Cont: The One Covid-19 Science and Medicine Thread Part 5

OMG, everyone panic! People are still catching covid - what shall we do?
Not panic, but not treat it lightly either.

Do we:

A - Attempt the utterly laughable idea that society should conform to the "Davos standard" and spend billions of dollars a day enforcing rules people don't want and will not comply with. (and in many cases are absurd because they're impossible), or:
Straw man. Nobody was suggesting that.


B - Accept that 2 deaths in NZ a day from covid, with a 90% chance they're at least 70, and a 75% chance they're over 80 isn't worth panicking over.
Not panicking, just treating it seriously.

The enormous majority of the population chooses B.
I don't know what the thew vast majority of the population is doing, but figures suggest a large proportion have decided Covid is 'over' and not worth taking seriously. The result is a surge in cases that could easily have been avoided without draconian measures, but human nature being the way it is...

So a few old people are dying, who cares! But deaths are not the only concern. Many people are having ongoing health issues that are seriously affecting their quality of life and may eventually kill them. This is not 'just' a cold.

The latest NZ figures are in and they are disappointing. Reported cases are way down, but that's because people can't be bothered testing or reporting anymore. Reported cases are no longer an accurate measure of actual Covid cases. Hospital admissions are surging to the same level as this time last year, and wastewater detections are staying high at a similar level to last November. That's right, things are no better than they were a year ago.

45% of sequenced cases are the EG.5 variant, the same one that's been surging in other countries. It's more infectious than Omicron and better at evading current vaccinations. And now HV.1 is taking over in the US. Where have we heard this story before? It's Groundhog day, and Covid is not over!

Only 14 people in New Zealand died of Covid on the week ending 19th of November. Doesn't sound like many, but in January last year the weekly average was zero. Will we ever get back to that? I doubt it. But more importantly deaths from other viruses were also much lower than normal. If only the vast majority would continue taking sensible precautions the general health of the population could be much better. But that won't happen because nobody can be bothered taking it seriously anymore.

Yesterday I went to the medical centre to pick up my regular prescription. Sign on the door said wearing a mask is strongly recommended - which I did. A dozen patients in the room and guess how many were wearing masks? Me and one other. Nobody's enforcing the rules so nobody's following them - even though it wouldn't cost them anything to do so. This pandemic has taught us nothing. :mad:
 
Last edited:
We already know that he doesn't think healthy 80-year-olds should live on, but I think he's lowered that bar considerably since then.
Yeah, it's now 70. I am 66. In less than 4 years time my life will be worth nothing! - according to The Atheist. And people wonder why theists give us a hard time. Even in the Bible it was said that healthy people could expect to live for 80 years.

But don't worry, the cutoff age will magically go up again as The Atheist gets older...
 
Not panic, but not treat it lightly either.

I haven't suggested anywhere it should be.

I'll re-state it for you, because you clearly missed it being so far back, but my advice to people about covid has been consistent for the past 18 months:

Get vaccinated and stay up to date, stay the hell home if you're sick, wear a mask if you feel the need.

Straw man. Nobody was suggesting that.

Incorrect.

Dann has repeatedly stated that the world should be conforming to the protocols in place at Davos - from masking and distancing to HEPA-filtered air cond and all the other things it's easy to do when a group of very rich people decide to have a get-together. It would unquestionably cost billions of dollars a day. And that's aside from being a physical impossibility.

I don't know what the thew vast majority of the population is doing, but figures suggest a large proportion have decided Covid is 'over' and not worth taking seriously. The result is a surge in cases that could easily have been avoided without draconian measures, but human nature being the way it is...

The surge - such as it is - is minor compared to 2022 and hospitals are handling it more easily than they did during the post-covid surge in RSV and influenza. Waiting times aren't out of sight, and as you well know, that's in a hospital system liable to break at any time.

So a few old people are dying, who cares! But deaths are not the only concern. Many people are having ongoing health issues that are seriously affecting their quality of life and may eventually kill them. This is not 'just' a cold.

Funnily enough I made that exact point yesterday.

Give me an option as to how to minimise those risks.

And I mean an option that is physically viable and that the population might actually buy into.

If only the vast majority would continue taking sensible precautions the general health of the population could be much better. But that won't happen because nobody can be bothered taking it seriously anymore.

Looks you already answered the question I just put - nobody is going to do anything.

Yesterday I went to the medical centre to pick up my regular prescription. Sign on the door said wearing a mask is strongly recommended - which I did. A dozen patients in the room and guess how many were wearing masks? Me and one other. Nobody's enforcing the rules so nobody's following them - even though it wouldn't cost them anything to do so. This pandemic has taught us nothing. :mad:

I have to admit, I was disappointed the hospital system didn't retain compulsory masking. It's not just covid, it's sensible practice. I always fondly recall being at hospital for the birth of my youngest and hearing visitors coughing their lungs out while unmasked at the peak of the 'flu season.
 
Take another look at the first two weeks of March, and 2023.08.06 and 2023.08.27.

There are no excess deaths in those weeks. Weeks with excess deaths are marked with a red dot with a plus sign. BrettM already showed it but you can make it easier to see on the graph by shortening the period.

picture.php


So, as I said originally, there have not been any excess deaths in Japan since February.
 
There are no excess deaths in those weeks. Weeks with excess deaths are marked with a red dot with a plus sign. BrettM already showed it but you can make it easier to see on the graph by shortening the period.

[qimg]http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/picture.php?albumid=200&pictureid=13865[/qimg]

So, as I said originally, there have not been any excess deaths in Japan since February.
Still leaves the problem of is that conclusion significant? Does it predict anything? Does it predict the pandemic is over because cases were low in the off-season?

No, it doesn't unless you look at the bigger picture. There were more excess deaths in Japan in the previous winter than in any prior winter since 2017.

What conclusion does the bigger picture predict that the seasonal snapshot misses? And how does a snapshot of a single country predict the bigger picture?
 
Last edited:
There are no excess deaths in those weeks. Weeks with excess deaths are marked with a red dot with a plus sign. BrettM already showed it but you can make it easier to see on the graph by shortening the period.

[qimg]http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/picture.php?albumid=200&pictureid=13865[/qimg]

So, as I said originally, there have not been any excess deaths in Japan since February.


There is no need to make it easier for me by enlarging it. I do use reading glasses, but I have no problems seeing the graphics.
I told you to take a closer look at specific months to make you aware of this:
Week: 2023.03.05
Excess deaths: 0 to 1550
Week: 2023.03.12
Excess deaths: 0 to 692
(...)
Week: 2023.08.06
Excess deaths: 0 to 402
(...)
Week: 2023.08.27
Excess deaths: 0 to 203

The weeks that "are marked with a red dot with a plus sign" are the ones that cross the green line: "Upper bound threshold for excess deaths" when it gets really excessive and there can no no doubt.
The dashed line, - - - - -, is the one that marks excess deaths. The line is easier to see in the months with exiguous deaths.
 
It doesn't prove that at all.


The principle is that everything is interpreted by The Atheist as proving his point.
His most disgusting idea, the toe-tag one, doesn't need any reference to facts whatsoever.
As I mentioned above, Jonathan Howard witnessed toe-tags being used at a hospital during the first year of the pandemic before the bodies of COVID-19 victims were stored in refrigerator trucks outside hospitals, and he will be addressing the idea in one of the next episodes of his podcast series.

But since The Atheist doesn't listen to anything pandemic-related that doesn't come out of the Brownstone Institute, I doubt that he will ever understand it. He also doesn't seem to understand that, if true, his 'toe-tag' (or dry tinder) idea should have resulted in subsequent exiguous deaths. But for some reason, we still see excess deaths in most of the Western world except in the places where they have now starting incorporating the first pandemic years in their calculations, which is an ingenious way to make excess deaths disappear. In the future, the only way to the the excess deaths caused by the pandemic may be in statistics of life expectancy.
Life expectancy - 1770 to 2021 (Our World in Data)
 
Last edited:
The weeks that "are marked with a red dot with a plus sign" are the ones that cross the green line: "Upper bound threshold for excess deaths" when it gets really excessive and there can no no doubt.
The dashed line, - - - - -, is the one that marks excess deaths. The line is easier to see in the months with exiguous deaths.

The dashed line, - - - - -, is labeled "expected number of deaths" not "excess deaths". It's the center of a range between the lower bound and the upper bound that indicates a range of expected deaths. Of course there will be variations above and below that line. This does not rise to the level of statistical significance. That is only when it falls outside of that range. And during the period there were lots of other weeks where the total actually fell below the dashed "expected deaths" line. This is not a very important fact to point out.
 
The weeks that "are marked with a red dot with a plus sign" are the ones that cross the green line: "Upper bound threshold for excess deaths" when it gets really excessive and there can no no doubt.

No. That's wrong. Values between the green lines are considered to be within the normal range. Values above the upper one are considered to constitute excess deaths.

The dashed line, - - - - -, is the one that marks excess deaths. The line is easier to see in the months with exiguous deaths.

No, the dashed line is the point estimate of expected deaths. If any value above that line were considered excess deaths, then half of all weeks ever would be considered to have excess deaths, which would be useless information, if for no other reason, than by construction half of all weeks will be above the average. There is random variation. Only when the number of deaths exceeds what can reasonably considered to due to random variation are the deaths considered excess.
 
Still leaves the problem of is that conclusion significant? Does it predict anything? Does it predict the pandemic is over because cases were low in the off-season?

I'm not claiming to make any prediction about the future. We'll have to wait and see about that.

I will only note that basically Japan ended pretty much all pandemic-era government policies this spring, and since then we haven't seen much reported about any sort of resurgence. You no longer need to take a Covid test before boarding a plane to travel to Japan, nor show proof of vaccination or go through special quarantine procedures upon arrival. Things are back to normal here. The only difference is that more people wear masks than they used to (this includes me, in situations where it is called for, like on a crowded commuter train). But even the masks are finally coming off for many people, even here. Oh, by the way, I'm back to commuting to the office on 3 days per week, and working from home on the other days.

I'm not trying to prove anything. Just noting that so far, there has not been a significant resurgence yet, even though all the policies have been relaxed.
 
The dashed line, - - - - -, is labeled "expected number of deaths" not "excess deaths". It's the center of a range between the lower bound and the upper bound that indicates a range of expected deaths. Of course there will be variations above and below that line. This does not rise to the level of statistical significance. That is only when it falls outside of that range. And during the period there were lots of other weeks where the total actually fell below the dashed "expected deaths" line. This is not a very important fact to point out.


"Excess deaths" is a quotation from your link:
Week: 2023.03.05
Excess deaths: 0 to 1550
Week: 2023.03.12
Excess deaths: 0 to 692
(...)
Week: 2023.08.06
Excess deaths: 0 to 402
(...)
Week: 2023.08.27
Excess deaths: 0 to 203


It's not something I made up. There are also percentages. 5% for the first week of March, for instance. I know about statistical significance. That is the point of the "0" in "0 to 1550", to indicate that even as much as 5% excess (or exiguous) deaths may be a statistical fluke or "variations above and below that line."
 
Last edited:
I will only note that basically Japan ended pretty much all pandemic-era government policies this spring, and since then we haven't seen much reported about any sort of resurgence.


I'm not in Japan, and I don't read Japanese, but have seen it reported in English:
Rise in new COVID-19 cases in Japan shows little sign of abating (The Japan Times, July 18, 2023)
The news comes as the number of new cases continues to grow in Japan amid what is widely considered a ninth wave of coronavirus infections.
New COVID variant detected in Japan amid wave of infections (The Japan Times, Sep 8, 2023)

Well, my son's class is closed today because a lot of kids are off sick. Presumably this is because of Covid.

In Japan, and no doubt elsewhere, there is a system called gakkyuu heisa, or school closures due to spreading illnesses. In recent years it was mostly used for flu, but a load of kids from my son's school are off, so a few classes have shut down, and it may end up being the whole school.

Looking at the news, it seems this is also happening in Niigata, Kanagawa, Chiba, Kyushu and Okayama, so it is spreading far and wide.

This completely makes sense to me. However, the difference between flu and Covid is that with Covid it is less predictable seasonally.


Good if it was all a false alarm and there's no ninth wave, but was it and isn't there?
 
I'm not in Japan, and I don't read Japanese, but have seen it reported in English:
Rise in new COVID-19 cases in Japan shows little sign of abating (The Japan Times, July 18, 2023)

Good if it was all a false alarm and there's no ninth wave, but was it and isn't there?

There was a ninth wave, but each successive wave seems to result in fewer cases of severe illness or death compared to the previous one. Absent were reports of Covid wards at hospitals being overfull or increases in deaths due to Covid. The website I used to refer to to track statistics such as the number of "critically ill" or deaths stopped publishing data back in May, so it is no longer easy to find good statistics.
 
I'm not claiming to make any prediction about the future. We'll have to wait and see about that.
Of course, but TA is claiming the pandemic is over. Were you meaning to show something else by your data link?

I will only note that basically Japan ended pretty much all pandemic-era government policies this spring, and since then we haven't seen much reported about any sort of resurgence. You no longer need to take a Covid test before boarding a plane to travel to Japan, nor show proof of vaccination or go through special quarantine procedures upon arrival. Things are back to normal here. The only difference is that more people wear masks than they used to (this includes me, in situations where it is called for, like on a crowded commuter train). But even the masks are finally coming off for many people, even here. Oh, by the way, I'm back to commuting to the office on 3 days per week, and working from home on the other days.

I'm not trying to prove anything. Just noting that so far, there has not been a significant resurgence yet, even though all the policies have been relaxed.
And using the bar graph you cited you can't say cessation of precautions had no negative effect. It will take more than 12 months to confirm the pattern.

Precautions ended this spring. Rates dropped in March and they were lower than the previous March. But they were at a peak last Jan which as I noted was higher than any previous Jan since 2017. IOW that is mixed results.

https://exdeaths-japan.org/en/graph/weekly/


BTW, people for the most part are not going to easily go back to masking precautions (Japan and some other Asian cultures may be the exception). I don't know about other precautions like testing and reporting.
 
The dashed line represents, quote, "Expected number of deaths" and the deaths above that line are the, quote, "Excess deaths".

Nope. It's deaths above the green line that are excess. The range in between the solid gray line and the solid green line is the range of expected deaths.


I've now read the documentation, and the truth is somewhere between what you two are saying.

The solid lines are the 95% prediction interval for expected deaths. Excess deaths are expressed as ranges, which you see when you hover your mouse over a data point. The upper bound of the range is the difference between the observed number of deaths and the point estimate of the expected number of deaths (the dashed line). The lower limit is the larger of (a) 0 or (b) the observed number of deaths minus the upper bound of the 95% prediction interval for expected deaths (the green line). The range is a sort-of one-sided confidence interval for the excess deaths. If the observed number of deaths x is below the value at the green line u, then the reported range of excess deaths will be (0, x), and the excess deaths can be considered not statistically significant (since they could plausibly be 0). If the observed number deaths is above the green line, then the reported range of excess deaths will be (x–u, x), and the excess deaths can be considered statistically significant (because 0 is outside the plausible range).

Weeks with fewer observed deaths than expected are handled analogously.

It makes little sense to me to truncate these interval estimates at 0, but that's what they do.
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom