The Trials of Amanda Knox and Raffaele Sollecito: Part 28

Status
Not open for further replies.
You do realize that the Independent was bought off by the massive, million dollar PR machine, don't you? Or maybe it was the ghost of Raffaele's dead "Uncle" Rocco, the Mafia Don, haunting the author. Speaking of which, has Vixen...or anyone else for that matter...provided evidence that they were closely related? Or the alleged photo showing Dr. Sollecito at the (cancelled) memorial?:D

The picture of Francesco at Rocco's memorial is in ISF archives.
 
Me neither. But both of us are calling the kettle black.

At this point with Knox being taken in by the N.A. innocence community, with her speaking and media stuff.....

... all that the remaining slut-shamers accomplish is to make Knox's point for her. It's the problem with them posting off the same song-sheet, they very rarely bother these days dealing with evidence - and in my opinion there's a reason for that.

They have to see how many times they can say "lies, lies, lies...." without specifically listing what those lies had been. And the Achilles Heel of it all, what lies have Knox and/or Sollecito told outside this case - I mean, if you're going to make the case that they're pathological than it would be nice if when making that slur, you actually provided evidence of it.

The remaining nutters are stuck in that week in 2007 when Mignini controlled the narrative - controlled it mainly by incarcerating those he wanted to deprive of a voice. His lies got all the way around the world before the truth could get its pants on.

But since March 2015 - those prosecution/investigative lies and "amnesiac" efforts have been exposed for what they were. Empty vessels.

Vixen here on ISF is reduced to simply making a specious claim, then when the claim is disproved, waiting 6 months and making it again as if for the first time.

So tell me again, why do we bother? These days when Vixen does that, all Knox gets out of it is another episode of "Scarlett Letter Reports". Knox then kinds links to the many women her age who've been assaulted in social media like it.

They discover they have voices and are not afraid to use them. The remaining nutters need better strategy - they're letting their urge to slut-shame overwhelm the message they believe they're sending - that the facts are on their side. Aside from the fact that they're not on their side - maybe that's the reason why they yell, "lies, slut, lies, slut, lies, slut......" so loud and long.

I say - at this point they are simply proving what Knox (and other women) have been saying. So perhaps there is a use for them.

I doubt there'll be another series. Sluts tend to be very boring people. One trick ponies.
 
Yes. This and other related incidents very clearly points to the opinion that the judges in the Massei trial (and, as is widely reported elsewhere, judges in trials - especially first-instance trials - throughout Italy) had already formed the default view that the prosecutors' case (prosecutors, remember, who were literal and emotional friends/allies of judges, as members of the very same judicial group) was effectively likely to be sound, fair and objective - and that by contrast any defence objections were effectively likely to nothing more or less than sophistic attempts to thwart justice.


I've said it before, etc, etc..... but Italian criminal justice is fundamentally unfit for purpose (its purpose being the fair and accurate application of justice as it is defined in modern liberalised-democracy jurisprudence and ethics, in as speedy a manner as is practicably possible, with ample safeguards and correctional procedures and proper levels of accountability). Italy itself is broken in so very many ways. Gorgeous place to go for short holidays - but horrible place to try to do business, or in which to live as an expat (it may be great for years, but as soon as you're either a victim or a suspect of any sort of crime, or you get embroiled in any kind of civil dispute, or regulatory dispute, or dispute with local or central government.....)

Contract law is completely different from criminal law. In Italy one is expected to bend over backwards to allow a provider of services to put right your complaints about their service/s. In criminal law once again, the defendant is given the upper hand, with two automatic rights to appeal, all the way up to the Supreme Court and 50% get off.

If the murder had happened in Texas, the pair would have fried on Old Smoky by now.
 
I doubt there'll be another series. Sluts tend to be very boring people. One trick ponies.

Just couldn't resist slut-shaming. You also don't get - at all - how your disgusting posts contribute to the need for the series.

Keep posting, there'll be a second season.
 
Knox had been lying in wait for Mez ever since she returned from having a GREAT time at Halloween. She was up at her usual 5:00am to confront Mez at the cottage. Still there when Mez finally got up at about one or two. Raff came around to join her. Mez was off again out of the door leaving Knox to seethe at Mez' popularity and great social life, whilst she had none. Just a weird wimpy boyfriend who took drugs, whilst Mez' handsome boyfriend went ski-ing.

Please stop using the familiar name for the victim.

There was no premeditation. No one was "lying in wait", save for Rudy Guede who'd broken in and was there when the victim came home.
 
Knox had been lying in wait for Mez ever since she returned from having a GREAT time at Halloween. She was up at her usual 5:00am to confront Mez at the cottage. Still there when Mez finally got up at about one or two. Raff came around to join her. Mez was off again out of the door leaving Knox to seethe at Mez' popularity and great social life, whilst she had none. Just a weird wimpy boyfriend who took drugs, whilst Mez' handsome boyfriend went ski-ing.

BrilliantDirtyBeardedcollie-max-1mb.gif
 
The latest misstatements from one or more guilters include the following delusional comments:

"...the Italian Scientific Police followed ENSFI standards.
....
Their aim is to produce objective result. They could not care less about the nonentity 'personalities' involved, nor would they succumb to threats to their objectivity."

The statement by the Marasca CSC panel - which is obviously the statement of Italian judicial authorities, and not the statement of an anonymous online poster - however, states the following:

"4.1 .... In homicides such as this (such pressure) affects not only the timing but also the competence and the correctness of the investigative activities. Not only this, but when – as in this case – the outcome of such research depends greatly on scientific investigations, the aseptic collection of all the samples useful for the investigation – in conditions that guarantee prior sterility that avoids possible contamination – constitutes, notably, the first prudent, shrewd and essential prelude – in its turn – of a correct analysis and “reading” of the recovered samples. So when the central point of technical activity contains specialist genetic investigations, the contribution of investigative activity is ever more relevant; credible parameters of correctness must respect international standards of protocols, following fundamental rules of approach prescribed by the scientific community, on the basis of statistical and validated observations.
The rigorous respect of such methodical norms offers a conventional coefficient of acceptable credibility of such results, primarily linked to their reproducibility - namely the possibility of obtaining these results, and only these, reproduced with a constantly identical method and under identical conditions, according to fundamental empirical rules. ....

4.2 As will be seen, all of this is essentially missing from the present trial. ....

7.1 ....
In making implicit reference to judicial interpretation of legitimacy, the judge a quo [of the trial from which this appeal is being heard] didn’t hesitate to attribute evidentiary value to the aforementioned {genetic, DNA profile} results (f. 217).

The assumption cannot be shared.

.... As a general rule, it is possible to adhere to these conclusions {of the evidenciary value of DNA profile results}, on the condition though that the activity of collecting samples, storage and analysis of the exhibits has respected the regulations of the experience approved by the protocols of the profession. Which must also be true, a fortiori [even more so], even in the lesser case, where the findings of the analysis don’t provide a successful identification, but rather only of compatibility.

The principle of the necessary correctness of the method in the phase of collection, storage and analysis of the data examined, so as to preserve its integrity and authenticity, was stated by this Court ....

The justifiable reasoning lies, in the opinion of this Court, in the same notion of circumstantial evidence offered by the legal code, that, in Article 192 section 2, orders that “The existence of a fact cannot be deduced from pieces of circumstantial evidence unless they are serious, precise and consistent”, with the outcome that an element of evidence of the case, to qualify as being circumstantial evidence, must have the characteristics of seriousness, preciseness and consistency ....

Taking into account such considerations one really cannot see how the results of the genetic analysis – that were performed in violation of the recommendations for the protocols regarding the collection and storage – can be considered endowed of the characteristics of seriousness and preciseness.

....these rules epitomise the standards for [determining] the reliability of the results of the analysis, whether it is to determine identity, or merely compatibility with a specific genetic profile. Otherwise, no importance can be given to the acquired data, not even as circumstantial evidence (cf. Section 2, n. 2476 of 27/11/2014, dep. 2015, Santangelo, Rv. 261866, on the necessity of correct storage of the material containing genetic profiles, for the purposes of “repeatability” of technical findings capable of extrapolating the genetic profile; repeatability that is, moreover, dependent on the quantity of the trace and the quality of the DNA present on the biological exhibits collected; id. N. 2476/14 cit. Rv. 261867).

...it is absolutely certain that those methods were not complied with (cf., among others, ff. 206-207 and the cited requested findings of the expert report Conte-Vecchiotti, ordered by the Perugian Court of Appeal). ...."
 
There is plenty of material on this topic already, so please do a search and get up to speed.

Good try but not only did I do my homework but I published not only the content of CPP Article 530 but provided a link to it for you. You are wrong and, as we've so often seen in the past, you refuse to admit it.

Why don't YOU provide us the content of 530.2 since you're the one claiming what I (and others) have posted is wrong.
 
Contract law is completely different from criminal law. In Italy one is expected to bend over backwards to allow a provider of services to put right your complaints about their service/s. In criminal law once again, the defendant is given the upper hand, with two automatic rights to appeal, all the way up to the Supreme Court and 50% get off.

If the murder had happened in Texas, the pair would have fried on Old Smoky by now.


Texas Cowboy: Any last meal request?

Amanda Knox: I'd really like to say I'm dying for a pizza but it doesn't seem right.
 
Good try but not only did I do my homework but I published not only the content of CPP Article 530 but provided a link to it for you. You are wrong and, as we've so often seen in the past, you refuse to admit it.

Why don't YOU provide us the content of 530.2 since you're the one claiming what I (and others) have posted is wrong.



"Good try"? I think you mean "bloody abysmal, mendacious, wilfully-misdirecting, weasel, intellectually-dishonest, embarrassingly poor try"...... :rolleyes:
 
You've got several things wrong here:

1. Jovana's mother did not know Vanessa Sollecito. Jovana testified she met Raffaele through a mutual friend named Giovani who lived on Corso Garibaldi.

2. The suitcase was to be put on a bus, not a train.

3. Jovana's mother did not "change her mind". When she tried to give the suitcase to the bus driver, he refused to take it. Jovana said it was "not like in Serbia" where, apparently, this was not unusual.
No one in Italy. But, according to Jovana, it was done in Serbia where she and her mother were from. It was a simple cultural misunderstanding and not the conspiracy you'd like to believe.

Try reading the court testimony.

Your pal, Stacyhs, made this claim. Are you calling her a liar?


If someone is lying here, it's not me.

When asked about how the suitcase was supposed to arrive, Jovana P. replied:

With a bus which arrived at midnight, but at that point I was unaware that one could not send things this way in Italy so, I went by Raffaele’s to ask…
(Court Hearing of March 21, 2009)

By saying that "one could not send things this way in Italy" and the fact her Serbian mother had tried to send the suitcase in this manner implies that it was done that way in Serbia. Note that I also said "apparently it was not unusual".
 
Absolute nonsense: the Italian Scientific Police followed ENSFI standards.

Stop insulting a team of highly qualified competent scientists who've entered the police forensics team as amongst the best of their generation.

Their aim is to produce objective result. They could not care less about the nonentity 'personalities' involved, nor would they succumb to threats to their objectivity.

o ENSFI requires multiple tests before DNA results can be considered reliable. Even the RIS expert witness testified a single sample can not be considered reliable, even for standard tests, let alone LCN. Stefanoni failed to amplify more than once on all critical DNA samples.

o ENSFI requires you not perform LCN profiling in a lab not certified for such tests. You should never perform LCN profiling in a lab that has already processed DNA from the suspected sources. Neither of these procedures were followed.

o ENSFI certainly does not endorse an unqualified police officer, in a non-sterile environment like a police station, to remove an item of evidence from a sealed collection bag and then place in inside a non-sterile box sitting on the desk and not appropriate for evidence collection.

o I doubt ENSFI would consider it good practice to store a piece of metal in a plastic container, allowing the evidence to rust and become unusable.

o ENSFI would not have considered the extra male alleles on the bra clasp as 'stutter' and failed to report them.

o I doubt ENSFI would consider it good practice to pick up a piece of evidence with a dirty glove, stroke it, pass it alone to other technicians and then put that piece of evidence back down on the ground to photograph it.

o I doubt anyone following ENSFI would consider DNA negative, TMB negative samples to nonetheless be samples of the victim's blood.

These are just a few things that quickly come to mind. There's a reason why every single expert, world wide, who has looked at this case and commented has been exceedingly critical of how Stefanoni and the Scientific Police handled the case. It's why the court, in acquitted Amanda and Raffaele, was extremely critical of Stefanoni and the SP. You calling this nonsense is about as useful as declaring it "dark" at midnight.
 
Don't do yourself down. However, you can change.

When I wrote that, I made a bet with myself what your response would be. I won that bet. You are nothing if not predictable.

The picture of Francesco at Rocco's memorial is in ISF archives.

Sure it is. Which is why you produced it as evidence in order to unequivocally prove you were right. Oh, wait....No. You didn't. Now, why could that be?

(Note to self: Vixen will claim it's not her job to produce evidence of her claims and/or we're too lazy to look it up ourselves.)
 
Contract law is completely different from criminal law. In Italy one is expected to bend over backwards to allow a provider of services to put right your complaints about their service/s. In criminal law once again, the defendant is given the upper hand, with two automatic rights to appeal, all the way up to the Supreme Court and 50% get off.

If the murder had happened in Texas, the pair would have fried on Old Smoky by now.


Well now.... firstly, this post is a whole load of non sequitur if it's meant as a "reply" to mine. What on Earth has contract law got to do with anything whatsoever (especially in respect of the point my post was actually making)?

And secondly, you really do have to stop with this crap about "the defendant is given the upper hand" in Italian criminal justice. Are you seriously unaware that the appeal court and SC reviews are set out to potentially benefit the prosecution just as much as the defence? Are you really that uninformed about this after all these years? Do you really still not understand that in THIS VERY CASE, the Chieffi SC panel effectively overturned the Hellmann acquittals, in a decision which (unless you're on a totally different planet....) rather definitely benefited the prosecutors and not the defence?

Thirdly, if you're claiming that "50% get off", well now then: what are you terming "getting off"? Are you suggesting that these 50% are people who are factually guilty but who manage to evade justice? Or are you suggesting that these 50% are factually innocent? See: you can't have it both ways on this, Vixen. A rational, critical thinker, if confronted by a statistic (if it's true and reliable) showing that 50% of criminal defendants in Italian trials are ultimately acquitted, would immediately have three thoughts: either 1) Italian law enforcement institutions and prosecutors are manifestly and institutionally incompetent at doing their jobs properly in terms of investigating and prosecuting cases; 2) Italian prosecutors are charging and trying far, far too many people whom they have little realistic chance of seeing convicted by the courts (and, by necessary extension, they are treating suspects unjustly); and/or 3) Italian courts are institutionally incompetent, even when factually guilty defendants are put before them.

But they wouldn't think what you apparently thought about people "getting off".

And lastly, regarding your stupid final sentence: death sentence cases in US states get an automatic appeal in any case (you clearly didn't even know that, did you?). Oh and the death penalty in Texas is by lethal injection now (and has been for many, many years now). You didn't know that either, did you?
 
Well now.... firstly, this post is a whole load of non sequitur if it's meant as a "reply" to mine. What on Earth has contract law got to do with anything whatsoever (especially in respect of the point my post was actually making)?

And secondly, you really do have to stop with this crap about "the defendant is given the upper hand" in Italian criminal justice. Are you seriously unaware that the appeal court and SC reviews are set out to potentially benefit the prosecution just as much as the defence? Are you really that uninformed about this after all these years? Do you really still not understand that in THIS VERY CASE, the Chieffi SC panel effectively overturned the Hellmann acquittals, in a decision which (unless you're on a totally different planet....) rather definitely benefited the prosecutors and not the defence?

Thirdly, if you're claiming that "50% get off", well now then: what are you terming "getting off"? Are you suggesting that these 50% are people who are factually guilty but who manage to evade justice? Or are you suggesting that these 50% are factually innocent? See: you can't have it both ways on this, Vixen. A rational, critical thinker, if confronted by a statistic (if it's true and reliable) showing that 50% of criminal defendants in Italian trials are ultimately acquitted, would immediately have three thoughts: either 1) Italian law enforcement institutions and prosecutors are manifestly and institutionally incompetent at doing their jobs properly in terms of investigating and prosecuting cases; 2) Italian prosecutors are charging and trying far, far too many people whom they have little realistic chance of seeing convicted by the courts (and, by necessary extension, they are treating suspects unjustly); and/or 3) Italian courts are institutionally incompetent, even when factually guilty defendants are put before them.

But they wouldn't think what you apparently thought about people "getting off".

And lastly, regarding your stupid final sentence: death sentence cases in US states get an automatic appeal in any case (you clearly didn't even know that, did you?). Oh and the death penalty in Texas is by lethal injection now (and has been for many, many years now). You didn't know that either, did you?


I did know that too. Old Smoky remains a euphemism for being topped by the state.

Yes, death row prisoners get an appeal. One of the 13 - 15 steps includes confessing your crime and another showing remorse, including apologising to their victim's family.

Instead we have the pair gloating and defiantly spitting in the eye of justice.
 
Good try but not only did I do my homework but I published not only the content of CPP Article 530 but provided a link to it for you. You are wrong and, as we've so often seen in the past, you refuse to admit it.

Why don't YOU provide us the content of 530.2 since you're the one claiming what I (and others) have posted is wrong.[/QUOTE]

No, no, no, TC! Don't you understand by now that Vixen only has to claim something is so? She does not have to actually provide evidence. As the SNL Church Lady would say, "Well now, isn't she special?"
 
Good try but not only did I do my homework but I published not only the content of CPP Article 530 but provided a link to it for you. You are wrong and, as we've so often seen in the past, you refuse to admit it.

Why don't YOU provide us the content of 530.2 since you're the one claiming what I (and others) have posted is wrong.

It's been done several times, including a citation by a professor at Bath Uni, an expert in Italian history and law.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom