LondonJohn
Penultimate Amazing
- Joined
- May 12, 2010
- Messages
- 21,467
This was a seminar held in Italy 2017 hosted by Italian science institutions regarding how the scientific police in the Kercher case screwed up:
http://www.ancrim.it/files/24-mag-2017-Quando-la-scientifica-sbaglia---Omicidio-Meredith-Kercher.pdf
Very interesting. Especially as this seminar was held under the auspices of (among others) the Italian Institute of Forensic Sciences and the (Italian) National Association of Criminologists and Criminalists ("ANCRIM"). The former is primarily involved in advancing education and best practice in the field, while - very interestingly - the latter is a government-recognised body for regulation and accountability of the forensic science field in Italy*.
So - in spite of the ongoing howls-into-the-well of pro-guilt commentators, even Italy's relevant professional and regulatory bodies know that there were serious errors (including "malpractice") in the way forensic evidence was collected, transported, stored, analysed, interpreted and presented in the Knox/Sollecito trial process. Something that was also realised and concluded very long ago by any critical thinker with a) an understanding of the scientific method and b) even a rudimentary understanding of the relevant forensics protocols/procedures relevant to this case.
Everyone knows that police and forensic scientists the world over can and do make mistakes (sometimes serious mistakes, and occasionally deliberate malpractice). But what genuinely takes one's breath away with regard to the Knox/Sollecito case is/was: 1) the sheer magnitude of the errors across the board - from incompetent collection of forensic evidence which immediately massively compromised its integrity, through jaw-dropping ineptitude in transportation and storage of evidence, through to wholly improper suspect-centric analysis and interpretation, in a lab which was fundamentally unfit for purpose, and in which even the most basic requisite protocols and processes were never followed; and 2) the repeated and ongoing lying/dissembling/misdirection by the lead forensic analyst and prosecutors - by denying that mistakes were ever even made, by wilfully trying to cover up serious mistakes, by repeated attempts at misdirection, and by flat-out lies in court. Astonishing. And massively unjust.
* From the ANCRIM website (my translation, and my bolding for emphasis):
The National Association of Criminologists and Criminalists is a non-profit professional association that aims to achieve the broadest regulatory and social recognition of the roles of the criminologist and the criminalist, and to enhance the professionalism of its members according to European, national and regional laws in force, while facilitating the choice and protection of operatives in compliance with the rules about competition.