The Trials of Amanda Knox and Raffaele Sollecito: Part 28

Status
Not open for further replies.
I see the posts constantly from the PGP that say that Marasca said they were there at the murder scene while totally ignoring that Marasca prefaced that with the words 'even if'. Two words that at a minimum suggest at the least that possibly if not probably what followed was a hypothetical. That is a lie of of omission. Now while it is possible that such an ommission is not a lie and simply an innocent error. For our resident guilter, the omission cannot be claimed as neither innocent or honest. It is a deliberate act of obfuscation of the facts. That makes it a lie.

It's not just the "even if", as in "Nevertheless, even if attribution (of contact with blood) is certain, the trial element would not be unequivocal as a demonstration of posthumous contact with that blood."

It's not just that, the ISC more than telegraphs in Section 9.2 of its report what it is setting out to demonstrate. Then the demonstrate it, and come to the conclusion that the pair must be innocent, even if taking seriously the best the prosecution had to offer. Prior to the "even if" statement, the Italian Supreme Court specifically set out the parameters of what they were about to write.

They specifically said that what is to come is a compendium of both sides of the case, the prosecution side as well as the defence side, to see if any of it makes sense....

Marasca-Bruno said:
9.2 The aspects of the objectively contradictory nature [of evidence] can be, as
shown below, illustrated for each defendant, in a synoptic presentation of the
elements favourable to the hypothesis of guilt and of the elements against it, as
they are shown, of course, by the text of the challenged ruling and of the previous
ones.​
As for the "elements favorable to the hypothesis of guilt," M-B go on to examine those elements, and at the end find that even if they are true, they still do not cross the boundary necessary to find the pair guilty.

The guilt-PR machine completely ignores this. Instead, they'd have us believe that M-B really did think the pair guilty, but acquitted and exonerated them anyway. The guilter-PR machine has since promised that there will be some last-minute reversal, where Marasca-Bruno will be taken away in prison vans.....

.... be that as it may, it is more than 3 years since the acquittals - which is the term that the Italian media to this day uses to describe the 2015 decision - and there's a small group of English language nutters who claim that say it never happened that way.

These are the same people who, themselves, forge pictures of Francesco Sollecito presumably leaving a funeral mass for Rocco Sollecito, a funeral mass which.....

N
E
V
E
R

H
A
P
P
E
N
E
D

Yet that does not stop them from forging evidence. If ever anything was deserving of a designation, "guilter PR-machine", what more is there?
 
Last edited:
Ummm...Rocco Sollecito was born June 9, 1948 and (according to the court records) Francesco Sollecito was " nato a Giovinazzo il 4 giugno 1948." Wow...that was one short pregnancy between the two 'brothers'. Try doing just a modicum of research before posting.

Citation, please, for your claim that Raffaele 'hung out with the Italian mafioso there'. Not that I'm expecting one, of course.

It's all covered in mafia sympathiser rag OGGI.

No, it is not. The following is the only OGGI article I could find regarding RS's trip to the Dominica Republic. It does not mention him hanging out with Italian mafioso. It only mentions this:

(RS)...maintains friendly relations with many fellow countrymen living on the island, including a pavese who moved to Santo Domingo for work and a Roman businessman with several businesses in the tourism sector.

https://translate.google.com/transl...ito-ai-caraibi-le-foto-esclusive/&prev=search

I looked at several articles referring to RS's D.R. trip and they all refer back to this single OGGI article. Once again, you are making a claim with no evidence to support it. Figures.:jaw-dropp
 
It's not just the "even if", as in "Nevertheless, even if attribution (of contact with blood) is certain, the trial element would not be unequivocal as a demonstration of posthumous contact with that blood."

It's not just that, the ISC more than telegraphs in Section 9.2 of its report what it is setting out to demonstrate. Then the demonstrate it, and come to the conclusion that the pair must be innocent, even if taking seriously the best the prosecution had to offer. Prior to the "even if" statement, the Italian Supreme Court specifically set out the parameters of what they were about to write.

They specifically said that what is to come is a compendium of both sides of the case, the prosecution side as well as the defence side, to see if any of it makes sense....

​
As for the "elements favorable to the hypothesis of guilt," M-B go on to examine those elements, and at the end find that even if they are true, they still do not cross the boundary necessary to find the pair guilty.

The guilt-PR machine completely ignores this. Instead, they'd have us believe that M-B really did think the pair guilty, but acquitted and exonerated them anyway. The guilter-PR machine has since promised that there will be some last-minute reversal, where Marasca-Bruno will be taken away in prison vans.....

.... be that as it may, it is more than 3 years since the acquittals - which is the term that the Italian media to this day uses to describe the 2015 decision - and there's a small group of English language nutters who claim that say it never happened that way.

These are the same people who, themselves, forge pictures of Francesco Sollecito presumably leaving a funeral mass for Rocco Sollecito, a funeral mass which.....

N
E
V
E
R

H
A
P
P
E
N
E
D

Yet that does not stop them from forging evidence. If ever anything was deserving of a designation, "guilter PR-machine", what more is there?

It's one thing after another. It's the total acceptance of every prosecution witness and expert and total summary dismissal of anything that is exculpatory including defense witnesses and experts. It's saying that any kind of exoneration is simply a #$@# spelling error for crise sakes.

That Vixen has the gall to repeat over and over the lie that there was woman's shoeprint in Merediths blood is particularly galling to me. Anyone who has seen the very thorough rebuttal knows that without a doubt that the print is simply another of Rudy's Nike shoeprint. But Vixen says that because that expert used an image editing tool (Photoshop) to rotate and overlay the print to show how it was the Nike print, that what they were really doing was dishonestly distorting it. Something that would have been obvious and easy to pinpoint if he had.

I see Vixen saying things about telecom which are demonstrably false and ignorant, the one area where I have significant expertise. And no matter how many times I correct her, she will repeat those untruths.
It's grown more than a little tiresome.
 
Last edited:
It is possible that the 2007 photo of Francesco was not photoshopped in by someone in the guilt camp. The fact that the link to the original article does show that two photos in that position have been removed is curious and perhaps telling. It is possible that the photos were removed voluntarily by the author or the publisher due to being a mistake. The fact that no mention is made in the article of Francesco is supportive that it was either not there originally or that it was a mistake of some sort. As I told Vixen earlier, a picture is not included in an article and then not identified or referred to in any way. It would have no purpose.

What is unforgiveable is that this lie about F.S. attending a non-existent memorial to Rocco S and that there is a photo as evidence will continue to be spread by the remaining TJMK fanatics. It will continue to be spread along with the 'FR and RS are closely connected to the mafia, Napapijri jacket, red stripe cap, charter plane, mixed blood, footprints in blood, et al. lies.
 
Could be a twin born five days apart...? No? Could still be a second cousin (shared grandparents). I am close to all of my second cousins.

In short: No.

You still resort to all kinds of excuses as to why this imagined relationship has never once been mentioned in any article or why PGP like yourself have never provided evidence of it.
Is it logical in your world that all those articles on Rocco's death would not include identifying Rocco as Raffaele's uncle the year after Raffaele was definitively acquitted of one of the most publicized crimes in Italy? REALLY?

Learn to stop digging the hole and to admit when you're wrong.
 
Paranoia strikes deep
Into your life it will creep
.

~ Stephen Stills

How ironic coming from someone who maintains that every expert, witness, and judge who does not support guilt is corrupt and/or a shill.

Besides, as the vilest Writer has his Readers, so the greatest Liar has his Believers; and it often happens, that if a Lie be believ’d only for an Hour, it has done its Work, and there is no farther occasion for it. Falsehood flies, and the Truth comes limping after it; so that when Men come to be undeceiv’d, it is too late; the Jest is over, and the Tale has had its Effect…

~ Jonathan Swift, 1710
 
It is possible that the 2007 photo of Francesco was not photoshopped in by someone in the guilt camp. The fact that the link to the original article does show that two photos in that position have been removed is curious and perhaps telling. It is possible that the photos were removed voluntarily by the author or the publisher due to being a mistake. The fact that no mention is made in the article of Francesco is supportive that it was either not there originally or that it was a mistake of some sort. As I told Vixen earlier, a picture is not included in an article and then not identified or referred to in any way. It would have no purpose.

What is unforgiveable is that this lie about F.S. attending a non-existent memorial to Rocco S and that there is a photo as evidence will continue to be spread by the remaining TJMK fanatics. It will continue to be spread along with the 'FR and RS are closely connected to the mafia, Napapijri jacket, red stripe cap, charter plane, mixed blood, footprints in blood, et al. lies.

I'm only seeing one photo missing which I assume corresponds to the photo of Rocco Sollecito in the dot nut posting. It appears to me they took two pictures from the article (Rocco, the church) and then added the 'generic' photo from Francesco as well as the one of him leaving the courthouse in 2007, and then copied the one paragraph from the article which was not nearly as clear/definitive as the one prior to it which made it clear the mass was never held. Why the picture of Rocco would now not be in the article I have no idea, but it's irrelevant.
 
I'm only seeing one photo missing which I assume corresponds to the photo of Rocco Sollecito in the dot nut posting. It appears to me they took two pictures from the article (Rocco, the church) and then added the 'generic' photo from Francesco as well as the one of him leaving the courthouse in 2007, and then copied the one paragraph from the article which was not nearly as clear/definitive as the one prior to it which made it clear the mass was never held. Why the picture of Rocco would now not be in the article I have no idea, but it's irrelevant.

In the original article there are two X's with one statement saying "Risultati immagini per Sollecito boss" ("image results for Sollecito boss"). I only just translated this which gives us a good clue that the pic of FS was not originally there. The plural is only for the photos but only one "boss" which indicates the photos were of the same person. This clearly points to some photoshopping going on in the PMF pic which Vixen posted.

I'd love to hear the "reason" for this from those who spread this falsehood about FS and RS being mafia connected.
 
Last edited:
In the original article there are two X's with one statement saying "Risultati immagini per Sollecito boss" ("image results for Sollecito boss"). I only just translated this which gives us a good clue that the pic of FS was not originally there. The plural is only for the photos but only one "boss" which indicates the photos were of the same person. This clearly points to some photoshopping going on in the PMF pic which Vixen posted.

I'd love to hear the "reason" for this from those who spread this falsehood about FS and RS being mafia connected.

OK, I'm only showing a single broken link but agree the translation is "image results..". Regardless, clearly the photo(s) was/were of "Boss" Rocco, not Francesco.

Quennell would never admit the slight of hand, but that's fine. As Bill keeps saying, it just gives Amanda more things to talk about.
 
I know exactly where you got that:
http://www.perugiamurderfile.net/viewtopic.php?f=1&t=461&start=8000

And they got it from here (scroll almost down to the bottom):
https://www.deliapress.it/products/...-a-messa-boss-papa-mi-riceva-sono-addolorato/
The trouble with this is that the alleged pictures (and most certainly not the one photoshopped in of the "stock" pic of Dr. Sollecito) do not appear.
That photo claiming it is of Dr. Sollecito coming out of the church is not mentioned anywhere in the article...nor are Francesco or Raffaele at all. That picture of Dr. Sollecito could have been taken at any time, including of him coming out of his own local church as it is not identified in the article. Once again: why is it that NO article EVER mentioned Dr. Sollecito being at the (non-existent) memorial mass OR mentioned either him or Raffaele in any article related to Rocco Sollecito?
As for the alleged memorial mass, I've already quoted and cited the article that says that NONE was ever held. Try reading it again:

http://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/montre...lled-1.3913273

Just like you're stuck in the 2009 evidence whirlpool, you can't get past the end result that no mass was held even at dawn. PERIOD. END STOP.

OK, I'm only showing a single broken link but agree the translation is "image results..". Regardless, clearly the photo(s) was/were of "Boss" Rocco, not Francesco.

Quennell would never admit the slight of hand, but that's fine. As Bill keeps saying, it just gives Amanda more things to talk about.

Did you click on the highlighted link above? This is to the original article.

Of course they'd never admit it. They never admit to being wrong about anything. I think it's a prerequisite for being a TJMKer in good standing.
 
Did you click on the highlighted link above? This is to the original article.

Of course they'd never admit it. They never admit to being wrong about anything. I think it's a prerequisite for being a TJMKer in good standing.

Stop looking for trouble where none exists.

The author of the article on the mafia innocuously included a picture of a figure exiting a building, alongside a picture of Rocco Sollecito, and someone recognised it as Raff's dad.

Picture now gone.

Move along, nothing to see.
 
Stop looking for trouble where none exists.

The author of the article on the mafia innocuously included a picture of a figure exiting a building, alongside a picture of Rocco Sollecito, and someone recognised it as Raff's dad.

Picture now gone.

Move along, nothing to see.

I'd say the guilters desperately grasping at straws with this mafia nonsense is something to see. Something funny :D
 
Stop looking for trouble where none exists.

The author of the article on the mafia innocuously included a picture of a figure exiting a building, alongside a picture of Rocco Sollecito, and someone recognised it as Raff's dad.

Picture now gone.

Move along, nothing to see.


Yeah..... that's not what happened though, is it Vixen?

You see, suppose I was writing a media article on the funeral of (camp UK TV personality) Dale Winton. I wouldn't just google something like "Winton photo" - and then unintentionally place into the article a photo of a COMPLETELY DIFFERENT person who happened to share the surname "Winton" - e.g. Sir Nicholas Winton (who saved Jewish children in occupied Europe in WWII).

Likewise, whoever wrote this article - assuming he/she had even a tiny amount of competence as a journalist - would not have inadvertently included a photo of Francesco Sollecito in a story about Rocco Sollecito.

No, Vixen. In all probability, what ACTUALLY happened here is that someone in the pro-guilt community mendaciously added in that photo of Francesco Sollecito (taken in a completely different place at a completely different time....), in order to try to deceive people into thinking that the article was associating Francesco Sollecito with any kind of eulogy for Rocco Sollecito.

Again: I realise that credulous poor-thinkers with gigantic inbuilt biases might find it extremely difficult to understand/accept that this is what the evidence suggests. And for the pro-guilt community, OF COURSE it's easier and much more convenient to "believe" that we were all innocently led astray by the careless mistake of a journalist (in Vixen-parlance: "It weren't our fault, guvnor!"). But I guess that's illustrative of the difference between almost all pro-acquittal/pro-innocence commentators (who use critical thinking and rational analysis, with absence of prior judgement or any inbuilt bias, to look at all the (rational, credible) evidence and draw objective conclusions from it) and almost all pro-guilt commentators (who don't......).
 
I'm only seeing one photo missing which I assume corresponds to the photo of Rocco Sollecito in the dot nut posting. It appears to me they took two pictures from the article (Rocco, the church) and then added the 'generic' photo from Francesco as well as the one of him leaving the courthouse in 2007, and then copied the one paragraph from the article which was not nearly as clear/definitive as the one prior to it which made it clear the mass was never held. Why the picture of Rocco would now not be in the article I have no idea, but it's irrelevant.


What would be interesting would be if someone with intellectual honesty - and sufficient intellect and perspicacity - within the pro-guilt community would seek to find out exactly WHO among them consciously and knowingly doctored that media article in this way, in a deliberately deceptive attempt to link Francesco Sollecito with Rocco Sollecito. But I think we all know that will never, ever happen.
 
In short: No.

You still resort to all kinds of excuses as to why this imagined relationship has never once been mentioned in any article or why PGP like yourself have never provided evidence of it.
Is it logical in your world that all those articles on Rocco's death would not include identifying Rocco as Raffaele's uncle the year after Raffaele was definitively acquitted of one of the most publicized crimes in Italy? REALLY?

Learn to stop digging the hole and to admit when you're wrong.



"Could be a twin born five days apart?" AHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHA!!!
 
Did you click on the highlighted link above? This is to the original article.

Of course they'd never admit it. They never admit to being wrong about anything. I think it's a prerequisite for being a TJMKer in good standing.

Yeah, I'm looking at the original. And btw, if you view the image info for the missing photo you'll see the source of it is... TJMK!

https://truejustice.org/ee/images/perugia/frontpage4/4092.jpg

Go figure.
 
Yeah, I'm looking at the original. And btw, if you view the image info for the missing photo you'll see the source of it is... TJMK!

https://truejustice.org/ee/images/perugia/frontpage4/4092.jpg

Go figure.

This reminds me of the BTK killer. He sent a a floppy disk to the police that included metadata that said the disk was used by a computer at the Christ Lutheran Church and the document on it was saved by someone named Dennis. The police then found that Dennis Rader was the President of the Congregation. Whoops!

Here we now have proof that someone at TJMK published a lie and fabricated their supporting evidence.
 
This reminds me of the BTK killer. He sent a a floppy disk to the police that included metadata that said the disk was used by a computer at the Christ Lutheran Church and the document on it was saved by someone named Dennis. The police then found that Dennis Rader was the President of the Congregation. Whoops!

Here we now have proof that someone at TJMK published a lie and fabricated their supporting evidence.

Repeating:

Some of the guilters fabricate hoaxes, then their follower-guilters spread the hoaxes. It's a hoax, just like the police and prosecutor claiming that "see you later, good evening" in Italian means making an appointment with someone to commit a murder/rape.

The core guilters are people who like hoaxes and enjoy fabricating and continuing them - while their follower-guilters don't have the critical thinking skills to recognize the hoaxes and/or are so blinded by bias that they choose not to recognize the hoaxes and/or enjoy a "good" malicious hoax also, so they spread the hoaxes online.
 
How ironic coming from someone who maintains that every expert, witness, and judge who does not support guilt is corrupt and/or a shill.

Besides, as the vilest Writer has his Readers, so the greatest Liar has his Believers; and it often happens, that if a Lie be believ’d only for an Hour, it has done its Work, and there is no farther occasion for it. Falsehood flies, and the Truth comes limping after it; so that when Men come to be undeceiv’d, it is too late; the Jest is over, and the Tale has had its Effect…

~ Jonathan Swift, 1710

That's my new favourite word. 'Vilest'. Please can we bring it back. Some of the best lines include this word. For example, 'the vilest offender'.

It has a ring to it. 'V i l e s t'. It rolls off the tongue. 'Vilest'.....

'Vile bodies'. Lets have a vile revivial. 'The vilest writer' ~ Jonathan Swift - what a fine writer.
 
I'm only seeing one photo missing which I assume corresponds to the photo of Rocco Sollecito in the dot nut posting. It appears to me they took two pictures from the article (Rocco, the church) and then added the 'generic' photo from Francesco as well as the one of him leaving the courthouse in 2007, and then copied the one paragraph from the article which was not nearly as clear/definitive as the one prior to it which made it clear the mass was never held. Why the picture of Rocco would now not be in the article I have no idea, but it's irrelevant.

That's right.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom