Cont: The One Covid-19 Science and Medicine Thread Part 5

Mea culpa - I thought that was so obviously tongue-in-cheek due to physical impossibility that nobody would take it seriously.

I've heard it said that deer are "the most dangerous animal in the United States" (they kill more people than any other animal).

Although, to be fair people are more dangerous to deer than the other way around. When deer kill people it's almost always by getting hit by a car, which sometimes results in the death of people in the car, and much more often results in the death of the deer itself.

It's the deer hit by motorcycles that kill the most, or actually the motorcyclists that swerve to miss the soft Deer, and hit the hard trees, guard rails and Rocks.
I was riding a Yamaha 4 Wheeler once an wound up with a young buck sitting on my shoulder. Was scratched and Brused but a lot better off than that young buck considering what the handle bars poked..
Bet he never jumped out infront of a 4 Wheeler again.
 
In an interesting turn of events, it might well be the panic over "long covid" is just a result of the huge number of infections rather than anything specific to SARS-CoV-2.

https://www.cnbc.com/2023/10/06/long-colds-could-be-as-common-as-long-covid-study.html


But Long Covid is way longer, and the symptoms way more tangential.

This cousin of mine, younger than me, mid twenties, used to be healthy as the proverbial horse (and now way fatter than any horse I've seen), came down with a bad case of Covid, back when it was new. Now plagued with massive weight gain, hair loss, allergies, diabetes, cholesterol even. Pressure as well maybe, I don't remember exactly, that too I think. All old-person ailments. And apparently it's all Long Covid.

I'm not sure if his doctors (as well as alternate med quacks he frequents, he's very superstitious and given to all manner of woo, including religious woo) are misleading him, but either way, whether real or imagined, or maybe partly real or partly imagined, but I think Long Covid refers to a very different animal (whether real, or mythical, or a bit of both) than this Long Cold.


_____

Like I said, he's crazy superstitious, believes a dizzyingly wide variety of nonsense. But his symptoms are real. Nor are they from before his bad case of Covid. All psychosomatic? Doubt it! All coincidence, the timing? Doubt it!

( Although he goes to quacks and faith healers et cetera, he's also being treated by good regular doctors as well. )


What I was getting at is, Long Covid is a very different beast. Even if mythical, it refers to something very different than a longer term continuation and worsening of those same symptoms. And nor am I sure it is fully mythical --- although I guess some/much of it may well be.
 
But Long Covid is way longer, and the symptoms way more tangential.

And identical to ME/CFS, which is allegedly a post-vrial disease. It can be a cold, influenza or other virus that sparks the ME/CFS, and it makes sense some of them will be post-coronavirus of some kind.

Emeritus Professor Warren Tate, of Otago Uni is apparently the number one man on MS/CGS and he's confident they're the same disease.

Even if not the exact same thing, there seems to be consensus that they're very similar, with strongly overlapping symptoms:

https://www.frontiersin.org/articles/10.3389/fmed.2023.1187163/full

https://www.news-medical.net/news/2...look-at-the-similarities-and-differences.aspx
 
And identical to ME/CFS, which is allegedly a post-vrial disease. It can be a cold, influenza or other virus that sparks the ME/CFS, and it makes sense some of them will be post-coronavirus of some kind.

Emeritus Professor Warren Tate, of Otago Uni is apparently the number one man on MS/CGS and he's confident they're the same disease.

Even if not the exact same thing, there seems to be consensus that they're very similar, with strongly overlapping symptoms:

https://www.frontiersin.org/articles/10.3389/fmed.2023.1187163/full

https://www.news-medical.net/news/2...look-at-the-similarities-and-differences.aspx


Ah, interesting! I was aware, vaguely, of chronic fatigue, that is I knew it's a thing, but I hadn't really known about ME/CFS really, and the diverse symptoms it might present. So clearly Long Covid isn't a whole different animal; it's simply yet another likely trigger for ME/CFS. ...So that, I suppose, treating Long Covid essentially would amount to treating ME/CFS, albeit possibly with conditions peculiar to the Covid-triggered variation. ...Which sounds like potatoes-potaytoes, but not really! Because it means doctors and researchers don't have to invent the treatment wheel afresh, it means they only need to tweak what they already have a bit to account for Covid-triggered peculiarities.


...Didn't know it was that high, the incidence of Long Covid. Your report (the dense one, the Komaroff-Lipkin thing) says apparently 40%+ of acute Covid cases develop Long Covid! ...Ties in with what my cousin's going through, what they say there, it's 2+ years since his Covid --- poor guy'd spent some harrowing days in the ICU back then.

Thanks for posting, I'll send these reports to him to check out. (I mean, I need hardly do that really, like I said he's being treated by regular doctors, the woo-peddlers he goes to are in addition to regular treatment. And I've no doubt the regular doctors know what they're doing. But still.)
 
...Didn't know it was that high, the incidence of Long Covid. Your report (the dense one, the Komaroff-Lipkin thing) says apparently 40%+ of acute Covid cases develop Long Covid!

I think that's a highly misleading statistic on two fronts. Firstly it depends how you count acute cases, and more importantly, it doesn't recognise that many people with long covid come right after a period of time.

The true numbers are still fairly unknown, but scanning sick leave records doesn't show anything like the impact being anywhere near 10% let alone 40%.

My best estimate, working with a database of over 2000 employees is under 1%, and that may be overstated as well as not everyone reported being sick with covid. That seems to fit with what GPs are saying too. Still a lot of people, though.
 
Reality Check



Comparable with influenza, indeed! So let's compare them! I've found the German numbers:
In :GERMANY: gab es in den vergangenen 12 Monaten mehr als 20x so viele #COVID19-Todesfälle wie Influenza-Tote. Seit der 40. KW 2022 wurden 1.096 Todesfälle mit #Influenza und 22.266 Todesfälle mit #SARSCoV2 an das RKI übermittelt.
#CovidIsNotOver #Coronavirus
Ralf Wittenbrink (Twitter/X, Oct 6, 2023)

In the previous 12 months, there were more than 20 times as many COVID-19 deaths as influenza deaths in Germany. Since week 40, 2022, 1,096 influenza deaths and 22,266 SARS-CoV-2 deaths were reported to the Robert Koch Institute (RKI).
#CovidIsNotOver #Coronavirus

Seit der 40. MW 2022 wurden bisher 1.096 Todesfälle mit Influenzavirusinfektion an das RKI übermittelt.
(...)
Es wurden 22.266 Todesfälle mit SARS-CoV-2-Infektion übermittelt.
ARE-Wochenbericht des RKI (Robert Koch Institute)
In pre-vaccination 2020, the number of C-19 deaths was 39,761.

As for 'car crash deaths', let's take a look at the number of people who died in traffic accidents in 2022:
Pressemitteilung Nr. 073 vom 24. Februar 2023. WIESBADEN – Im Jahr 2022 sind in Deutschland 2 782 Menschen bei Unfällen im Straßenverkehr ums Leben gekommen.
Unfallbilanz 2022: 220 Verkehrstote mehr als im Vorjahr (Statistisches Bundesamt, Feb 24, 2023)
2,782, 220 more than in 2021.


I have pointed out that Our World in Data no longer gets the numbers from many countries. I thought that I had made this clear to The Atheist, but ...
I assume this means that The Atheist now understands that his claims about the most recent COVID-19 numbers are, to quote himself, on the level of "Utter bollocks ... idiotic article ... sensationalist idiot ... scaremonger ... OMG WTF..." because of delayed (or maybe entirely abandoned; it's hard to tell) registering and reporting of numbers as mentioned in my recent reality check of The Atheist's claims.
post 3,003
 
Last edited:
... it means doctors and researchers don't have to invent the treatment wheel afresh, it means they only need to tweak what they already have a bit to account for Covid-triggered peculiarities.


You imply that there already is a treatment that works. There isn't, unfortunately. The current treatment for ME/CFS is learning-to-live-with-it therapy. Notice the reservations:
There is no cure or approved treatment for myalgic encephalomyelitis/chronic fatigue syndrome (ME/CFS). However, some (!) symptoms can be treated or managed. Treating these symptoms might (!) provide relief for some (!) patients with ME/CFS but not others. Other strategies, like learning new ways to manage activity, can also be helpful.
Treatment of ME/CFS (CDC)


How does ME/CFS affect people?
For most people, ME/CFS is a lifelong disease. Full recovery (a return to pre-illness functioning) is rare and estimated at less than 10%. For some people with ME/CFS, as time passes and their disease improves, they will find they can do more, but it is a slow and gradual process. However, this is not the case for everyone. Some people find their disease worsens over time, others may remain somewhat stable. With support and pacing, people can often improve their quality of life.
Chronic Fatigue Syndrome (CFS) (BetterHealth.vic.gov.au, July 7, 2022)
 
In the previous 12 months, there were more than 20 times as many COVID-19 deaths as influenza deaths in Germany. Since week 40, 2022, 1,096 influenza deaths and 22,266 SARS-CoV-2 deaths were reported to the Robert Koch Institute (RKI).

Hey, that's cool - just ignore the obvious fact that there were 20 times more covid infections than influenza.

Just another dishonest attempt to create panic.

#CovidIsNotOver #Coronavirus

#Letsallpanic
 
The number of infections will continue to decrease as immunity increases.

It's still the total numbers of deaths in this particular exchange. People are still dying of COVID, no need to panic but there is a need to take the risk seriously.


And the number of infections in this area is huge at the moment. People are out sick with COVID everywhere.

Maybe Japan hasn't been hit yet.
 
Last edited:
Czech Republic is slowing down, maybe even peaking. Hard to tell how bad it is, as indeed we test much less.
Deaths (which are the easiest to count) are at about 1 per day, compared to 200 in the worst times with Alpha.
But the season change is just starting, wonder how that's gonna affect it. Covid reacts weirdly on seasons, sometimes is seems it doesn't care at all. But there must be some effect.
 
It's still the total numbers of deaths in this particular exchange.

Yes, and the numbers are still dropping. Data extending back 12 months is out of date.

And the number of infections in this area is huge at the moment. People are out sick with COVID everywhere.

Maybe Japan hasn't been hit yet.

Au contraire - as posted a couple of weeks back, Japan has had the surge and despite the age of their population, deaths and critical care have been quite low.

But the season change is just starting, wonder how that's gonna affect it. Covid reacts weirdly on seasons, sometimes is seems it doesn't care at all. But there must be some effect.

The pattern may change, but there's been a definite surge in infections in autumn pretty much everywhere. We had a surge at the start of autumn that didn't carry through winter, Japan has had it, and so does USA and Czechia.
 
Japan had long wave through the whole summer. The minimum was in March, and clear increase since May.

https://mainichi.jp/english/covid19

That recent Okinawa surge was more like in the middle of travel season. If anything, increased tourism has caused it. When I got it in May, it must have been Helsinki or Osaka airport. Osaka was especially crowded, and I spent 3 hours getting through arrival procedures, surrounded mostly by unmasked coughing Chinese.

Same here, the exponential factor changed in August, which is middle of 2 month summer school holiday, and middle of summer. It wasn't school starting on September 1st, even though that hardly helped. And the weather was exceptionally warm till last week.

Would be interesting to straight out map it against average temperatures in the region .. but compared to flu it's highly irregular.
 
Last edited:
Goodo - thanks for that update.

It's hard to know exactly what's going on thanks to the lack of collated data. Maybe we need to apply wave dynamics to it, but I'd definitely go along with travel being a good driver. Aeroplanes and airports are perfect vectors for lots of diseases, but nice airborne ones like covid and measles are clear winners.

Schools are a big driver, too, as they are for all sorts of viruses. We seem to have hit a pattern in NZ that infections rise then school holidays start and they drop again. Filthy little bastards.
 
IHMO at the moment it's ruled by the wave front phenomenon .. like in forest fire .. it just burns through fuel and leaves less flammable area behind it. Seasons (nature, travel) do slow it down or accelerate it, but so far not strongly enough. It might take time for the wave to align with them .. and it might have been the case with other seasonal diseases.
 
Fluffy piece here on people who have had covid multiple times: https://www.nbcnews.com/health/health-news/covid-5-times-people-describe-illnesses-rcna118132

Very small number of people involved, and at least two of the five are morbidly obese.

The article finishes with some common sense, which is a nice change:

However, Merad said, young, healthy people shouldn’t panic about getting Covid multiple times.

“We are going to be reinfected, the same way we are reinfected by flu. But the most severe infection was the one that we observed when we were not vaccinated,” she said.

Emily said that after getting Covid five times, she feels less worried about the virus’ threat.

“I don’t want to stay inside to avoid it,” she said. “It just seems like something we live with now.”
 
A new study finds that the risk of getting Guillain-Barré Syndrome within 6 weeks after COVID increases by six times, and decreases by more than half after getting the BioNTech vaccine.
Association Between Guillain-Barré Syndrome and COVID-19 Infection and Vaccination: A Population-Based Nested Case-Control Study

ETA: The study was conducted in Israel, which used almost exclusively the BioNTech vaccine (aka Pfizer vaccine) during the study period.

Guillain-Barré Syndrome is quite rare so you need to study millions of people to get enough cases to be statistically significant.
 
Last edited:
Association Between Guillain-Barré Syndrome and COVID-19 Infection and Vaccination: A Population-Based Nested Case-Control Study

ETA: The study was conducted in Israel, which used almost exclusively the BioNTech vaccine (aka Pfizer vaccine) during the study period.

Guillain-Barré Syndrome is quite rare so you need to study millions of people to get enough cases to be statistically significant.


Then how did they get statistically significant results with only 836 subjects?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom