The Trials of Amanda Knox and Raffaele Sollecito: Part 28

Status
Not open for further replies.
I think about the social dynamics of this case far more than I do about the evidence of this case since it cut and dried that Amanda or Raffaele were not involved.

Group think, misogyny, sexual dynamics between man and women, tribalism, cognitive bias, the media dynamics and how these things came into play which resulted in dramatically changing the lives of two innocent people. The lunacy of the PGP?

I wonder how many changed their minds an if some never will. If Amanda has not seen a whiff of trouble in her life when she's 50,60,70 will Vixen etc ever come around or will they think she just never got caught?

It's the social dynamics and psychology of the case that intrigue me, too. A book should be written about it without delving into guilt or innocence.

I know I changed my mind. I assumed they were guilty when all the information I could get was coming from the police and prosecutors. It wasn't until I could actually start evaluating the evidence of the forensic and medical experts, etc. that I realized the prosecution's case was not solid at all.
 
It's the social dynamics and psychology of the case that intrigue me, too. A book should be written about it without delving into guilt or innocence.I know I changed my mind. I assumed they were guilty when all the information I could get was coming from the police and prosecutors. It wasn't until I could actually start evaluating the evidence of the forensic and medical experts, etc. that I realized the prosecution's case was not solid at all.

This is me as well. Usually, the people that are arrested are guilty so assuming they were too is normal. It probably was a year after the murder that I started to get interested enough to delve into what happened. I do remember thinking nonsense about the satanic rituals or manage a trois stories that were reported so much in the news.

Thanks for the link into the Dunning Kruger effect. That is fascinating.
 
.
.
.
I know I changed my mind. I assumed they were guilty when all the information I could get was coming from the police and prosecutors. It wasn't until I could actually start evaluating the evidence of the forensic and medical experts, etc. that I realized the prosecution's case was not solid at all.


It wasn't until 6 months into the Massei trial (when the TMB testing was revealed and the nefarious DNA testing of Stefanoni came to light) that it became apparent that Mignini had been framing Knox/Sollecito. The defense requested a dismissal, but Massei refused.
 
Raffaele visited Perugia recently. He was there the same time as Guede who was out of prison for the weekend. It would have been interesting if the two had run into each other.

http://www.ilgiornale.it/news/crona...orna-perugia-e-ragazza-americana-1526427.html



"What? Sollecito visited Perugia recently?? What a sick bastard! Does he have no shame whatsoever??! Not only does he help stab a poor young woman (a future Secretary-General of the United Nations, no less) to death, then lie about it, then write a book lying about it, then have the temerity not to apologise about that lying in clear defiance of an explicit court order to do so..... but now he actually feels the need to go back to a town where he has no business, where all the inhabitants hate his guts, simply in order to mock his victim!"

(copyright: most pro-guilt commentators)
 
It wasn't until 6 months into the Massei trial (when the TMB testing was revealed and the nefarious DNA testing of Stefanoni came to light) that it became apparent that Mignini had been framing Knox/Sollecito. The defense requested a dismissal, but Massei refused.


Yes. This and other related incidents very clearly points to the opinion that the judges in the Massei trial (and, as is widely reported elsewhere, judges in trials - especially first-instance trials - throughout Italy) had already formed the default view that the prosecutors' case (prosecutors, remember, who were literal and emotional friends/allies of judges, as members of the very same judicial group) was effectively likely to be sound, fair and objective - and that by contrast any defence objections were effectively likely to nothing more or less than sophistic attempts to thwart justice.


I've said it before, etc, etc..... but Italian criminal justice is fundamentally unfit for purpose (its purpose being the fair and accurate application of justice as it is defined in modern liberalised-democracy jurisprudence and ethics, in as speedy a manner as is practicably possible, with ample safeguards and correctional procedures and proper levels of accountability). Italy itself is broken in so very many ways. Gorgeous place to go for short holidays - but horrible place to try to do business, or in which to live as an expat (it may be great for years, but as soon as you're either a victim or a suspect of any sort of crime, or you get embroiled in any kind of civil dispute, or regulatory dispute, or dispute with local or central government.....)
 
It's the social dynamics and psychology of the case that intrigue me, too. A book should be written about it without delving into guilt or innocence.

I know I changed my mind. I assumed they were guilty when all the information I could get was coming from the police and prosecutors. It wasn't until I could actually start evaluating the evidence of the forensic and medical experts, etc. that I realized the prosecution's case was not solid at all.


I know I've said both these things myself many times before as well, but:

1) I also truly did start out as a believer in the safety and correctness of the Knox/Sollecito convictions in this case. I remember hearing snippets from the Massei trial in the media here in UK during 2009, and I actually remember where I was (driving round Hyde Park Corner late in the evening after a night out) when I heard the Massei verdicts over the radio. And I genuinely did then only buy "Darkness Descending" in March 2010 purely because it was on a "buy one, get one free" offer alongside a book I actually did want to buy - and because I remembered the case. And then, of course, having read DD, and having thought that everything within it was accurate, reliable and true, it only reinforced my belief in Knox's/Sollecito's guilt. I genuinely did then seek out online resources to try to see what people were discussing about a few smaller elements of the case - which is when I alighted upon pmf.org. And it was then that I quickly realised that a) there were fundamental, serious problems underpinning all the convictions; b) pretty much everyone on pmf.org was pro-guilt, and pretty much everyone was either ignoring, handwaving or horribly rationalising every single one of these problems; c) pretty much anyone on pmf.org who challenged any facet of the convictions - irrespective of the clarity/civility of their position - was "disappeared" from the site in extremely short order; and d) pretty much everyone on pmf.org, from the administrators on downwards, was a gold-plated nutjob.

2) I also have long held the belief that the online commentary dynamics around this case - specifically in respect of the Knox/Sollecito trial process and Knox/Sollecito themselves - are a fascinating and extremely worthwhile case study into important areas of group/individual psychology in a Web 2.0 world of messageboards and social media, especially where one takes into account the disconnect in personas between certain people's real-world identities and their constructed online personas. Thankfully there have by now (to my knowledge) been two pretty interesting academic exercises looking into exactly these things. And, as all of us here have known for a very, very long time....... while it's undeniable that the pro-acquittal/pro-innocence "side" of things has indeed attracted a very small number of individuals with potential mental health issues, these studies have shown conclusively that the really serious questions have to be asked about the motivation and psychology of the pro-guilt community. I think there's a good bit more to be done, and I do genuinely think that the academic and medical communities have an awful lot to learn about individual and group behaviours/activism from this case.
 


It's so very bizarre isn't it?

I and many others have explained on these threads, time and again, what 530.1 actually means in practice (both in terms of the letter and the spirit of the code) - notwithstanding of course the (inconvenient - to pro-guilt commentators) truth that there are NOT legally different "flavours" of acquittal in Italy, and that the different paras of 530 are nothing more than reactionary clumsiness on the part of the people who rewrote the code after the legislative changes were effectively forced onto Italy in the late 80s. It's in fact manifestly clear - through proper, informed analysis - that the Italian 530.1 is absolutely NOT "equivalent" in any way to the Scottish "not proven" verdict*. And that's been articulated here many times (without, IIRC, ever even any attempt from a pro-guilt commentator to engage in meaningful debate over this interpretation).

And yet the same old suspects just carry on trotting out the same old misrepresentations. Whether it's wilful, or through ongoing inability to understand, or simply through lack of intellectual capacity, it's impossible to say. I suppose it must be the same as what rational thinkers feel when they try to engage Moon-landing-hoax theorists in debate: no matter how much a rational, scientific thinker explains how (for example) the sheer forces of gravity and inertia (related to the force applied to the flag by the astronaut) will make the flags on the Moon sway and ripple, without any need whatsoever for air pressure to be present, the nutters will come back as if not a jot of that went in, with their "AH-HAAAA! How are those flags fluttering around like that if there's no atmosphere and therefore no air resistance or wind on the Moon's surface????!!1!!!11!!"


Sometimes there's simply no reasoning with those who are unable or incapable of understanding reason.........


* In fact, while all Scottish "not proven" verdicts would indeed map onto the Italian 530.1.... the vast majority of Scottish "not guilty" verdicts would also map onto the Italian 530.1. And it's only the comparative extremely small proportion of Scottish "not guilty" verdicts that would map onto 530.2: only, in fact, those in which the court ruled that no crime was ever even committed, or those where the court deemed that the innocence of the defendant(s) could be satisfactorily proven (and of course only a vanishingly small number of that latter category of cases ever make it as far as a criminal trial in any event - because if the defendant is able to prove his/her factual innocence, then it's near-inconceivable that charges would ever even be brought, let alone the case progressing to a full trial).
 
Last edited:
I know I've said both these things myself many times before as well, but:

1) I also truly did start out as a believer in the safety and correctness of the Knox/Sollecito convictions in this case. I remember hearing snippets from the Massei trial in the media here in UK during 2009, and I actually remember where I was (driving round Hyde Park Corner late in the evening after a night out) when I heard the Massei verdicts over the radio. And I genuinely did then only buy "Darkness Descending" in March 2010 purely because it was on a "buy one, get one free" offer alongside a book I actually did want to buy - and because I remembered the case. And then, of course, having read DD, and having thought that everything within it was accurate, reliable and true, it only reinforced my belief in Knox's/Sollecito's guilt. I genuinely did then seek out online resources to try to see what people were discussing about a few smaller elements of the case - which is when I alighted upon pmf.org. And it was then that I quickly realised that a) there were fundamental, serious problems underpinning all the convictions; b) pretty much everyone on pmf.org was pro-guilt, and pretty much everyone was either ignoring, handwaving or horribly rationalising every single one of these problems; c) pretty much anyone on pmf.org who challenged any facet of the convictions - irrespective of the clarity/civility of their position - was "disappeared" from the site in extremely short order; and d) pretty much everyone on pmf.org, from the administrators on downwards, was a gold-plated nutjob.

2) I also have long held the belief that the online commentary dynamics around this case - specifically in respect of the Knox/Sollecito trial process and Knox/Sollecito themselves - are a fascinating and extremely worthwhile case study into important areas of group/individual psychology in a Web 2.0 world of messageboards and social media, especially where one takes into account the disconnect in personas between certain people's real-world identities and their constructed online personas. Thankfully there have by now (to my knowledge) been two pretty interesting academic exercises looking into exactly these things. And, as all of us here have known for a very, very long time....... while it's undeniable that the pro-acquittal/pro-innocence "side" of things has indeed attracted a very small number of individuals with potential mental health issues, these studies have shown conclusively that the really serious questions have to be asked about the motivation and psychology of the pro-guilt community. I think there's a good bit more to be done, and I do genuinely think that the academic and medical communities have an awful lot to learn about individual and group behaviours/activism from this case.

Indeed. I have come across a small handful of pro-innocence posters who are definitely in the "potential mental health problems" group, but the truly nasty trolls and sick people belong in the pro-guilt group. Among these is a troll who masquerades under many names but his favorite is "Joe Zoo". Then there's the doctor who was literally mentally ill and attacked his therapist, Brendan Mull. He had his medical license suspended. Another was a woman, who was primarily known as "Ghislane" but had many names (mhill4, Potestas, ex-libris, et al) due to being banned from sites. She once told me that my daughter should be shot solely for being my daughter and "scumbag lines like your aren't fit to walk the earth." A fan of hers was a man who went by, ironically, "Think1st" who stalked me on the internet leaving ugly messages about my daughter who had zero to do with the Kercher case and had never even posted about it. The list goes on and on. I'm sure several of you have stories of your own run-ins with psycho guilters.
 
Last edited:
Indeed. I have come across a small handful of pro-innocence posters who are definitely in the "potential mental health problems" group, but the truly nasty trolls and sick people belong in the pro-guilt group. Among these is a troll who masquerades under many names but his favorite is "Joe Zoo". Then there's the doctor who was literally mentally ill and attacked his therapist, Brendan Mull. He had his medical license suspended. Another was a woman, who was primarily known as "Ghislane" but had many names (mhill4, Potestas, ex-libris, et al) due to being banned from sites. She once told me that my daughter should be shot solely for being my daughter and "scumbag lines like your aren't fit to walk the earth." A fan of hers was a man who went by, ironically, "Think1st" who stalked me on the internet leaving ugly messages about my daughter who had zero to do with the Kercher case and had never even posted about it. The list goes on and on. I'm sure several of you have stories of your own run-ins with psycho guilters.

You forgot Grahame Rhodes who talked in graphic detail how Amanda would be murdered and how he would laugh when it happened.
 
Raffaele visited Perugia recently. He was there the same time as Guede who was out of prison for the weekend. It would have been interesting if the two had run into each other.

http://www.ilgiornale.it/news/crona...orna-perugia-e-ragazza-americana-1526427.html

Once again another Italian media source confirms that Raffaele had been "acquitted definitively" back in 2015. This must infuriate the remaining guilt campaigners... no mention at all of the Scottish verdict of "not proven".

I wonder why?
 
Indeed. I have come across a small handful of pro-innocence posters who are definitely in the "potential mental health problems" group, but the truly nasty trolls and sick people belong in the pro-guilt group. Among these is a troll who masquerades under many names but his favorite is "Joe Zoo". Then there's the doctor who was literally mentally ill and attacked his therapist, Brendan Mull. He had his medical license suspended. Another was a woman, who was primarily known as "Ghislane" but had many names (mhill4, Potestas, ex-libris, et al) due to being banned from sites. She once told me that my daughter should be shot solely for being my daughter and "scumbag lines like your aren't fit to walk the earth." A fan of hers was a man who went by, ironically, "Think1st" who stalked me on the internet leaving ugly messages about my daughter who had zero to do with the Kercher case and had never even posted about it. The list goes on and on. I'm sure several of you have stories of your own run-ins with psycho guilters.

I remember Think1st. He once went on a rant that all PIP are uncultured swine that buy cheap non imported olive oil/wine (??) and that the defining trait of the PGP was an over abundance of empathy. He deleted his posting account after the final acquittal because even weirdo guilters like him saw the futility in spamming "the mafia must've fixed it" for years on end.

I first encountered guilters on the CNN comment board and that's what drew me into the case, because it was just another news story until I discovered there was a strange cast of characters obsessed with a girl in a crime where a blood covered criminal was found standing over the body. Hmm who did it, apparently not the guy with the bloody knife marked hands who raped the victim, according to them. That was my entrance down the rabbit hole.
 
It's Jovana Popovic. At least get that much correct.

So you've got nothing... no contradiction's in the account given by four different people; no explanation for how they got with Jovana and her mother to come up with this story within hours of the discovery of the murder; no evidence from the bus company to contradict Jovana's mother; no explanation for why Jovana and her mother would be willing to risk a conspiracy to conceal a murder charge for people they barely knew; no evidence that Michele contradicted Jovana about trying to contact him first. No surprise here.

Do you have any evidence to prove Jovana made the claim "people do this in Serbia all the time"? I've just read her court testimony, start to finish, and she never makes such a claim so I'm just wondering where you got this from? Surely you didn't just make that up... right? --RIGHT???

Leave an unattended suitcase? So now you're trying to couch this as if she tried to pull a typical terrorist tactic. Nice try (well, not really, but..) but that's NOT what she was trying to do. She asked the bus driver if she could put the suitcase on the bus for her daughter to receive in Perugia. For whatever reason she thought she might be able to do this and apparently she was told it was not allowed. Bum rush? More colorful hyperbole to make your point, I suppose. Much more likely she was politely advised that was not allowed. How does the phrase "gilding the lily" apply here?


Your pal, Stacyhs, made this claim. Are you calling her a liar?
 
A clarification. Not only did the Marasca CSC panel fault the Nencini appeal court's legal reasoning, they also found that the Nencini court judgment had violated Italian law and the Italian Constitution. Thus, it would be erroneous to state that they had even "probably" considered the Nencini judgment fair.

For example, in Section 4.1 and 4.2, without explicitly mentioning CPP Article 192 in that section, the Marasca CSC panel MR agrees with the appellants that the Nencini court violated that law by the improper use of DNA profile data, not obtained in accordance with international standards, and thus not properly usable to establish a fact. The MR attacks the DNA evidence as deficient in lacking reliability and repeatability, and thus not able to establish a fact. CPP Article 192.2 states: The existence of a fact cannot be inferred from circumstantial evidence unless such evidence is serious, precise, and consistent.

In Section 4.3 and 4.3.1, the MR criticizes the way that the results of Guede's trial was used in the Nencini judgment, as a violation of CPP Article 192.3, which requires corroborating evidence to confirm the reliability of such alleged evidence from an accused co-conspirator. The Marasca CSC panel MR goes on to point out, in Section 4.3.2, that this use of Guede's trial results or his unexamined statements also violates the Italian Constitution, Article 111, Clause 4, as well as several laws (CPP articles) elaborating on that constitutional provision.

Absolute nonsense: the Italian Scientific Police followed ENSFI standards.

Stop insulting a team of highly qualified competent scientists who've entered the police forensics team as amongst the best of their generation.

Their aim is to produce objective result. They could not care less about the nonentity 'personalities' involved, nor would they succumb to threats to their objectivity.
 
Guys you're missing the bigger picture. Vixen is conceding that Popovic's testimony is damning to the prosecution's timeline and crime scenario. Since no court rejected Popovic she's practically conceding reasonable doubt.

The only time her testimony was considered significant is when Florence and the Supreme Court threw out Raff's claim for compensation.


They used Papa Sollecito's and Popovic's evidence against him.
 
Your pal, Stacyhs, made this claim. Are you calling her a liar?


Once again..... please try reading back the bat-guano stuff you've actually written (and to which others have responded) before attempting to construct yet more strawman misdirection.

The post of yours to which TruthCalls had responded said this (YOUR WORDS):

Try and leave an unattended suitcase on any public transport in Europe and you'll get the bum's rush.

Hahaha 'Popovich says people do this in Serbia all the time'.



Let's look at that first sentence of yours, shall we? You wrote about leaving unattended suitcases on public transport, Vixen. And then, in that second sentence of yours, you stated that this was what Popovic said people did in Serbia.

But that's NOT what Popovic (via her mother) said she was trying to do on the night in question. Her mother was not simply trying to "leave an unattended suitcase" on a bus. Rather, Popovic stated that her mother was trying to place a suitcase on the bus with the consent of the driver, such that the case could be taken to Perugia.

So you'd already created your own strawman, Vixen. And then you surpassed even yourself by creating ANOTHER strawman in claiming that Stacyhs had said that Jovana had said "people (leave unattended suitcases on public transport" all the time. Rather, Jovana had said it was common in Serbia for people to ask bus drivers to allow suitcases to be carried from point to point. Very different, Vixen.

Another day, (yet) another piece of attempted sophistry........................
 
No PGP has ever wondered in the history of this case if it might be a little implausible that Amanda and Raffaele rushed out on 15 minutes notice to slaughter Meredith, and pick up a random burglar along the way.

Vixen arguing Popovic is a bent witness is one of the most pro-PIP arguments a guilter has ever made.

Knox had been lying in wait for Mez ever since she returned from having a GREAT time at Halloween. She was up at her usual 5:00am to confront Mez at the cottage. Still there when Mez finally got up at about one or two. Raff came around to join her. Mez was off again out of the door leaving Knox to seethe at Mez' popularity and great social life, whilst she had none. Just a weird wimpy boyfriend who took drugs, whilst Mez' handsome boyfriend went ski-ing.
 
Last edited:
Hadn't seen this. Very nice article. Thanks for the link.

I notice Vixen hasn't said anything regarding Article 530 and what paragraphs 1 and 2 say. I suspect this is Vixen denial... she can't admit she's wrong so she'll just avoid it for a while, resurfacing some time later repeating her claim. She's nothing if not predictable.

There is plenty of material on this topic already, so please do a search and get up to speed.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom