The Trials of Amanda Knox and Raffaele Sollecito: Part 28

Status
Not open for further replies.
I stand corrected.

When Grinder argued all of this, he was reacting to initial reports that it had been a 530.1 acquittal, to which defence lawyers added, "that's the best acquittal possible."

Sensing an opportunity to embarrass FOA's, to which he was not a friend, Grinder tried to make hay that, then, the FOA had to admit that 530.2 was some mythical lesser acquittal. Which it wasn't.

There are only 530 acquittals. The rest is commentary.

Very true.

Except that an appeal court can acquit citing CPP Article 605, using the specifications of CPP Article 530.

The Hellmann appeal court cited CPP Article 605 in its (provisional) acquittal of Knox and Sollecito on the murder/rape charges, following the specifications prescribed in CPP Article 530, while under CPP Article 605 convicting Knox of "simple" calunnia supposedly following the law in Article 533.

CPP Article 605 gives an appeal court the authority to deliver a judgment confirming or amending the judgment under appeal.
 
Nonsense. Present actual cases where 530.1 was cited instead of 530.2 if they are so common. 530.2 is not a "rare loophole". In the past, I presented at least six cases where 530.2 was used to prove that your claim that " for not having committed the act" was not a "typo".

Your entire claims are based on your outrageous and deliberate logical fallacy, i.e., the false premise, that 530,1 refers to "being found innocent" and that 530,2 means 'not guilty', as per usual meaning.

You're lying and you know you're lying. How does it make you feel that everybody knows you are lying. All in the name of protecting your heroine, Amanda Knox.

The fact that you wilfully lie on Amanda Knox' behalf, proves decisively IMV that you believe her to be guilty as charged.
 
Numbers has explained this. What the 2015 Court of Cassation wrote was that Judge Nencini should not have convicted on the basis of the "evidence" Nencini had had before his court.

It's not so much that there was "never any evidence of their guilt," it's that the evidence that the various prosecution(s) brought into the Italian lower courts was not sufficient to convict anyone.

As the 2015 Supreme Court noted several times in its report, none of the "evidence" that the Nencini court had had before it addressed the main fact of the case, that:

​

** Note the qualifier of, "even if".

As for Section 530, which governs verdicts, there are three possibilities:

- Guilty
- Not guilty because of acquittal
- Not guilty because of "Non doversi procedere", meaning that either an amnesty has been granted or that a statute of limitations has passed.​

There is NO DIFFERENCE in the modifiers to Section 530 acquittals.

- Perché il fatto non sussiste - Because the action allegedly committed by the defendant never took place
- Perché l'imputato non lo ha commesso - Because the action allegedly committed by the defendant was actually committed by another party
- Perché il fatto non costituisce reato - Because the action was committed by the defendant, but is not considered a crime, for he was excused (e.g. self defense)
- Perché il fatto non è previsto dalla Legge come reato - Because the action was committed by the defendant, but is no longer considered to be a crime by the law
- Perché l'imputato non è punibile - Because the action was committed by the defendant, but the defendant is not liable for his crime, because he was legally insane at the time​
The modifier has no effect on the fact that ALL OF THESE are acquittals. One is no less an acquittal than another.

It's amazing that 3 1/2 years following the acquittals, some are still arguing that a 530.2 acquittal is somehow inferior to a 530.1 acquittal.


Marasca-Bruno very clearly state it is 100% certain Knox was at the scene of the murder. They did not 'declare her innocent' at all. Far from it. The convictions were annulled because Bruno pal Bongiorno pointed out they could use the loophole of 'insufficient evidence', which got off Andreotti and Berlusconi and various political terrorists in the 60's.
 
Marasca-Bruno very clearly state it is 100% certain Knox was at the scene of the murder. They did not 'declare her innocent' at all. Far from it. The convictions were annulled because Bruno pal Bongiorno pointed out they could use the loophole of 'insufficient evidence', which got off Andreotti and Berlusconi and various political terrorists in the 60's.

Insufficient evidence is a "loophole"?

Thanks for this observation. It's all we need to hear in assessing your contributions to this (never ending) thread.

BTW - no one has denied that Knox (and Sollecito) were at the scene. The issue, as per their acquittal, was "when".
 
Last edited:
Insufficient evidence is a "loophole"?

Thanks for this observation. It's all we need to hear in assessing your contributions to this (never ending) thread.

BTW - no one has denied that Knox (and Sollecito) were at the scene. The issue, as per their acquittal, was "when".

If you knew anything about law, a case being dismissed due to 'insufficient evidence' is a tool for the lower, prreliminary courts.

I reckon Italy has hung on to this loophole so that mafia types can evade justice.

Marasca & Bruno Italian Supreme Court: "Found guilty as charged by the merits courts, in a fair trial that went on for eight months? Had your appeal thrown out? Had the evidence retested and it is still incriminating? Well, Trump has slipped us some funds he should have handed to US IRS tax officials and Bongiorno has friends and family in Sicily and Bruno was once charged with mafia activity, so let's see what we can do at our half-day hearing. Ah, here we are, 'insufficient evidence'. Still on the statute books! Guilty of rape and murder but here's a clause to let them off. Whoops."
 
Once again, I'm not going to belabor this point with you. However, I will address the highlighted part regarding 530.1 and .2.

This is not a good comparison as the people discussing what the meaning is were fluent Italian speakers. The 530.1 vs 530.2 nonsense was being argued by someone who is not "fluent", shall we say, in Italian law and whose "evidence" actually contradicted her own claim.

Stop it, Stacyhs, stop it. You are embarrassing even the ultra-Friends of Amanda.

(I never thought this was possible, so maybe there's a compliment to be found in there.)
 
I reckon Italy has hung on to this loophole so that mafia types can evade justice.
This is stupid, even for you. You may be the only person in the world who regards "insufficient evidence" as a loophole - or incriminating.

Marasca & Bruno Italian Supreme Court: "Found guilty as charged by the merits courts, in a fair trial that went on for eight months? Had your appeal thrown out? Had the evidence retested and it is still incriminating? Well, Trump has slipped us some funds he should have handed to US IRS tax officials and Bongiorno has friends and family in Sicily and Bruno was once charged with mafia activity, so let's see what we can do at our half-day hearing. Ah, here we are, 'insufficient evidence'. Still on the statute books! Guilty of rape and murder but here's a clause to let them off. Whoops."

This is a direct quote? Page number please.

At least this thread has come back alive and we'll make the 30th Continuation - based on inanities.
 
Last edited:
Yes, I agree regarding the 530.1 and .2. My bad. I think I was remembering another discussion about this. There have been so many of them.

Your entire claims are based on your outrageous and deliberate logical fallacy, i.e., the false premise, that 530,1 refers to "being found innocent" and that 530,2 means 'not guilty', as per usual meaning.

You're lying and you know you're lying. How does it make you feel that everybody knows you are lying. All in the name of protecting your heroine, Amanda Knox.

The fact that you wilfully lie on Amanda Knox' behalf, proves decisively IMV that you believe her to be guilty as charged.


Apparently, my post where I admit openly that I made an error went right over your head. Admitting error is something we never see from you even when you are proved wrong beyond any doubt as in the "dropped theft charges". As for the rest of your nonsense, thanks for my first good laugh of the day.
 
Last edited:
If you knew anything about law, a case being dismissed due to 'insufficient evidence' is a tool for the lower, prreliminary courts.

I reckon Italy has hung on to this loophole so that mafia types can evade justice.

Marasca & Bruno Italian Supreme Court: "Found guilty as charged by the merits courts, in a fair trial that went on for eight months? Had your appeal thrown out? Had the evidence retested and it is still incriminating? Well, Trump has slipped us some funds he should have handed to US IRS tax officials and Bongiorno has friends and family in Sicily and Bruno was once charged with mafia activity, so let's see what we can do at our half-day hearing. Ah, here we are, 'insufficient evidence'. Still on the statute books! Guilty of rape and murder but here's a clause to let them off. Whoops."

Wow. Just wow. :jaw-dropp
 
Marasca-Bruno very clearly state it is 100% certain Knox was at the scene of the murder. They did not 'declare her innocent' at all. Far from it. The convictions were annulled because Bruno pal Bongiorno pointed out they could use the loophole of 'insufficient evidence', which got off Andreotti and Berlusconi and various political terrorists in the 60's.



WOW! Just wow! This implies that all defendants found 'not guilty' are free due to the 'loophole of insufficient evidence'. But, why is 'insufficient evidence' a loophole? I don't understand. This reasoning is above my pay grade . . .
 
If you knew anything about law, a case being dismissed due to 'insufficient evidence' is a tool for the lower, prreliminary courts. I reckon Italy has hung on to this loophole so that mafia types can evade justice.

Marasca & Bruno Italian Supreme Court: "Found guilty as charged by the merits courts, in a fair trial that went on for eight months? Had your appeal thrown out? Had the evidence retested and it is still incriminating? Well, Trump has slipped us some funds he should have handed to US IRS tax officials and Bongiorno has friends and family in Sicily and Bruno was once charged with mafia activity, so let's see what we can do at our half-day hearing. Ah, here we are, 'insufficient evidence'. Still on the statute books! Guilty of rape and murder but here's a clause to let them off. Whoops."

Except this case was not dismissed. Amanda and Raffaele were ACQUITTED because the prosecution presented insufficient evidence to prove guilt BARD. In truth, they really only brought with them a half-baked fictional tale, supported by no concrete evidence, and the Supreme Court busted them on it.
 
Last edited:
Nonsense. The first phrases learnt in a foreign language is, "hello", "goodbye", "good morning", "good evening" and "good night". Nobody varies it.

There was a murder, Knox was at the scene. Of course the cops are suspicious. It''s their job.

LOL i know you are not the sharpest tool in the box vixen, but surely this nonsense is even below your IQ level. People make mistakes when they are talking in a language they are in the process of learning. its not difficult to understand. Are you deliberately trying to be come across as a complete idiot? if you are i must congratulate you at your success lol

As you know very well there is no evidence that amanda and raffaele were at the crime scene, if there was they would still be in prison. Your insistence about the silly phone message is your inability to accept that the police made a fundamental mistake, not amanda
 
Nonsense. The first phrases learnt in a foreign language is, "hello", "goodbye", "good morning", "good evening" and "good night". Nobody varies it.

There was a murder, Knox was at the scene. Of course the cops are suspicious. It''s their job.

Straw man. Amanda never meant to use, nor did she use, "good-bye" in her text. Notice she did use "buona serata" correctly.

No one has ever said cops shouldn't be suspicious or that Amanda shouldn't have been asked about the text. Another staw man.
 
Maryville University will honor renowned civil rights attorney Kathleen Zellner with the Sister Mary Byles Peace and Justice Prize at 2 p.m. on Friday, September 21. Zellner will be recognized for her extraordinary success in wrongful conviction advocacy.
“Maryville is honored to recognize Kathleen Zellner and her inspirational work,” says Margaret Onken, vice president for development and alumni relations. “The Sister Mary Byles Peace and Justice Prize and Lecture serves as a reminder of how a single person can champion issues of social justice and equity, and achieve far-reaching results. It sets a standard—not only for Maryville students, but for all of us—to embrace diversity, encourage dialogue, and look out for one another.”
https://www.maryville.edu/mpress/byles-peace-justice-prize-zellner/


Zellner was described as "the crafty 'death bed confessions extractor' … who knows how to get key witnesses to retract their witness statements or get others to 'confess' in their place" by Vixen. (http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?t=324645&page=86)
 
It's not as if she does it for nothing. She earns about US$8m pa.

She has no scruples at all.

So you base your opinion of her on the amount of money she makes, heh? Do you have a source for this $8m pa?

Do you really think that those she represents, who are in prison, or their families have $8m to pay her? Get real.

The Avery family has paid Kathleen T. Zellner and Associates at least $14,000 since the firm began representing Avery in January of 2016; meanwhile Zellner’s law firm has provided pro bono services to Steven Avery in the amount of $603,350.99

•As of June 7, 2017, Zellner’s law firm had expended $232,541.98 on experts since taking on Avery’s case. Zellner’s law firm has also incurred $428,000 in legal fees in the representation of Avery. All together Zellner has spent $660,541.98 during her time as Avery’s post conviction counsel. If we subtract $57,190.99 from this we see that in total Zellner has expended $603,350.99. All of this is only to be paid back to the firm in the event that Avery is released and wins a civil lawsuit.

https://www.reddit.com/r/TickTockMa...avery_family_has_paid_kathleen_t_zellner_and/
 
Zellner's law firm does a lot of pro bono work and if they don't win the case and their client does not receive a hefty monetary judgment, the firm loses that money. It costs a lot to do research and hire experts and these cases often go on for years.

LB: What is the biggest challenge facing your law firm and how do you address that challenge?

Zellner: The biggest challenge is we do our work pro bono on a lot of these exoneration cases. Obviously, it’s very costly to fund pro bono cases.

The civil rights and medical-malpractice cases we take to trial result in multimillion-dollar verdicts and are based on contingent fees. The fees from those verdicts cover the expenses for our work on exoneration cases. It’s a juggling act.
https://www.chicagolawbulletin.com/archives/2014/04/22/kathleen-zellner-4-22

She earns every dollar she makes. You instantly demonize her because she's associated with Innocence Projects which supported Amanda Knox and with which she is now associated. That is why you attack it and Zellner.
 
https://www.maryville.edu/mpress/byles-peace-justice-prize-zellner/


Zellner was described as "the crafty 'death bed confessions extractor' … who knows how to get key witnesses to retract their witness statements or get others to 'confess' in their place" by Vixen. (http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?t=324645&page=86)


Wow! My son is an MBA graduate from Maryville University--located in a St. Louis suburb. Yes, I have 'donated' considerable $ to the university.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom