The Trials of Amanda Knox and Raffaele Sollecito: Part 26

Status
Not open for further replies.
Let's recap. Someone said they wondered who was the originator of the theory Knox was given a ticket by a police office after a wild party.

I proffered my opinion (which in the language of the PIP and Agumennon equates to 'lie') that it was an early John Follain article in the SUNDAY TIMES in which he interviewed old chums of Knox from Seattle.

Stacyhs then pronounced me a liar, as she claimed it was the DAILY MAIL. Enter you and Argumennon calling me a 'liar' therefore (obviously, insulting a PGP gets a free pass).

I then pointed out that there can be more than one witness to an incident in response to yours and Stacyhs's claim that there can only be one newspaper report and one witness.

Stacyhs then demanded I reproduce it for her and given her history of demanding I research things for her, which she doesn't do to anybody else, I politely pointed her in the direction of how she can search the article for herself. She came back and said she can't be bothered.

We discussed this article in the past so she can do a search on the thread.

Let's face it, there will be people here who remember the discussion, but don't have the decency to say so.

In the meantime we have you and Stacyhs childishly calling me names knowing you can get away with it.
You keep mentioning something that DOESN'T EXIST. No quotes,...No citations ...Nothing to back up any alternative descriptions of that party. You said it was fine journalism. If there is an alternative that quotes others at the party it is incumbent on you to provide it.

We've proven that the Daily Mail's account is FALSE. You're saying that FOLLAIN wrote his own article that appeared in The Times that Follain sourced. Prove it or go away.
 
Last edited:
I was referring to John Follain's SUNDAY TIMES article wherein he spoke to acquaintances of Knox from Seattle, who described her wild behaviour to him.


Incidentally, do you have any evidence the said policeman doesn't exist?

Is this the article to which you referred?

from The Times "Is this the face of a killer?" Jan 30th, 2008:

Knox had only one brush with the law in Seattle: a $269 fine for throwing a noisy summer party at the house she rented a short walk north of the campus. The houses on the leafy street are made of painted wood, sofas sit on the porches and a few Stars and Stripes fly over doors. Neighbours recall waking in the small hours to the sound of loud, drunken voices and of beer cans and bottles being thrown down an alley. The cops came and Knox paid the fine, getting her friends to pay her back afterwards. One neighbour remembers Knox as bright, hard-working and focused, disciplined about her academic studies and her sports, so excited about going to Italy that she spoke in Italian to the neighbour's husband, who had lived in Rome.​

If it is then it is only fair to point out what acquaintances of Knox said in this article:

Knox went to the £5,900-a-year Seattle preparatory school, run by Jesuits and the second-fanciest school in the city. She followed the school's strict dress code, sang in the choir and said her daily prayers. Kent Hickey, the school's head, has only positive memories of Knox, who played football competitively.

"She was a good and thoughtful girl, very talented in drama. A very strong student," was all he would say before invoking privacy laws and clamming up. She played the part of an orphan in the school's production of the musical Annie.

She remained a good student at Seattle's Washington University, where she read Italian, German and creative writing, making the Dean's List of high-achievers. Knox studied hard but also found time for sport - she played football, went rock climbing and did yoga - and worked in two bars on the campus, which echoes Oxbridge; it boasts neo-gothic libraries and halls, and even a quadrangle, lined with cherry trees.

There, almost all Knox's friends refuse to talk about her, at the request of Knox's parents, who have hired a public-relations adviser to help them. It's a measure of how badly the more lurid stories about Knox have been received that Jeff Tripoli, the news editor of the university newspaper, posted on his blog: "F*** the British press".

But Tripoli, 21, a journalism student from Las Vegas, turns out to be willing to talk. He speaks about Knox both in the present tense and in the past tense, as if in some way she was dead to him. Sipping a soft drink - a party the previous night involved the outgoing editor eating a 12-egg omelette - Tripoli doesn't recognise the Knox he knew in the media coverage. "The media wants a movie: pretty, reckless monster with no emotions kills roommate at kinky sex party. But that's not possible. Amanda is the girl next door, wholesome and sporty and fun to be with." Unprompted, Tripoli says that he had "a huge crush" on Knox. He had no luck, though. What attracted him so much?

"She's got a cute personality. She's funny and sporty. She's cute, but not beautiful or sexy. I was more attracted by her personality."
Knox, he said, was nerdy in a good way; she had tea parties with her friends where they drank exotic teas. "In Seattle, that's weird," he says.
Surely Knox wasn't a teetotaller; had he ever seen her drunk? Tripoli gives a tight, embarrassed smile. "I've seen her under the influence of alcohol. But I've never seen her out of control."

And the man-eater depicted by the media? "That's crazy. She didn't sleep around. She had two long-term relationships over two years. She didn't even dress provocatively. At this Hallowe'en party, usually it's an excuse for girls to dress up slutty, but Amanda wore the least revealing clothes of all. I felt like telling her that she hadn't got the point of Hallowe'en.
Tripoli says Knox was still attached to her last campus boyfriend, David Johnsrud, after moving to Italy. At university he shaved his head Mohawk-style, wore kilts and shared Knox's taste for tea parties. Tripoli once e-mailed Knox: "You're cute, but you have a weird taste in men." To which Knox replied: "Tell me about it."

In December 2006, during her second year, Knox posted a short story on MySpace called Baby Brother; a young woman is drugged and raped by another young woman. One passage reads: "She fell on the floor, she felt the blood on her mouth and swallowed it. She couldn't move her jaw and felt as if someone was moving a razor on the left side of her face." On her MySpace site, Knox says she wants to meet "people with passions and ideas", that she likes "to always do new things". Her heroine is "my mom".

Assuming this is not simply adolescent grandstanding, on her Facebook page she reveals her interests are "men". Her entry for "About Me" reads: "A lot of my friends say I'm a hippy, but I am thinking I am just weird. I don't get embarrassed and therefore have very few social inhibitions… The bigger and scarier the roller coaster the better." More prosaically, she loves the Beatles, the Harry Potter books and Monty Python movies.​

The article then deals with the party charge (above) before dealing with the "less than wholesome" Amanda Knox which "emerged" in Italy.
 
Is this the article to which you referred?

from The Times "Is this the face of a killer?" Jan 30th, 2008:

Knox had only one brush with the law in Seattle: a $269 fine for throwing a noisy summer party at the house she rented a short walk north of the campus. The houses on the leafy street are made of painted wood, sofas sit on the porches and a few Stars and Stripes fly over doors. Neighbours recall waking in the small hours to the sound of loud, drunken voices and of beer cans and bottles being thrown down an alley. The cops came and Knox paid the fine, getting her friends to pay her back afterwards. One neighbour remembers Knox as bright, hard-working and focused, disciplined about her academic studies and her sports, so excited about going to Italy that she spoke in Italian to the neighbour's husband, who had lived in Rome.​

If it is then it is only fair to point out what acquaintances of Knox said in this article:

Knox went to the £5,900-a-year Seattle preparatory school, run by Jesuits and the second-fanciest school in the city. She followed the school's strict dress code, sang in the choir and said her daily prayers. Kent Hickey, the school's head, has only positive memories of Knox, who played football competitively.

"She was a good and thoughtful girl, very talented in drama. A very strong student," was all he would say before invoking privacy laws and clamming up. She played the part of an orphan in the school's production of the musical Annie.

She remained a good student at Seattle's Washington University, where she read Italian, German and creative writing, making the Dean's List of high-achievers. Knox studied hard but also found time for sport - she played football, went rock climbing and did yoga - and worked in two bars on the campus, which echoes Oxbridge; it boasts neo-gothic libraries and halls, and even a quadrangle, lined with cherry trees.

There, almost all Knox's friends refuse to talk about her, at the request of Knox's parents, who have hired a public-relations adviser to help them. It's a measure of how badly the more lurid stories about Knox have been received that Jeff Tripoli, the news editor of the university newspaper, posted on his blog: "F*** the British press".

But Tripoli, 21, a journalism student from Las Vegas, turns out to be willing to talk. He speaks about Knox both in the present tense and in the past tense, as if in some way she was dead to him. Sipping a soft drink - a party the previous night involved the outgoing editor eating a 12-egg omelette - Tripoli doesn't recognise the Knox he knew in the media coverage. "The media wants a movie: pretty, reckless monster with no emotions kills roommate at kinky sex party. But that's not possible. Amanda is the girl next door, wholesome and sporty and fun to be with." Unprompted, Tripoli says that he had "a huge crush" on Knox. He had no luck, though. What attracted him so much?

"She's got a cute personality. She's funny and sporty. She's cute, but not beautiful or sexy. I was more attracted by her personality."
Knox, he said, was nerdy in a good way; she had tea parties with her friends where they drank exotic teas. "In Seattle, that's weird," he says.
Surely Knox wasn't a teetotaller; had he ever seen her drunk? Tripoli gives a tight, embarrassed smile. "I've seen her under the influence of alcohol. But I've never seen her out of control."

And the man-eater depicted by the media? "That's crazy. She didn't sleep around. She had two long-term relationships over two years. She didn't even dress provocatively. At this Hallowe'en party, usually it's an excuse for girls to dress up slutty, but Amanda wore the least revealing clothes of all. I felt like telling her that she hadn't got the point of Hallowe'en.
Tripoli says Knox was still attached to her last campus boyfriend, David Johnsrud, after moving to Italy. At university he shaved his head Mohawk-style, wore kilts and shared Knox's taste for tea parties. Tripoli once e-mailed Knox: "You're cute, but you have a weird taste in men." To which Knox replied: "Tell me about it."

In December 2006, during her second year, Knox posted a short story on MySpace called Baby Brother; a young woman is drugged and raped by another young woman. One passage reads: "She fell on the floor, she felt the blood on her mouth and swallowed it. She couldn't move her jaw and felt as if someone was moving a razor on the left side of her face." On her MySpace site, Knox says she wants to meet "people with passions and ideas", that she likes "to always do new things". Her heroine is "my mom".

Assuming this is not simply adolescent grandstanding, on her Facebook page she reveals her interests are "men". Her entry for "About Me" reads: "A lot of my friends say I'm a hippy, but I am thinking I am just weird. I don't get embarrassed and therefore have very few social inhibitions… The bigger and scarier the roller coaster the better." More prosaically, she loves the Beatles, the Harry Potter books and Monty Python movies.​

The article then deals with the party charge (above) before dealing with the "less than wholesome" Amanda Knox which "emerged" in Italy.

That looks like it, thanks. Mind you, the one I had in mind was in the SUNDAY TIMES by John Follain.

Soz, having read it, that's not it.

I am loath to take out a sub again.
 
Last edited:
That looks like it, thanks. Mind you, the one I had in mind was in the SUNDAY TIMES by John Follain.

Soz, having read it, that's not it.

I am loath to take out a sub again.

In other words, that's far to complimentary of Knox and not some nasty hatchet job you had in your head. I don't buy it Vixen. I believe eiter you remember the nasty false piece in The Daily Mail or are covering yourself with this phantom piece in The Sunday Times.

I never read the Follain piece. I DID read Malone's article and when I SAID in my post that it was a fabrication it was this article I was referring to.
 
Last edited:
I don't know who wrote the Daily Mail article about the party in Seattle but that was a total lie. It was clear that the reporter hadn't spoke with anyone. He just took the police report and then crafted as outrageous story he could out of it. He quotes 'un-named party goers. I know he never talked to the officer because I have.

That was the kind of journalism that was emblematic in this case. Cheap sensationalism.

AFAIAA the original article was from the SUNDAY TIMES by John Follain (for it is he), who spoke to people who knew Knox from her Seattle days.


Perfectly good journalism.

Um, no. It was in the DM Online and was concocted by Andrew Malone. Please do at least a bit of research before posting misinformation. Nor was it "good journalism" as the gross exaggeration and downright false information printed has been thoroughly debunked by the actual police report. I can draw of a list of proven lies in that fiction if you'd like. Of course, I understand how some would think concocting a story not based on evidence is considered "perfectly good journalism" by some.

http://www.dailymail.co.uk/femail/article-498853/The-wild-raunchy-past-Foxy-Knoxy.html

I was referring to John Follain's SUNDAY TIMES article wherein he spoke to acquaintances of Knox from Seattle, who described her wild behaviour to him.


Incidentally, do you have any evidence the said policeman doesn't exist?

Let's recap. Someone said they wondered who was the originator of the theory Knox was given a ticket by a police office after a wild party.

I proffered my opinion (which in the language of the PIP and Agumennon equates to 'lie') that it was an early John Follain article in the SUNDAY TIMES in which he interviewed old chums of Knox from Seattle.

Stacyhs then pronounced me a liar, as she claimed it was the DAILY MAIL. Enter you and Argumennon calling me a 'liar' therefore (obviously, insulting a PGP gets a free pass).

I then pointed out that there can be more than one witness to an incident in response to yours and Stacyhs's claim that there can only be one newspaper report and one witness.

Stacyhs then demanded I reproduce it for her and given her history of demanding I research things for her, which she doesn't do to anybody else, I politely pointed her in the direction of how she can search the article for herself. She came back and said she can't be bothered.

We discussed this article in the past so she can do a search on the thread.

Let's face it, there will be people here who remember the discussion, but don't have the decency to say so.

In the meantime we have you and Stacyhs childishly calling me names knowing you can get away with it.

Ahem....please point out exactly where I "pronounced (you) a liar". Nor did I "claim" it was the Daily Mail. It was the Daily Mail as has been proved.

Please point out where I said that "there can only be one newspaper report and one witness." Good luck.

I didn't "demand" your produce the link. I asked you...which you ignored:

Link to this alleged article? I've been unable to find any such article. Not that you'd make this up.

Since you have linked to it many times, perhaps you'd be kind enough to provide a link once again. My google searches have resulted in nothing regarding Follain interviewing people from Seattle who knew Knox. Forgive me for wanting to read the article myself.

I ask for links to claims you make. You repeatedly refuse to provide them. As I've told you before, it is up to the person who makes a claim to provide the evidence to it. It is not up to others to have to go in search of something that may not even exist. Which, given your history, is a very distinct possibility. Face it, Vix...if you can provide evidence, you do. If you can't, you don't. So stop with this nonsense of trying to pass the buck ( oh dear, another Americanism) onto others. It's just too darn obvious.

Please quote me calling you any "childish names".
 
AFAIAA the original article was from the SUNDAY TIMES by John Follain (for it is he), who spoke to people who knew Knox from her Seattle days.


Perfectly good journalism.

I was referring to John Follain's SUNDAY TIMES article wherein he spoke to acquaintances of Knox from Seattle, who described her wild behaviour to him.
Incidentally, do you have any evidence the said policeman doesn't exist?

That looks like it, thanks. Mind you, the one I had in mind was in the SUNDAY TIMES by John Follain.

Soz, having read it, that's not it.

I am loath to take out a sub again.

It cannot be this article as nowhere does anyone describe Knox's "wild behavior" to him. In fact, quite the contrary. So, I sill ask you politely once again to provide a link to the alleged article wherein anyone tells Follain of Knox's "wild behavior". And no...I will not go in search of this article, because frankly, I do not believe it exists. I do believe you simply made a mistake and confused the Malone fabrication with Follain. But why you cannot admit this is beyond me.
 
A better use of the PGP's time than tracking down lost tabloid articles about a random party girl would be to track down a neutral individual with no understanding or interest in this case of reasonable intelligence (perhaps a correlation) and relay to them, say, all the facts surrounding Quintavalle's testimony. Then ask them if they find Quintavalle to be a witness with reliable relevant testimony with regards to the whereabouts of Amanda Knox on the particular morning in question.

When they consistently find that the only people prone to believe Quintavalle are those disposed with a visual image of Knox running around with the butcher knife from Psycho, maybe they will finally have their grand epiphany that the case is built on weak evidence and blind faith?

Vixen, I recommend you try this experiment and report back.
 
A better use of the PGP's time than tracking down lost tabloid articles about a random party girl would be to track down a neutral individual with no understanding or interest in this case of reasonable intelligence (perhaps a correlation) and relay to them, say, all the facts surrounding Quintavalle's testimony. Then ask them if they find Quintavalle to be a witness with reliable relevant testimony with regards to the whereabouts of Amanda Knox on the particular morning in question.

When they consistently find that the only people prone to believe Quintavalle are those disposed with a visual image of Knox running around with the butcher knife from Psycho, maybe they will finally have their grand epiphany that the case is built on weak evidence and blind faith?

Vixen, I recommend you try this experiment and report back.

I would also suggest doing the same with Curatolo's testimony. No one free of a pre-existing opinion on the case would find him credible in the least. Or Nara Capezzali, for that matter.
 
Last edited:
From the Follain article above:

In December 2006, during her second year, Knox posted a short story on MySpace called Baby Brother;a young woman is drugged and raped by another young woman. One passage reads: "She fell on the floor, she felt the blood on her mouth and swallowed it. She couldn't move her jaw and felt as if someone was moving a razor on the left side of her face."

This is the passage that Follain changed into a woman on woman crime when, in fact, the rapist in Knox's story was a man. There are only two reasons for this:
1) Follain did not read the story and relied on the hearsay of another party or
2) he did read the story and chose to lie about the story in order to make it more salacious and/or sellable.

Either way, it shows a complete lack of professionalism.
 
Besides boasting about imaginary qualifications, PGP are now coming up with stories about famous people who handed out these qualifications. PGP come up with Walter Mitty fantasies about their academic achievements and they have the cheek to call Amanda a pathological liar.

Would you like to elaborate what you mean by this?
 
No, where we differ is that I provide links to evidence that supports what I claim. I don't just claim that an article, a quote, etc. exists and then do a dodge and run when asked for evidence/link. Here's another "Americanism" for you: put up or shut up.

What? No claims that my parents were "drugged up hippies"? You're slipping.

Er, your parents made a beeline for Haight Astbury and hung around with Brian Wilson, John Phillips and Charles Manson? The 'Summer of Love' was in the '50's??? And of course, they didn't inhale pot themselves.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=G1731cD1Ef4
 
Last edited:
Would you like to elaborate what you mean by this?

The Walter Mitty syndrome is used to describe fantasists who make make up stories. PGP make up stories about their academic achievements eg obtaining degrees in psychology and accounting, being a member of Mensa. This is why I used to Walter Mitty fantasies to describe made up stories about academic achievements. My point was very simple to understand and PGP who boast about their intelligence could not understand it.
 
Er, your parents made a beeline for Haight Astbury and hung around with Brian Wilson, John Phillips and Charles Manson? The 'Summer of Love' was in the '50's??? And of course, they didn't inhale pot themselves.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=G1731cD1Ef4

The reference was to "stoned hippies", not to whether they attended the Summer of Love. Do try and focus. Nice touch bringing in Manson. Not that it has diddley squat to do with your completely unsupported accusation that Burleigh's parents were "stoned hippies".

Please address my earlier questions:

1.....please point out exactly where I "pronounced (you) a liar".

2. Please point out where I said that "there can only be one newspaper report and one witness."

3. Please quote me calling you any "childish names".
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom