The Mentality of Skeptics

That's exactly the mentality of a pseudoskeptic/debunker. They're desperate to come to a conclusion if a question causes them cognitive dissonance.
No, you are incorrect again. As I've demonstrated time and again, provisional conclusions are perfectly acceptable.
http://www.skeptic.com/about_us/

Modern skepticism is embodied in the scientific method, which involves gathering data to formulate and test naturalistic explanations for natural phenomena. A claim becomes factual when it is confirmed to such an extent it would be reasonable to offer temporary agreement. But all facts in science are provisional and subject to challenge, and therefore skepticism is a method leading to provisional conclusions. Some claims, such as water dowsing, ESP, and creationism, have been tested (and failed the tests) often enough that we can provisionally conclude that they are not valid. Other claims, such as hypnosis, the origins of language, and black holes, have been tested but results are inconclusive so we must continue formulating and testing hypotheses and theories until we can reach a provisional conclusion.
On the other hand, you've demonstrated nothing on this thread other than extreme intellectual dishonesty. Which I have demonstrated once again, above.
 
Heironimus is the only person who has ever publicly claimed to be the person in the costume. His personal connection to Patterson & Gimlin is strong and he tells the story of how the hoax happened to his recollection. That should matter. That should matter a lot.

You somehow got past two things at the minimum...

1. No confirmatory evidence has ever been produced for Bigfoot.
2. A guy has confessed to wearing the costume in the PGF.

The body of a Bigfoot can't authenticate the PGF, but it'll make the PGF appear more plausible to people who have a hard time analyzing the film.

BobH isn't able to back up his claim. As for why he would make the claim, he might be jealous of Gimlin or perhaps is enemies with him. Who knows.

Resume said:
"skepticism is a method leading to provisional conclusions."

It seems you're interpreting that as "skepticism is the method of making provisional conclusions". There's a critical difference there.
 
As I've demonstrated time and again, provisional conclusions are perfectly acceptable.

It's acceptable if it's based on proper evidence. Making unsupported conclusions to get rid of uncertainty and cognitive dissonance isn't.
 
It's acceptable if it's based on proper evidence.
Or utter lack of evidence where said evidence is necessarily expected.

Making unsupported conclusions to get rid of uncertainty and cognitive dissonance isn't.
Making unsupported assertions when you don't even understand the terms you're attempting to use isn't acceptable.
 
What's happening:

*guy sees evidence of Bigfoot*

*isn't able to handle the cognitive dissonance*

*joins the JREF forum*

*tries hard to convince himself that there's no such thing*

*reads a thread like this which addresses the real issue*

*uses the debate on Bigfoot as a red herring*

I'm not a guy, but I don't think I've seen evidence of Bigfoot. Would you please tell me when and where that happened, since you say it did?
 
BobH isn't able to back up his claim. As for why he would make the claim, he might be jealous of Gimlin or perhaps is enemies with him. Who knows.
BH tells the story of being in the costume. Why just reject that? Think about Gimlin. He can't back up his claim. You should be saying that he also can't back up his claim. What does Gimlin do? Well, he shows up at Bigfooter conferences and repeats his story. He doesn't back up the existence of Bigfoot, he just repeats the story. You've decided that his story is better than the other Bob. Maybe it's your anxiety of losing a hobby. Who knows.
 
The body of a Bigfoot can't authenticate the PGF, but it'll make the PGF appear more plausible to people who have a hard time analyzing the film.

BobH isn't able to back up his claim. As for why he would make the claim, he might be jealous of Gimlin or perhaps is enemies with him. Who knows.



It seems you're interpreting that as "skepticism is the method of making provisional conclusions". There's a critical difference there.

 
skepticism is a method of examining claims whereby we may reach conclusions.

A proper conclusion may be what you're working towards, but the forming of a conclusion itself isn't part of the method. Forming a conclusion is only wrong when you form it without proper evidence or a proper lack of evidence.

Pseudoskepticism is when you deny evidence in order to form your incorrect conclusion. For instance, you would have to deny all of the evidence available for the existence of Sasquatch to convince yourself that it doesn't exist.
 
Pseudoskepticism is when you deny evidence in order to form your incorrect conclusion. For instance, you would have to deny all of the evidence available for the existence of Sasquatch to convince yourself that it doesn't exist.
This might be a reasonable argument if . . . actually not even then.

The vast bulk of bigfoot evidence is hearsay, which is useless. The rest are witness testimonies (anecdotes), which are unverifiable, unfalsifiable, and useless. Tracks? Casts of tracks? Useless. Virtually no one in the scientific community is interested in footie because of this weak evidence, and that's isn't their fault.

Instead of getting all pissy and using terms you don't understand, much less have the ability to defend, get some actual testable evidence and we can discuss it. Until then, you have nothing. Except your incessant whining.
 
A proper conclusion may be what you're working towards, but the forming of a conclusion itself isn't part of the method. Forming a conclusion is only wrong when you form it without proper evidence or a proper lack of evidence.

Pseudoskepticism is when you deny evidence in order to form your incorrect conclusion. For instance, you would have to deny all of the evidence available for the existence of Sasquatch to convince yourself that it doesn't exist.

 
That's not the definition of it at all. I posted the definition straight from multiple dictionaries, yet you deny it ;)

You posted a definition of Skepticism, the colloquial one, which is not the same as the scientific skepticism being applied in relation to Bigfoot, UFOs and psychics. Scientific skepticism is about weighing evidence and basing your opinions on it rather than the wooist approach to their pet fantasy, which is that it is true and no evidence to the contrary will persuade them otherwise. For example, IR trail cameras that have found dozens if not hundreds of new species in areas of the world far wilder than the Pacific Northwest of the USA fail to find bigfoot? A skeptic would see that as evidence against the existence of bigfoot, the true believers simply assert that the IR 'scares them off'.

A proper conclusion may be what you're working towards, but the forming of a conclusion itself isn't part of the method. Forming a conclusion is only wrong when you form it without proper evidence or a proper lack of evidence.

Like believing in Bigfoot for example

Pseudoskepticism is when you deny evidence in order to form your incorrect conclusion.

Like believing in Bigfoot for example.

Your fundamental lack of understanding scientific skepticism keeps showing. People don't deny the evidence for Bigfoot, they evaluate its quality and weigh it against the evidence that makes it nigh on impossible for a large primate to still be lurking in the forests of the USA without ever yielding up a corpse or winding up in a zoo. To date all the Bigfoot believers have come up with are a few shoddy images of dubious provenance and various bits of biological 'evidence' about which great claims are made but are somehow never submitted to proper testing.
 
Last edited:
OS, you could watch the Bigfooters on BFF become denialist scoftics if you would only spout your research on alien-Bigfoot like you do here. Do you avoid that because you don't want to reveal that they are bad skeptics who are wracked with anxiety over the idea of aliens delivering Bigfoot to us? Tell Boresman that the tracks he saw were created by an alien experiment.

I bet you could provoke those boys to be more vile than y'all say that we are. Tell them what you really think. :D
 
Speaking of "reality", I can only hope this thread has proven once and for all there's absolutely no amount of 'intelligent reason' that could change OS's game.

"He's dug in deeper than an Alabama tick."

A big problem is the majority of folks here have a genuine desire to be helpful to others (as opposed to folks like me who just want to call people names), and maybe especially so to people who appear to only be 'misguided' about the obvious truth. The thing is if he really was just a "misguided" knowledge seeker, he'd have long ago danced the Dead Bigfoot jig after 'accepting' the simple reality we've tried to show him.

That is, you guys think you're playing a nice, fair "debate" game against an opponent of similar ilk, but you're actually playing it against an abstract set of ever-changing rules that specifically despises things like fair-play and honesty and anything else that would expose the game.

The only reason that it seems like up is down and left is right with regards to posts by this <cough> valued forum member who reports all posts that make him cry named OS is he's been deliberately trying to make it seem that way. With a straight face he's been ******* with the dictionary definition of "skepticism" since the OP and at every opportunity since he hilariously attempts to redefine something.

How is it cosmically possible definitions of words are the ones truly responsible for the existence or non-existence of Bigfoot, e.g. Bigfoot exists because we're "denialists"? Only a gamer playing in a fictional universe could come up with such a premise. :cool:
 
Their goal is to get proof of the existence of what people call Sasquatch in hopes that it'll establish protection for the "species". They've sold all of their trail cameras except for a few that they personally own. They haven't written a paper on their older study and that's probably because there isn't much to write about. The level of activity didn't get crazy for them until they started employing the strategy of staying in that forest for longer than a week.

In other words, if you're stating it right, they cannot be convinced at this point of any conclusion but the unproven one they already hold. No matter how long they continue not finding evidence, they'll keep on doing it.
 
What's actually happening:

*guy sees what he thinks is evidence of Bigfoot*

*isn't able to handle the cognitive dissonance when everyone tells him why his evidence is faulty*

*joins the ISF forum*

*tries hard to convince himself that all those doubters have it wrong and I'll be famous when I prove it too!*

*Creates thread throwing a tantrum over skeptics wanting actual evidence and blurry videos and photos.*

*keeps shifting the goal posts*

I fixed it to reflect reality.
 
...
Pseudoskepticism is when you deny evidence in order to form your incorrect conclusion. ...

That's not it.
Pseudo-skepticism is when you cloak your existing irrational belief(s) or irrational mindset in skeptically sounding rhetoric.
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom