The towers were designed to survive a plane impact

Just looking for a simple yes or no with thanks to 'were they specifically designed to survive an impact by a large jet plane'

merci


No, the buildings were not specifically designed to survive an impact by a large jet plane.

It was after their design was completed that the question was raised whether the buildings would survive an impact (I believe, in part, because of their height) and it was estimated that they would survive the basic impact. To arrive at that, the engineers had to determine what kind of impact (what the plane was doing and what its circumstances were) was expected and then their calculations would flow from that.

If someone proposed, "I have a block of metal (or a metal tank containing the maximum amount of fuel a 707 could carry) weighing what a 707 would weigh and fired it at the maximum speed a 707 could attain into or at a given location where it would do the most damage to the building structure, would the building survive?" is a different proposition from "a 707 trying to locate the airfield in fog, flying relatively slowly, and low on fuel".

Another thing would be, for instance, if one assumes that the contents would be relatively unflammable or very limited amounts or that the fire suppresion system would handle that (a simplifying assumption) so that the jet fuel load would burn out in a matter of minutes but that the contents would not catch fire and be a continuing heat source, one could make a judgement that the effects of the jet fuel would be minimal threat to the survival of the building since the heat source would be gone and, even if the fire protection was compromised, the structure could take that amount of heat. Probably Robertson made that kind of assumption, given his tools available and the kind of impact expected, when he did his calculations and made his conclusions. In light of what happened, it wouldn't be the first time that assumptions, especially about the fire, proved to be incorrect.

In the end the buildings survived the impacts but did not survive the continuing degradation of their structure caused by the widespread and uncontrolled fires.
 
The two towers were the first structures outside of the military and nuclear industries designed to resist the impact of a jet airliner, the Boeing 707. It was assumed that the jetliner would be lost in the fog, seeking to land at JFK or at Newark. To the best of our knowledge, little was known about the effects of a fire from such an aircraft, and no designs were prepared for that circumstance. Indeed, at that time, no fireproofing systems were available to control the effects of such fires.
http://www.nae.edu/Publications/Bri...ecurity/ReflectionsontheWorldTradeCenter.aspx
Robertson, the guy who designed the structure of the WTC, designed for an impact of a 707 at 180 mph. Verified by a study after 911, the WTC would survive, or resist a 200 mph impact.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom