Oh they'll almost certainly try once again with "We simply called Knox in for a friendly chat to see if she had further information that could help our investigation, and then she simply blurted out the accusation against Lumumba out of nowhere!".
As (apparently) incorrect as the above scenario is*, the interesting thing IMO will be how they try to address what happened next. After all, even if the above scenario truly had occurred, Italian law dictated that the police should immediately have terminated the interview, appraised Knox of her rights, got her a lawyer, and from then on only the PM could interview her and only in the presence of her lawyer. What they absolutely could/should not have done in the aftermath of her verbal "confession/accusation" was type up her statement and get her to sign it - all without having been informed of her rights or being given access to legal counsel.
* IMO there is very strong evidence to suggest that in fact Knox was coerced - almost certainly unlawfully - into naming Lumumba as the killer. This evidence takes the form of a) the court testimony of the "interpreter" Donnino (which can only support the idea that the police were instructing Knox to "remember" certain events); b) the revealing "eventually (Knox) buckled and told us what we already knew to be correct" words of Perugia Police Chief De Felice to reporters the following day; and c) the consistent account of Knox herself.
...d) the SMS exchange with Lumumba, which the police incorrectly interpreted as Amanda meeting up with Lumumba that night - evidence that it was the police and not Amanda who brought Lumumba into the discussion.
Also the Gemelli CSC panel judgment, the Hellmann appeal court judgment, and the Boninsegna first-instance judgment, all of which stated - or, in the case of Hellmann, implied - that Knox's defense rights had been violated.
One task for the Italian government, if it wishes to defend itself in the case, is to provide a rational, reasonable, and honest explanation, based on evidence, and not in violation of the European Convention of Human Rights or ECHR case-law, of why Knox's statements from the interrogation could be used against her for the charge of calunnia while they could not, according to Gemelli, be used against her otherwise.
Last edited:
