and utter nonsense. And employing a bogus "statistic" pulled out of the proverbial fundament. You've been schooled extensively (and with a proper evidence base) on this many times before.



This means 'not guilty' as Brits, Yanks and Canuck understand the term.


Rubbish. Again, you've been well and truly schooled on the fact that 530.1 does not map directly/exclusively to "not guilty". In fact, not only do all 530.1 acquittals map onto "not guilty", but also the vast majority of 530.2 acquittals map onto "not guilty".



Marasca-Bruno applied Art 530 Paragraph 2 - usually used as a rare loophole to get prominent politicians off the hook


Total nonsense. Or maybe you'd care to supply actual, reliable evidence to support this preposterous claim. Oh wait: you can't - because it's total bat guano which is entirely a figment of your own rabidly pro-guilt-at-any-cost imagination.....



- which was 'insufficient evidence'. A 'not proven' verdict, despite two merits courts finding clear guilt on all the evidence put before them.


Once again, you've been schooled multiple times that 530.2 does not map exclusively onto "not proven". Sure, a (small) proportion of 530.2 acquittals would map to "not proven", but the vast majority - including, clearly, the Knox/Sollecito acquittals - map onto "not guilty". In passing, you embarrassingly still don't understand the meaning of the term "insufficient evidence".
 
(Of course, as has been pointed out here several times recently (and many times in the past as well).... the "differentiation" of verdicts under 530 is now a totally artificial and non-statutory artifact which seems only to remain in existence within the Italian Code of Criminal Procedure because of either a) apathy around properly rewriting the Code to properly reflect current Italian legislation, or b) reactionary attitudes among the Italian judiciary: an unwillingness or inability to change the way they categorise acquittals, even though the categorisation has now totally disappeared under Italian law.)
 
Originally Posted by sept79:
Wow! My son is an MBA graduate from Maryville University--located in a St. Louis suburb. Yes, I have 'donated' considerable $ to the university.

What's this? A proud dad moment?


Kiss my back side . . . .
 
Read my post again, read your reply again, and then answer this question:

What's wrong with you?

Notice how she uses the plural in order to make it look like this is usual practice for Zellner? I can find one time she got a death bed confession and it was from her own client and did not get one of Zellner's clients off. I suppose I could accuse Vixen of lying like she accused me, but I'll give her the benefit of the doubt and assume it was a mistake.
 
Last edited:
(Of course, as has been pointed out here several times recently (and many times in the past as well).... the "differentiation" of verdicts under 530 is now a totally artificial and non-statutory artifact which seems only to remain in existence within the Italian Code of Criminal Procedure because of either a) apathy around properly rewriting the Code to properly reflect current Italian legislation, or b) reactionary attitudes among the Italian judiciary: an unwillingness or inability to change the way they categorise acquittals, even though the categorisation has now totally disappeared under Italian law.)

You're trying to explain this to someone who claimed the following...

Vixen said:
Paragraph one, (530.1) has four sub-sections numbered one to four. Subsection no 2 of 530.1 is NOT Article 530.2.

530.1 paras 1,2,3,4 is completely separate and different from 530.2, which has no subsections.


The misapprehension has arisen, because whoever compiled the wikipedia in this, omitted article 530.2, leading people to believe 530.1, para 2, was what the Supreme Court was referring to.

I seem to recall the last time we had the 530.1/530.2 conversation, Vixen was asked to provide the content of what she thinks is 530.2, and she once again failed to deliver. It's rather comical that someone who doesn't even know what's contained within the C.P.P. would come here pretending to understand how to interpret it.
 
You're trying to explain this to someone who claimed the following...



I seem to recall the last time we had the 530.1/530.2 conversation, Vixen was asked to provide the content of what she thinks is 530.2, and she once again failed to deliver. It's rather comical that someone who doesn't even know what's contained within the C.P.P. would come here pretending to understand how to interpret it.

It's a cause of amusement that the guilters don't have the foggiest notion of how the Italian laws of the CPP are organized into numbered paragraphs (and, when necessary, lettered sub-paragraphs of a numbered paragraph). Of course, they may be faking this apparent lack of knowledge to cover up the fact that they have no valid arguments.

On the other hand, the cause of the Knox - Sollecito case was the failure of the Italian police, prosecutors, and (some) judges to violate rather than fairly apply the relevant articles of Italian law listed in the CPP. Had the authorities obeyed the law, Knox, Sollecito, and Lumumba would never have been arrested, nor would Knox or Sollecito ever have been tried. The authorities could have devoted their time to more quickly apprehending Guede.
 
I seem to recall the last time we had the 530.1/530.2 conversation, Vixen was asked to provide the content of what she thinks is 530.2, and she once again failed to deliver. It's rather comical that someone who doesn't even know what's contained within the C.P.P. would come here pretending to understand how to interpret it.

For the record, this is from the Italian-language version of Wikisource:

https://it.wikisource.org/wiki/Codice_di_procedura_penale/Libro_VII/Titolo_III
 
Zellner is one of the worst kinds of unscrupulous blood-sucking vultures.


<snip>
Speaking of "cross-examination", too bad lawyers for Knox & Sollecito were somehow never fortunate enough to have enjoyed that privilege with Guede, now isn't it? Well, I mean about the events that occurred on November 1, 2007 in the cottage anyway. Gee, I wonder why Guede wasn't chomping at the bit to testify directly against AK & RS during the Hellman trial - about the events on 11/1/07?
<snip>


Edited by Loss Leader: 
Edited for Rules 0/12.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
For the record, this is from the Italian-language version of Wikisource:

https://it.wikisource.org/wiki/Codice_di_procedura_penale/Libro_VII/Titolo_III

Bill, thanks for calling attention to this source. What is especially useful (for clarity, it doesn't apply to this case) is that the text references the applicable Italian Criminal Code (CP, "c.p." in the text).

Here is the Italian text:

"Art. 530 Sentenza di assoluzione

1. Se il fatto non sussiste, se l’imputato non lo ha commesso, se il fatto non costituisce reato o non è previsto dalla legge come reato ovvero se il reato è stato commesso da persona non imputabile (85 s. c.p.) o non punibile per un’altra ragione, il giudice pronuncia sentenza di assoluzione indicandone la causa nel dispositivo.

2. Il giudice pronuncia sentenza di assoluzione anche quando manca, è insufficiente o è contraddittoria la prova che il fatto sussiste, che l’imputato lo ha commesso, che il fatto costituisce reato o che il reato è stato commesso da persona imputabile.

3. Se vi è la prova che il fatto è stato commesso in presenza di una causa di giustificazione (50-54 c.p.) o di una causa personale di non punibilità ovvero vi è dubbio sull’esistenza delle stesse, il giudice pronuncia sentenza di assoluzione a norma del comma 1.

4. Con la sentenza di assoluzione il giudice applica, nei casi previsti dalla legge, le misure di sicurezza (222, 2402 c.p.)."

Google translation (with one or two minor corrections or comments by me):

"Art. 530 Judgment of acquittal

1. If the fact does not exist, if the defendant has not committed it, if the fact does not constitute a crime or is not provided for by the law as a crime or if the crime was committed by a person not liable (85 s. c.p.) or not punishable another reason, the judge pronounces an acquittal sentence by indicating the cause in the device.

2. The judge pronounces the acquittal sentence {also} even when it is absent, the evidence that the offense exists, that the defendant has committed it, that the fact constitutes a crime or that the crime was committed by an imputable person is insufficient or contradictory.

3. If there is evidence that the fact was committed in the presence of a cause of justification (50-54 of the criminal code) or a personal cause of non-punishment or there is doubt about the existence of the same, the judge pronounces a sentence of acquittal pursuant to paragraph 1.

4. With the sentence of acquittal, the judge applies, in the cases foreseen by the law, the security measures (222, 2402 c.p.)."

The Italian "anche" translates to the English "also", "even", "too". Source:
http://www.reverso.net/translationresults.aspx?lang=EN&direction=italian-english

Thus, the language of CPP Art. 530.2 is by the use of "anche" a continuation of Art. 530.1 in effect of the specifications contained in 530.1. It is this kind of simple language issue which the guilters can not or will not acknowledge.

This bizarre but transparent linguistic trick or incomprehension by the guilters is really similar to the Italian police interpreting "see you later" as meaning that Knox had a definite appointment to meet Lumumba, when both Ficarra and Donnino admitted in court testimony, before judges Massei and Boninsegna, respectively, that the Italian words actually had a generic meaning. Ficarra made it clear that the Italian words may have had the specific meaning of an appointment "for us", meaning for the police in their suspect-centric interrogation.
 
Last edited:
This bizarre but transparent linguistic trick or incomprehension by the guilters is really similar to the Italian police interpreting "see you later" as meaning that Knox had a definite appointment to meet Lumumba, when both Ficarra and Donnino admitted in court testimony, before judges Massei and Boninsegna, respectively, that the Italian words actually had a generic meaning. Ficarra made it clear that the Italian words may have had the specific meaning of an appointment "for us", meaning for the police in their suspect-centric interrogation.

It's not so bizarre once you figure out their motive for doing it.

Years ago, there were 100s of Vixens trolling the net and news-outlet comments sections. What those trolls needed was some "authoritative" source. TJMK, the now defunct pair of PMFs and the fake-wiki provided it. It helped the trolls feel justified in vilifying innocent people, citing that veneer of legal respectability.

The antidote, of course, is simply linking to truly authoritative content, like the Wikisource citation above.

With now just Vixen trolling these waves - and maybe six diehards still on TJMK - it's a lot easier to put real stuff in front of inquirer's.
 
Last edited:
I'm still waiting for Vixen to provide a case wherein Zellner got a death bed confession that got off her client who had been convicted of the crime. In fact, she claims more than one such case exists so I don't see why she can't provide even one. Oh, wait...yes, I can.

I expect she will never address this.
 
I'm still waiting for Vix to admit that she was wrong about exonoree, and Zellner client, Ryan Ferguson being freed from prison due to an Alford plea. Someone who can't admit to such a simple and ultimately insignificant error like this....you have to wonder what it must be like to have to deal with them in real life about stuff that actually matters.
 
I'm still waiting for Vixen to quote one forensic-DNA expert who agrees with Stefanoni's DNA work presented at trial. So far she's mentioned a professor who also conceded that Stefanoni had not followed international protocols, and another expert who conceded he'd not seen the negative controls.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom