Cont: The One Covid-19 Science and Medicine Thread Part 5

Does Long Covid Brain Fog Start In The Gut

LEVY: What is interesting is that 90% of the serotonin in the body
is actually made in the gut.

STONE: Their hunch was this lack of serotonin could be a consequence
of what's known as viral persistence. It's a major line of research in long
COVID. Multiple studies have found evidence of an ongoing viral infection.
So, Levy says, they checked for genetic material in their own study participants.

LEVY: About 30% of the patients, we could find viral RNA in their
gastrointestinal tract. We took this, and we tried to model it in mice.

STONE: There they focused on inflammation that was driven by Type I
interferon. Christoph Thaiss, also on the Penn team, says this inflammatory
response messed with the body's ability to absorb the amino acid tryptophan.

THAISS: And it's actually the direct precursor to the production of serotonin
in the gut. So if there's less tryptophan, there's less serotonin production.


Got long covid, eat more turkey.
 
Rare is relative. I've seen 3 cases (one in the hospital and 2 friends) which doesn't seem rare to me.

From Wiki:
You don't need to look at "millions" in this case. And there are millions of COVID cases and vaccinations.

They looked at over 3 million cases. From your link:
GBS occurs in 3 months or less from the offending cause (IIRC, it may be 6 weeks) and they followed these folks for a year.

IOW I find the study credible.

I would agree the study seems sound.
 
The abstract says, "Multivariable conditional logistic regression models showed that the OR for GBS associated with SARS-CoV-2 infection and COVID-19 vaccine administration was 6.30 (95% CI 2.55-15.56) and 0.41 (95% CI 0.17-0.96), respectively."

It's not clear to me whether that means the OR for vaccination is controlled for SARS-CoV-2 or not. It should be clearer in the full paper, but I won't have access to it until it is officially published in an issue of the journal (for now, it's just on the journal's website). If not, then vaccination would likely be protective for GBS by reducing COVID-19 incidence or severity.

What they did was look for GBS in the period following an event, either Covid-19 or vaccination. It is possible that some one might have got covid, then been vaccinated then got GBS or vice versa. Since the effects are in opposite directions, this can only diminish the magnitude of effect.
 
Yes, it could. That's the first the correct thing you've said on the subject.




I didn't say the authors were wrong. I said you were. That's why I'm writing to you and not to them.




Yeah, but that's not really what they did, despite how they worded that statement. Their study is retrospective. They took patients in their database who had been diagnosed with GBS and matched them to patients in their database who were not, and compared the COVID and vaccination rates in each group. That is not conceptually different than taking patients from a GBS clinic and matching them to community controls and comparing their respective COVID and vaccination rates. Basically, because they had a large database, they were able to find enough cases. But you don't need a large database to study a rare disease; you need a population of cases.



I don't know what you are talking about because their study design does not allow them to estimate the incidence of GBS after COVID infection. It allows them to estimate the inverse: the incidence of COVID infection in those with a GBS diagnosis.

But what this does allow is a large control population rather than having to create controls.

But what they do know is the incidence in a large unselected population, that is not a figure you can get from a clinic.

They then case matched on a 10:1 basis which is much better than most case control studies. They could only do this because they stared with a large unselected population. It would have been very difficult to do this from a clinic population.

Given GBS was a major concern as a side effect of vaccination this is good evidence that vaccination is not causing GBS.
 
Last edited:
The abstract says, "Multivariable conditional logistic regression models showed that the OR for GBS associated with SARS-CoV-2 infection and COVID-19 vaccine administration was 6.30 (95% CI 2.55-15.56) and 0.41 (95% CI 0.17-0.96), respectively."

It's not clear to me whether that means the OR for vaccination is controlled for SARS-CoV-2 or not. It should be clearer in the full paper, but I won't have access to it until it is officially published in an issue of the journal (for now, it's just on the journal's website). If not, then vaccination would likely be protective for GBS by reducing COVID-19 incidence or severity.


I just read the full paper. Indeed, the authors say that the observed protective effect of the vaccine (BioNTech) against GBS was probably due to its protective effect against SARS-CoV-2 infection. It could be that if incidence of COVID-19 were lower, an increase in GBS with vaccination (as seen with some other vaccines including some for COVID-19) might have been observed.
 
Given GBS was a major concern as a side effect of vaccination this is good evidence that vaccination is not causing GBS.


The study provides no evidence that the vaccine doesn't cause GBS. To see if the vaccine causes GBS, you would have to look at the effect of vaccination separately among those who did and did not have an infection, something this study was way to small to do. At best, this study shows that, if the vaccine causes GBS, it prevents even more GBS by preventing cases of COVID.
 
Last edited:
The study provides no evidence that the vaccine doesn't cause GBS. To see if the vaccine causes GBS, you would have to look at the effect of vaccination separately among those who did and did not have an infection, something this study was way to small to do. At best, this study shows that, if the vaccine causes GBS, it prevents even more GBS by preventing cases of COVID.

I am not sure this makes sense.

If the vaccine causes GBS then it would likely do so both in those who have had an infection and those who haven't.

Realistically I don't think you will fiind a population who have never had a Sars-CoV-2 infection. Nor do I think one could do a large study PCR testing partcipants e.g. weekly to correctly classify infection status three months before and after vaccination or placebo, even done as a crossover study this would be too large to be done. Thy needed nearly 5 million patient years to pick up the 76 cases of BGS, that is roughly 60,000 patient years to pick up one case of GBS.

If we are thinking that some people may have both had SARS-CoV-2 and been vaccinated that is unlikely, as active infection was a contra-indication to infection. In any case that would diminish the protective effect of the vaccination. What you can say is that people with GBS were more likely to have not been vaccinated in the previous 3 months prior to daignosis than to have been vaccinated. This is not like the OR being 1 and sayting that this may conceal an effect the CI 0.17-0.96 is quite good.

Are you saying that the effect of the vaccine is to reduce GBS by reducing the severity of infections and that some of those in the control group may have had infections that caused GBS, but weren't correctly classified as infected? This mis-classification should affect both cases and controls.

But if we gave the vaccine to a population where SARS-CoV-2 was not circulating so there was no protective effect there might be no benefit from vaccination and potentially harm?

(Vaccines may have benefits unrelated to the disease they protect against - e.g. neonatal BCG vaccination against TB seems to reduce risk of developing asthma and allergies. This may offer benefit even in communities where TB is uncommon.)
 
The study provides no evidence that the vaccine doesn't cause GBS. To see if the vaccine causes GBS, you would have to look at the effect of vaccination separately among those who did and did not have an infection, something this study was way to small to do. At best, this study shows that, if the vaccine causes GBS, it prevents even more GBS by preventing cases of COVID.

I am not sure this makes sense.

If the vaccine causes GBS then it would likely do so both in those who have had an infection and those who haven't.


Correct. So the only way to determine whether there is an effect of the vaccine on the risk of GBS other than by reducing the incidence (or severity) of COVID is to look at the incidence of GBS among those with and without vaccination (within the prior 6 weeks) separately in those who had a recent (within 6 weeks) COVID diagnosis and those who did not.

Realistically I don't think you will fiind a population who have never had a Sars-CoV-2 infection.

You could have at the time the study was conducted, but it is irrelevant, because infection causes GBS within 8 weeks.

Nor do I think one could do a large study PCR testing partcipants e.g. weekly to correctly classify infection status three months before and after vaccination or placebo, even done as a crossover study this would be too large to be done.

Irrelevant.

Thy needed nearly 5 million patient years to pick up the 76 cases of BGS, that is roughly 60,000 patient years to pick up one case of GBS.

As I said, the study was too small to determine what independent effect there was, if any, of vaccination on GBS.

Are you saying that the effect of the vaccine is to reduce GBS by reducing the severity of infections and that some of those in the control group may have had infections that caused GBS, but weren't correctly classified as infected? This mis-classification should affect both cases and controls.

No. I am simply saying that the observed reduction in GBS among the recently vaccinated was likely due to vaccine-induced reduction in COVID (infection or severity).

But if we gave the vaccine to a population where SARS-CoV-2 was not circulating so there was no protective effect there might be no benefit from vaccination and potentially harm?

Yes. It is possible that COVID-19 vaccination actually increases the risk of GBS, but that would not be observable in the study because the effect was more than offset by a reduction in infection-mediated GBS. If that is the case and risk of COVID were sufficiently low, then risk of GBS (and other side effects) from vaccination could exceed the benefit.
 
Last edited:
Editorial from The John Snow Project. Pretty grim reading!

The long-established principles governing how we respond to new infectious diseases have now completely changed – the precedent has been established that dangerous emerging pathogens will no longer be contained, but instead permitted to ‘ease’ into widespread circulation. The intent to “let it rip” in the future is now being openly communicated84. With this change in policy comes uncertainty about acceptable lethality. Just how bad will an infectious disease have to be to convince any government to mobilize a meaningful global public health response?

We have some clues regarding that issue from what happened during the initial appearance of the Omicron “variant” (which was really a new serotype85 86 of SARS-CoV-2. Despite some experts warning that a vaccine-only approach would be doomed to fail, governments gambled everything on it. They were then faced with the brute fact of viral evolution destroying their strategy when a new serotype emerged against which existing vaccines had little effect in terms of blocking transmission. The reaction was not to bring back NPIs but to give up, seemingly regardless of the consequences.
'Endemic' SARS-CoV-2 and the death of public health (The John Snow Project, Nov 6, 2023)
 
New article in The Lancet:
A former minister for health in England wrote to me that “The COVID-19 inquiry will make us the laughing stock in the eyes of the world.” But it is worse than that. The level of criminal incompetence exposed by recent witnesses to the UK COVID-19 Inquiry, chaired by Baroness Heather Hallett, has proven that many, if not most, of over 230 000 deaths were preventable. Amid the claims of extreme misogyny, profanity, and chaos that litter the evidence is a story of complete government breakdown.
Offline: “Laughing at the Italians”https://www.thelancet.com/journals/lancet/article/PIIS0140-6736(23)02504-7/fulltext (The Lancet, Nov 11, 2023)
 
dann said:
New article in The Lancet:
A former minister for health in England wrote to me that “The COVID-19 inquiry will make us the laughing stock in the eyes of the world.” But it is worse than that. The level of criminal incompetence exposed by recent witnesses to the UK COVID-19 Inquiry, chaired by Baroness Heather Hallett, has proven that many, if not most, of over 230 000 deaths were preventable. Amid the claims of extreme misogyny, profanity, and chaos that litter the evidence is a story of complete government breakdown.
Offline: “Laughing at the Italians”https://www.thelancet.com/journals/lancet/article/PIIS0140-6736(23)02504-7/fulltext (The Lancet, Nov 11, 2023)
Taking Wikipedia's estimate of the UK's population of 67 million at face value, that's an overall death rate of 345 per 100,000 population. Compare that with the USA, which was slightly higher at 355 deaths per 100,000.

Now compare those two with a country that had a sane government: Canada. Their death rate was 137 per 100,000. Many other countries did even better.

That's what one gets for electing idiots to lead the country.
 
Taking Wikipedia's estimate of the UK's population of 67 million at face value, that's an overall death rate of 345 per 100,000 population. Compare that with the USA, which was slightly higher at 355 deaths per 100,000.

Now compare those two with a country that had a sane government: Canada. Their death rate was 137 per 100,000. Many other countries did even better.

That's what one gets for electing idiots to lead the country.


Seems like that’s what one gets for naively drawing causal conclusions from observational data.
 
Taking Wikipedia's estimate of the UK's population of 67 million at face value, that's an overall death rate of 345 per 100,000 population. Compare that with the USA, which was slightly higher at 355 deaths per 100,000.

Now compare those two with a country that had a sane government: Canada. Their death rate was 137 per 100,000. Many other countries did even better.

That's what one gets for electing idiots to lead the country.

Seems like that’s what one gets for naively drawing causal conclusions from observational data.

Well, Israel also had about the same number as that of Canada.
 
Taking Wikipedia's estimate of the UK's population of 67 tmillion at face value, that's an overall death rate of 345 per 100,000 population. Compare that with the USA, which was slightly higher at 355 deaths per 100,000.

Now compare those two with a country that had a sane government: Canada. Their death rate was 137 per 100,000. Many other countries did even better.

That's what one gets for electing idiots to lead the country.
Seems like that’s what one gets for naively drawing causal conclusions from observational data.
Well, Israel also had about the same number as that of Canada.


The numbers for the UK, the USA, Canada, Israel and a couple of others. Notice that Japan and Singapore appear to have stopped reporting in July, the UK, the USA, Canada and Denmark in October. Australia and New Zealand are still reporting:
Cumulative confirmed COVID-19 deaths per million people (Our World in Data)

New Zealand and Australian health experts are advising people to wear masks as both countries mark an increase in COVIC-19 cases and hospitalisations ahead of the summer hoiidays.
In a statement, Australia's New South Wales health ministry said there'd ben a "moderate" rise in COVID-19 activity, including the number of people presenting to emergency departments.
"Consider wearing a mask in crowded indoor areas and be kind to people who choose to wear a mask," NWS Health said on X.
With large family gatherings also expected in the coming months, South Australia's top doctors have called for Christmas congregations to be held outside.
Esperts recommend people wear masks, celebrate Xmas outdoors amid another COVID-19 wave (MSN/Newshub, Nov 11, 2023)


No, COVID-19 isn't the flu or the common cold.

A leading epidemiologist says it appears the country is experiencing a fifth wave of Covid-19.
Te Whatu Ora reported more than 5800 confirmed cases this week, and more than 200 hospitalisations.
Professor Michael Baker told First Up it was the highest hospitalisation figure in six months, and the highest wastewater detection rate since January. The real number of cases would be higher than what was being reported too, he said.
(...)
"We actually have to go back right back to January to see this number of copies of the virus in the wastewater across New Zealand. So that's one thing to look at, and the other are the hospitalisations - and they're at their highest point for six months.
'Fifth wave' of Covid-19 apparent as Kiwis fail to take up booster[/b] (RNZ, Nov 10, 2023)


Imagine what it would be like if the pandemic hadn't been over! :mad:
 
OMG, everyone panic! People are still catching covid - what shall we do?

Do we:

A - Attempt the utterly laughable idea that society should conform to the "Davos standard" and spend billions of dollars a day enforcing rules people don't want and will not comply with. (and in many cases are absurd because they're impossible), or:

B - Accept that 2 deaths in NZ a day from covid, with a 90% chance they're at least 70, and a 75% chance they're over 80 isn't worth panicking over.

The enormous majority of the population chooses B.
 
Taking Wikipedia's estimate of the UK's population of 67 million at face value, that's an overall death rate of 345 per 100,000 population. Compare that with the USA, which was slightly higher at 355 deaths per 100,000.

Now compare those two with a country that had a sane government: Canada. Their death rate was 137 per 100,000. Many other countries did even better.

That's what one gets for electing idiots to lead the country.
You need to be very careful about these numbers as the definition of covid deaths differs. Germany has a noticeable lower Covid mortality than its neighbbours, but a higher excess mortality suggesting Germany under registered covid deaths. Also absolute death rates are a very poor measure in a disease with very strong age related mortality, rates need to be age adjusted.

https://www.thelancet.com/article/S0140-6736(21)02796-3/fulltext
https://www.ons.gov.uk/peoplepopula...rnationalmeasuresofexcessmortality/2022-12-20
https://www.economist.com/graphic-detail/coronavirus-excess-deaths-tracker
 
You need to be very careful about these numbers as the definition of covid deaths differs. Germany has a noticeable lower Covid mortality than its neighbbours, but a higher excess mortality suggesting Germany under registered covid deaths. Also absolute death rates are a very poor measure in a disease with very strong age related mortality, rates need to be age adjusted.

Estimating excess mortality due to the COVID-19 pandemic: a systematic analysis of COVID-19-related mortality, 2020–21 [The Lancet]
Comparing different international measures of excess mortality [Office for National Statistics]
Tracking covid-19 excess deaths across countries [The Economist]

I agree. The Lancet's article and especially its main table under "Results" is very informative. It shows the excess mortality rates for 2020-2021 were:

  • United Kingdom: 126.8/100,000 (169,000 deaths)
  • United States: 179.3/100,000 (1,130,000 deaths)
  • Canada: 60.5/100,000 (43,700 deaths)
The more accurate numbers still show that the UK and the US, with right-wing populist governments, clearly did a much worse job handling the pandemic than did Canada. However, Germany did poorly as well (excess mortality 120.5/100,000) while Norway did exceptionally well (7.2). Even Sweden, which started the pandemic with a "let's go for herd immunity" approach, did better than the UK and US, at 91.2/100,000.
 
I agree. The Lancet's article and especially its main table under "Results" is very informative. It shows the excess mortality rates for 2020-2021 were:

  • United Kingdom: 126.8/100,000 (169,000 deaths)
  • United States: 179.3/100,000 (1,130,000 deaths)
  • Canada: 60.5/100,000 (43,700 deaths)
The more accurate numbers still show that the UK and the US, with right-wing populist governments, clearly did a much worse job handling the pandemic than did Canada. However, Germany did poorly as well (excess mortality 120.5/100,000) while Norway did exceptionally well (7.2). Even Sweden, which started the pandemic with a "let's go for herd immunity" approach, did better than the UK and US, at 91.2/100,000.


Skeptics ought to know not to attribute causation to correlation.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom