The Trials of Amanda Knox and Raffaele Sollecito: Part 28

Status
Not open for further replies.
Oh they'll almost certainly try once again with "We simply called Knox in for a friendly chat to see if she had further information that could help our investigation, and then she simply blurted out the accusation against Lumumba out of nowhere!".

As (apparently) incorrect as the above scenario is*, the interesting thing IMO will be how they try to address what happened next. After all, even if the above scenario truly had occurred, Italian law dictated that the police should immediately have terminated the interview, appraised Knox of her rights, got her a lawyer, and from then on only the PM could interview her and only in the presence of her lawyer. What they absolutely could/should not have done in the aftermath of her verbal "confession/accusation" was type up her statement and get her to sign it - all without having been informed of her rights or being given access to legal counsel.


* IMO there is very strong evidence to suggest that in fact Knox was coerced - almost certainly unlawfully - into naming Lumumba as the killer. This evidence takes the form of a) the court testimony of the "interpreter" Donnino (which can only support the idea that the police were instructing Knox to "remember" certain events); b) the revealing "eventually (Knox) buckled and told us what we already knew to be correct" words of Perugia Police Chief De Felice to reporters the following day; and c) the consistent account of Knox herself.

...d) the SMS exchange with Lumumba, which the police incorrectly interpreted as Amanda meeting up with Lumumba that night - evidence that it was the police and not Amanda who brought Lumumba into the discussion.

Also the Gemelli CSC panel judgment, the Hellmann appeal court judgment, and the Boninsegna first-instance judgment, all of which stated - or, in the case of Hellmann, implied - that Knox's defense rights had been violated.

One task for the Italian government, if it wishes to defend itself in the case, is to provide a rational, reasonable, and honest explanation, based on evidence, and not in violation of the European Convention of Human Rights or ECHR case-law, of why Knox's statements from the interrogation could be used against her for the charge of calunnia while they could not, according to Gemelli, be used against her otherwise.
 
Last edited:
In terms of ECHR procedures: the ECHR only announces matters such as decisions of admissibility or inadmissibility when it actually publishes such information. The Registry will not provide any non-published information on such matters.

Furthermore, the admissibility or inadmissibility for each claim in an application which reaches the stage of Communication to the respondent state (Italy, for Knox v. Italy) may be published with the merits in the judgment. If a Communicated case is found to be inadmissible for each of its claims, typically a decision on the case is published in HUDOC.

For the Communicated case Knox v. Italy, neither a judgment nor a decision has yet been published, so the case remains pending. There are thousands of such pending cases before the ECHR. The ECHR states that 55,600 applications were pending as of 30 April 2018.

Knox v. Italy remains a "Noteworthy pending case" summarized in the Country Profile for Italy (see p. 13). That summary reads:

"Amanda Marie Knox v. Italy (no. 76577/13)
Case communicated to the parties in April 2016
This case concerns criminal proceedings in which Ms Knox was found guilty of making a false accusation. The offending statements were taken while she was being questioned in the context of criminal proceedings for the murder and sexual assault of her flatmate. The applicant was accused of implicating another person whom she knew to be innocent.
Ms Knox alleges that the criminal proceedings in which she was convicted were unfair, relying on Article 6 §§ 1 and 3 (a) (right to a fair trial – right to be informed promptly of the charge), (c) (right to legal assistance), (e) (right to assistance from an interpreter), Article 3 (prohibition of inhuman and degrading treatment) and Article 8 (right to respect for private and family life) of the Convention."
 
Since "pending" means "awaiting its turn" and does not mean "dead in the water" or "failed", one must wonder to what audience the guilters are directing their misrepresentations of the ECHR case Knox v. Italy.

Perhaps this misrepresentation by the guilters is some kind of tribal, in-group rallying cry - cheerleading intended to boost the spirits of the guilters, whose arguments have been shown to be entirely invalid and thus defeated, and who can only expect future defeats of their invalid and preposterous arguments.
 
NEWSFLASH: Application still dead in the water

E-mail from the European Court regarding Knox v. Italy application no. 76577/13 which was lodged with the Court on 23/11/2013.
Dear Sir,
Thank you for your message and please find here the information we can provide in response.
1. Both parties’ observations have been received by the Court’s Registry.
2. No decision as to the admissibility of the application has been taken yet.
We hope this helps.
With best wishes,
ECHR – Press Unit

Source: Ergon

Fresh from the "exactly similar" debacle....

Fresh from the news reports from Rocco Sollecito's Italian funeral mass which never happened....

Vixen just keeps on with her guilt-PR campaign with more nonsense.

When caught in a lie, the first rule of the guilt PR-campaign is to simply move on to the next one with no comment about the "still fresh" whoppers.

** Apologies for the split infinitive. I'm a Star Trek fan.
 
Fresh from the "exactly similar" debacle....

Fresh from the news reports from Rocco Sollecito's Italian funeral mass which never happened....

Vixen just keeps on with her guilt-PR campaign with more nonsense.

When caught in a lie, the first rule of the guilt PR-campaign is to simply move on to the next one with no comment about the "still fresh" whoppers.

** Apologies for the split infinitive. I'm a Star Trek fan.

This came from Ergon, who is behind the bogus 'collage' of photos intended to mislead people into thinking there had been a mass for Rocco Sollecito and with Francesco attending. Ergon and his minions are desperate. They have been wrong at every turn. The only thing they have left is to hope the ECHR doesn't rule in Amanda's favor and you can be sure as long as it's still pending they will try to spin things in a desperate effort to rally the troops.

I wouldn't be too hard on Vixen... none of this 'stuff' is hers. She's just waving the pom pom's and being a good little cheerleader. Ergon and Quennell continue to be the architects behind the guilt-PR campaign.
 
This came from Ergon, who is behind the bogus 'collage' of photos intended to mislead people into thinking there had been a mass for Rocco Sollecito and with Francesco attending. Ergon and his minions are desperate. They have been wrong at every turn. The only thing they have left is to hope the ECHR doesn't rule in Amanda's favor and you can be sure as long as it's still pending they will try to spin things in a desperate effort to rally the troops.

I wouldn't be too hard on Vixen... none of this 'stuff' is hers. She's just waving the pom pom's and being a good little cheerleader. Ergon and Quennell continue to be the architects behind the guilt-PR campaign.

The problem with some PGP is that they believe everything that Quennell, Ergon and the rest of the "Main Contributors" on TJMK claim. They do little, if any, research of their own to verify those claims. They just regurgitate whatever they read on TJMK. It would take a little effort on their part but they could just as easily have found what we did:

1. No evidence of RS ever owning or wearing a Napapijri jacket or red stripe
cap has ever been produced.
2. RS is right-,not left-, handed.
3. AK returned to the US on a regularly scheduled flight, not chartered.
4. No evidence of FS or RS being mafia related was ever produced.
5. No evidence of FS or RS being closely related to Rocco Sollecito was ever produced.
6. No memorial for Rocco S. was actually held.
7. Francesco S never attended the non-existent memorial.
8. The photo alleged to prove he was there was taken years before in Perugia.
9. No evidence of RS "hanging out with mafioso" in the Dominican Republic was ever produced.
10. No evidence of Jovana Popovic's testimony being false was ever produced.
11. No evidence that Jovana's mother was a friend of, or even acquainted with, Vanessa Sollecito was ever produced.
12.No evidence that Vanessa Sollecito was fired from the Carabinieri for "tampering with the evidence" was ever produced.
13. No evidence that "Papa Sollecito... (falsely) provided his boy with an alibi" was ever produced.

I could add more examples but why bother? The TJMK crowd will continue to make false claims and their (few remaining) fans will continue to swallow them hook, line, and sinker.
 
Last edited:
Fresh from the "exactly similar" debacle....

Fresh from the news reports from Rocco Sollecito's Italian funeral mass which never happened....

Vixen just keeps on with her guilt-PR campaign with more nonsense.

When caught in a lie, the first rule of the guilt PR-campaign is to simply move on to the next one with no comment about the "still fresh" whoppers.** Apologies for the split infinitive. I'm a Star Trek fan.

When asked to provide evidence for a claim, the second rule of the guilt PR-campaign is to claim it's not their job, that the person requesting the evidence is just too lazy to look it up themselves, that "it's common knowledge", or that they just "shan't".
 
Last edited:
** Apologies for the split infinitive. I'm a Star Trek fan.

No need to apologize. The no split infinitive rule is an utterly stupid "rule" whose idiocy is bottomless. The braindead subhuman cretins who devised the rule ages and ages ago should be treated with complete and utter contempt. The rule is in other words total bull-*. It should be buried in the past along with other atrocities.
 
Did the cops who arrested Amanda Knox really smell something from her, as they claimed?

A crime writer believes a killer can give off an 'evil smell'.

Former marine Berry-Dee has written a new book called Talking with Female Serial Killers after meeting them all over the world.

He told the Mirror: 'Dennehy was, without doubt, the most evil person I have ever met', and is 'streets ahead' of Aileen Wuornos, who murdered seven men in Florida between 1989 and 1990 by shooting them at point-blank range.

'Well-spoken' serial killer Dennehy has put on a lot of weight in jail, he said.

She appeared to threaten him by getting her face as close to his as possible and staring at him without blinking.

He added: 'I could smell evil coming off her - it’s a smell like no other so it’s impossible to describe but it’s acrid and dirty'.
 
Italy's laughably incompetent attempts to run its own country (no government since March, serial failures to form a govt, the latest attempt involving appointing a (literal) joker as PM and seeing what he could do (he couldn't do anything and resigned yesterday...), the President intervening to block the installation of certain individuals into certain cabinet posts, in a probable breach of the Constitution) is a fairly good pointer towards the incompetence, ineptitude and reactionary patronage which riddles its criminal justice system.

For a long time now, Italy's executive and legislature have - for a variety of reasons - been apparently unable to draft and pass appropriate legislation for criminal justice, and they have been similarly incapable of setting up appropriate bodies (with appropriate and enforceable powers) to regulate the criminal justice system and hold it properly to account. Italy is a failing country by pretty much every metric. And the Knox/Sollecito trial process is merely a window into one part of that failure - because not only was the Knox/Sollecito trial process the story of just one inept, egomaniacal, (improperly and unlawfully) resolute prosecutor, an unlawful group of police officers, an inept and partisan forensics collector/analyst (with an inept team), and inept and unlawful convicting courts.... it was also the product of systemic, institutionalised failings and problems within the system.
 
Did the cops who arrested Amanda Knox really smell something from her, as they claimed?

A crime writer believes a killer can give off an 'evil smell'.

This thread went three days without a post, and THIS is what breaks the silence?

I now seriously believe that Vixen is a PIP-false-flag operation designed to make the guilter-PR campaign look looney toons.

ETA - the stoopid cop did not say anyone smelled like evil, they said that someone smelled like sex. Just when we thought it could not get any more stoopid, Vixen comes up with this - while on other posts denying that world-renowned forensic-DNA experts have called the DNA case against RS and AK total bollucks.

Yup, that's how the guilter-PR campaign rolls.
 
Last edited:
Oh dear. Seriously? SERIOUSLY?

(And I believe SomeAlibi is the go-to guy round here for bogus pseudoscientific "smell test" crap.........)

If the case against Amanda and Raffaele was such a slam dunk and there was a a mountain of evidence, why do PGP over a decade after Meredith's murder have to resort to ludicrous arguments which reek of desperation such as claiming evil can be detected through smell.
 
Did the cops who arrested Amanda Knox really smell something from her, as they claimed?

A crime writer believes a killer can give off an 'evil smell'

Former marine Berry-Dee has written a new book called Talking with Female Serial Killers after meeting them all over the world.

He told the Mirror: 'Dennehy was, without doubt, the most evil person I have ever met', and is 'streets ahead' of Aileen Wuornos, who murdered seven men in Florida between 1989 and 1990 by shooting them at point-blank range.

'Well-spoken' serial killer Dennehy has put on a lot of weight in jail, he said.

She appeared to threaten him by getting her face as close to his as possible and staring at him without blinking.

He added: 'I could smell evil coming off her - it’s a smell like no other so it’s impossible to describe but it’s acrid and dirty'.
http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/art...Joanna-Dennehy-threatened-kill-Rose-West.html.

ROTFLMAO! You begin your first post in several days with not only a ridiculous post but a lie as well. The cops who arrested Amanda never said they smelled anything coming from her. This stupidity may work on fellow "we'll believe anything negative about Knox no matter how ludicrous" PGP, but not on anyone who actually knows this case and has more than half a brain.

Barbie Nadeau claimed to have been told by a crime reporter named Carmignani who, in turn, claimed he had been told by unidentified police on Nov.2 that Knox "smelled of sex". Yet, not a single person who was in close physical contact with Amanda verified this claim. Not Battistelli, Marsi, Romanelli, Grande, Altieri, or Zaroli who were at the cottage. Not the Carabinieri who where there. Not the cops at the police station. Not Mignini. Not Sophie Purton or any of the other "British birds". Can you guess why that might be, Vixen? Think real hard.
 
Last edited:
ROTFLMAO! You begin your first post in several days with not only a ridiculous post but a lie as well. The cops who arrested Amanda never said they smelled anything coming from her. This stupidity may work on fellow "we'll believe anything negative about Knox no matter how ludicrous" PGP, but not on anyone who actually knows this case and has more than half a brain.

Barbie Nadeau claimed to have been told by a crime reporter named Carmignani who, in turn, claimed he had been told by unidentified police on Nov.2 that Knox "smelled of sex". Yet, not a single person who was in close physical contact with Amanda verified this claim. Not Battistelli, Marsi, Romanelli, Grande, Altieri, or Zaroli who were at the cottage. Not the Carabinieri who where there. Not the cops at the police station. Not Mignini. Not Sophie Purton or any of the other "British birds". Can you guess why that might be, Vixen? Think real hard.

For the olfactory-challenged, just what does "sex" smell like? Cheap wine?
 
For the olfactory-challenged, just what does "sex" smell like? Cheap wine?

And this coming from cops who couldn't tell the difference between bleach and lysoform.

In the pic taken of Amanda's room on Nov. 4, there is a green bath towel hanging over the back of a chair as if to dry. You know...like someone had taken a shower earlier. Oh, I know! Amanda placed it there to make it look like she had taken a shower. Clever girl! She just thought of everything except, you know...removing the bathmat with "Raff's" bloody foot print and the pillowcase with "her" bloody shoeprint.:jaw-dropp

https://www.google.com/search?hl=en...u2BKg#imgrc=cM2scsotspmlCM:&spf=1527548128959
 
This was a seminar held in Italy 2017 hosted by Italian science institutions regarding how the scientific police in the Kercher case screwed up:

Seminar: When the science is wrong. The murder of Meredith Kercher

The chain of custody is decisive for the correct acquisition of the trial source in trial and for the genuineness of its analysis. Unfortunately, in Italy there is a strong delay in understanding its importance, often affirmed only in words.

The seminar will analyze in depth the concept of chain of custody, seizure and acquisition, with reference to the various sources of evidence (physical and digital), comparing different forensic systems (USA, UK, etc.).

If it is important to learn the correct investigative methodologies, it is equally important to analyze the mistakes made by others, which can be avoided. The case of Perugia, the world of criminalistics (forensics) plays an important role in this sense. Through the analysis of the inspection carried out in the house where the English student was killed, errors and "malpractice" of the intervening police officers will be highlighted. Finally, the concept of "defensive investigation" will be examined, showing the role it played in bringing about the acquittal of Amanda Knox and Raffaele Sollecito.

http://www.ancrim.it/files/24-mag-2017-Quando-la-scientifica-sbaglia---Omicidio-Meredith-Kercher.pdf
 
Originally Posted by Vixen View Post
Did the cops who arrested Amanda Knox really smell something from her, as they claimed?

A crime writer believes a killer can give off an 'evil smell'.
I doubt this is true. But even if it was, it is objectively useless.

There are many, many studies proving that killers give off an 'evil smell'. They were done by the same scientific groups that proved cops have a higher than average ability to tell when people are lying, cops' "gut instincts" are incredibly accurate, you can tell a person's innocence or guilt by their eyes and that people never, ever confess to something they didn't do or isn't true unless they are physically tortured, under age 18, or mentally challenged.

Oh, wait....
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom