The Trials of Amanda Knox and Raffaele Sollecito: Part 28

Status
Not open for further replies.
People stick up for their friends all the time. The families of the WM3 had no problem providing alibis for the accused, claiming Echols had been home as of the time of the murders, as was the other guy.

What is your evidence of this friendship, including evidence that it wasn't just a casual one; it had to be strong enough for someone to risk being involved in a cover-up of a murder. Popovic's mother wasn't a friend so why would she risk that? And I'm still waiting to hear WHEN they had the opportunity to get together to create the story in the first place.

The funny thing here is no one ever questioned Popovic's testimony - no one. Not the police, not the prosecutor, not the courts. Just our open-minded, unbiased Vixen.

Compare this to Curatolo claiming to have seen Amanda and Raffaele on a night when there was holiday ruckus with people in costume boarding disco buses, and how you've desperately tried to argue this didn't have to be Halloween. Or how Quintavalle told Vulturno, after looking at a picture of Amanda, that he had seen her a couple of times but always in the company of Raffaele, only to change his mind a YEAR later and then claim he saw her alone that morning. Or how Capezzali, the elderly, hard of hearing woman who claims to have heard a scream at 23:00 or later followed by footsteps running in two different directions - something that has been proven to be virtually impossible even for someone with good hearing - and who claimed the following morning she read about the murder on the cover of a paper two hours before the body was found. In ALL cases you accept the testimony as honest, accurate, reliable and without question. But Popovic... nope, has to be a conspiracy to cover up a crime.

I'm guessing you have absolutely no idea how dishonest and disingenuous you prove yourself to be with comments like this.
 
What is your evidence of this friendship, including evidence that it wasn't just a casual one; it had to be strong enough for someone to risk being involved in a cover-up of a murder. Popovic's mother wasn't a friend so why would she risk that? And I'm still waiting to hear WHEN they had the opportunity to get together to create the story in the first place.

The funny thing here is no one ever questioned Popovic's testimony - no one. Not the police, not the prosecutor, not the courts. Just our open-minded, unbiased Vixen.

Compare this to Curatolo claiming to have seen Amanda and Raffaele on a night when there was holiday ruckus with people in costume boarding disco buses, and how you've desperately tried to argue this didn't have to be Halloween. Or how Quintavalle told Vulturno, after looking at a picture of Amanda, that he had seen her a couple of times but always in the company of Raffaele, only to change his mind a YEAR later and then claim he saw her alone that morning. Or how Capezzali, the elderly, hard of hearing woman who claims to have heard a scream at 23:00 or later followed by footsteps running in two different directions - something that has been proven to be virtually impossible even for someone with good hearing - and who claimed the following morning she read about the murder on the cover of a paper two hours before the body was found. In ALL cases you accept the testimony as honest, accurate, reliable and without question. But Popovic... nope, has to be a conspiracy to cover up a crime.

I'm guessing you have absolutely no idea how dishonest and disingenuous you prove yourself to be with comments like this.

As I said, I am sceptical of Popovich's story, for reasons I went on to state.

The court found her story accepted. And it still found Raff and Knox guilty of aggravated murder.

I've been asked by work colleagues to falsely say someone is not at their desk, when they want to avoid a phone call. People ask others to cover up for them all the time.

(I just tell the caller the other person is 'not available ATM' so not a complete lie.)
 
Paragraph one, (530.1) has four sub-sections numbered one to four. Subsection no 2 of 530.1 is NOT Article 530.2.

530.1 paras 1,2,3,4 is completely separate and different from 530.2, which has no subsections.


The misapprehension has arisen, because whoever compiled the wikipedia in this, omitted article 530.2, leading people to believe 530.1, para 2, was what the Supreme Court was referring to.

As Williams would say... round and round we go.

So let's try this one more time.

https://www.brocardi.it/codice-di-procedura-penale/libro-settimo/titolo-iii/capo-ii/sezione-i/art530.html?utm_source=internal&utm_medium=link&utm_campaign=articolo&utm_content=nav_art_prec_top

This is NOT wikipedia, this is straight from the Italian CPP. I copied Article 530 (all four paragraphs) here for your convenience but by all means, please use the link to go read for yourself. You'll notice there are these handy-dandy "<- ART.PREVIOUS" and "ART.NEXT ->" links on both the top and bottom of each page. That should assist you as you find your way to Article 530.2, where you can then copy/paste the content here.

OR.... you can just admit you are wrong and be done with it. You're choice. I'll just kick back with some popcorn and enjoy the action.

Article 530 Code of criminal procedure
(Presidential Decree September 22nd 1988, n.477)
Judgment of acquittal

Device of the art. 530 Code of criminal procedure
Sources → Code of Penal Procedure → SEVENTH BOOK - Judgment → Title III - Judgment → Chapter II - Decision → Section I - Dismissal

1. If the fact does not exist [ 541 2, 542 ], if the defendant has not committed it [ 541 2, 542 ], if the fact does not constitute a crime or is not provided for by the law as a crime or if the crime was committed as a non-imputable person [cp 85 ] or not punishable by another reason, the judge pronounces an acquittal sentence by indicating the cause in the operative part.

2. The judge pronounces the acquittal sentence even when it is absent, it is insufficient or contradictory evidence that the fact exists, that the defendant committed it, that the offense is a crime or that the offense was committed by an imputable person (1).

3. If there is evidence that the fact was committed in the presence of a cause of justification or a personal cause of non-punishment or there is doubt about the existence of the same, the judge pronounces an acquittal sentence pursuant to paragraph 1.

4. With the sentence of acquittal, the judge applies, in the cases foreseen by the law, the security measures [ 537 ].
 
As I said, I am sceptical of Popovich's story, for reasons I went on to state.

The court found her story accepted. And it still found Raff and Knox guilty of aggravated murder.

I've been asked by work colleagues to falsely say someone is not at their desk, when they want to avoid a phone call. People ask others to cover up for them all the time.

(I just tell the caller the other person is 'not available ATM' so not a complete lie.)

No, you didn't state any reasons. What you did was created a wholly unsubstantiated, fully biased fictional account of why Popovic testified as she did. In fact, the reasons to believe her were;

1. Her mother confirms her effort to send the suitcase and why it was denied
2. Her mother confirms calling Jovana to tell her it wasn't coming.
3. Amanda and Raffaele told the police at the Questura of Jovana's request and her coming by to say she no longer needed a ride.
4. The rapid, wholly consistent story from four people without any obvious opportunity to fabricate the story between them.
5. The unlikelihood that a casual friend and her mother (not at all familiar with any of them) would risk being involved in a cover-up of a murder.
6. No known inconsistencies in the story from any of the people involved.
7. The witnesses were deemed credible by the courts
8. (possible) Confirmation by the bus company that Popovic's mother tried to send the suitcase but was denied.
9. Popovich first asked another person (Michele) to give her a ride to the bus station. Michele was prevented - therefore Popovic asked Raffaele. If Popovic's story was made up it would not include this part. (credit to Wilson85 for bringing up this point!)

Despite this you go out of your way to fabricate from whole cloth why you choose not to believe her.

It wouldn't be so bad if you were overly suspicious of every witness, but that you accept without question the testimony of some of the easiest people to prove contradiction and credibility issues for shows just how closed-minded and biased you are with this case.
 
Last edited:
From the post-mortem, it was clear there were at least two knives involved. One, similar to the one Raff had on his person at the questura was deemed responsible for the relatively smaller stab wounds on the left side of the victim's neck and a large kitchen knife for the fatal wounds on the other side of the neck.

How this pair sleeps at night escapes me.

The post-mortem does not "make clear" that two knives were used. If it had, you'd have quoted from/cited it.

Just chucking that sentence into a post on ISF demonstrates that you'll invent anything.
 
No, you didn't state any reasons. What you did was created a wholly unsubstantiated, fully biased fictional account of why Popovic testified as she did. In fact, the reasons to believe her were;

1. Her mother confirms her effort to send the suitcase and why it was denied
2. Her mother confirms calling Jovana to tell her it wasn't coming.
3. Amanda and Raffaele told the police at the Questura of Jovana's request and her coming by to say she no longer needed a ride.
4. The rapid, wholly consistent story from four people without any obvious opportunity to fabricate the story between them.
5. The unlikelihood that a casual friend and her mother (not at all familiar with any of them) would risk being involved in a cover-up of a murder.
6. No known inconsistencies in the story from any of the people involved.
7. The witnesses were deemed credible by the courts
8. (possible) Confirmation by the bus company that Popovic's mother tried to send the suitcase but was denied.

Despite this you go out of your way to fabricate from whole cloth why you choose not to believe her.

It wouldn't be so bad if you were overly suspicious of every witness, but that you accept without question the testimony of some of the easiest people to prove contradiction and credibility issues for shows just how closed-minded and biased you are with this case.


They were not under any risk as nobody can prove that there never was any suitcase due to be placed on the bus, as it never happened.

As for Raff and Knox, as defendants they are legally entitled to lie to their hearts' content.

And they did.

They lied, and lied, and lied.


And lied again.


And are still lying today (although Raff appears to have been gagged).
 
They were not under any risk as nobody can prove that there never was any suitcase due to be placed on the bus, as it never happened.

As for Raff and Knox, as defendants they are legally entitled to lie to their hearts' content.

And they did.

They lied, and lied, and lied.


And lied again.


And are still lying today (although Raff appears to have been gagged).
Lord love a duck.

Should I post the comprehension "list of lies" again, drawn from the ever-articulate Harry Rag's posts?

From Harry's own keyboard to Cassazione's ears, Harry tried his best to provide detail to the slander, and came up well short.
 
As I said, I am sceptical of Popovich's story, for reasons I went on to state.

The court found her story accepted. And it still found Raff and Knox guilty of aggravated murder.

I've been asked by work colleagues to falsely say someone is not at their desk, when they want to avoid a phone call. People ask others to cover up for them all the time.

(I just tell the caller the other person is 'not available ATM' so not a complete lie.)

Popovich first asked another person (Michele) to give her a ride to the bus station. Michele was prevented - therefore Popovic asked Raffaele. If Popovic's story was made up it would not include this part.
 
Lord love a duck.

Should I post the comprehension "list of lies" again, drawn from the ever-articulate Harry Rag's posts?

From Harry's own keyboard to Cassazione's ears, Harry tried his best to provide detail to the slander, and came up well short.

Talk about the pot calling the kettle black. Vixen has lied so many times we'd need a calculator to keep up.

Of course, Vixen avoids all the very credible reasons why she should accept the testimony as truthful, not least of which being the investigators who worked so hard to try to convict Amanda and Raffaele never disputed the testimony.

I notice Vixen has now moved up from being suspicious to certainty that "it never happened". Of course, had the investigators had any doubts about this testimony they could have tracked down the driver of the bus that evening and confirmed Popovic's mother tried to send the suitcase. And this, of course, renders this blathering comment from Vixen moot;

"They were not under any risk as nobody can prove that there never was any suitcase due to be placed on the bus, as it never happened."

Imagine if the investigators interviewed the bus driver and s/he stated no one ever tried to send a suitcase on the bus. That would certainly be a problem for someone who claimed they tried to do that and were told by the driver they couldn't. But Vixen just ignores this and claims there was no risk in lying to help cover for someone she didn't know.

But Curatolo, Quintavalle, Capezzali... yeah, they're all credible and beyond reproach.
 
As Williams would say... round and round we go.

So let's try this one more time.

https://www.brocardi.it/codice-di-procedura-penale/libro-settimo/titolo-iii/capo-ii/sezione-i/art530.html?utm_source=internal&utm_medium=link&utm_campaign=articolo&utm_content=nav_art_prec_top

This is NOT wikipedia, this is straight from the Italian CPP. I copied Article 530 (all four paragraphs) here for your convenience but by all means, please use the link to go read for yourself. You'll notice there are these handy-dandy "<- ART.PREVIOUS" and "ART.NEXT ->" links on both the top and bottom of each page. That should assist you as you find your way to Article 530.2, where you can then copy/paste the content here.

OR.... you can just admit you are wrong and be done with it. You're choice. I'll just kick back with some popcorn and enjoy the action.

Interesting that "Next Article" ("Art. Successivo" in the original) leads to CPP Article 531, not Article 530.2.

Could this mean that there is a conspiracy by the Mafia and/or Masons to change the website? Or did a guilter not read all the relevant information?

It's a mystery that will never be solved!
 
Great tweet here. It is a reproduction of the court testimony in which Amanda Knox confesses that she offered Patrick Lumumba's name freely and voluntarily, without any pressure from the police.

https://twitter.com/Robyn__Duncan/status/960449261300305921

Bang goes another PR lie.

This is just pitiful. Stop misrepresenting things along with that RD troll. Knox was clearly referring to two different occasions. The first is when she was being interrogated and the second is when she was writing her memorandum hours later. In the memorandum, she does not accuse Lumumba. In fact, she clearly states that she is unsure of the verity of her previous statements and is not sure if it actually happened at all.
 
Paragraph one, (530.1) has four sub-sections numbered one to four. Subsection no 2 of 530.1 is NOT Article 530.2.

530.1 paras 1,2,3,4 is completely separate and different from 530.2, which has no subsections.


The misapprehension has arisen, because whoever compiled the wikipedia in this, omitted article 530.2, leading people to believe 530.1, para 2, was what the Supreme Court was referring to.


Spectacularly incorrect. And boneheadedly stupid.

the ".1" of 530.1 indicates the paragraph number. It's Section 530, Paragraph 1.

It's childishly simple to actually RESEARCH AND READ the Italian Code of Criminal Procedure, and its English translation. And if one does that, one will immediately and easily see that Section 530 has four paragraphs - and they are annotated 530.1, 530.2, 530.3 and 530.4. Section 530.1 consists of just one paragraph of text.

Please, please, can a pro-guilt commentator come here to make an argument who at least doesn't make (and REPEAT) such ridiculous errors as this? Please??
 
Many killers start out as burglars:

Source: https://pdfs.semanticscholar.org/4558/accdeeb60f1666a1ec56de4bfc637a1b1941.pdf

Interesting read. Describes Guede to a T, 8 years before he sliced open Kercher's neck and sexually assaulted her then left her to choke on her own blood and bleed out while he dug through her purse for goodies.

This is one of the most common of logical fallacies: 'Homer is a man, therefore, all men are Homer'.

Bagels never said that all killers start out as burglars. Try again.
 
This is one of the most common of logical fallacies: 'Homer is a man, therefore, all men are Homer'.


Er no.

While you have (finally) accurately identified a (theoretical) form of logical fallacy, that fallacy in no way applies to the argument you addressed. It is not in any way a logical fallacy to point out that many murderers do indeed graduate from crimes against property or animals through to murder, and then to point out that Guede had a prior history of burglary (whereas of course Sollecito and Knox did not). The argument was NOT that this therefore necessarily meant that Sollecito and Knox could not have been participants in Kercher's murder - if that HAD been the argument, then you'd have been correct in identifying and pointing out the logical fallacy. But you were wrong to claim the fallacy had been used.

"Logical fallacy" fail Number 17,439 on your part, I believe........
 
More skilled sophistry. This does not legally apply to Knox and Sollecito. At the merits trial and at the appeal they were confirmed guilty of Aggravated Murder ('aggravated' because it involved sexual assault of their victim : US equivalent = first degree murder).

It was entirely illegal for the Supreme Court to annul the conviction. In a serious crime such as a murder, they do not have the jursidiction to dismiss charges, where a defendant has fairly been found guilty in a fair trail.


Oh blimey. Can you still not understand?

Knox and Sollecito DID NOT GET FAIR TRIALS from the convicting courts.

That's precisely how and why the Supreme Court annulled and acquitted.

Jesus.
 
This is not a grade 1 'not guilty' which the vast majority of not guilty verdicts are.


This is an astonishingly, laughably incorrect assertion.

Or perhaps you can actually show me reliable, credible statistics on the relative proportions of acquittals in Italian criminal courts which are under 530.1 and 530.2. Oh, what's that? You don't HAVE any such statistics? And you've just pulled a bogus "fact" straight out of your backside to try to bolster your argument? Ah, thought so.
 
Interesting that "Next Article" ("Art. Successivo" in the original) leads to CPP Article 531, not Article 530.2. Could this mean that there is a conspiracy by the Mafia and/or Masons to change the website? Or did a guilter not read all the relevant information?

It's a mystery that will never be solved!

Exactly... I was providing Vixen the rope to hang herself with. I can't wait to see how she explains this one away. It should prove to be highly entertaining! :popcorn1
 
Even the illegal Marasca Supreme Court confirms Knox was definitely at the murder scene whilst Meredith Kercher's blood was still wet, in that it states clearly, she washed the victim's blood from her hands.

FACT.


*sigh*

Get a friend (!!)* to explain to you how/why the Marasca panel was effectively forced to ensure that its MR did not conflict in any way with the verdicts and MRs of the prior settled cases (i.e. the Guede murder trial process and the Knox criminal slander trial process).


* But not that gold-plated nutcase Robyn Duncan......
 
Complete and utter nonsense. In no jurisdiction that I know of does a defendant 'have to prove his innocence'.


You've entirely failed to understand my post.



A common or garden 'not guilty' verdict (530,1 in Italy) merely means the State has failed to prove its case. Nothing more, nothing less.


Once again: 530.1 is NOT a "common-or-garden not-guilty verdict". Please, please get an education by reading the actual Section 530 of the Italian Code of Criminal Procedure. As has been pointed out to you more times that I can remember, 530.1 is effectively only ever used where either a) the court deems that no crime was even committed (e.g. a rape trial where the court deems that what occurred was actually consensual sex rather than the crime of rape), or b) the defendant can actually factually prove his/her innocence to the satisfaction of the court.

Please educate yourself properly before coming here and attempting to make arguments. It's embarrassing and a waste of time all round, otherwise.....
 
Spectacularly incorrect. And boneheadedly stupid.

the ".1" of 530.1 indicates the paragraph number. It's Section 530, Paragraph 1.

It's childishly simple to actually RESEARCH AND READ the Italian Code of Criminal Procedure, and its English translation. And if one does that, one will immediately and easily see that Section 530 has four paragraphs - and they are annotated 530.1, 530.2, 530.3 and 530.4. Section 530.1 consists of just one paragraph of text.

Please, please, can a pro-guilt commentator come here to make an argument who at least doesn't make (and REPEAT) such ridiculous errors as this? Please??

This is the problem....the pro-guilt side has no valid arguments to make. That explains why we see the continual repetition of absurdities by those who still post.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom