The Trials of Amanda Knox and Raffaele Sollecito: Part 28

Status
Not open for further replies.
No PGP has ever wondered in the history of this case if it might be a little implausible that Amanda and Raffaele rushed out on 15 minutes notice to slaughter Meredith, and pick up a random burglar along the way.

Vixen arguing Popovic is a bent witness is one of the most pro-PIP arguments a guilter has ever made.
 
Although the most pro-PIP argument some guilters make are those that argue Guede is innocent and his date story is true. That's basically conceding Amanda Knox is innocent from the get go since it answers the main question posed on page 1 of thread 1: How can Amanda Knox and Rudy Guede both be guilty. They're agreeing with us PIP: they can't.
 

Hadn't seen this. Very nice article. Thanks for the link.

I notice Vixen hasn't said anything regarding Article 530 and what paragraphs 1 and 2 say. I suspect this is Vixen denial... she can't admit she's wrong so she'll just avoid it for a while, resurfacing some time later repeating her claim. She's nothing if not predictable.
 
Hadn't seen this. Very nice article. Thanks for the link.

I notice Vixen hasn't said anything regarding Article 530 and what paragraphs 1 and 2 say. I suspect this is Vixen denial... she can't admit she's wrong so she'll just avoid it for a while, resurfacing some time later repeating her claim. She's nothing if not predictable.

Also note that this UK publication freely admits that RS and AK had been exonerated in 2015.

We call that a fact. Vixen calls it a typing error.
 
Last edited:
Last edited:
Oooooooops!!!! My bad.

Or as our good friend would say, "typing error." <ducking, running>

You do realize that the Independent was bought off by the massive, million dollar PR machine, don't you? Or maybe it was the ghost of Raffaele's dead "Uncle" Rocco, the Mafia Don, haunting the author. Speaking of which, has Vixen...or anyone else for that matter...provided evidence that they were closely related? Or the alleged photo showing Dr. Sollecito at the (cancelled) memorial?:D
 

Bill, thanks for posting this link to a very informative article in an Irish publication.

It does have one error regarding Guede's conviction:

"Now her {Amanda's} name has been cleared, and another man is serving a life sentence for the murder of Meredith, who was just 21 when her own life was taken from her."

Guede's original sentence was "life" but this was reduced to 30 years because he chose a "fast track" trial, and it was again reduced, on appeal, to 16 years. The appeal court considered that Guede's maximum sentence before mitigating circumstances was 24 years. The reasoning used by the Borsini appeal court to reduce Guede's sentence to 16 years included the following:

"Then, apart from the attempt to staunch the flow of blood from the wound and the proof that it was not he that held the knife that was compatible with the worst of the lesions, it should also be remembered that Guede was the only one, even if in a somewhat fanciful reconstruction of events, to indicate the perpetrators.

Taking into account the elements and the circumstances of the crime and, above all else, of the unspeakable suffering inflicted on the victim, the panel holds that it must deliver a judgment in which the mitigating and aggravating circumstances are considered of equal value.

As a result of the aforementioned judgment of equivalence, the sentence applicable becomes that covered in article 575 of the Penal Code.

In conclusion, the panel holds that the standard sentence on which to apply the reduction of one third for the process chosen, must still be in relation to the undeniable seriousness of the crime, being the maximum foreseen of 24 years."

The reasoning for the reduction of sentence shows that Guede was rewarded by a reduction in his sentence for naming Knox and Sollecito as perpetrators, without any corroborating evidence supporting his statements, and while always maintaining his legally permitted refusal to testify under questioning by the lawyers for Knox and Sollecito. It's an example of an unethical and unfair deception by the Italian prosecutors and judges.
 
To go on a bit about the issue of whether or not Knox and Sollecito received "fair trials", it's important to consider the definition of the term in the Italian and Council of Europe contexts.

The relevant articles of the Italian Constitution include:

Art. 10
The Italian legal system conforms to the generally recognised principles of international law. ....

Art. 13
Personal liberty is inviolable.
No one may be detained, inspected, or searched nor otherwise subjected to any restriction of personal liberty except by order of the Judiciary stating a reason and only in such cases and in such manner as provided by the law.In exceptional circumstances and under such conditions of necessity and urgency as shall conclusively be defined by the law, the police may take provisional measures that shall be referred within 48 hours to the Judiciary for validation and which, in default of such validation in the following 48 hours, shall be revoked and considered null and void.
Any act of physical and moral violence against a person subjected to restriction of personal liberty shall be punished.
The law shall establish the maximum duration of preventive detention.

Art. 14
The home is inviolable.
Personal domicile shall be inviolable.
Home inspections, searches, or seizures shall not be admissible save in the cases and manners complying with measures to safeguard personal liberty.

Art. 15
Freedom and confidentiality of correspondence and of every other form of communication is inviolable.
Limitations may only be imposed by judicial decision stating the reasons and in accordance with the guarantees provided by the law.

Art. 24
Anyone may bring cases before a court of law in order to protect their rights under civil and administrative law.
Defense is an inviolable right at every stage and instance of legal proceedings.The poor are entitled by law to proper means for action or defense in all courts.
The law shall define the conditions and forms of reparation in case of judicial errors.
Art. 27
Criminal responsibility is personal.
A defendant shall be considered not guilty until a final sentence has been passed. ....

Art. 28
Officials of the State or public agencies shall be directly responsible under criminal, civil, and administrative law for acts committed in violation of rights.
In such cases, civil liability shall extend to the State and to such public agency.

Art. 101
Justice is administered in the name of the people.
Judges are subject only to the law.
Art. 111
Jurisdiction is implemented through due process regulated by law. All court trials are conducted with adversary proceedings and the parties are entitled to equal conditions before an impartial judge in third party position. The law provides for the reasonable duration of trials. In criminal law trials, the law provides that the alleged offender shall be promptly informed confidentially of the nature and reasons for the charges that are brought and shall have adequate time and conditions to prepare a defence. The defendant shall have the right to cross-examine or to have cross-examined before a judge the persons making accusations and to summon and examine persons for the defence in the same conditions as the prosecution, as well as the right to produce all other evidence in favour of the defence. The defendant is entitled to the assistance of an interpreter in the case that he or she does not speak or understand the language in which the court proceedings are conducted.In criminal law proceedings, the formation of evidence is based on the principle of adversary hearings.
The guilt of the defendant cannot be established on the basis of statements by persons who, out of their own free choice, have always voluntarily avoided undergoing cross-examination by the defendant or the defence counsel.The law regulates the cases in which the formation of evidence does not occur in an adversary proceeding with the consent of the defendant or owing to reasons of ascertained objective impossibility or proven illicit conduct.
All judicial decisions shall include a statement of reasons.
Appeals to the Court of Cassation in cases of violations of the law are always allowed against sentences and against measures affecting personal freedom pronounced by ordinary and special courts. This rule can only be waived in cases of sentences by military tribunals in time of war.
Appeals to the Court of Cassation against decisions of the Council of State
and the Court of Accounts are permitted only for reasons of jurisdiction.
______
European Convention on Human Rights {Italy is a signatory and is legally bound to it, in accordance with treaty and Italian Constitution Article 10}

1. In the determination of ... any criminal charge against him, everyone is entitled to a fair and public hearing within a reasonable time by an independent and impartial tribunal established by law. Judgment shall be pronounced publicly ....
2. Everyone charged with a criminal offence shall be presumed innocent until proved guilty according to law.3. Everyone charged with a criminal offence has the following minimum rights:
(a) to be informed promptly, in a language which he understands and in detail, of the nature and cause of the accusation against him;
(b) to have adequate time and facilities for the preparation of his defence;
(c) to defend himself in person or through legal assistance of his own choosing or, if he has not sufficient means to pay for legal assistance, to be given it free when the interests of justice so require;
(d) to examine or have examined witnesses against him and to obtain the attendance and examination of witnesses on his behalf under the same conditions as witnesses against him;
(e) to have the free assistance of an interpreter if he cannot understand or speak the language used in court.

ECHR case-law has extended the above protections to include the questioning of a suspect by police and the detention of an accused person as stages of the criminal proceedings.
 
I'm not sure why you all bother. Vixen has proven over and over and over again, she doesn't care about the facts.

Last week she said that Amanda took a charter home and NEVER admitted she was wrong.

And I provided airline schedules and video of Amanda in the commercial airport in Rome getting her boarding pass checked with the BA flight 553 on the reader board above her. That is a daily flight from Rome to London Heathrow. As well as Associated Press vido titled Amanda Knox Plane arrives in Seattle which shows BA flight 49, a 747-400 landing at SeaTac. This proceeded the small press conference 15 minutes later. As a small footnote, Amanda is wearing the same clothes in the airport in Rome as she is in the press conference.

Now she says Popovic was lying for Amanda and Raffaele for no reason other than she Vixen doesn't believe Popovic's story about the suitcase. There was a time you could do that kind of thing in the United States.

I used Greyhound to get something to a customer overnight when they called after FedEx had picked up. I drove it to the Seattle bus terminal and paid a hefty sum to get it shipped to the bus terminal in Portland on the 10 pm bus to Portland. My customer had to pick it up at the terminal. I've also shipped packages from airport to airport.
 
Last edited:
I'm not sure why you all bother. Vixen has proven over and over and over again, she doesn't care about the facts.

Me neither. But both of us are calling the kettle black.

At this point with Knox being taken in by the N.A. innocence community, with her speaking and media stuff.....

... all that the remaining slut-shamers accomplish is to make Knox's point for her. It's the problem with them posting off the same song-sheet, they very rarely bother these days dealing with evidence - and in my opinion there's a reason for that.

They have to see how many times they can say "lies, lies, lies...." without specifically listing what those lies had been. And the Achilles Heel of it all, what lies have Knox and/or Sollecito told outside this case - I mean, if you're going to make the case that they're pathological than it would be nice if when making that slur, you actually provided evidence of it.

The remaining nutters are stuck in that week in 2007 when Mignini controlled the narrative - controlled it mainly by incarcerating those he wanted to deprive of a voice. His lies got all the way around the world before the truth could get its pants on.

But since March 2015 - those prosecution/investigative lies and "amnesiac" efforts have been exposed for what they were. Empty vessels.

Vixen here on ISF is reduced to simply making a specious claim, then when the claim is disproved, waiting 6 months and making it again as if for the first time.

So tell me again, why do we bother? These days when Vixen does that, all Knox gets out of it is another episode of "Scarlett Letter Reports". Knox then kinds links to the many women her age who've been assaulted in social media like it.

They discover they have voices and are not afraid to use them. The remaining nutters need better strategy - they're letting their urge to slut-shame overwhelm the message they believe they're sending - that the facts are on their side. Aside from the fact that they're not on their side - maybe that's the reason why they yell, "lies, slut, lies, slut, lies, slut......" so loud and long.

I say - at this point they are simply proving what Knox (and other women) have been saying. So perhaps there is a use for them.
 
Last edited:
Me neither. But both of us are calling the kettle black.

At this point with Knox being taken in by the N.A. innocence community, with her speaking and media stuff.....

... all that the remaining slut-shamers accomplish is to make Knox's point for her. It's the problem with them posting off the same song-sheet, they very rarely bother these days dealing with evidence - and in my opinion there's a reason for that.

They have to see how many times they can say "lies, lies, lies...." without specifically listing what those lies had been. And the Achilles Heel of it all, what lies have Knox and/or Sollecito told outside this case - I mean, if you're going to make the case that they're pathological than it would be nice if when making that slur, you actually provided evidence of it.

The remaining nutters are stuck in that week in 2007 when Mignini controlled the narrative - controlled it mainly by incarcerating those he wanted to deprive of a voice. His lies got all the way around the world before the truth could get its pants on.

But since March 2015 - those prosecution/investigative lies and "amnesiac" efforts have been exposed for what they were. Empty vessels.

Vixen here on ISF is reduced to simply making a specious claim, then when the claim is disproved, waiting 6 months and making it again as if for the first time.

So tell me again, why do we bother? These days when Vixen does that, all Knox gets out of it is another episode of "Scarlett Letter Reports". Knox then kinds links to the many women her age who've been assaulted in social media like it.

They discover they have voices and are not afraid to use them. The remaining nutters need better strategy - they're letting their urge to slut-shame overwhelm the message they believe they're sending - that the facts are on their side. Aside from the fact that they're not on their side - maybe that's the reason why they yell, "lies, slut, lies, slut, lies, slut......" so loud and long.

I say - at this point they are simply proving what Knox (and other women) have been saying. So perhaps there is a use for them.

I must admit, this is is the first time I had heard the claim that Popovic was lying, so I can understand going over that nonsense claim. At least it was new. But the motivation has been argued non-stop since it was issued. I mean how many times can the meaning of the words 'even if' be argued? Or 'not guilty' vs 'innocent'?

As for what Knox is doing with Scarlett Letters, I think she is doing what is needed. So much of humanity has always revolved around sexuality and people's attitudes about women's sexuality has almost always been unfair and wrong. It permeated this case. I haven't seen any of the episodes yet. I hope they are good for Amanda's sake.

In some ways, Amanda is very much like a modern day Hester Prynne.
 
I must admit, this is is the first time I had heard the claim that Popovic was lying, so I can understand going over that nonsense claim. At least it was new. But the motivation has been argued non-stop since it was issued. I mean how many times can the meaning of the words 'even if' be argued? Or 'not guilty' vs 'innocent'?

As for what Knox is doing with Scarlett Letters, I think she is doing what is needed. So much of humanity has always revolved around sexuality and people's attitudes about women's sexuality has almost always been unfair and wrong. It permeated this case. I haven't seen any of the episodes yet. I hope they are good for Amanda's sake.

In some ways, Amanda is very much like a modern day Hester Prynne.

It was the first time I'd heard anyone claim Popovic was lying, too. I wonder how many PGP actually believe that nonsense? I'd say not too many as it's not come up before in anything I've read except here.

I agree that how women are treated regarding sex vs men was very obvious in this case. Not one word do I see from the PGP condemning the MEN who were having sex, just Amanda. I never saw a PGP criticize Silenzi for bragging to his friends about the kind of sex he had with Meredith. Go figure; Amanda gets skewered as having loose morals and Trump gets elected president!:boggled:
 
It is exactly similar to the Scottish law 'not proven'.

As courts are supposed to come to a decision this rubric is being phased out.

In fact, it is astonishing that the Marasca court pulled it out of the hat. It was the only way it could get the pair out of jail. And it is as illegal and bent as a nine-bob note.

:jaw-dropp
 
It was the first time I'd heard anyone claim Popovic was lying, too. I wonder how many PGP actually believe that nonsense? I'd say not too many as it's not come up before in anything I've read except here.

I agree that how women are treated regarding sex vs men was very obvious in this case. Not one word do I see from the PGP condemning the MEN who were having sex, just Amanda. I never saw a PGP criticize Silenzi for bragging to his friends about the kind of sex he had with Meredith. Go figure; Amanda gets skewered as having loose morals and Trump gets elected president!:boggled:

Exactly, the man is almost even celebrated as a 'stud', while the woman is demonized as a 'slut'. This historical double standard goes back since the beginning of humans.

Amanda the she-devil temptress that lured the two nice Italian boys into raping and killing her roommate of a month. That ANYONE believes that nonsense stuns me. That their orgy transformed into torture and murder is also unbelievable. But those are their narratives that we hear.

What makes people equate sexuality with violence? From what I can see, 90 plus percent are sexual. That some are also violent is more coincidence than ANYTHING. It is irrelevant how many sex partners any of them had have. Far more important in evaluating people for potential to this kind of crime is their history of violence and crime. Neither of which can be attributed to Amanda or Raffaele. I think it is quite telling that neither Amanda or Raffaele despite the paparazzi has shown even the slightest sign of violent behavior before the murder or since the murder.

If i was in theur shoes and given some people's actions toward them, I doubt I would be so docile.

Also, what is it about women's sexuality that frightens people? And what I really don't get is how women become allies in that misogyny? In many ways, some of them are far worse than other men. Vixen demonstrates this with her posts although she denies it.
 
It is exactly similar to the Scottish law 'not proven'.

As courts are supposed to come to a decision this rubric is being phased out.

In fact, it is astonishing that the Marasca court pulled it out of the hat. It was the only way it could get the pair out of jail. And it is as illegal and bent as a nine-bob note.

Maybe Jovana Popovic and her mother were behind it. Or was it the Mafia? The Masons? The Illuminati? Satanic sects? The US State Department? Judge Heavey? The Marriott PR juggernaut? Senator Cantwell? Vecchiotti and Conti? Vinci? The Grassy Knoll Shooter in Dallas? Or...could it have been a vast conspiracy of all of them? Hmmmmm….
 
Exactly, the man is almost even celebrated as a 'stud', while the woman is demonized as a 'slut'. This historical double standard goes back since the beginning of humans.

Amanda the she-devil temptress that lured the two nice Italian boys into raping and killing her roommate of a month. That ANYONE believes that nonsense stuns me. That their orgy transformed into torture and murder is also unbelievable. But those are their narratives that we hear.

What makes people equate sexuality with violence? From what I can see, 90 plus percent are sexual. That some are also violent is more coincidence than ANYTHING. It is irrelevant how many sex partners any of them had have. Far more important in evaluating people for potential to this kind of crime is their history of violence and crime. Neither of which can be attributed to Amanda or Raffaele. I think it is quite telling that neither Amanda or Raffaele despite the paparazzi has shown even the slightest sign of violent behavior before the murder or since the murder.

If i was in theur shoes and given some people's actions toward them, I doubt I would be so docile.

Also, what is it about women's sexuality that frightens people? And what I really don't get is how women become allies in that misogyny? In many ways, some of them are far worse than other men. Vixen demonstrates this with her posts although she denies it.

I suspect it has to do with control. Once men realized that women did not just become pregnant, but that men impregnated them, it became about control. In order to be sure they were their children's fathers, men had to control women's sex lives. In order to control their sex lives, they had to control women's lives in general. Thus women lost virtually all legal rights to their fathers and then to their husbands. But besides controlling women legally, women also had to be controlled through society's view of them. Society had to tell women...and they had to believe...that good women did not like or have sex; it was something to be endured and endured only within the confines of marriage. Close your eyes and think of England! Bad women had sex outside these narrow confines and if a good woman violated the rules, she too became a bad woman.

Men could have as much sex outside marriage as they wanted because illegitimate children did not inherit. And, until recently, paternity could not be verified only sometimes ruled out. Men could literally walk away from all responsibility.

Why are women some of the worst when it comes to slut shaming other women? I think there are several reasons: resentment, jealousy, needing to feel superior and, especially, seeing other women as competition.
Another reason is the way women generally handle things vs men. When I was teaching, it was very interesting to watch the middle schoolers in the yard. The boys were far more physical when they had confrontations or arguments. The girls were not generally physical but vocal. They used their words to hurt. They were "catty".
 
I suspect it has to do with control. Once men realized that women did not just become pregnant, but that men impregnated them, it became about control. In order to be sure they were their children's fathers, men had to control women's sex lives. In order to control their sex lives, they had to control women's lives in general. Thus women lost virtually all legal rights to their fathers and then to their husbands. But besides controlling women legally, women also had to be controlled through society's view of them. Society had to tell women...and they had to believe...that good women did not like or have sex; it was something to be endured and endured only within the confines of marriage. Close your eyes and think of England! Bad women had sex outside these narrow confines and if a good woman violated the rules, she too became a bad woman.

Men could have as much sex outside marriage as they wanted because illegitimate children did not inherit. And, until recently, paternity could not be verified only sometimes ruled out. Men could literally walk away from all responsibility.

Why are women some of the worst when it comes to slut shaming other women? I think there are several reasons: resentment, jealousy, needing to feel superior and, especially, seeing other women as competition.
Another reason is the way women generally handle things vs men. When I was teaching, it was very interesting to watch the middle schoolers in the yard. The boys were far more physical when they had confrontations or arguments. The girls were not generally physical but vocal. They used their words to hurt. They were "catty".

I think about the social dynamics of this case far more than I do about the evidence of this case since it cut and dried that Amanda or Raffaele were not involved.

Group think, misogyny, sexual dynamics between man and women, tribalism, cognitive bias, the media dynamics and how these things came into play which resulted in dramatically changing the lives of two innocent people. The lunacy of the PGP?

I wonder how many changed their minds an if some never will. If Amanda has not seen a whiff of trouble in her life when she's 50,60,70 will Vixen etc ever come around or will they think she just never got caught?
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom