Cont: The One Covid-19 Science and Medicine Thread Part 5

Skeptics ought to know not to attribute causation to correlation.

The fact remains that of the 38 countries in the OECD, when ranked by their excess mortality rates for 2021-2022, Canada is #9, the UK is at #21, and the USA at #25. Both the UK and the US, despite being wealthy, democratic societies, are in the bottom half of the rankings. Even Costa Rica and Turkiye did better than those two.

There is certainly a correlation. Unfortunately, short of winding back the clock and putting Hillary Clinton into the White House and a different prime minister into Number 10, we can't confidently say it's a correlation. But Trump's bumbling response and Johnson's "screw 'em" shenanigans didn't help.
 
The fact remains that of the 38 countries in the OECD, when ranked by their excess mortality rates for 2021-2022, Canada is #9, the UK is at #21, and the USA at #25. Both the UK and the US, despite being wealthy, democratic societies, are in the bottom half of the rankings. Even Costa Rica and Turkiye did better than those two.


The fact remains that it is just a correlation. I was at a presentation by Scott Atlas where he showed essentially the opposite among US states: the stricter a state's lockdowns were, the higher its COVID mortality was. It's just another correlation. He made the same mistake you are, assuming that the relationship represents cause and effect. In fact, it is no more meaningful than yours.

You can't assume that a correlation is due to your pet hypothesis; it practice, it rarely is. You have to adjust for confounding factors—differences between the populations that could account for the different outcomes (eg, age distributions, population density, etc.)—before you can conclude that your hypothesized cause is the correct one.
 
Last edited:
Interesting like Japan is suddenly not so good, if you use excess death data (44/100k). Sure, still greatly better than most western countries. But ten times more than South Korea, who also managed to report slightly more than excess death seems to indicate. While Japan under-reported death rate by factor of 6, one of the worst in "civilized countries".
 
The fact remains that it is just a correlation. I was at a presentation by Scott Atlas where he showed essentially the opposite among US states: the stricter a state's lockdowns were, the higher its COVID mortality was. It's just another correlation. ...
I doubt there is even such a correlation. Can you cite the evidence he was using?
 
Omicron's going to be much lower than the flu ... somewhere over the rainbow

OMG, everyone panic! People are still catching covid - what shall we do?

Do we:
A - Attempt the utterly laughable idea that society should conform to the "Davos standard" and spend billions of dollars a day enforcing rules people don't want and will not comply with. (and in many cases are absurd because they're impossible), or:

B - Accept that 2 deaths in NZ a day from covid, with a 90% chance they're at least 70, and a 75% chance they're over 80 isn't worth panicking over.

The enormous majority of the population chooses B.


The number of reported Covid-19 cases across New Zealand increased more than 32% week-on-week, according to new data released by health officials.
Officials have reported a “spike” in case counts, wastewater results and deaths in recent weeks, which experts say is likely due to waning immunity and the introduction of new hybrid variants, which increase the community’s susceptibility.
In the seven days to midnight on Sunday, 7881​ Covid-19 cases were reported – up from 5947​ last Monday: an increase of 32.5%​.
(...)
As at midnight Sunday, 349​ people were in hospital with Covid-19, up from 284​ the same time a week ago, Te Whatu Ora said
Reported Covid-19 cases up 32% week-on-week (Stuff.co.nz, Nov 20, 2023)


Last year in March, The Atheist made this prediction: "'Flu deaths here are ~500 a year, and omicron's going to be much lower than that."
Much lower than ~500 a year wasn't true then, and it isn't true now.


I haven't looked up the most recent NZ number of deaths from Omicron and the flu, but there's this relating to the death toll of Omicron vs. influenza in the USA:
The dominant variant of the coronavirus has proved to be not only staggeringly infectious, but an evolutionary marvel.
(...)
The U.S. Centers for Disease Control and Prevention found that between October 2022 and September 2023, more than 80,000 people died of Covid, more than eight times as many as those who died of influenza.
Omicron, Now 2 Years Old, Is Not Done With Us Yet (New York Times, Nov 21, 2023)


And since we have seen the story about road deaths in comparison to the COVID-19 death toll a couple of times:
The National Highway Traffic Safety Administration (NHTSA) today announced that an estimated 42,795 people died in traffic crashes in the United States in 2022 – down 0.3% from the year before. That's an average of 117 people dying on our roads every single day last year.
Small Decrease in 2022 Traffic Deaths Sustains Pandemic-Fueled Surge in Roadway Fatalities as NHTSA Still Lacks a Confirmed Administrator (Governors Highway Safety Association, April 20, 2023)
An estimated 19,515 people died in motor vehicle traffic crashes, representing a decrease of about 3.3% as compared to 20,190 fatalities in the first half of 2022.
NHTSA Estimates Traffic Fatalities Continued to Decline in the First Half of 2023 (United States Department of Transportation, Sep 28, 2023)



If anybody is interested in a podcast series about the pandemic, I can recommend Jonathan Howard's new We Want Them Infected Podcast (Apple podcasts)
 
I haven't looked up the most recent NZ number of deaths from Omicron and the flu,

I wonder why.

Covid has been listed as killing 2-3 people a day in NZ, however, the Health Department's own statistics show that the death total is overstated by 100% because covid is listed as the primary cause of death in only 50% of the total, so it's pretty safe to say covid deaths this year have been around 600.

Influenza kills ~800 a year.

... but there's this relating to the death toll of Omicron vs. influenza in the USA:

Inflated for a certainty, as NZ's base numbers are.

Show me how many people died because of covid, not with covid.

And since we have seen the story about road deaths in comparison to the COVID-19 death toll a couple of times:

Good idea, because it allows me to reiterate that my statement related to worldwide traffic deaths, which are standing at 1.3 million a year.

Not even the wildest over-estimate will have covid deaths over a million in 2023.

Try again, this time without the fallacious and misleading information.

I will also note that the current 400-odd people with covid in hospital in NZ isn't straining the health system and isn't causing a problem for anyone. That number is less than 1/2 of the peaks seen in 2022. ICUs have very few cases, currently running at 10% of the numbers seen in 2022.

https://www.rnz.co.nz/news/in-depth/450874/covid-19-data-visualisations-nz-in-numbers
 
No one is panicking but then you've been told/shown that more than once in this thread...

...
Covid has been listed as killing 2-3 people a day in NZ, however, the Health Department's own statistics show that the death total is overstated by 100% because covid is listed as the primary cause of death in only 50% of the total, so it's pretty safe to say covid deaths this year have been around 600.

Influenza kills ~800 a year.
One of these bolded things is not like the other. :rolleyes:

In the US the cause of death statistics have been reported as flu and pneumonia. I think they are trying to be more precise now between flu, COVID, RSV and bacterial.

I couldn't find in your link any mention of the COVID death total being 100% overstated. And the 7 day rolling average doesn't mean the annual weekly average, it means the last 7 days.


...Inflated for a certainty, as NZ's base numbers are.

Show me how many people died because of covid, not with covid.

Good idea, because it allows me to reiterate that my statement related to worldwide traffic deaths, which are standing at 1.3 million a year.

Not even the wildest over-estimate will have covid deaths over a million in 2023.

Try again, this time without the fallacious and misleading information.
:id:

You don't think COVID could possibly still be killing over a million/yr worldwide? Also, the problem with both vehicle deaths and infectious disease deaths is that in many places in the world there is no or poor public health infrastructure collecting adequate cause of death data. So the data is limited.


I will also note that the current 400-odd people with covid in hospital in NZ isn't straining the health system and isn't causing a problem for anyone. That number is less than 1/2 of the peaks seen in 2022. ICUs have very few cases, currently running at 10% of the numbers seen in 2022.

https://www.rnz.co.nz/news/in-depth/450874/covid-19-data-visualisations-nz-in-numbers
You might want to review how cause of death is determined when it is multifactorial.

It's complicated under the best of circumstances when more than one condition contributed. Here are the rules in New Zealand.
Cause of death: Part 1
Start at Part 1(a) with the direct cause of death, then go back in time to the preceding (antecedent) conditions until you get to the condition that started the sequence of conditions leading to death. This is the underlying cause of death.

Part 1 (a): Direct cause of death
Enter the disease or condition that occurred as the last part of the sequence of events or conditions leading directly to death.
It can be the sole entry on the certificate when only one condition, such as viral myocarditis or asthma, was present at death.
Or it may be a complication (such as peritonitis, septicaemia or pneumonia) of another condition.
Note: Do not enter the mode of dying such as collapse, cardiac arrest or respiratory failure; that information is of little value.

Part 1 (b): Antecedent cause
If the direct cause entered in 1(a) arose as a consequence of any antecedent disease or injury, enter that antecedent cause at 1(b). For example, Perforation of colon.

If no other condition led to the condition entered in 1(b) then the condition in 1(b) is the underlying cause of death and no entry is required in 1(c). For example Chronic bronchitis in 1(b) may have led to Bronchopneumonia in 1(a). Chronic bronchitis was the underlying cause of death.

Part 1 (c):
It could be that a further antecedent disease or condition may have caused the conditions in both 1(b) and 1(a) and was the underlying cause of death. In such cases that antecedent condition, which was the starting point in the chain of related events leading to the direct cause of death, should be entered at 1(c). For example Diverticulitis in 1(c) may have led to Perforation of the colon in 1(b) and Peritonitis in 1(a).

On no account must the starting point of the sequence be entered in Part 2 because of lack of space in Part 1.
Note:

If more than two antecedent conditions led to the direct cause of death entered at 1(a), the starting (underlying) condition should be entered at 1(c) and the most important of the intervening conditions entered first at 1(b), followed by the second intervening condition (if space allows).
If two intervening conditions are entered in 1(b) they should be separated by a comma.
Cause of death Part 2
Part 2 is for entry of other conditions not directly related to the cause of death, but which have contributed to or have had an adverse effect on the conditions entered in Part 1 of the certificate.
Conditions entered in Part 2 must not be directly related to the underlying cause of death.
Infectious disease
Below the section Cause of death Part 2 on the Medical Certificate of Cause of Death is a field requesting information about any infectious disease the deceased may have been suffering from at the time of death. This is to assist the funeral director to meet reporting obligations set out in section 85 of the Health Act 1956 and its Regulations.
The infectious diseases to be reported on in certain circumstances under the Health Act 1956 are listed in Parts 1 and 2 of Schedule 1 of this Act.
Providing this information also makes the funeral director and other professionals aware of the infection so they can take the necessary precautions to keep themselves safe when handling the body.

Maybe you'd like to try again reporting the data on actual COVID deaths and provide a better source.
 
The fact remains that it is just a correlation. I was at a presentation by Scott Atlas where he showed essentially the opposite among US states: the stricter a state's lockdowns were, the higher its COVID mortality was. It's just another correlation. He made the same mistake you are, assuming that the relationship represents cause and effect. In fact, it is no more meaningful than yours.

You can't assume that a correlation is due to your pet hypothesis; it practice, it rarely is. You have to adjust for confounding factors—differences between the populations that could account for the different outcomes (eg, age distributions, population density, etc.)—before you can conclude that your hypothesized cause is the correct one.

I doubt there is even such a correlation. Can you cite the evidence he was using?


See this video presentation by Atlas. Relevant material begins at 6:39, and the data I was referring to are discussed from 7:11–7:39.
 
In Japan there is weekly data on total deaths. There's a seasonality to it.

https://exdeaths-japan.org/en/graph/weekly

It takes a few months to finalize the data so this isn't right up to the present but it does cover until the end of August. Apparently there have not been excess deaths showing up in the data since February.
 
Last edited:
In Japan there is weekly data on total deaths. There's a seasonality to it.

https://exdeaths-japan.org/en/graph/weekly

It takes a few months to finalize the data so this isn't right up to the present but it does cover until the end of August. Apparently there have not been excess deaths showing up in the data since February.
Are you looking at the same graph I'm looking at in your link? :boggled:

Or are you being sarcastic? What am I missing here? :confused:

https://exdeaths-japan.org/en/graph/weekly/
 

That ignores the first quarter fatality rate of 2023 which was higher than any qtr since 2017.

Data on charts like this one are almost never current because there's a delay in reporting getting to the people tracking the cases and deaths.

You should probably be comparing the second and third qtrs with previous years instead of falsely concluding because deaths fell in the 2nd and 3rd qtrs that indicates the fatality rate has gone down. Of course it went down, that's due to the seasonal variation in the fatality rate, not due to a shift in the virulence of the virus.

That graph says the opposite, the fatality rate increased last winter (southern hemisphere's winter).
 
I couldn't find in your link any mention of the COVID death total being 100% overstated. And the 7 day rolling average doesn't mean the annual weekly average, it means the last 7 days.

You're still showing your lack of comprehension skills - I said 2 a day, the figures show 2 a day. The page I gave you splits up with covid and because of covid.

You don't think COVID could possibly still be killing over a million/yr worldwide?

Absolutely certain of it.

While recent covid death totals are sparse, the last million deaths took 22 months: https://www.worldometers.info/coronavirus/

Maybe you'd like to try again reporting the data on actual COVID deaths and provide a better source.

The source I gave you is New Zealand's official data from the Health Ministry. Your inability to read it is your problem.
 
You're still showing your lack of comprehension skills - I said 2 a day, the figures show 2 a day. The page I gave you splits up with covid and because of covid.

Absolutely certain of it.

While recent covid death totals are sparse, the last million deaths took 22 months: https://www.worldometers.info/coronavirus/

The source I gave you is New Zealand's official data from the Health Ministry. Your inability to read it is your problem.

The highlighted gratuitous snark is why some people get tired of trying to have a discussion with you.

BrettM cited a better source than the one you posted except they were looking at Japan. Your cite had no specifics one could use to evaluate the number.

I'm copy and pasting my words from post #172 above as they apply to any "rolling total".
SG said:
That ignores the first quarter fatality rate of 2023 which was higher than any qtr since 2017.

Data on charts like this one are almost never current because there's a delay in reporting getting to the people tracking the cases and deaths.

You should probably be comparing the second and third qtrs with previous years instead of falsely concluding because deaths fell in the 2nd and 3rd qtrs that indicates the fatality rate has gone down. Of course it went down, that's due to the seasonal variation in the fatality rate, not due to a shift in the virulence of the virus.

That graph says the opposite, the fatality rate increased last winter (southern hemisphere's winter).

Here's a link to the graph. It was initially cited by Puppycow.
https://exdeaths-japan.org/en/graph/weekly/


The bottom line, the number of fatalities in New Zealand at some single point like a week in Nov doesn't show the trend which is needed to assess the risk COVID poses.
 
Reality Check

Unfortunately, these reality checks of The Atheist's posts are necessary, as always:

Covid has been listed as killing 2-3 people a day in NZ, however, the Health Department's own statistics show that the death total is overstated by 100% because covid is listed as the primary cause of death in only 50% of the total, so it's pretty safe to say covid deaths this year have been around 600.

Influenza kills ~800 a year.

NZ numbers:
Covid-19 deaths to date 2022 versus the average yearly deaths of influenza and (!!!) pneumonia from 1991 to 2019.
Covid-19: 2193
Influenza: 695
Covid-19 hospitalisations versus influenza hospitalisations
2020 C19 98; flu 553
2021 C19 872; flu 150
2022 C19 20,516; flu 5,087

Cause of death New Zealand - rate per 100,000Covid-19 deaths are for year-to-date 2022. Other deaths are for 2019
Covid-19: 43 Influenza and pneumonia: 17Covid-19 vs the flu: Death rates compared (RNZ.co.nz, Dec 13, 2022)


Cumulative confirmed COVID-19 deaths in New Zealand, from Nov 21, 2022, to Nov 21, 2023 (most recent numbers not yet in): 1,320

Cumulative confirmed COVID-19 deaths in New Zealand, from Jan 1 to Nov 13, 2023: 1,171

Inflated for a certainty, as NZ's base numbers are.

Show me how many people died because of covid, not with covid.


Show us how many people died because of influenza, not with influenza.
That question never occurs to COVID-19 minimizers because ... well, .... they're COVID-19 minimizers, so how could it?! For some reason, NZ's C-19 death toll is "inflated for a certainty," but for whatever reason the flu deaths aren't, I guess.

Good idea, because it allows me to reiterate that my statement related to worldwide traffic deaths, which are standing at 1.3 million a year.

Not even the wildest over-estimate will have covid deaths over a million in 2023.

Try again, this time without the fallacious and misleading information.


The Atheist repeatedly resorts to this particular trick of misdirection. He knows (he's been told often enough!) that many parts of the world don't have reliable C19 statistics. People dying of respiratory diseases aren't tested and consequently their death certificates (if they are issued at all) won't say, "Cause of death: COVID-19".
Traffic deaths are a lot easier to deal with in this respect.
But whenever you look at countries with reliable statistics, it is obvious that the number of traffic deaths is nowhere near the death toll of COVID-19. See the U.S. numbers in post 165.

I will also note that the current 400-odd people with covid in hospital in NZ isn't straining the health system and isn't causing a problem for anyone. That number is less than 1/2 of the peaks seen in 2022. ICUs have very few cases, currently running at 10% of the numbers seen in 2022.
This is unlike countries with fairly reliable statistics, like the USA or NZ, where traffic deaths are insignificant in comparison to C19 deaths.

https://www.rnz.co.nz/news/in-depth/450874/covid-19-data-visualisations-nz-in-numbers


As so often before when I am fact-checking The Atheist's lies about the pandemic, I recommend that you go to my previous post, the one he is responding to. It's an eye-opener about The Atheist's posting tricks to see all the facts and arguments that he leaves out - one of his usual tricks!
 
You're still showing your lack of comprehension skills - I said 2 a day, the figures show 2 a day. The page I gave you splits up with covid and because of covid.

Absolutely certain of it.

While recent covid death totals are sparse, the last million deaths took 22 months: https://www.worldometers.info/coronavirus/

The source I gave you is New Zealand's official data from the Health Ministry. Your inability to read it is your problem.


The Atheist won't let go of his favorite ad hominems, but as for his other claims:

Currently, the number is 20 C19 deaths a week in NZ (and probably rising), but never mind.
I look forward to seeing The Atheist show us the page that splits up with influenza and because of influenza." (We all know it's never gonna happen, and it's not a good sign that NZ is now at a place where the health authorities feel that it has become important to make this split.)*

The last million C19 deaths confirmed, registered and reported to Worldometers may have taken 22 months, but
1) some countries never confirmed, registered and reported C19 deaths;
2) many countries used to confirm, register and report, but have now stopped reporting C19 deaths, for instance the USA and Japan in May 2023, and Iceland in November 2022.

I assume that The Atheist will continue to refer to Worldometers while pretending that it is a reliable source, as more and more countries stop reporting:
See?! Nobody dies of COVID-19 anymore! It's gone!


*ETA:
New Zealand: Over the past week, there have been 3,816 new cases reported. The total number of cases since the first case in New Zealand stands at 2,477,820, with 3,393 deaths attributed to COVID-19. The Ministry of Health has changed its definition of COVID-19 deaths, from deaths within 28 days of testing positive to deaths attributed to COVID-19. Auckland has the highest number of cases, with 231,786 cases in total.
Epidemic and emerging disease alerts in the Pacific as of 17 October 2023 (ReliefWeb.int)
It does make the numbers look so much better, doesn't it?!
 
Last edited:
The highlighted gratuitous snark is why some people get tired of trying to have a discussion with you.


Don't even try. It's possible to have a discussion about The Atheist's claims, but not with him.

BrettM cited a better source than the one you posted except they were looking at Japan. Your cite had no specifics one could use to evaluate the number.

I'm copy and pasting my words from post #172 above as they apply to any "rolling total".


They will no doubt be ignored again.

Here's a link to the graph. It was initially cited by Puppycow.
https://exdeaths-japan.org/en/graph/weekly/


The bottom line, the number of fatalities in New Zealand at some single point like a week in Nov doesn't show the trend which is needed to assess the risk COVID poses.


If cherry-pickng can make it look as if he's right about something, he'll cherry-pick.
 
In Japan there is weekly data on total deaths. There's a seasonality to it.

https://exdeaths-japan.org/en/graph/weekly

It takes a few months to finalize the data so this isn't right up to the present but it does cover until the end of August. Apparently there have not been excess deaths showing up in the data since February.


Take another look at the first two weeks of March, and 2023.08.06 and 2023.08.27.
April to September, late spring to early autumn, are usually the months when the pandemic numbers are low. (And yet the numbers appear to be rising in Australia and New Zealand.)

Why look at excess total deaths? Why not look at COVID-19 deaths? It makes sense to look at excess deaths to estimate pandemic deaths in countries with insufficient statistics of causes of death, but I don't think Japan is one of those.
 
The highlighted gratuitous snark is why some people get tired of trying to have a discussion with you.

You see snark, I see frustration at people unable to click a mouse.

I'll make it easy for you - this is off the page I linked to:

coviddata.JPG


As you can see quite clearly, the actual covid deaths are less than half the number some people like to use as a scare tactic. That's 2199 deaths sine the start of the pandemic.

The bottom line, the number of fatalities in New Zealand at some single point like a week in Nov doesn't show the trend which is needed to assess the risk COVID poses.

Then look harder - deaths in November are higher than they have been. We're running at 2 a day, and you can bet your last dollar that almost every one of them is someone very already waiting to die in a care home or hospice.

Unfortunately, these reality checks of The Atheist's posts are necessary,

:dl:

If your idea of a "reality check" is to use false and misleading data, I'm sure that makes sense. You continue to over-state the deaths and have made the terminal error of doing so again in your posts here. Covid deaths in NZ since the start of the pandemic are 2199, not 5000. You're out by 60% every time you touch your keyboard.

I note from the other thread that I'm not the only person utterly bored to coma by your efforts to get everyone to listen to your panicked raving.

NZ numbers:

Quoted above - try disagreeing with them.

For some reason, NZ's C-19 death toll is "inflated for a certainty," but for whatever reason the flu deaths aren't, I guess.

That's because nobody who died in a car crash three weeks after having influenza is added to 'flu deaths, yet covid mysteriously is.
 
Reality Check

Then look harder - deaths in November are higher than they have been. We're running at 2 a day, and you can bet your last dollar that almost every one of them is someone very already waiting to die in a care home or hospice.


In Jonathan Howard's most recent podcast in his series We Want Them Infected, COVID-19: Myths vs. Reality, he promised that one of the next episodes will be about one of The Atheist's favourite pandemic myths, the one about the 'toe tags'.
I'll post a link in this thread when it's been uploaded.
Unlike The Atheist and unlike me, Jonathan Howard was dealing with the people who got toe tags at the beginning of the pandemic, so he has seen with his own eyes that very far from everybody was "someone very already waiting to die in a care home or hospice" if they hadn't been infected.

In the meantime, it would be interesting to hear The Atheist's definiton of "almost every one of them." We already know that he doesn't think healthy 80-year-olds should live on, but I think he's lowered that bar considerably since then.
I assume that his definition will be as far removed from reality as his always wrong predictions.

And I can see that he's gone back to resorting to his favorite emoji:
When in doubt and entirely at a loss for arguments, the laughing dog seems to serve as his emotional support animal.

If your idea of a "reality check" is to use false and misleading data, I'm sure that makes sense. You continue to over-state the deaths and have made the terminal error of doing so again in your posts here. Covid deaths in NZ since the start of the pandemic are 2199, not 5000. You're out by 60% every time you touch your keyboard.


My idea of reality check is to not make unsupported claims and to link to all the facts I provide. The Atheist could learn something from that, but I don't think he will.

I note from the other thread that I'm not the only person utterly bored to coma by your efforts to get everyone to listen to your panicked raving.

Yes, somebody else didn't like the pandemic facts I presented in the other thread and posted something at the level of The Atheist's :dl:. Not surprising at all, and for The Atheist something to keep him company when reality proves him wrong.

Quoted above - try disagreeing with them.


Disagreeing with whom?!

That's because nobody who died in a car crash three weeks after having influenza is added to 'flu deaths, yet covid mysteriously is.


The Atheist actually appears to think that so many people die in car crashes within a month after having been tested positive for COVID-19 that it inflates the number of COVID-deaths significantly.
In fact, even if ten percent of the number of traffic deaths was subtracted from the number of C19 deaths, it would still amount to almost nothing, but minimizers gonna minimize whenever they see an option to do so no matter how ridiculous.

And notice once again everything The Atheist leaves out in his response to my previous reality check earlier today, not least all the factual references. They are far from all part of quotations, so it requires the effort of deliberate cherry-picking to remove them.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom