The Trials of Amanda Knox and Raffaele Sollecito: Part 26

Status
Not open for further replies.
Yeah, but still... you do realize this is TWO admissions of 'having it wrong' by Vixen in one day. Yes, even as she admits she was wrong she's trying to twist it, but it is progress.

There was also a third instance of Vixen owning up to a mistake - I'm wracking my brain to remember it. But it was a legitimate admission.
 
Yeah, but still... you do realize this is TWO admissions of 'having it wrong' by Vixen in one day. Yes, even as she admits she was wrong she's trying to twist it, but it is progress.

"OK...fair enough"; she still can't say "I was wrong".

Note that she says TMofMK has corrected the text but she never says "I was wrong" And then tries to laud them for their honesty.



There was also a third instance of Vixen owning up to a mistake - I'm wracking my brain to remember it. But it was a legitimate admission.

She claimed Battistelli said something he never said. I don't remember what it was. I can't keep track of all the false claims.
 
Last edited:
Oh, my! I've found the smoking gun regarding Maori colluding with the (not so) independent forensics experts! A frequent contributor to TJMK, whose credibility is unassailable, gave this as evidence citing PMF as the source:

1.Barbie Nadeau in Angel Face:
'Concern that the independent experts weren’t so independent after all spread quickly after several journalists saw Vecchiotti with Raffaele’s lawyer Luca Maori in the courthouse halls and coffee bars of Perugia. Curious, too, was the fact that the Vecchiotti-Conti report cited more American forensic standards than Italian ones, and that many of these had also been quoted by the Friends of Amanda.'

The curious thing is, when I search for this quote, including several short phrases from it, in Nadeau's book via Amazon's "Look inside" feature, nothing comes up except for "0 results". Nothing.

Even in this alleged (but unfound) quote from Nadeau's book, journalists were hardly seeing Maori "wining and dining" Conti and Vecchiotti.
 
Bill Williams said:
There was also a third instance of Vixen owning up to a mistake - I'm wracking my brain to remember it. But it was a legitimate admission.
She claimed Battistelli said something he never said. I don't remember what it was. I can't keep track of all the false claims.

Yes, that was it.

What I don't get - my opinion only - is the wreckless disregard for things factual. All of us, me included, have made or fair share of mistakes, or have aired assumptions which turned out to be just air.

As I posted before, one of the advantages of private PMs with people of diametrically (and sometimes heated) opposed points of view is that there actually tend to be fewer examples of wreckless disregard for basic facts.

Let me put one out there - I still do not "get" why journalists would impugn some sort of corruption about Vecchiotti, just because she'd been seen chatting with Maori or even having a glass of wine with him at a coffee bar. It would not bother me in the least if Stefanoni had similarly been seen chatting with Mignini, or if members of the RIS Carabinieri at the Nencini trial had briefed either side about what they found with a retesting of the knife with Sample 36I.

I don't get it? I also don't get why it is allowed to mushroom into gigantic claims that "Vecchiotti is a criminal", etc. etc., said with no reference to the tenuousness of Barbie Nadeau's original claims - which turn out perhaps not even to have been her claims.

It's the wanton wrecklessness of it all.
 
One last kick at the cat.

The wrecklessness is also in the way they treat the world-renowned experts who have waded in on this case. Vecchiotti is perhaps only a nationally recognized Italian forensic-DNA expert but it is positively ludicrous the way they criminalize and defame her for her expert opinions on this case.

Then there is Dr. Peter Gill, Saul Kassin, Steve Moore, Ron Hendry - agreed, not all of whom are internationally recognized. It's not just that guilters claim those people might be mistaken.....

..... they accuse them of being criminals or incompetent, all the while while not advancing one expert of their own - save for Patrizia Stefanoni - to vouch for the work.

That's just wreckless - and strategically alienating. I mean, who are they trying to attract to their point of view?

Finally - is the fake-Wiki really still touting "mixed blood"? For Pete's sake, even Massei's court in 2009 discounted that. 2009!!! That claim is based on claiming to know the origin of trace-DNA found at a scene where one would habitually be expected to find such a thing - a bathroom the person had used for weeks - and then claim to know the source of such trace-DNA; when by definition the source cannot be known.

The remaining guilters are still arguing what Mignini and Comodi argued in 2008. Mignini and Comodi won in 2009, but judging from even the appeal document they themselves wrote for the coming Hellmann trial in 2011, you'd have thought they'd lost! MOO is that that is because even Massei disbelieved major prosecution stuff - like mixed blood.

This is 2017. Most of the fake-Wiki has not been editted since 2014. The pair have been exonerated - 2 1/2 years ago. It looks like the exoneration in 2015 took the wind out of the sails of most guilters....

..... so why is ANYONE citing the fake-Wiki?
 
Last edited:
Yes, that was it.

What I don't get - my opinion only - is the wreckless disregard for things factual. All of us, me included, have made or fair share of mistakes, or have aired assumptions which turned out to be just air.

As I posted before, one of the advantages of private PMs with people of diametrically (and sometimes heated) opposed points of view is that there actually tend to be fewer examples of wreckless disregard for basic facts.

Let me put one out there - I still do not "get" why journalists would impugn some sort of corruption about Vecchiotti, just because she'd been seen chatting with Maori or even having a glass of wine with him at a coffee bar. It would not bother me in the least if Stefanoni had similarly been seen chatting with Mignini, or if members of the RIS Carabinieri at the Nencini trial had briefed either side about what they found with a retesting of the knife with Sample 36I.

I don't get it? I also don't get why it is allowed to mushroom into gigantic claims that "Vecchiotti is a criminal", etc. etc., said with no reference to the tenuousness of Barbie Nadeau's original claims - which turn out perhaps not even to have been her claims.

It's the wanton wrecklessness of it all.

I think it's pretty obvious why the PGP have to have claim corruption in regards to C&V: to negate their professional findings. Just as with Amanda and Raff, they have to be attacked on a personal level. They must be shown to be dishonest, lying, morally inferior characters. But they must also be attacked on a professional level despite the fact that the balance of opinion of other forensic experts is, by far, in agreement with C & V. We can be absolutely sure that, if they had agreed with Stefanoni, we'd be reading from the PGP how professional, upright, and competent they were .

I cannot say with 100% certainty that the alleged Nadeau quote is not accurate as I do not have the book. All I can say is that I most certainly could not find it anywhere else except the one source I cited and that the Amazon "Look inside" feature returned 0 results.
 
Citations) for the highlighted part?

I believe you are referring to the DVD made by the independent experts showing the collection of evidence by the police and errors therein. I can find no evidence that it was 1) made for the defense's eyes only or 2) Vecchiotti was almost arrested by the carabinieri, 3) she appealed to Hellmann or 4) Hellmann, as a result of this appeal, ordered a copy made for the court and prosecution.

What I did find was that 1) the DVD was appropriately filed with the Perugia Court of Appeals, 2) that the carabinieri were sent by the prosecution to seize the DNA from Vecchiotti but could not as they had no warrant to do so, and 3) that the prosecutor applied to get a copy of the DVD from Hellmann and he granted it.


http://www.umbrialeft.it/notizie/meredith-depositato-dvd-sul-sopralluogo-della-scientifica



MEREDITH MURDER: THE SCIENTIFIC BRANCH DVD OF IMAGES USED BY EXPERTS LODGED

http://www.libero-news.it/news/7920...vd-immagini-scientifica-usato-dai-periti.html


Your spin on this was very misleading. Police did not "almost arrest" Vecchiotti nor was she colluding with the defense. The police tried to seize the DVD without a warrant for it. She was not "forced" to give a copy to the prosecutor; the prosecutor requested a copy and it was granted by Hellmann.

Once again: Citation(s) for the highlighted part?


LOL Your very own Candace Dempsey.

ROFLMAO Even the PIP find her writing trashy.


In a thug move, Perugia prosecutors sent two police patrols to Rome today and tried to seize a DVD from the court-appointed independent experts who testified Monday in the Amanda Knox and Raffaele Sollecito appeals trial, according to Perugia-based blogger Frank Sfarzo and confirmed by Libero News.

This latest harassment follows threats by police forensic scientist Patrizia Stefanoni to sue the experts for “false statements” supposedly made in their 145-page, meticulously argued report. After a five-month investigation, the experts reject police forensics, call the DNA tests “unreliable,” and identify 54 glaring mistakes that could free the two college students.

So what did the experts do when two police patrols invaded their workspace?

“Today cops entered at the same time the hospital Gemelli and La Sapienza University, both in Rome, looking for Stefano Conti and Carla Vecchiotti, ” wrote blogger Frank Sfarzo. Prosecutor Giuliano Mignini convinced Google to pull his blog, but U.S. supporters have rebuilt it in WordPress. “According to university sources who witnessed part of the event the cops were sent by the Procura of Perugia (ndr., prosecutor’s office), and ordered Conti and Vecchiotti to hand over the DVD containing the presentation with which yesterday the two scientists had explained their report in court.”

Since the cops didn’t have warrants, the experts didn’t hand over the DVD. Instead, they dialed Judge Hellmann for support. He made a copy available to the prosecution.
 
Last edited:
Yes, that was it.

What I don't get - my opinion only - is the wreckless disregard for things factual. All of us, me included, have made or fair share of mistakes, or have aired assumptions which turned out to be just air.

As I posted before, one of the advantages of private PMs with people of diametrically (and sometimes heated) opposed points of view is that there actually tend to be fewer examples of wreckless disregard for basic facts.

Let me put one out there - I still do not "get" why journalists would impugn some sort of corruption about Vecchiotti, just because she'd been seen chatting with Maori or even having a glass of wine with him at a coffee bar. It would not bother me in the least if Stefanoni had similarly been seen chatting with Mignini, or if members of the RIS Carabinieri at the Nencini trial had briefed either side about what they found with a retesting of the knife with Sample 36I.

I don't get it? I also don't get why it is allowed to mushroom into gigantic claims that "Vecchiotti is a criminal", etc. etc., said with no reference to the tenuousness of Barbie Nadeau's original claims - which turn out perhaps not even to have been her claims.

It's the wanton wrecklessness of it all.


Bar standards.
 
One last kick at the cat.

The wrecklessness is also in the way they treat the world-renowned experts who have waded in on this case. Vecchiotti is perhaps only a nationally recognized Italian forensic-DNA expert but it is positively ludicrous the way they criminalize and defame her for her expert opinions on this case.

Then there is Dr. Peter Gill, Saul Kassin, Steve Moore, Ron Hendry - agreed, not all of whom are internationally recognized. It's not just that guilters claim those people might be mistaken.....

..... they accuse them of being criminals or incompetent, all the while while not advancing one expert of their own - save for Patrizia Stefanoni - to vouch for the work.

That's just wreckless - and strategically alienating. I mean, who are they trying to attract to their point of view?

Finally - is the fake-Wiki really still touting "mixed blood"? For Pete's sake, even Massei's court in 2009 discounted that. 2009!!! That claim is based on claiming to know the origin of trace-DNA found at a scene where one would habitually be expected to find such a thing - a bathroom the person had used for weeks - and then claim to know the source of such trace-DNA; when by definition the source cannot be known.

The remaining guilters are still arguing what Mignini and Comodi argued in 2008. Mignini and Comodi won in 2009, but judging from even the appeal document they themselves wrote for the coming Hellmann trial in 2011, you'd have thought they'd lost! MOO is that that is because even Massei disbelieved major prosecution stuff - like mixed blood.

This is 2017. Most of the fake-Wiki has not been editted since 2014. The pair have been exonerated - 2 1/2 years ago. It looks like the exoneration in 2015 took the wind out of the sails of most guilters....

..... so why is ANYONE citing the fake-Wiki?


The Murder of Meredith Kercher webpage was updated fairly recently with a whole batchload more court documents and transcripts.

It is an excellent library of source material for journalists, lawyers and anybody interested in the facts of the case and not the grotesque Trumpesque circus spin on it we get from the US fake media and the PIP.
 
The Murder of Meredith Kercher webpage was updated fairly recently with a whole batchload more court documents and transcripts.

It is an excellent library of source material for journalists, lawyers and anybody interested in the facts of the case and not the grotesque Trumpesque circus spin on it we get from the US fake media and the PIP.

Probably a truly neutral observer with a reasonable understanding of criminal evidence could discern that the case against the students is weak at best and closer to a baseless witch hunt, just using TMOMK as a source.

The only thing that might throw them for a loop is some of the prosecution's more baseless claims that TMOMK passes on unfiltered. Like a female's alleged bloody shoeprint in the bedroom. There one only needs to look at a photo of it to see that it is clearly Rudy's shoeprint (which is why I suspect no photo of what should be an incontrovertible end to the PIP position is shown). Of course one could find it if they dug through the prosecution's reports linked on the site.

The main obstacle the prosecution has to overcome is giving a compelling and conclusive reason why a crime scene covered in the abundant forensic traces a known knife carrying burglar requires the addition of two random accomplices that have no connection to said burglar. People will be looking for things like, forensic evidence against Amanda positively timestamped to the time of the crime, instead they will get blood negative DNA negative stains. They will be looking for text and phone exchanges between Amanda and Rudy, or witnesses that saw them together, and instead they will get Rudy's unprompted confession that he was there alone and images of him snooping around the cottage not long before the murder on CCTV alone.

None of those things are an issue for you PGP, because you take Amanda's guilt as a starting axiom and have let cognitive bias prevent you from comprehending how a compelling case against Rudy hurts the prosecution. But they're significant barriers for convincing rationally minded folks. Admittedly, that leaves plenty out there for the taking.
 
How sick is it for someone who wrote sick rape/murder fantasies and convicted of falsely accusing Patrick Lumumba of the rape and murder she and Raff were found guilty of in the merits trial and appeal (annulled by the Supreme Court on non-legal grounds) to get to write for the LA TIMES about other sick criminals.

As per usual Knox turns the story round to one about herself, so no change to the narcissism there, then.

Interestingly, she also championed the cause of swimmer Brock Turner found 'dry humping' a woman in a coma on public ground.

I suspect Party Rock boyfriend, Chris Robinson, had a hand in helping her to write it and iron out the illiterate grammatical errors and spelling gaffes.

Pretentiously, she writes that whilst Michelle Carter - who urged her boyfriend to kill himself, which he then did - whilst 'morally and philosophically wrong' was 'unlawfully convicted'.

Really?

In which way is it 'philosophically' wrong? Just big words for form over substance. In fact there is plenty of philosophical literature on suicide: Hamlet, The Savage God; The Myth of Sisyphus, and so on and so forth. Who is Amanda Knox to say it is 'philosophically wrong' but not illegal? Someone who writes about her 'best truth' and things her 'head' is 'confusedly' telling her 'in blurry images'.

Fact is, it might be considered 'morally wrong' for someone who is a Christian, but Knox is a rabid atheist who frets she may never become President as she would be unable to swear on the Bible at the inauguration. What planet is this being on?

Legally: unfortunately for Knox suicide or aiding suicide was illegal in many western countries even up until the sixties, with 'assisted suicide' still being unlawful, with some countries, such as Switzerland allowing it for medical reasons in special clinics.

The fact the prosecutor in Carter's case had a criminal statute against her and there was jurisdiction to hear her case, means it cannot have been 'unlawful' to convict her, whether or not you agree with the charge.

How much was Knox paid for leeching off the murder of her roommate? Enquiring minds need to know.

What was LA TIMES thinking?
 
Last edited:
What was LA TIMES thinking?

Amanda Knox would be a nobody none of us ever heard of, but then they showed pics of her giving the evil eye next to pics of giant knives wrapped in evidence bags and you people ate it up and turned her into a star. Congratulations.
 
Amanda Knox would be a nobody none of us ever heard of, but then they showed pics of her giving the evil eye next to pics of giant knives wrapped in evidence bags and you people ate it up and turned her into a star. Congratulations.

No, bagels, Amanda Knox did it all by herself and probably relishes her infamy.
 
No, bagels, Amanda Knox did it all by herself and probably relishes her infamy.


Vixen, you do know that:

1) there was never a single piece of credible, reliable evidence that Knox (or Sollecito) participated in the murder of Meredith Kercher;

2) the very high likelihood is that Knox and Sollecito were exactly where they always claimed they were (barring the unlawfully coercive police interrogations of 5/6 November 2007....) - alone together in Sollecito's apartment - throughout the entire evening and night of the murder;

3) all of the known evidence is entirely consistent with Guede acting alone?


Just for your information, like. Cos you seem to have some sort of unsupported and emotionally-charged vendetta against both Knox and Sollecito. Why is that, Vixen?
 
Fact is, it might be considered 'morally wrong' for someone who is a Christian, but Knox is a rabid atheist who frets she may never become President as she would be unable to swear on the Bible at the inauguration. What planet is this being on?


Why do you seem to think that someone has to hold Christian beliefs in order to have a moral code, Vixen?
 
How sick is it for someone who wrote sick rape/murder fantasies and convicted of falsely accusing Patrick Lumumba of the rape and murder she and Raff were found guilty of in the merits trial and appeal (annulled by the Supreme Court on non-legal grounds) to get to write for the LA TIMES about other sick criminals.

As per usual Knox turns the story round to one about herself, so no change to the narcissism there, then.

Interestingly, she also championed the cause of swimmer Brock Turner found 'dry humping' a woman in a coma on public ground.

I suspect Party Rock boyfriend, Chris Robinson, had a hand in helping her to write it and iron out the illiterate grammatical errors and spelling gaffes.

Pretentiously, she writes that whilst Michelle Carter - who urged her boyfriend to kill himself, which he then did - whilst 'morally and philosophically wrong' was 'unlawfully convicted'.

Really?

In which way is it 'philosophically' wrong? Just big words for form over substance. In fact there is plenty of philosophical literature on suicide: Hamlet, The Savage God; The Myth of Sisyphus, and so on and so forth. Who is Amanda Knox to say it is 'philosophically wrong' but not illegal? Someone who writes about her 'best truth' and things her 'head' is 'confusedly' telling her 'in blurry images'.

Fact is, it might be considered 'morally wrong' for someone who is a Christian, but Knox is a rabid atheist who frets she may never become President as she would be unable to swear on the Bible at the inauguration. What planet is this being on?

Legally: unfortunately for Knox suicide or aiding suicide was illegal in many western countries even up until the sixties, with 'assisted suicide' still being unlawful, with some countries, such as Switzerland allowing it for medical reasons in special clinics.

The fact the prosecutor in Carter's case had a criminal statute against her and there was jurisdiction to hear her case, means it cannot have been 'unlawful' to convict her, whether or not you agree with the charge.

How much was Knox paid for leeching off the murder of her roommate? Enquiring minds need to know.

What was LA TIMES thinking?


I know! Terrible, isn't it Vixen?! The entire editorial staff of a major US daily newspaper seems to have been hoodwinked by the lies pumped out by the Gogerty Marriott PR supertanker and the nasty PIPs!!!!

Time for a concerted PGP email campaign to the LA Times methinks, Vixen!
 
Interestingly, she also championed the cause of swimmer Brock Turner found 'dry humping' a woman in a coma on public ground.

I suspect Party Rock boyfriend, Chris Robinson, had a hand in helping her to write it and iron out the illiterate grammatical errors and spelling gaffes.

As I'm not as obsessive about Ms Knox as some people apparently are, I was unaware of her championing the cause of Brock Turner, which I found rather surprising. So I went looking for what she'd written about the case. It's this, in case anybody else here didn't know:

https://www.westsideseattle.com/wes...das-view-stanford-rape-case-redirecting-focus

I'll let you read it for yourself and decide if you think "championing the cause of Brock Turner" is what this article actually does. :rolleyes:
 
Why do you seem to think that someone has to hold Christian beliefs in order to have a moral code, Vixen?

Anti-suicide is a Christian thing is it not? In my local church, suicides (and strangely, murder victims and fallen 'Reds') are buried to one side separate from the rest of the dear departed congregation.

I have no idea what other religions believe but I know Albert Camus was quite sympathetic to the idea.
 
I know! Terrible, isn't it Vixen?! The entire editorial staff of a major US daily newspaper seems to have been hoodwinked by the lies pumped out by the Gogerty Marriott PR supertanker and the nasty PIPs!!!!

Time for a concerted PGP email campaign to the LA Times methinks, Vixen!

'Email campaign'?! What are you on about?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom