The Mentality of Skeptics

I'm a wildlife biologist who loves the idea of bigfoot and all manner of other crypto-creatures, e.g. lake monsters, sauropods in the Congo, rumored un-extinct thylacines, etc.

I love the idea of extraterrestrials visiting Earth! It would mean that we're really not alone in the universe, and I would be utterly fascinated to learn about them biologically, technologically, etc.

Ghosts and the spirit world? Of course! I love the idea that there is a spirit realm and that I have the possibility to live on past my biological time on earth. There is an increasing number of dead people with whom I'd love the chance to visit with again.

Like most people OS, I would be greatly pleased to learn that any of these things were real. I have really tried to let myself believe in all of them at different points in my life. I've gone out of my way to try to convince myself that such things exist, OS. But they don't. The evidence for each simply doesn't pass muster. It doesn't matter that I want them to be true - they are real or not regardless of my feelings about them.

So how does my desire for them to be true -and my attempts to convince myself of same - jibe with your cognitive dissonance tripe? You claim that, because I am skeptical of these things, that I am doing the opposite, i.e., that despite the evidence for these things I work to convince myself that they don't exist. You've got it completely backwards, and I hardly think that I am an anomaly among skeptics in this regard.
 
^^^^^^
Well spoken and I admire your willingness to attempt to reason with OS.

But as we've seen from his posts at BFF this is just a game to him. He's not interested in understanding a skeptics postion or trying to educate himself. The discussions are disingenuous and insulting and it's intentional.

It's just one big trolling expedition IMO....but it is fun to call him out on his bull **** and expose him and his BFF buddies for what they are.
 
Last edited:
I also am a deep skeptic and convinced that the things discussed do not exist. I don't go looking for them either, but you'd better believe when I go out on Lake Champlain I have a good camera and a telephoto lens. If a Champ ever appears, I will be the one to get a clear shot and you'd better bet I'll change my tune in a hurry.

I truly do not believe such things exist, and that doubt extends to the fact that I will not waste one minute looking for them. But I'd be happy if they show up.
 
The title is "Mentality of a skeptic" not once in that first post did the word Bigfoot, Sasquatch, ect. come up. He talked about ambiguity and cognitive dissonance and the ability or inability to tolarate ambiguity. Which is basically, cognitive closure. No Bigfoots.

By post 23 the Bigfoot derailing occurs. I got it back on track by pounding on the psychology issues, but the the thread got rejacked by the herd mentality and group think of this forum.

Again, psychology seems to make the majority of people here very uncomfortable.

The guy who posted said topic is clearly Bigfoot-oriented, hence his picture. He's posted threads along this line of thinking before, and likely will do again, he has also now fully taken the tracks and derailed them into yet another obvious thread about Bigfoot.

If you couldn't see that coming, then you obviously gave him too much of a benefit of your doubt. It appears you were reeled in, hook, line, and sinker, and began to give everyone a lesson in how not to apply psychology, which was great. However, you've been applying your contrived and arrogantly incorrect theories on a bunch of people who are likely less psychologically vulnerable than you are. I don't see any lack of comfort in a bunch of people, myself included, who are here to discuss the obvious ignorance and gaming of our resident believer.

Your big failure here, is in thinking that this is about the psychology of people who say nay to giant alien-monkeys. In reality, it's quite clearly a bunch of people taking the proverbial pish out of someone who is obviously playing a silly game. It's gone beyond reasoning, it's gone beyond gaming.

If you want to act like OS began this thread to delve into the psychology of people who don't believe that such places as the suburbs of Chicago are riddled with stealthy, paranoid giants, then more fool you, fella ;) lol.

Yeah, we're all really uncomfortable here. :boggled:

It seems more like you're a little perturbed by scepticism, tbh, bro.
 
Last edited:
The guy who posted said topic is clearly Bigfoot-oriented, hence his picture. He's posted threads along this line of thinking before, and likely will do again, he has also now fully taken the tracks and derailed them into yet another obvious thread about Bigfoot.

If you couldn't see that coming, then you obviously gave him too much of a benefit of your doubt. It appears you were reeled in, hook, line, and sinker, and began to give everyone a lesson in how not to apply psychology, which was great. However, you've been applying your contrived and arrogantly incorrect theories on a bunch of people who are likely less psychologically vulnerable than you are. I don't see any lack of comfort in a bunch of people, myself included, who are here to discuss the obvious ignorance and gaming of our resident believer.

Your big failure here, is in thinking that this is about the psychology of people who say nay to giant alien-monkeys. In reality, it's quite clearly a bunch of people taking the proverbial pish out of someone who is obviously playing a silly game. It's gone beyond reasoning, it's gone beyond gaming.

If you want to act like OS began this thread to delve into the psychology of people who don't believe that such places as the suburbs of Chicago are riddled with stealthy, paranoid giants, then more fool you, fella ;) lol.

Yeah, we're all really uncomfortable here. :boggled:

It seems more like you're a little perturbed by scepticism, tbh, bro.


Shorter thread for OS: [Why can't you just think like I do? *sniffle*]
 
Shorter thread for OS: [Why can't you just think like I do? *sniffle*]

Pretty much, in a nutshell. I fail to grasp how anyone can give any credence to a kid who lies about people, avoids answering posts that they take the time to type, and then copy and pastes those same unanswered posts to his support-group on another forum.

He's clearly here at the ISF to collect brownie-points for being some sort of a cyber-piñata.
 
So how does my desire for them to be true...

The people here are desperate to have an answer that can get rid of their cognitive dissonance. They don't not want Bigfoot to be true, they just don't want to be in the middle where they are uncertain, which is why you'll see some of them switch to the opposite position from time to time. It doesn't surprise me at all that some of you romanticize about knowing that the opposite side is true.
 
The people here are desperate to have an answer that can get rid of their cognitive dissonance. They don't not want Bigfoot to be true, they just don't want to be in the middle where they are uncertain, which is why you'll see some of them switch to the opposite position from time to time. It doesn't surprise me at all that some of you romanticize about knowing that the opposite side is true.

I hope you do not find this offensive, but you seem to be making stuff up out of whole cloth.

I realize I am not one of the angst-ridden "skeptics" against which you rail, but still: might you deign to provide actual examples of the behaviour you appear to have pop-psychologized (to coin a neologism) into being? From here, your persons of straw appear to have sprung from your forehead, fully-formed.

Any chance you might provide actual examples?
 
Last edited:
The people here are desperate to have an answer that can get rid of their cognitive dissonance. They don't not want Bigfoot to be true, they just don't want to be in the middle where they are uncertain, which is why you'll see some of them switch to the opposite position from time to time. It doesn't surprise me at all that some of you romanticize about knowing that the opposite side is true.

Weren't you desperate to have an answer, which is why you made up your mind to 100% believe, without ever seeking actual evidence, without ever seeing one in your entire life?

Interestingly, we've got the exactly logical stance a bunch of people could ever hope to have, having never seen any actual evidence, nor having seen an actual Bigfoot in the history of the world, and having realised just how many proponents are as bent as a Uri Geller spoon.
 
Last edited:
The people here are desperate to have an answer that can get rid of their cognitive dissonance. They don't not want Bigfoot to be true, they just don't want to be in the middle where they are uncertain, which is why you'll see some of them switch to the opposite position from time to time. It doesn't surprise me at all that some of you romanticize about knowing that the opposite side is true.

I'm fine with bigfoot being real should that be the case, I am not fine in credulity which your currently immersed in.

Despite what my forum name might imply, I have a great love for the unknown and the as of yet unexplained. A good example is I regarded The Giant Squid as nothing more than fantasy however thanks to real compounding evidence, Clear unambiguous photos/videos and examinable specimens of the creature I have changed that assumption and fully except I was previously wrong and that the creature indeed exists.
 
The people here are desperate to have an answer that can get rid of their cognitive dissonance. They don't not want Bigfoot to be true, they just don't want to be in the middle where they are uncertain, which is why you'll see some of them switch to the opposite position from time to time. It doesn't surprise me at all that some of you romanticize about knowing that the opposite side is true.

Evidence?
 
Any chance you might provide actual examples?

There's people like Nakani and Crowlogic who have switched from one position to the opposite without ever confronting the fact that they don't know the answer. Some of them haven't switched, but the insecurity of their position can be seen when they react with anger and make personal attacks and accusations. Ask yourself this, why would someone devote all of their free time to trying to debunk just one particular cryptid? There's so much "woo" out there. Why just Bigfoot when it pisses them off so much?

I'm fine with bigfoot being real should that be the case, I am not fine in credulity which your currently immersed in.

Despite what my forum name might imply, I have a great love for the unknown and the as of yet unexplained. A good example is I regarded The Giant Squid as nothing more than fantasy however thanks to real compounding evidence, Clear unambiguous photos/videos and examinable specimens of the creature I have changed that assumption and fully except I was previously wrong and that the creature indeed exists.

The problem is the Sasquatch phenomenon is far more complex than any other cryptid mystery we've had. The giant squid for instance had the advantage of not looking like a person in a suit and physical proof of its existence wasn't being covered up. The DNA wasn't of a known species either. All of this together made its discovery pretty simple.
 
There's people like Nakani and Crowlogic who have switched from one position to the opposite without ever confronting the fact that they don't know the answer. Some of them haven't switched, but the insecurity of their position can be seen when they react with anger and make personal attacks and accusations. Ask yourself this, why would someone devote all of their free time to trying to debunk just one particular cryptid? There's so much "woo" out there. Why just Bigfoot when it pisses them off so much?



The problem is the Sasquatch phenomenon is far more complex than any other cryptid mystery we've had. The giant squid for instance had the advantage of not looking like a person in a suit and physical proof of its existence wasn't being covered up. The DNA wasn't of a known species either. All of this together made its discovery pretty simple.

You still wonder why no one wants to take your claims seriously?

Do tell, Why is there a vast conspiracy to cover up evidence and who is behind it?
 
There's people like Nakani and Crowlogic who have switched from one position to the opposite without ever confronting the fact that they don't know the answer. Some of them haven't switched, but the insecurity of their position can be seen when they react with anger and make personal attacks and accusations. Ask yourself this, why would someone devote all of their free time to trying to debunk just one particular cryptid? There's so much "woo" out there. Why just Bigfoot when it pisses them off so much?



The problem is the Sasquatch phenomenon is far more complex than any other cryptid mystery we've had. The giant squid for instance had the advantage of not looking like a person in a suit and physical proof of its existence wasn't being covered up. The DNA wasn't of a known species either. All of this together made its discovery pretty simple.

OS, when you have to make up lies about people and avoid addressing their posts, only to then copy and paste their posts onto another forum to gain some moral-support, then it tells you a LOT about their confidence in general.

;)

I've got a boxing tournament coming up for charity, all for a good cause, down in London: would you like to be my guest of honour? I doubt it. I'd happily go out Squatching with you, (even though you admittedly don't Squatch,) if you came down and did some real work with me.
 
The problem is the Sasquatch phenomenon is far more complex than any other cryptid mystery we've had.
Not really. It's claimed to be a biological creature inhabiting an explored and exploited finite environment.
The giant squid for instance had the advantage of not looking like a ]person in a suit and physical proof of its existence wasn't being covered up.
What cover-up? By whom? To what extent? Evidence?
The DNA wasn't of a known species either. All of this together made its discovery pretty simple.
A novel primate would have novel DNA. Genetic engineering would be evident in the genome sequencing. It's pretty simple.
 
Not really. It's claimed to be a biological creature inhabiting an explored and exploited finite environment.

What cover-up? By whom? To what extent? Evidence?

A novel primate would have novel DNA. Genetic engineering would be evident in the genome sequencing. It's pretty simple.

Worse still when scientists constructed an Ecological Niche Model for Bigfoot using the areas in question it came back as a very close match for the ENM for The Black bear.

Clearly the evidence is being covered up by the M.I.B. Damn you Will Smith, Let the truth be known!
 
Last edited:
Genetic engineering would be evident in the genome sequencing.

It's not possible to tell the difference between artificial tampering and mutations from the DNA itself. If you think it is, then I would like to see evidence of it.

If it falls within modern human range, then it's going to be considered modern human even if it differs a bit. Everyones DNA differs to a certain extent. A few artificially introduced differences won't make it a new species.
 
Last edited:
How do you know this? Have you conducted experiments and observed repeatable results? Or, are you just guessing?

They look the same and function the same. If you were to create a human with night vision, how will you be able to tell that the gene was introduced artificially and that it wasn't just some lucky random mutation?
 
There's so much "woo" out there. Why just Bigfoot when it pisses them off so much?

I can't speak for anyone else, but for me it's because Bigfoot is so perfectly absurd. You've amply demonstrated the absurd things you need to believe if you believe in bigfoot.

If you say Nyarlahotep dances eternally in the core of the earth to the mad piping of his servitors, I would decline to agree but when pressed I would be forced to concede that the center of the earth is not a national park with a quarter million visitors a year.

I do not believe that the worlds' governments (under orders from the MST3K Information Club, which secretly runs the world) are suppressing information about alien visitors. However, I will agree that aliens are likely to attract significant official attention. I cannot give credence to an international agreement to suppress information about a nine-foot ape.

To believe in Bigfoot, you need to think Bigfoot is too scary to photograph, oh, except that one time. To watch a bigfooter is to watch someone who can effortlessly swallow any absurdity to avoid confronting the obvious fact there is no such animal.

Your attempts at psychoanalyzing people you've never met in a desperate attempt to keep your delusions is no more solid than your understanding of North American fauna. I don't believe anyone here is defensive or frightened except for you.

The rest of us are laughing.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom