The Trials of Amanda Knox and Raffaele Sollecito: Part 28

Status
Not open for further replies.
o ENSFI requires multiple tests before DNA results can be considered reliable. Even the RIS expert witness testified a single sample can not be considered reliable, even for standard tests, let alone LCN. Stefanoni failed to amplify more than once on all critical DNA samples.

o ENSFI requires you not perform LCN profiling in a lab not certified for such tests. You should never perform LCN profiling in a lab that has already processed DNA from the suspected sources. Neither of these procedures were followed.

o ENSFI certainly does not endorse an unqualified police officer, in a non-sterile environment like a police station, to remove an item of evidence from a sealed collection bag and then place in inside a non-sterile box sitting on the desk and not appropriate for evidence collection.

o I doubt ENSFI would consider it good practice to store a piece of metal in a plastic container, allowing the evidence to rust and become unusable.

o ENSFI would not have considered the extra male alleles on the bra clasp as 'stutter' and failed to report them.

o I doubt ENSFI would consider it good practice to pick up a piece of evidence with a dirty glove, stroke it, pass it alone to other technicians and then put that piece of evidence back down on the ground to photograph it.

o I doubt anyone following ENSFI would consider DNA negative, TMB negative samples to nonetheless be samples of the victim's blood.

These are just a few things that quickly come to mind. There's a reason why every single expert, world wide, who has looked at this case and commented has been exceedingly critical of how Stefanoni and the Scientific Police handled the case. It's why the court, in acquitted Amanda and Raffaele, was extremely critical of Stefanoni and the SP. You calling this nonsense is about as useful as declaring it "dark" at midnight.
Just for the record: ENFSI Best Practice Manuals ;)
 
In Vixen's mind a country's high conviction rate is a reflection on "more justice served" and not "higher standard of evidence brought to trial."

It's a cargo cultish thought process. I do get a good laugh though seeing guilters badmouth the Italian judicial system they spent eight years fervently defending.
 
It's been done several times, including a citation by a professor at Bath Uni, an expert in Italian history and law.

In other words, you CAN'T provide evidence to back your bogus claim and rather than be mature enough to admit you're wrong you're going to continue with this ludicrous claim.

That's OK Vixen. We ALL know you are wrong. No one else here has had a problem providing the evidence. You're the only one who claims something else and you're the only one who can't provide evidence to back your claim. You've already embarrassed yourself with the claim, as if we didn't have access to the CPP to read for ourselves. Had you simply admitted you were wrong it would be over, and you'd likely have earned a measure of respect in the process. Instead, you choose to continue to dig. Unreal.
 
The parade through the streets was banned. There was a memorial service. Can't stop the priest from doing what he likes in his own church.

False on both counts. Both the archbishop and the local police banned the original mass supposed to be held at 6:30 PM. The police declared it could only be held at dawn, but that too was cancelled:


An archbishop and a local police chief in southern Italy have forced the scrapping of a public mass for the soul of a reputed Canadian crime clan boss, slain near Montreal.

Rocco Sollecito, 67, was gunned down in May while driving his car in Laval. Police said Sollecito had high-level ties to the former reputed head of the Montreal Mafia.
•Rocco Sollecito, reputed high-ranking Montreal Mafia member, killed in Laval

A priest in Grumo Appula, the Italian town of Sollecito's roots, posted notices inviting parishioners to mass Tuesday evening. But the police chief ordered the mass held at dawn instead to avoid drawing a big crowd.

Bari-Bitonto Archbishop Francesco Cacucci also opposed the evening public mass, calling it a "great scandal.'' He called it inappropriate for someone who didn't live a Christian life.

In the end, no mass at all was celebrated.
http://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/montreal/montreal-mafia-rocco-sollecito-mass-cancelled-1.3913273

I have a question for you, Vixen: why was no mention of Francesco or Raffaele Sollecito ever made in any of the articles written about Rocco Sollecito at the time of his death? In 2016, a relationship between them would definitely have been mentioned, especially in Italy. Yet none was. Care to hazard a guess why that was?

As for that alleged photo of Francesco, it's no wonder you have failed to produce it. It doesn't exist any more than the memorial existed.
 
False on both counts. Both the archbishop and the local police banned the original mass supposed to be held at 6:30 PM. The police declared it could only be held at dawn, but that too was cancelled:



http://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/montreal/montreal-mafia-rocco-sollecito-mass-cancelled-1.3913273

I have a question for you, Vixen: why was no mention of Francesco or Raffaele Sollecito ever made in any of the articles written about Rocco Sollecito at the time of his death? In 2016, a relationship between them would definitely have been mentioned, especially in Italy. Yet none was. Care to hazard a guess why that was?

As for that alleged photo of Francesco, it's no wonder you have failed to produce it. It doesn't exist any more than the memorial existed.

Quite a few forum members will recall the picture.

Keep up the trolling.
 
It's been done several times, including a citation by a professor at Bath Uni, an expert in Italian history and law.

You are referring to Prof. Anna Bull who teaches
Politics, Languages & International Studies
.

https://researchportal.bath.ac.uk/en/persons/anna-bull

Anna Cento Bull is Professor of Italian History and Politics at the University of Bath, UK.
http://www.unrest.eu/anna-cento-bull/

She is NOT an expert in Italian LAW whatsoever.
 
Quite a few forum members will recall the picture.

Keep up the trolling.

Really? Yet no one here has mentioned recalling it. Why do you keep lying? If you could produce this photo, you would. You know it, we know it, anyone reading this forum knows it. Raper and Slick Pete on TJMK refer to this alleged photo, yet it is not even produced there. Hmmmmm. I wonder why that is?

This is your problem: you just make things up.
Or, you honestly believe something when you say it, but when unable to provide a single shred of evidence for it, you don't have the ethics to admit it. Continuing to claim something you know to be false or unsupported by any evidence is the action of a troll.

I notice you failed to answer my question: why was no mention ever made of Rocco's "brother", Francesco, or is "nephew", Raffaele, in any article written about Rocco?
 
Last edited:
I doubt there'll be another series. Sluts tend to be very boring people. One trick ponies.

Really? That hasn't been my experience. I have found them to be adventurous and not uptight about anything. I'll take a slut over a prude with a stick up her bum every day and twice on Sunday.
 
I'm having a mental image of someone searching in vain through the ISF and TJMK archives for a photo that doesn't exist. It's "exactly similar" to the same fruitless search a while back for Raffaele's Napapijri jacket and cap with a red stripe.
 
Quite a few forum members will recall the picture.

Keep up the trolling.

Why are you accusing others of trolling when you:

1) Have not produced the alleged picture?
2) Have not cited ONE forum member (other than yourself) who recalls the picture?​
You make claims and allegations. They seldom line up with anything factual.
 
I'm having a mental image of someone searching in vain through the ISF and TJMK archives for a photo that doesn't exist. It's "exactly similar" to the same fruitless search a while back for Raffaele's Napapijri jacket and cap with a red stripe.

I can all but guarantee you she isn't searching for a photo she knows does not exist. It's just easier for her to claim a non-existent photo exists than it is admitting she's wrong.

What really amuses me is her claim re; Art. 530. I mean, it's one thing to claim a non-existent photo exists knowing full well it doesn't (though probably thinking it's tough to prove a negative so what the hell) but it's quite another to continue to repeat a claim when the evidence to the contrary has been posted numerous times. She blames it on a Wikipedia error as if any of us are relying on Wikipedia. Even when faced with a copy of the CPP she continues to lie about it. And she has the chutzpah to accuse Amanda and Raffaele of lying.
 
The parade through the streets was banned. There was a memorial service. Can't stop the priest from doing what he likes in his own church.

You have shown nothing that contradicts news reports that the memorial was cancelled.
 
If the murder had happened in Texas, the pair would have fried on Old Smoky by now.

It's Old Smokey and no they wouldn't have. Add the death penalty in the United States to that exceedingly long list of things about which you know nothing. Only 6 states even still potentially use the electric chair with 2 more reserving its use in case lethal injection is ever ruled unconstitutional. Texas is not one of those states.

Unlikely that the "pair" would have ever seen the inside of a courtroom other than in hapless and routinely humiliated Italy:p
 
Why are you accusing others of trolling when you:

1) Have not produced the alleged picture?
2) Have not cited ONE forum member (other than yourself) who recalls the picture?​
You make claims and allegations. They seldom line up with anything factual.

Errata:

I have found pictures of the Rocco Sollecito funeral which was held in June 2016 in the Ahuntsic-Cartierville borough of Montréal in Québec, on the north of the island.

http://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/montreal/rocco-sollecito-mafia-funeral-1.3614868

There are no pictures of anyone related to Raffaele Sollecito. The funeral service scheduled for December 2016 at Grumo Appula, the Italian town of Rocco Sollecito's roots, was first rescheduled to avoid controvery, then cancelled altogether by the local archbishop, citing scandal.

http://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/montreal/montreal-mafia-rocco-sollecito-mass-cancelled-1.3913273
 
Last edited:
You are referring to Prof. Anna Bull who teaches .

https://researchportal.bath.ac.uk/en/persons/anna-bull

http://www.unrest.eu/anna-cento-bull/

She is NOT an expert in Italian LAW whatsoever.

Stacyhs, thanks for posting this. Here are descriptions of Professor Bull's professional work and expertise:

"Anna Cento Bull

Anna Cento Bull is Professor of Italian History and Politics at the University of Bath, UK. She has examined the legacy of 1960s-1970s Italian terrorism, exploring issues related to reconciliation, memory, truth and justice and comparing the views of victims, perpetrators and politicians close to the right. Early research focussed on extreme-right terrorism. The findings of this research have been published as journal articles, book chapters, and a solo-authored book, Italian Neofascism. The Strategy of Tension and the Politics of Nonreconciliation, published by Berghahn in 2007 (re-published in paperback in 2011). More recently, her research has examined the end of terrorism and its legacy in Italy with reference to both left and right terrorism, thanks to a new major round of interviews with former terrorists and victims/relatives of victims. A new book, entitled Ending Terrorism in Italy, written jointly with Dr Philip Cooke, University of Strathclyde, was published by Routledge in 2013. During the course of her research on Italian terrorism she was awarded an AHRC Research Grant (2005) and an AHRC Research Fellowship (2010)."

Source: http://www.unrest.eu/anna-cento-bull/


"Professor Anna Bull was appointed Professor of Italian in 1996, having taught at Bath since 1987. She graduated from the University of Naples and wrote her doctorate at the University of Reading, where she subsequently held a lectureship. Her research interests include Italian fascism and neofascism, the Lega Nord, regionalism, federalism and political cultures and identities

She teaches a final-year option ‘Political Terrorism and its Legacy in Italy' and contributes to the Italian Politics and Society courses. She also convenes a postgraduate unit, Multi-Level Governance and Multi-Layered Citizenship in Europe and contributes to other MA units.

Her publications include From Peasant to Entrepreneur. The Survival of the Family Economy in Italy [with P. Corner] (1993), Entrepreneurial Textile Communities [with M. Pitt and J. Szarka] (1993), Social Identities and Political Cultures in Italy (2000), and [with M. Gilbert] The Lega Nord and the Northern Question in Italian Politics (2001), Italian Neofascism. The Strategy of Tension and the Politics of Nonreconciliation (2007) and [edited with G. Baldini] Politica in Italia 2008 (2009)."

Source: https://theconversation.com/profiles/anna-cento-bull-122077

Professor Bull's background relates to the study of terrorism in Italy, as well as the history and culture of Italy; she is not a lawyer and has no publications related directly to Italian law.
 
Last edited:
I can all but guarantee you she isn't searching for a photo she knows does not exist. It's just easier for her to claim a non-existent photo exists than it is admitting she's wrong.

What really amuses me is her claim re; Art. 530. I mean, it's one thing to claim a non-existent photo exists knowing full well it doesn't (though probably thinking it's tough to prove a negative so what the hell) but it's quite another to continue to repeat a claim when the evidence to the contrary has been posted numerous times. She blames it on a Wikipedia error as if any of us are relying on Wikipedia. Even when faced with a copy of the CPP she continues to lie about it. And she has the chutzpah to accuse Amanda and Raffaele of lying.

The guilters resort to remarkable misdirections in an attempt to hide their obvious lack of valid arguments and their readily apparent misunderstandings and/or misstatements of Italian law and other relevant topics.

Here's the short-form verdict (aka, the disposition) from the Marasca CSC panel motivation report, translated:

"FOR THESE REASONS

Pursuant to Article 620 letter A) Italian Code of Criminal Procedure; annuls the ruling under appeal with respect to the crime under charge B) of the rubric because the crime is extinct due to statute of limitations;

pursuant to Articles 620 letter L) and 530, section 2 Italian Code of Criminal Procedure; excluding the aggravating circumstance under Italian under Article 61 n. 2 Penal Code, in relation to the crime of calumny, annuls the ruling under appeal without referral with respect to the crimes under charges A), D) and E) of the rubric because the appellants did not commit the act.

Recalculates the sentence imposed upon appellant Amanda Maria Knox for the crime of calumny {calunnia = false accusation} in three years of confinement.

Thus decided 27/03/2015"

The recent artificial controversy generated by one or more guilters about Article 530 - pretending that there was a separate "Article 530.2", when the notation "Article 530.2" is simply a short-hand designation for "Article 530 section 2" (aka "Article 530 paragraph 2", aka "Article 530,2") was a misdirection to cover-up the guilters' false statements about the significance of the acquittal.

The original Italian word translated as "section" in the translation is "comma", which in context may be translated as either "section" or "paragraph".
 
Last edited:

Also here.
http://enfsi.eu/documents/forensic-guidelines/

Steffanoni clearly did not meet ENFSI standards for hair analysis. The guidelines show she failed to follow best practice when using non-standard protocols e.g. around testing of DNA on the knife.

Mentioned in the guideline

♦ Environmental monitoring procedures should be documented. Test results shall be recorded and reviewed.
♦ In case of a contamination event, the lab should implement corrective/preventive actions as necessary.
As a minimum the laboratories should keep the following information concerning
traceability of contaminations:
1. Contamination count vs. total number of samples processed;
a. Number of contaminations in reference samples;
b. Number of contaminations in case work samples
2. Contamination analysis;
a. Number of sample to sample contaminations;
b. Number of person to sample contaminations.
3. Determination of the analytical step where the contamination has likely
occurred (Crime Scene, Sampling, Extraction (separate automatic from
manual), Amplification, Electrophoresis).
4. Specific activity that led to the contamination (human factor, machine,
procedure).

ENFSI quotes Gill and Butler in their best practice manuals; Steffanoni not so much (ie not at all).
 
I can all but guarantee you she isn't searching for a photo she knows does not exist. It's just easier for her to claim a non-existent photo exists than it is admitting she's wrong.
What really amuses me is her claim re; Art. 530. I mean, it's one thing to claim a non-existent photo exists knowing full well it doesn't (though probably thinking it's tough to prove a negative so what the hell) but it's quite another to continue to repeat a claim when the evidence to the contrary has been posted numerous times. She blames it on a Wikipedia error as if any of us are relying on Wikipedia. Even when faced with a copy of the CPP she continues to lie about it. And she has the chutzpah to accuse Amanda and Raffaele of lying.

Admitting she was wrong? What a laugh. Vixen wouldn't admit she was wrong about the charter despite being provided video footage of Amanda having her boarding pass being checked with the commercial fight number on the reader board above her head. She came up with excuses including that you can charter a commercial flight. Like Trump, she appears incapable of an admission of error.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom