Cont: The One Covid-19 Science and Medicine Thread Part 5

Bad News

Finally, some info on the new mono-valent vax and current variants. I've been waiting for this.

XBB.1.5 monovalent mRNA vaccine booster elicits robust neutralizing antibodies against emerging SARS-CoV-2 variants

Also, I'm looking at getting the flu vax too. It's ramping up strongly here in Calif. Covid-19 is at a somewhat higher level but isn't ramping as much. Ideally, I want to get the shots 1 to 2 months prior to the transmission peaks since they both wane rather quickly at three months. So probably in the next 1 to 2 weeks.


The monovalent XBB.1.5 doesn't seem to offer much immunity against the new variant JN.1, according to a new study from the The Sato Lab (Kei Sato).
From a tweet:
"JN.1 shows a robust resistance to monovalent XBB.1.5 vaccine sera. These results suggest that JN.1 is one of the most immune-evading variants to date. S:L455S can contribute to increased immune evasion, which partly explains the increased Re of JN.1."

From the abstract:
BA.2.86 has evolved and its descendant, JN.1 (BA.2.86.1.1), emerged in late 2023. JN.1 harbors S:L455S and three mutations in non-S proteins. S:L455S is a hallmark mutation of JN.1: we have recently shown that HK.3 and other "FLip" variants carry S:L455F, which contributes to increased transmissibility and immune escape ability compared to the parental EG.5.1 variant.

Virological characteristics of the SARS-CoV-2 JN.1 variant
(bioRxiv, Dec 8, 2023)


Speculation: It may not be a good idea to target primarily the spike protein, which seems to be mutating faster than vaccines can be developed. From the very beginning, Cuba instead targeted the receptor-binding domain of the virus, which doesn't appear to be as mutatable. All the Cuban C19 vaccines are based on this principle.

An engineered SARS-CoV-2 receptor-binding domain produced in Pichia pastoris as a candidate vaccine antigen (PubMed/Epub, Aug 8, 2022)
Cubas coronavacciner: »Vi vidste, at vi havde gode chancer« (Cuba-venner.dk, June 27, 2021)
 
Last edited:
Not sure what you mean here. Why do you think your test kit expiration dates haven't been extended? Did you check the lot numbers against the FDA link, or are you not in the US?


Two separate issues here.

1) I didn't say the water evaporated out of plastic containers, though it might depending on the plastic. But things like chlorine and iodine do.

2)The FDA approved the tests for X number of months. But it's not like they had said test kits for the last 5 years with which to observe and determine the longer expiration dates.

Did I not already link to this?

Authorized At-Home OTC COVID-19 Diagnostic Tests and Expiration Dates

Mileage of other countries' tests may very.

Absolutely the control on the test you are using can give you valid information on the specific tests you are using.


Jesus ******* Christ. My point was that the guy who thinks the solution in his test kit evaporated was mistaken. Worse yet, by diluting the concentration by a factor of three, if anything, he made the test less reliable.
 
Last edited:
This is a fairly in-depth analysis of the future risks from covid, written by what appears to be a very well-qualified expert.*

The Future Risk of Long Covid

But it is very reassuring to see that the worst impacts of the pandemic, even when it comes to long Covid, are almost certainly well behind us in 2023.

*I have some doubts: he is Australian and he's holding a cat in his photo. Caution strongly advised.
 
Not sure where to put this, but it is from emergency room doctors retelling their stories of what life was like for them in the first year of the pandemic. In particular, these stories are being retold as a way of combating some of the garbage that Covid denialists came up with about a) Covid being no big thing, b) ventilators being unnecessary c) doctors upgrading patients to Covid just to get money d) the idea that doctors never bothered treating patients or trying things out.

Link
 
This is a fairly in-depth analysis of the future risks from covid, written by what appears to be a very well-qualified expert.*

The Future Risk of Long Covid



*I have some doubts: he is Australian and he's holding a cat in his photo. Caution strongly advised.

Gideon Meyerowitz-Katz has always been a very reliable source throughout the pandemic. He was one of those that showed how the studies supporting ivermectin were flawed.
 
Now, some years after COVID-19 burst upon the the world, what is the view on fomite transmission? A few months after the scare started, I saw a documentary where some researchers claimed, that while viral material could be found on fomites in infected homes, this viral material was damaged, and could no longer infect.

But much later, the official recommendations were still to disinfect all surfaces to avoid fomite transmission.

What role did (does) fomite transmission actually have for COVID-19, according to current knowledge?
 
What role did (does) fomite transmission actually have for COVID-19, according to current knowledge?

Very minor, but unquestionably some cases were passed on via fomite transmission. I don't think there's a simple answer to how many, and the point about degradation of the virus is only partly correct.

In dry conditions, tiny fomites will break down quite quickly due to degradation of the lipid envelope. In sunshine, the UV light will destroy it in seconds. On the other side, in humid or damp conditions, they will be viable for much longer, and if it's a visible amount of material, I'm sure the viable time could be up to days.

Given the ease of airborne transmission, you're probably 10,000 times more likely to get it just breathing, but good hand hygiene is good anyway.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
This is unfortunate:


Study Finds Paxlovid Treatment Does Not Reduce Risk of Long COVID
https://www.ucsf.edu/news/2024/01/4...vid-treatment-does-not-reduce-risk-long-covid

A team of researchers from UC San Francisco has found that Paxlovid did not reduce the risk of developing long COVID for vaccinated, non-hospitalized individuals during their first COVID-19 infection. They also found that a higher proportion of individuals than previously reported experience rebounds after taking Paxlovid.

Study
https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/full/10.1002/jmv.29333

Study actually shows slightly higher long covid with Paxlovid but not statistically significant.

Among those treated with nirmatrelvir, 57/353 (16.1%) reported Long COVID symptoms compared to 176/1258 (14.0%) untreated (odds ratio [OR]: 1.18; 95% confidence interval [CI]: 0.84–1.65; p = 0.31; Table 2).
 
Now, some years after COVID-19 burst upon the the world, what is the view on fomite transmission? A few months after the scare started, I saw a documentary where some researchers claimed, that while viral material could be found on fomites in infected homes, this viral material was damaged, and could no longer infect.

But much later, the official recommendations were still to disinfect all surfaces to avoid fomite transmission.

What role did (does) fomite transmission actually have for COVID-19, according to current knowledge?


Our own Teknologisk Institut discovered very early on (I think it was late-2020) that there was virtually no transmission from fomites: Coronavirus smitter ikke gennem fødevarer (Teknologisk.dk)

For the people involved in Denmark's early pandemic response, it took till early last year to discover this:
Tidligere faglig direktør i Statens Serum Institut, Kåre Mølbak, som spillede en central rolle i at rådgive om smittehåndtering under pandemien, fortryder, at afspritning blev prioriteret så højt under coronaepidemien. I stedet skulle udluftning, ventilation og luftrensning i risikosituationer kombineret med effektive masker have været topprioriteret.
Tidligere SSI-direktør fortryder corona-anbefaling (Sundhedspolitisk Tidsskrift, Mar 7, 2023)


However, some public health authorities seem to value consistent information over correct information.

The chance of COVID-19 surface transmission is less than 1 in 10,000.
Surface Cleaning and COVID-19: What You Should Know (WebMD, Dec 26, 2022)
 
This is a fairly in-depth analysis of the future risks from covid, written by what appears to be a very well-qualified expert.*

The Future Risk of Long Covid

But it is very reassuring to see that the worst impacts of the pandemic, even when it comes to long Covid, are almost certainly well behind us in 2023.

*I have some doubts: he is Australian and he's holding a cat in his photo. Caution strongly advised.


One should always be cautious of quotations presented by The Atheist, and even more so when they start with "But ...":

This doesn’t mean that long Covid is no longer an issue. There are many people who got sick in 2020 who are still suffering terribly years later. Even if the rate of long Covid is now low, and falling, there are still enough infections that the number of people experiencing new cases of long Covid will be at least in the hundreds of thousands in the US alone for years to come. But it is very reassuring to see that the worst impacts of the pandemic, even when it comes to long Covid, are almost certainly well behind us in 2023.
The future risk of long Covid (Stuff.co.nz, Dec 16, 2023)


Another problem with the article, which is an "OPINION" and not a "fairly in-depth analysis" as The Atheist claims, is that its numbers are pre-JN.1 sub-variant and thus doesn't take into account the surging number of infections in many countries in December 2023, which makes this statement outdated:
Infection risk is decreasing over time. This is a fairly well-proven fact. If you look at the Office for National Statistics in the UK, with their excellent Covid-19 infection survey, the proportion of the population being infected peaked during Omicron in 2022 and has declined since then.


That is the problem with "a fairly well-proven fact" in this pandemic of a continually mutating and evolving virus: It's damn hard to predict what it will do next, and at the time when he mentioned that "the initial results of the Winter Coronavirus Infection Survey suggest that around 1% of people had Covid-19 in the UK in the last week of November 2023, compared to about double that number from a similar time last year," that percentage would have risen considerably in December 2023:

In England and Scotland, the estimated prevalence of SARS-CoV-2 on 13 December 2023 was 4.2% (95% Credible intervals (CrI): 3.3%, 5.4%), which is equivalent to around 2,549,000 individuals (95% CrI: 1,996,000 to 3,236,000) being infected with SARS-CoV-2. This corresponds to around 1 in 24 people (95% CrI: 1 in 30 to 1 in 19).
Winter Coronavirus (COVID-19) Infection Study: estimates of epidemiological characteristics, 21 December 2023 (Gov.UK, Dec 22, 2023)


And that was only the "increase in prevalence of SARS-CoV-2 in England and Scotland during the 2 weeks leading up to 13 December 2023."
 
Our own Teknologisk Institut discovered very early on (I think it was late-2020) that there was virtually no transmission from fomites: Coronavirus smitter ikke gennem fødevarer (Teknologisk.dk)

For the people involved in Denmark's early pandemic response, it took till early last year to discover this:



However, some public health authorities seem to value consistent information over correct information.


Thanks, Dan. It is as I suspected.
 
Our own Teknologisk Institut discovered very early on (I think it was late-2020) that there was virtually no transmission from fomites: Coronavirus smitter ikke gennem fødevarer (Teknologisk.dk)

For the people involved in Denmark's early pandemic response, it took till early last year to discover this:



However, some public health authorities seem to value consistent information over correct information.

Yet in Australia I still frequently see signs saying "stop the spread of Covid 19 by washing your hands." Shops also provide disinfectant for hands.

Yet the above are insignificant compared to wearing a mask. Yet masks are a rare sight.
 
It's the same in Denmark, unfortunately, to this very day.
Hvis man er blevet smittet med influenza eller covid-19 anbefaler SSI, at man bliver hjemme, så smittekæden brydes.
Derudover kan god håndhygiejne og udluftning mindske risikoen for, at andre i husstanden bliver smittet.
Coronasmitten står i stampe og kan have nået sit toppunkt (BT.dk, dec 28, 2023)
If you have been infected with the flu or COVID-19, the SSI recommends that you stay home in order to break the cycle of transmission.
In addition to this, good hand hygiene and ventilation may lower the risk that other people in your home get infected.
The level of infection has evened out and may have peaked

Not a word about face masks. (And open windows are frowned upon this time of the year with temperatures below 0oC.)
The reporting of new cases, hospitalizations and deaths is notoriously delayed during the holidays.
However, the number of new cases may actually have peaked at this point. We'll know in a week or two.
 
This is a fairly in-depth analysis of the future risks from covid, written by what appears to be a very well-qualified expert.*

The Future Risk of Long Covid

*I have some doubts: he is Australian and he's holding a cat in his photo. Caution strongly advised.


I already criticized The Atheist's post in post 231, but since then I've come across more information about the guy that The Atheist thinks is a "a very well-qualified expert." In some respects, he actually is. His name is Gideon Meyerowitz-Katz.

On Twitter/X, he calls himself Health Nerd.

In (very) early 2020, he tweeted this:
An early Valentine's poem:
Roses are red,
Violets are blue,
Don't worry about coronavirus,
You're much more likely to die of the flu
Health Nerd (Twitter/X, Feb 3, 2020


What's worse is that he displays the same hyperbolic optimism when he writes about long covid:
What the Latest Evidence Actually Says About Long COVID (Slate, Aug 25, 2023)
The article had to be updated only four days later:
Update, Aug. 29, 2023: This piece has been updated to clarify that there are likely tens of thousands of people disabled due to COVID-19 in a country the size of the U.S., rather than globally. This figure is an estimate, extrapolated from a study done in the U.K. at a time of peak prevalence of inactivity due to long COVID.


And even the "likely tens of thousands of people disabled due to COVID-19 in a country the size of the U.S." appears to be an understatement:

There is considerable risk of ongoing symptoms after acute SARSCOV2 infection.
The risk is highest in young adults and females, which is very different from the pattern seen in severe acute COVID-19.
The majority of Long COVID cases are in people of working age.
Around 24 percent of those with Long COVID at 3 months continued to have symptoms at 12 months.
In the United States, in 2021, 720,000 people aged 20 and older reached the 1-year duration mark; in 2022, this number is estimated to be 520,000.Recovery for the vast majority of long COVID cases occurs within a year.
Long COVID: Examining Long-Term Health Effects of COVID-19 and Implications for the Social Security Administration: Proceedings of a Workshop. (National Library of Medicine)


I tend to agree with Chad Pilcher, who writes:
Gideon Meyerowitz-Katz deserves credit for the work he has done in debunking anti-vax arguments. But when it comes to Long Covid and COVID risks in general, he is very much in the pollyanna "vax & relax" camp, and out pretty far over his skis with these guesstimate models. I take them with a heavy dash of salt.


Some people in this thread are in the same camp.
 
Can anyone point me to some authoritative information on the risk of catching Covid while

in an airport,
on a plane, and
when wearing or not wearing a mask?
 
Normally, one is advised to do moderate exercise after recovering from an illness. This appears to be counterproductive for long Covid-19. Apparently, there is damage to the mitochondria impairing energy production. Yuck.

Muscle abnormalities worsen after post-exertional malaise in long COVID
https://www.nature.com/articles/s41467-023-44432-3

Our participants showed large variability in exercise tolerance (V̇O2max and peak power), fiber type composition, and mitochondrial enzyme activity, but despite this large heterogeneity, all patients experienced post-exertional malaise one day after the exercise test. As such, we conclude that the pathophysiology of fatigue and a reduced exercise capacity is distinct from the rapid development of post-exertional malaise in long COVID patients. The development of post-exertional malaise could in turn, however, lead to a further reduction in exercise capacity in patients, as the acute reduction in mitochondrial SDH activity, occurrence of tissue necrosis, and possibly intramuscular accumulation of amyloid-containing deposits could worsen skeletal muscle metabolism and force production over time, causing a vicious downward circle.
 
Can anyone point me to some authoritative information on the risk of catching Covid while

in an airport,
on a plane, and
when wearing or not wearing a mask?

Going to a vacation ? Wear a mask. Covid on a hotel sucks. Airplane is relatively well ventilated though, and there is only a handful of people sitting around you. Visit to a shopping mall is probably worse.
 
Can anyone point me to some authoritative information on the risk of catching Covid while

in an airport,
on a plane, and
when wearing or not wearing a mask?

The information has been accumulated over time. Early on there was research that showed which seats in a restaurant were at greater risk than not. Better ventilation was recommended.

People who were in a church choir infected each other. Singing and shouting was implicated.

There was at least one study that showed the virus was airborne. Fomites and droplet spread have not been shown to be a common means of transmission.

Other studies found 80% of the virus was blocked if the infected person wore the mask and the person protecting themself wearing a mask blocked 20%. I don't know how they measured that.

There's more I'll post as I think of it.

Oh yeah, re airplanes, you're at risk the closer you sit to an infected person. We know this from research of other airborne pathogens. It probably applies.
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom