The Trials of Amanda Knox and Raffaele Sollecito: Part 28

Status
Not open for further replies.
This was a seminar held in Italy 2017 hosted by Italian science institutions regarding how the scientific police in the Kercher case screwed up:



http://www.ancrim.it/files/24-mag-2017-Quando-la-scientifica-sbaglia---Omicidio-Meredith-Kercher.pdf


Very interesting. Especially as this seminar was held under the auspices of (among others) the Italian Institute of Forensic Sciences and the (Italian) National Association of Criminologists and Criminalists ("ANCRIM"). The former is primarily involved in advancing education and best practice in the field, while - very interestingly - the latter is a government-recognised body for regulation and accountability of the forensic science field in Italy*.

So - in spite of the ongoing howls-into-the-well of pro-guilt commentators, even Italy's relevant professional and regulatory bodies know that there were serious errors (including "malpractice") in the way forensic evidence was collected, transported, stored, analysed, interpreted and presented in the Knox/Sollecito trial process. Something that was also realised and concluded very long ago by any critical thinker with a) an understanding of the scientific method and b) even a rudimentary understanding of the relevant forensics protocols/procedures relevant to this case.

Everyone knows that police and forensic scientists the world over can and do make mistakes (sometimes serious mistakes, and occasionally deliberate malpractice). But what genuinely takes one's breath away with regard to the Knox/Sollecito case is/was: 1) the sheer magnitude of the errors across the board - from incompetent collection of forensic evidence which immediately massively compromised its integrity, through jaw-dropping ineptitude in transportation and storage of evidence, through to wholly improper suspect-centric analysis and interpretation, in a lab which was fundamentally unfit for purpose, and in which even the most basic requisite protocols and processes were never followed; and 2) the repeated and ongoing lying/dissembling/misdirection by the lead forensic analyst and prosecutors - by denying that mistakes were ever even made, by wilfully trying to cover up serious mistakes, by repeated attempts at misdirection, and by flat-out lies in court. Astonishing. And massively unjust.




* From the ANCRIM website (my translation, and my bolding for emphasis):

The National Association of Criminologists and Criminalists is a non-profit professional association that aims to achieve the broadest regulatory and social recognition of the roles of the criminologist and the criminalist, and to enhance the professionalism of its members according to European, national and regional laws in force, while facilitating the choice and protection of operatives in compliance with the rules about competition.
 
There are many, many studies proving that killers give off an 'evil smell'. They were done by the same scientific groups that proved cops have a higher than average ability to tell when people are lying, cops' "gut instincts" are incredibly accurate, you can tell a person's innocence or guilt by their eyes and that people never, ever confess to something they didn't do or isn't true unless they are physically tortured, under age 18, or mentally challenged.

Oh, wait....



No, but Sherlock Holmes could solve crimes - with 100% accuracy and reliability - by intuition alone! So if Holmes could do it, surely so could fellow sleuthing geniuses such as Mignini and Giobbi! Surely!!

Oh...... what's that? Holmes was purely a fictional construct, operating in a fictional universe where he could do whatever the writer wanted him to do? Ahhhh........


(Which reminds me: I think I'll write a series of detective novels in which my sleuthing hero can solve every crime simply by looking into each potential suspect's left eye while simultaneously holding their right thumb - he'll have discovered that this is a fail-safe way of assessing factual guilt or non-guilt instantaneously. And then I'll definitely expect real-life police detectives to start to adopt this same approach to identifying suspects and solving crimes ;) )
 
We all know that a young, fit man could not possibly have pulled himself up to Filomena's bedroom window. It's just impossible. Therefore, this video of a young man from Mali saving a baby dangling from an upper story balcony by pulling himself up must be "bent" and/or the young man is just a shill for someone:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ZEqWh6fl_sA
 
No, but Sherlock Holmes could solve crimes - with 100% accuracy and reliability - by intuition alone! So if Holmes could do it, surely so could fellow sleuthing geniuses such as Mignini and Giobbi! Surely!!

Oh...... what's that? Holmes was purely a fictional construct, operating in a fictional universe where he could do whatever the writer wanted him to do? Ahhhh........


(Which reminds me: I think I'll write a series of detective novels in which my sleuthing hero can solve every crime simply by looking into each potential suspect's left eye while simultaneously holding their right thumb - he'll have discovered that this is a fail-safe way of assessing factual guilt or non-guilt instantaneously. And then I'll definitely expect real-life police detectives to start to adopt this same approach to identifying suspects and solving crimes ;) )

Just think! You could be the next Nick van der Leek! Maybe someone here could edit it for you. Hmmmm… let me think who that might be....:confused:
 
ROTFLMAO! You begin your first post in several days with not only a ridiculous post but a lie as well. The cops who arrested Amanda never said they smelled anything coming from her. This stupidity may work on fellow "we'll believe anything negative about Knox no matter how ludicrous" PGP, but not on anyone who actually knows this case and has more than half a brain.

Barbie Nadeau claimed to have been told by a crime reporter named Carmignani who, in turn, claimed he had been told by unidentified police on Nov.2 that Knox "smelled of sex". Yet, not a single person who was in close physical contact with Amanda verified this claim. Not Battistelli, Marsi, Romanelli, Grande, Altieri, or Zaroli who were at the cottage. Not the Carabinieri who where there. Not the cops at the police station. Not Mignini. Not Sophie Purton or any of the other "British birds". Can you guess why that might be, Vixen? Think real hard.

For the olfactory-challenged, just what does "sex" smell like? Cheap wine?

Let's just say for argument sakes, that someone could smell sex from Amanda. How is that incriminating? Does it offer any insight at all to the case? If you think it does, you're an idiot.

Far more likely, this is part of the narrative of the story someone wants to tell. The beginning of the press slutifying Amanda Knox. Sex and murder sells millions of books. Mundane interrupting a burglary, not so much.
 
Last edited:
We all know that a young, fit man could not possibly have pulled himself up to Filomena's bedroom window. It's just impossible. Therefore, this video of a young man from Mali saving a baby dangling from an upper story balcony by pulling himself up must be "bent" and/or the young man is just a shill for someone:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ZEqWh6fl_sA

Great link. That guy easily scaled 4 floors in under 20 seconds!
 
I suspect either Carmignani or the police (whom he claims told him this. Who knows if anyone actually did) were just enjoying a bit of salacious gossip. But leave it to the PGP to think it's a proven fact that it even happened.
 
We all know that a young, fit man could not possibly have pulled himself up to Filomena's bedroom window. It's just impossible. Therefore, this video of a young man from Mali saving a baby dangling from an upper story balcony by pulling himself up must be "bent" and/or the young man is just a shill for someone:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ZEqWh6fl_sA

Yes, but if you look closely you can see he scuffs the 3rd floor railing and, had one been present, he surely would have bent a protruding nail. Fine forensic analysis requires a keen eye.
 
This was a seminar held in Italy 2017 hosted by Italian science institutions regarding how the scientific police in the Kercher case screwed up:



http://www.ancrim.it/files/24-mag-2017-Quando-la-scientifica-sbaglia---Omicidio-Meredith-Kercher.pdf

This puts the following comment by Vixen in perspective;

Vixen said:
Absolute nonsense: the Italian Scientific Police followed ENSFI standards.

Stop insulting a team of highly qualified competent scientists who've entered the police forensics team as amongst the best of their generation.

Their aim is to produce objective result. They could not care less about the nonentity 'personalities' involved, nor would they succumb to threats to their objectivity.

ETA: I wonder if there was anything published as a result of this seminar. I would really like to read their analysis of the investigation.
 
Last edited:
ROTFLMAO! You begin your first post in several days with not only a ridiculous post but a lie as well. The cops who arrested Amanda never said they smelled anything coming from her. This stupidity may work on fellow "we'll believe anything negative about Knox no matter how ludicrous" PGP, but not on anyone who actually knows this case and has more than half a brain.

Barbie Nadeau claimed to have been told by a crime reporter named Carmignani who, in turn, claimed he had been told by unidentified police on Nov.2 that Knox "smelled of sex". Yet, not a single person who was in close physical contact with Amanda verified this claim. Not Battistelli, Marsi, Romanelli, Grande, Altieri, or Zaroli who were at the cottage. Not the Carabinieri who where there. Not the cops at the police station. Not Mignini. Not Sophie Purton or any of the other "British birds". Can you guess why that might be, Vixen? Think real hard.


What? The claim was she smelt of 'cat pee' (you have sex on the brain). If you have ever smelt a tom cat, you'll understand just how rancid this is, especially bearing in mind, she claimed to have had two showers in the last 24 hours with lots of Raff scrubbing her all over, including cottom buds for her ears.
 
Mach claimed he could smell the evil off people as well.

Too bad none of Ted Bundy's 30 victims could smell it coming. They didn't have Mach's or Vixen's nose I suppose.

This sort of weird hyper-personalization is definitely a trait of objective rationality and not a trait of being on a witch hunt. Rofl
 
What? The claim was she smelt of 'cat pee' (you have sex on the brain). If you have ever smelt a tom cat, you'll understand just how rancid this is, especially bearing in mind, she claimed to have had two showers in the last 24 hours with lots of Raff scrubbing her all over, including cottom buds for her ears.
Oh, that's right. She smelled like cat pee because she was on cocaine and anyone taking enough coke to smell like cat whiz winds up murdering their roommate.
 
No, just you and BiWi enjoying salacious gossip.

The gossip comes from you and I do not enjoy it.

Care to comment on a forensic conference in Italy which cites the Kercher murder investigation as the way not to do DNA forensics?

I thought not.
 
What? The claim was she smelt of 'cat pee' (you have sex on the brain). If you have ever smelt a tom cat, you'll understand just how rancid this is, especially bearing in mind, she claimed to have had two showers in the last 24 hours with lots of Raff scrubbing her all over, including cottom buds for her ears.

First of all, let me just opine that this is an utterly stupid subject, even by your own standards.

Second, in what universe does the word of an author getting it from another author who got it from an "unidentified" source carry even the slightest semblance of credibility.

Third, you were actually onto something but then you let your bias keep you from making even the most basic of observations. As you noted, Amanda claims to have showered twice, the most recent being just hours early. So if she reeked, as you so eagerly want to believe, wouldn't the prosecution have called witnesses to testify that she reeked and prove she was lying about taking a shower? That they didn't either proves this is a bogus claim or it further proves the incompetence of the police. Take your pick.

Finally, you quote the author, Berry-Dee, as saying "I could smell evil coming off her - it’s a smell like no other so it’s impossible to describe but it’s acrid and dirty". However, you also say police claimed Amanda "smelt of cat pee". I can assure you that cat pee, while rather horrible, does not smell like "no other". It's a very common smell and I'm sure if Berry-Dee meant to say 'evil smells like cat pee' then that is what he would have wrote.

I agree with Stacy - three days and this was the best you could come up with?
 
What? The claim was she smelt of 'cat pee' (you have sex on the brain). If you have ever smelt a tom cat, you'll understand just how rancid this is, especially bearing in mind, she claimed to have had two showers in the last 24 hours with lots of Raff scrubbing her all over, including cottom buds for her ears.

I assure you no one can smell evil. If you buy that, you will buy anything. You also cannot credibly prove that anyone smelled cat pee either. It's really sad that you would find that worth considering, much less repeating.
 
Did the cops who arrested Amanda Knox really smell something from her, as they claimed?

A crime writer believes a killer can give off an 'evil smell'.

ROTFLMAO! You begin your first post in several days with not only a ridiculous post but a lie as well. The cops who arrested Amanda never said they smelled anything coming from her. This stupidity may work on fellow "we'll believe anything negative about Knox no matter how ludicrous" PGP, but not on anyone who actually knows this case and has more than half a brain.

Barbie Nadeau claimed to have been told by a crime reporter named Carmignani who, in turn, claimed he had been told by unidentified police on Nov.2 that Knox "smelled of sex". Yet, not a single person who was in close physical contact with Amanda verified this claim. Not Battistelli, Marsi, Romanelli, Grande, Altieri, or Zaroli who were at the cottage. Not the Carabinieri who where there. Not the cops at the police station. Not Mignini. Not Sophie Purton or any of the other "British birds". Can you guess why that might be, Vixen? Think real hard.

What? The claim was she smelt of 'cat pee' (you have sex on the brain). If you have ever smelt a tom cat, you'll understand just how rancid this is, especially bearing in mind, she claimed to have had two showers in the last 24 hours with lots of Raff scrubbing her all over, including cottom buds for her ears.

Sigh. Do try and get the story straight:

Carmignani, who knew all the cops by name, broke away from the gaggle on the roof and sauntered down to the crime scene. The police confided to him some observations that never got to court. For example, police said Amanda’s body odor contradicted her claim that she’d just showered; she smelled like sex.

Nadeau, Barbie Latza. Angel Face: Sex, Murder and the Inside Story of Amanda Knox (S.55-56). Perseus Books Group. Kindle-Version.

Like I said, a LIE. No police ever said Knox smelled of cat urine. That lie is straight from you and the likes of Quennell who invented the body odor/sex smell = cat urine/cocaine use nonsense:

Hair tests for drugs are not too wonderful and nobody can say Knox was drug-free based on that. Let her explain the many symptoms - the smell of cat urine, the extreme highs and lows, the frequent giggles and depressions, the conniptions at the questura.
Posted by Peter Quennell on 07/31/14 at 08:44 PM

See below. We’ve actually had emails from ex amphetamine users (yes there are some) saying the look was a classic example of an amphetamine high (coke or crystal meth) which is what all the cops presumed it was.

We’ve never had anyone say that was the look of someone who smoked a little marijuana - although skunk can have strange effects.

And Knox’s smell was extremely telling, that cat urine smell is distinctive and wont go away, take 10 showers and it will still be there.
Posted by Peter Quennell on 07/31/14 at 10:54 PM

The police never said a word about Amanda smelling like cat pee... which is why you cannot provide evidence of it. It's just another lie. You need to stop believing everything you read on TJMK.
 
Last edited:
I assure you no one can smell evil. If you buy that, you will buy anything. You also cannot credibly prove that anyone smelled cat pee either. It's really sad that you would find that worth considering, much less repeating.

No, that's just Vixen enjoying some salacious gossip lies.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom