The Trials of Amanda Knox and Raffaele Sollecito: Part 28

Status
Not open for further replies.
Yeah..... that's not what happened though, is it Vixen?

You see, suppose I was writing a media article on the funeral of (camp UK TV personality) Dale Winton. I wouldn't just google something like "Winton photo" - and then unintentionally place into the article a photo of a COMPLETELY DIFFERENT person who happened to share the surname "Winton" - e.g. Sir Nicholas Winton (who saved Jewish children in occupied Europe in WWII).

Likewise, whoever wrote this article - assuming he/she had even a tiny amount of competence as a journalist - would not have inadvertently included a photo of Francesco Sollecito in a story about Rocco Sollecito.

No, Vixen. In all probability, what ACTUALLY happened here is that someone in the pro-guilt community mendaciously added in that photo of Francesco Sollecito (taken in a completely different place at a completely different time....), in order to try to deceive people into thinking that the article was associating Francesco Sollecito with any kind of eulogy for Rocco Sollecito.

Again: I realise that credulous poor-thinkers with gigantic inbuilt biases might find it extremely difficult to understand/accept that this is what the evidence suggests. And for the pro-guilt community, OF COURSE it's easier and much more convenient to "believe" that we were all innocently led astray by the careless mistake of a journalist (in Vixen-parlance: "It weren't our fault, guvnor!"). But I guess that's illustrative of the difference between almost all pro-acquittal/pro-innocence commentators (who use critical thinking and rational analysis, with absence of prior judgement or any inbuilt bias, to look at all the (rational, credible) evidence and draw objective conclusions from it) and almost all pro-guilt commentators (who don't......).

You silly, silly boy. Run along now.
 
What would be interesting would be if someone with intellectual honesty - and sufficient intellect and perspicacity - within the pro-guilt community would seek to find out exactly WHO among them consciously and knowingly doctored that media article in this way, in a deliberately deceptive attempt to link Francesco Sollecito with Rocco Sollecito. But I think we all know that will never, ever happen.

So you are claiming someone hacked the owner of the website to insert a pic of Frankie yet didn't bother to name him.

It is not even about the Kercher murder.

But then you are good at outlandish conjecture.
 
Stop looking for trouble where none exists.

The author of the article on the mafia innocuously included a picture of a figure exiting a building, alongside a picture of Rocco Sollecito, and someone recognised it as Raff's dad.

Picture now gone.

Move along, nothing to see.

It was YOU who claimed there was a photo showing Francesco S. at Rocco's (non-existent) memorial mass...a photo that you claimed "is in ISF archives" and that many on here "would remember seeing".

It was Ergon, Quennell, you, and other guilters who spread that lie on the internet, not us. So I suggest you and they move along and stop spreading this proven lie.
 
So you are claiming someone hacked the owner of the website to insert a pic of Frankie yet didn't bother to name him.

It is not even about the Kercher murder.

But then you are good at outlandish conjecture.

It's hardly conjecture. Someone at TJMK fabricated evidence and you are on ISF spreading that lie. Either it's an honest mistake on your part or it's another example of an absence of integrity.
 
So you are claiming someone hacked the owner of the website to insert a pic of Frankie yet didn't bother to name him.

It is not even about the Kercher murder.

But then you are good at outlandish conjecture.

The original website refers to two pictures of the "Sollecito boss". Note that is singular, not plural. So why would the picture you posted show two different people? A picture found on Perugia.net? A picture photoshopped to include another "comparison' photo of Francesco? Yes: why would someone do that? What could the motive possibly be? Hmmmmm…

"But then you are good at outlandish conjecture."

Oh, the irony! The irony!
 
The original website refers to two pictures of the "Sollecito boss". Note that is singular, not plural. So why would the picture you posted show two different people? A picture found on Perugia.net? A picture photoshopped to include another "comparison' photo of Francesco? Yes: why would someone do that? What could the motive possibly be? Hmmmmm…

"But then you are good at outlandish conjecture."

Oh, the irony! The irony!


It is obviously a straightforward error by the person who wrote the article on that website.

It is actually not uncommon for newspaper stories to depict the wrong person in a photo. There was one recently.

You don't really care about this, you just want to purvey the vilest trolling.
 
It is obviously a straightforward error by the person who wrote the article on that website.

It is actually not uncommon for newspaper stories to depict the wrong person in a photo. There was one recently.

You don't really care about this, you just want to purvey the vilest trolling.

You're alleging a vast high level mafia conspiracy to free a psycho killer twerp nobody for no reason, then for proof you link some bogus image. We're going to make fun of you and call you out on your ****. Deal with it gosh.
 
It is obviously a straightforward error by the person who wrote the article on that website.

It is actually not uncommon for newspaper stories to depict the wrong person in a photo. There was one recently.

You don't really care about this, you just want to purvey the vilest trolling.

Oh my...someone is using her new favorite word in an attempt to distract from the fact that she (and Quennell,et al.) are WRONG about Francesco S. attending a memorial mass that never happened.

Are you ready to admit you and Quennell are wrong about this? You know, actually use the word "wrong"?
 
The original website refers to two pictures of the "Sollecito boss". Note that is singular, not plural. So why would the picture you posted show two different people? A picture found on Perugia.net? A picture photoshopped to include another "comparison' photo of Francesco? Yes: why would someone do that? What could the motive possibly be? Hmmmmm…

"But then you are good at outlandish conjecture."

Oh, the irony! The irony!

To be honest, I'm trying to peel back the onion and, while it stinks, I'll be damned if I can figure out what happened here.

deliapress.it runs an article and has within it a jpeg which can no longer be loaded. That jpeg is sourced from TJMK, though I can't find it (4092.jpg) anywhere on the site (perhaps removed, perhaps stored in a members only area). So we can't know what that jpeg was though we can assume it was at least supposed to be a photo of Rocco Sollecito. Meanwhile, Vixen references a jpeg on dot net that is a collage of photos taken from various locations at various times, with no connection between the photos. The jpeg is titled "rocco mass". It's an obvious attempt to mislead people into thinking the mass took place (it didn't) and that Francesco was there (by using a photo taken years earlier of Francesco leaving the courthouse). This tactic by dot nut is not surprising, they are as dishonest and sleazy as TJMK. However, I'm not at all convinced there is a connection between the missing TJMK photo and the jpeg on dot nut.

I thought perhaps TJMK was the original author of the collage, but then why would deliapress.it link to it? It had no connection to the article other than the photo of Rocco but there are hundreds of photos of Rocco on the Internet so there was no need to link to a collage on TJMK.

ETA: I just found 4092 on TJMK and it's the photo of Francesco leaving the courthouse. So it's not the collage found on dot nut, but it's also not Rocco as implied by the caption. Something still seems fishy. I find it hard to believe deliapress.it erroneously posted a picture of Francesco when they meant to picture Rocco.
 
Last edited:
To be honest, I'm trying to peel back the onion and, while it stinks, I'll be damned if I can figure out what happened here.

deliapress.it runs an article and has within it a jpeg which can no longer be loaded. That jpeg is sourced from TJMK, though I can't find it (4092.jpg) anywhere on the site (perhaps removed, perhaps stored in a members only area). So we can't know what that jpeg was though we can assume it was at least supposed to be a photo of Rocco Sollecito. Meanwhile, Vixen references a jpeg on dot net that is a collage of photos taken from various locations at various times, with no connection between the photos. The jpeg is titled "rocco mass". It's an obvious attempt to mislead people into thinking the mass took place (it didn't) and that Francesco was there (by using a photo taken years earlier of Francesco leaving the courthouse). This tactic by dot nut is not surprising, they are as dishonest and sleazy as TJMK. However, I'm not at all convinced there is a connection between the missing TJMK photo and the jpeg on dot nut.

I thought perhaps TJMK was the original author of the collage, but then why would deliapress.it link to it? It had no connection to the article other than the photo of Rocco but there are hundreds of photos of Rocco on the Internet so there was no need to link to a collage on TJMK.

Most likely we'll never know what happened in this case. But what we do know is that:
1. Francesco never attended a memorial mass for Rocco as the mass never happened.
2. There is no evidence at all that Francesco and Raffaele are closely related to or have any connection to Rocco or the mafia.
 
It is obviously a straightforward error by the person who wrote the article on that website.

It is actually not uncommon for newspaper stories to depict the wrong person in a photo. There was one recently.

You don't really care about this, you just want to purvey the vilest trolling.

No, in fact it obviously a deliberate and outright fabrication. A liar that included the manipulation and distortion of photographic evidence. Unlike, the shoeprint, this is a misuse of a photo editing application like PhotoShop.
 
ECHR NEWSFLASH

NEWSFLASH: Application still dead in the water

E-mail from the European Court regarding Knox v. Italy application no. 76577/13 which was lodged with the Court on 23/11/2013.
Dear Sir,
Thank you for your message and please find here the information we can provide in response.
1. Both parties’ observations have been received by the Court’s Registry.
2. No decision as to the admissibility of the application has been taken yet.
We hope this helps.
With best wishes,
ECHR – Press Unit

Source: Ergon
 
Most likely we'll never know what happened in this case. But what we do know is that:
1. Francesco never attended a memorial mass for Rocco as the mass never happened.
2. There is no evidence at all that Francesco and Raffaele are closely related to or have any connection to Rocco or the mafia.

Very true and that IS what is important.

But I still would like to know what happened here. I don't put it past Quennell to have realized deliapress.it was using a photo of Rocco that TJMK was hosting and switched out the photo, resulting in a photo of Francesco in an article about a memorial mass for Rocco (that never happened, but why would Quennell let that stop him). Anything to claim a mafia connection.
 
NEWSFLASH: Application still dead in the water

E-mail from the European Court regarding Knox v. Italy application no. 76577/13 which was lodged with the Court on 23/11/2013.
Dear Sir,
Thank you for your message and please find here the information we can provide in response.
1. Both parties’ observations have been received by the Court’s Registry.
2. No decision as to the admissibility of the application has been taken yet.
We hope this helps.
With best wishes,
ECHR – Press Unit

Source: Ergon

So Italy has sent in their response too. I wonder what it was? Hopefully they went with something better than their police/prosecution recent interview "we had to get to our suspect fast before her mom rescued her" I don't think that will fly.
 
NEWSFLASH: Application still dead in the water
E-mail from the European Court regarding Knox v. Italy application no. 76577/13 which was lodged with the Court on 23/11/2013.
Dear Sir,
Thank you for your message and please find here the information we can provide in response.
1. Both parties’ observations have been received by the Court’s Registry.
2. No decision as to the admissibility of the application has been taken yet.
We hope this helps.
With best wishes,
ECHR – Press Unit

Source: Ergon



Umm... don't you mean "application still pending"? It seems you don't understand the meaning of the phrase "dead in the water". Or maybe you DO understand its meaning, and you deliberately employed it misleadingly? Which is it, Vixen?

(I do enjoy the notion of Ergon(!) routinely emailing the ECHR communications department to try to get updates though!)
 
You silly, silly boy. Run along now.


Uhhhhhhhhhh...... WHAT?

It's a while since I've seen such a pathetic, unsubstantive "response" to a post - a "response" which manifestly fails to address either a) any details of the post to which it was "responding", or b) anything related to this case whatsoever. Just a bizarre personal insult.

I wonder if you know yet that you were wrong about 1) there being any reliable evidence at all of Francesco Sollecito attending any form of eulogy for Rocco Sollecito (there is none whatsoever); and/or 2) the provenance, reliability and credibility of the "evidence" you so triumphantly produced in the form of that set of photos (the evidence very strongly supports the contention that someone within the pro-guilt community doctored the article in question by inserting additional photographs, in a mendacious attempt to link Francesco Sollecito to Rocco Sollecito)?

Or will you quietly try to handwave this one away while misdirecting by starting out on another issue - once again?
 
NEWSFLASH: Application still dead in the water

E-mail from the European Court regarding Knox v. Italy application no. 76577/13 which was lodged with the Court on 23/11/2013.
Dear Sir,
Thank you for your message and please find here the information we can provide in response.
1. Both parties’ observations have been received by the Court’s Registry.
2. No decision as to the admissibility of the application has been taken yet.
We hope this helps.
With best wishes,
ECHR – Press Unit

Source: Ergon

In other words, the case is still going through the usual painstakingly slow procedures. What a "NEWSFLASH". :rolleyes:
 
Uhhhhhhhhhh...... WHAT?

It's a while since I've seen such a pathetic, unsubstantive "response" to a post - a "response" which manifestly fails to address either a) any details of the post to which it was "responding", or b) anything related to this case whatsoever. Just a bizarre personal insult.

I wonder if you know yet that you were wrong about 1) there being any reliable evidence at all of Francesco Sollecito attending any form of eulogy for Rocco Sollecito (there is none whatsoever); and/or 2) the provenance, reliability and credibility of the "evidence" you so triumphantly produced in the form of that set of photos (the evidence very strongly supports the contention that someone within the pro-guilt community doctored the article in question by inserting additional photographs, in a mendacious attempt to link Francesco Sollecito to Rocco Sollecito)?

Or will you quietly try to handwave this one away while misdirecting by starting out on another issue - once again?[/QUOTE]

(Raising my hand eagerly and waving it to get your attention)

I know! I know! Let me answer it! Let me answer it! The correct answer is: She is trying to avoid having to admit she was wrong and trying to direct our attention elsewhere to something that is completely un-NEWSFLASH worthy!
 
So Italy has sent in their response too. I wonder what it was? Hopefully they went with something better than their police/prosecution recent interview "we had to get to our suspect fast before her mom rescued her" I don't think that will fly.


Oh they'll almost certainly try once again with "We simply called Knox in for a friendly chat to see if she had further information that could help our investigation, and then she simply blurted out the accusation against Lumumba out of nowhere!".

As (apparently) incorrect as the above scenario is*, the interesting thing IMO will be how they try to address what happened next. After all, even if the above scenario truly had occurred, Italian law dictated that the police should immediately have terminated the interview, appraised Knox of her rights, got her a lawyer, and from then on only the PM could interview her and only in the presence of her lawyer. What they absolutely could/should not have done in the aftermath of her verbal "confession/accusation" was type up her statement and get her to sign it - all without having been informed of her rights or being given access to legal counsel.


* IMO there is very strong evidence to suggest that in fact Knox was coerced - almost certainly unlawfully - into naming Lumumba as the killer. This evidence takes the form of a) the court testimony of the "interpreter" Donnino (which can only support the idea that the police were instructing Knox to "remember" certain events); b) the revealing "eventually (Knox) buckled and told us what we already knew to be correct" words of Perugia Police Chief De Felice to reporters the following day; and c) the consistent account of Knox herself.
 
Oh they'll almost certainly try once again with "We simply called Knox in for a friendly chat to see if she had further information that could help our investigation, and then she simply blurted out the accusation against Lumumba out of nowhere!".

As (apparently) incorrect as the above scenario is*, the interesting thing IMO will be how they try to address what happened next. After all, even if the above scenario truly had occurred, Italian law dictated that the police should immediately have terminated the interview, appraised Knox of her rights, got her a lawyer, and from then on only the PM could interview her and only in the presence of her lawyer. What they absolutely could/should not have done in the aftermath of her verbal "confession/accusation" was type up her statement and get her to sign it - all without having been informed of her rights or being given access to legal counsel.


* IMO there is very strong evidence to suggest that in fact Knox was coerced - almost certainly unlawfully - into naming Lumumba as the killer. This evidence takes the form of a) the court testimony of the "interpreter" Donnino (which can only support the idea that the police were instructing Knox to "remember" certain events); b) the revealing "eventually (Knox) buckled and told us what we already knew to be correct" words of Perugia Police Chief De Felice to reporters the following day; and c) the consistent account of Knox herself.

...d) the SMS exchange with Lumumba, which the police incorrectly interpreted as Amanda meeting up with Lumumba that night - evidence that it was the police and not Amanda who brought Lumumba into the discussion.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom