The Trials of Amanda Knox and Raffaele Sollecito: Part 28

Status
Not open for further replies.
You exhibit woefully poor understanding. The rent money element of the theft of Mez' property was dropped. Only the theft of the mobile phones was tried.

I wonder if you actually followed the case.

Fan worship is not a good method of assessing whether someone committed a crime.



Oh. Dear.

(First sentence, as so very often, both incorrect and amusingly - and of course unintentionally - ironic.....)

(Last sentence likewise.......)

(Penultimate sentence likewise.......)
 
Last edited:
Rudy Guede was never charged with stealing the money. Amanda Knox was.
You might want to take a look at the first two pages of the Micheli Report for Guede. On page 2 charge D is listed as follows:
D)
del delitto di cui agli arrt. 110,624 C.P., perché, in concorso con KNOX AMANDA MARIE e SOLLECITO RAFFAELE, per procurarsi un ingiusto profitto, nelle circostanze di tempo e di luogo di cui ai capi A) e C), si impossessavano della somma di € 300,00 circa, di due carte di credito, della Abbey Bank e deila Nationwide, entrambe del Regno Unito, e di due telefoni cellulari, appartenenti a KERCHER MEREDITH, sottraendoli alla stessa che li deteneva.

No, she was not acquitted. The charge was dropped.

[...]
You might want to read the final pages of judge Massei's report:
For the theft of the money (i.e. "residua imputazione di cui al capo D)") on the final page it reads:
Visto l'ar. 530 cpp
Assolve gl'imputati dalla residua imputazione di cui al capo D) perché il fatto non sussiste.

You are wrong. The charge for stealing the rent money was dropped, and only Amanda and Raff were charged with it.

From Massei re the charges:

Under chapter D of the charges, is ascribed to KNOX and to SOLLECITO, in complicity together, the theft of goods which belonged to Meredith Kercher (in particular two mobile phones, a sum of money, and two credit cards from British banks), in this case charged according to Article 624 bis of the Criminal Code.
Why not in the original Italian? (Massei page 3):
D)
del delitto di cui agli artt. 110, 624 c.p., perché, in concorso tra loro, per procurarsi un ingiusto profitto, nelle circostanze di tempo e di luogo di cui ai capi A) e C), si impossessavano della somma di € 300,00 circa, di due carte di credito, della Abbey Bank e della Nationwide, entrambe del Regno Unito, e di due telefoni cellulari, appartenenti a KERCHER MEREDITH, sottraendoli alla stessa che li deteneva
[fatto da qualificare ai sensi dell'art. 624-bis c.p., stante il riferimento al luogo di esecuzione del reato contenuto nel capo A). qui richiamato]
It should be obvious why "only Amanda and Raff were charged with it" in front of judge Massei (hint: Guede wasn't a defendant at that trial and had already been acquitted of that charge by judge Micheli because
dall'imputazione a lui ascritta al capo D). per non aver commesso il fatto;

From Massei re the verdict:

[this Court] Declares
KNOX Amanda Marie and SOLLECITO Raffaele guilty of the crimes ascribed to them under chapter A) of the charges, into said crime being absorbed the felony contested under chapter C), as well as [guilty] under chapter B), D) limited to the mobile phones and E) and, as far as regards KNOX Amanda Marie, additionally the crime she has been charged with under chapter F), all these crimes must be joined by the element of continuance and, excluding the aggravations provided for by articles 577 and 61(5) of the Criminal Code, to both [accused] conceding the generic mitigating circumstances equivalent to the remaining aggravation, [426] condemns them, to a sentence of 26 years of imprisonment for KNOX and to a sentence of 25 years of imprisonment for SOLLECITO (base penalty for the reiteration, 24 years of imprisonment) and each of them to pay court costs and prison custody.
See my quote from the Massei report above...
 
You've already been proved wrong on this claim.




There is no evidence whatsoever that they bought any drugs that night (or at any time by Knox) nor was it ever claimed by the prosecution. Stop making things up.



Another false claim. Filomena testified that both she and Laura knew Meredith had the rent money because Meredith told them she could give it to them then. Filomena told her not to give to her then but later as they had until Nov. 5 to pay it. She also testified that she didn't know if Amanda had heard the conversation regarding the rent money or not.



ROTFLMAO! And so says Guede who had no motive to try and pin the murder on Amanda, right?

What makes more sense as to who stole the money? A girl with no history of theft or breaking the law (I don't count a noise ticket for a loud party), who had over $4400 in the bank (and more in Seattle) or an unemployed, broke loser desperate for rent money with a history of theft and other illegal acts? Think really hard and the answer might come to you Hint: it isn't Knox.

More flannel than a pair of pyjamas.

Filomena and Laura were cleared of being under suspicion because they both had an alibi that was sound, verified and true.

Wow. What in the world does this have to do with anything? Did I ever say or even suggest that either of them had anything to do with the murder? YOU claimed that only Amanda knew that Meredith had the rent money which was false as Filomena's court testimony proves. More Trumpery: divert from the topic. Either that or you have a serious reading comprehension problem

Raff was found, and as upheld by the most recent Supreme Court, to have (a) not just not having an alibi, but (b) providing a provably false one (evidence against him in itself).

And again, what does this have to do with who was more likely to have stolen the money? Diversion alert!

Amanda, as you know, is too scared to apply for compensation as she would get the same 'bums rush' as Raff.

I don't know that and neither do you. But again, what does this have to do with who was more likely to have stolen the money? Diversion alert!

Let's recap what Martuscelli, Masi and Flavi have to say:

No, let's not as, again, what does this have to do with who was more likely to have stolen the money? Guede or Amanda/Raffaele?
 
Surely the unemployed thief with his DNA on the purse didn't steal the money
 
You exhibit woefully poor understanding. The rent money element of the theft of Mez' property was dropped. Only the theft of the mobile phones was tried.

I wonder if you actually followed the case.

Fan worship is not a good method of assessing whether someone committed a crime.

Sigh. You have been quoted directly from the Massei MR which clearly states that Knox and Sollecito were charged with the theft of the rent money, two credit cards and the two cell phones:


(D)
with the felony to which articles 110 and 624 of the Criminal Code apply, because, in complicity amongst themselves, to procure an unjust profit for themselves, in the circumstances of time and place in which chapters (A) and (C) apply, took possession of a sum of approximately 300 Euros, two credit cards, from Abbeybank and Nationwide, both based in the United Kingdom, and two mobile phones, the property of MEREDITH

You have been quoted the verdict from said Massei MR that found the guilty verdict limited only to the cell phones:

FOR THESE REASONS
Under articles 533 and 535 of the Criminal Procedure Code
[this Court] Declares
KNOX Amanda Marie and SOLLECITO Raffaele guilty of the crimes ascribed to them under chapter A) of the charges, into said crime being absorbed the felony contested under chapter C), as well as [guilty] under chapter B), D) limited to the mobile phones and E) and, as far as regards KNOX Amanda Marie, additionally the crime she has been charged with under chapter F),

Exonerates the accused of the residual charge under chapter D) because it was not proven that the crime was committed.


READ and try to COMPREHEND. It doesn't get any clearer than this. You are WRONG.

And some people wonder why we find you so entertaining.
 
Last edited:
Let's recap what Martuscelli, Masi and Flavi have to say:

Florence 22 January 2017 Presiding Judge Dr. Silvia Martuscelli Reporting Judge Dr. Paola MASI Filed with Registry [the clerk of court] 10 February 2017 Antonio Bossa Clerk

This finding was upheld by the Supreme Court.

And around and around we go, where we stop nobody knows.

This is about the dozenth time you've cited Raffaele's compensation trial as somehow being relevant to the 2015 Supreme Court acquittals.

What has happened in the meantime with this effort on your part?

The last PMF guilter-website closed because of corrupted software code. And no one in Italy, no one, has picked up on the implications of what you imply above.

English language guilters are disappearing like newsprint journalism. But there's always you.
 
Consider the following:

She recalled that on the morning of November 2 she had taken a shower and had used the sink; she had not used the bidet. She cleaned her ears using a cotton swab. She didn’t remember having turned on the bathroom light. As for her own room, she hadn’t taken note of the missing table lamp. The main light didn’t work. In order to get dressed she didn’t need to turn on the light because it was late morning and natural light came in from the front balcony to her room. She doesn’t remember whether she opened the shutters. After becoming aware of the broken window, she checked in her own room to see if her computer was there and, since it was, she calmed down. She didn’t check to see whether other things, like money, were missing. She recalled that she had told her mother that she was worried ‚because there’s a knife at Raffaele’s.‛ She was worried because she didn’t know how to explain such a thing.


Innocent nonchalance. <fx whistles>

So, Mez was €300 poorer and Amanda was found to have in her possession...a similar sum in cash. There's a burglary, yet only Mez' possessions were targetted. Clearly, a burglar with something in for Mez.

Knox has told you loud and clear who dunnit. Believe her.

Surprise, surprise, she 'didn't need the light as natural light came in from the balcony'. That's convenient.

That explains how she 'didn't notice her lamp was missing' (actually, on the floor of Mez' room).
 
Last edited:
Surely the unemployed thief with his DNA on the purse didn't steal the money

Who would have thunk it? A bunch of racist fascist far right Italians, still in the thrall of Mussolini and Hitler (according to LoJo) sticking up not for the 'rich American girl' but.... <wait for it>....a Black guy from Africa.

All these migrants turning up by boat and the fascist scum find in favour of Rudy instead of a German-with-ex-Nazi-relatives.

The world has gone mad.
 
Sigh. You have been quoted directly from the Massei MR which clearly states that Knox and Sollecito were charged with the theft of the rent money, two credit cards and the two cell phones:




You have been quoted the verdict from said Massei MR that found the guilty verdict limited only to the cell phones:






READ and try to COMPREHEND. It doesn't get any clearer than this. You are WRONG.

And some people wonder why we find you so entertaining.

The rent money went before the court because that was what was listed by a court.

Only a court had the power to dismiss the charge. The charge re the rent money was dropped due to submissions by the prosecution they didn't want to proceed with it.

Clear now?
 
Consider the following:




Innocent nonchalance. <fx whistles>

So, Mez was €300 poorer and Amanda was found to have in her possession...a similar sum in cash. There's a burglary, yet only Mez' possessions were targetted. Clearly, a burglar with something in for Mez.

Knox has told you loud and clear who dunnit. Believe her.

Surprise, surprise, she 'didn't need the light as natural light came in from the balcony'. That's convenient.

That explains how she 'didn't notice her lamp was missing' (actually, on the floor of Mez' room).

For decency's sake, please stop referring to the victim of this crime by her familiar name.
 
Consider the following:

She recalled that on the morning of November 2 she had taken a shower and had used the sink; she had not used the bidet. She cleaned her ears using a cotton swab. She didn’t remember having turned on the bathroom light. As for her own room, she hadn’t taken note of the missing table lamp. The main light didn’t work. In order to get dressed she didn’t need to turn on the light because it was late morning and natural light came in from the front balcony to her room. She doesn’t remember whether she opened the shutters. After becoming aware of the broken window, she checked in her own room to see if her computer was there and, since it was, she calmed down. She didn’t check to see whether other things, like money, were missing. She recalled that she had told her mother that she was worried ‚because there’s a knife at Raffaele’s.‛ She was worried because she didn’t know how to explain such a thing.

The bit about not lookin for her money is not quite true. She said she didn't remember if she looked for the money or not as the computer was the important thing for her as it had all her documents on it. Besides, if she wanted to support a "fake" robbery, why not claim her money was gone? That would have been the logical thing to do.

So, Mez was €300 poorer and Amanda was found to have in her possession...a similar sum in cash.

Yes, Amanda had money on her at the time of her arrest several days later. Money which her bank records showed she'd recently withdrawn. Go figure she'd have her money on her. Who da thunk it?

There's a burglary, yet only Mez' possessions were targetted. Clearly, a burglar with something in for Mez.

Yep, a burglar, desperate for money, quickly stole what was immediately at hand right next to the body of the woman he'd just sexually assaulted and murdered. That he didn't stick around taking time to go look for something else to steal in case one of 3 other roommates might come home is illogical in your world?

Knox has told you loud and clear who dunnit. Believe her.


Oh, I do! I do! She has told us it was Rudy Guede. And so does the evidence.
 
Last edited:
For decency's sake, please stop advocating that two clearly guilty parties should get away with a despicable crime.

We've returned to grade school. Given that it is your position that those two claims are equivalent and given that you believe RS and AK are guilty, you've in effect agreed to do the decent thing and start addressing the victim of this crime respectfully.
 
Who would have thunk it? A bunch of racist fascist far right Italians, still in the thrall of Mussolini and Hitler (according to LoJo) sticking up not for the 'rich American girl' but.... <wait for it>....a Black guy from Africa.

All these migrants turning up by boat and the fascist scum find in favour of Rudy instead of a German-with-ex-Nazi-relatives.

The world has gone mad.

Well, all the evidence against Guede might have had a little something to do with his being found guilty. Sheesh.

Vixen;12389630The rent money went before the court because that was what was listed by a court.

Well , DUH! The charges against the accused generally go before the court. By George, I think you've got it.

Only a court had the power to dismiss the charge. The charge re the rent money was dropped due to submissions by the prosecution they didn't want to proceed with it.

Would you like to present some actual evidence that the charges were dropped? You know, like a document or testimony or something? Anything? No? I thought not. Pardon me if I don't just take your unsupported word for it.

Clear now?

What is clear is that you have no evidence of your claims and simply cannot admit being wrong.

Well, Rudy suddenly had €250 to offer Kokomani for the loan of his car that evening.

KOKOMANI? He of the black plastic garbage bad and olive throwing defense? BWAAAAHAAAHAAAAHAAAAHAAAAA!!! This just keeps getting better and better.
 
Last edited:
Who would have thunk it? A bunch of racist fascist far right Italians, still in the thrall of Mussolini and Hitler (according to LoJo) sticking up not for the 'rich American girl' but.... <wait for it>....a Black guy from Africa.

All these migrants turning up by boat and the fascist scum find in favour of Rudy instead of a German-with-ex-Nazi-relatives.

The world has gone mad.

I guess you're forgetting that they only arrested Amanda to get to their #1 suspect, African immigrant Patrick, for the crime of being a "dirty black that deserved the electric chair" while part of Meredith's social circle.
 
Who would have thunk it? A bunch of racist fascist far right Italians, still in the thrall of Mussolini and Hitler (according to LoJo) sticking up not for the 'rich American girl' but.... <wait for it>....a Black guy from Africa.

All these migrants turning up by boat and the fascist scum find in favour of Rudy instead of a German-with-ex-Nazi-relatives.The world has gone mad.

What court "found in favor of Guede"? When did they acquit Guede? Oh...and you forget that the Italians were allies of those very same Nazis. Not that your comment has jack you-know-what to do with anything.

I guess you're forgetting that they only arrested Amanda to get to their #1 suspect, African immigrant Patrick, for the crime of being a "dirty black that deserved the electric chair" while part of Meredith's social circle.

LOL!!
 
Last edited:
For decency's sake, please stop advocating that two clearly guilty parties should get away with a despicable crime.


???

The clearly-guilty party did not get away with it. He got convicted.

The people to whom you refer are factually and legally not guilty, and are almost certainly factually innocent.

Clear now?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom