The Mentality of Skeptics

From his point of view or ours?

He engages us for a little while then goes to the BFF and harps about how mean and inept we are.

Ours.
From his point of view it's apparently at least interesting to see how long he can drag this out, prattling on endlessly about dictionary definitions and other inane non-arguments that bigfooters always resort to long after they have run out of ammunition to actually argue the creature's existence.

The guy just stated that Leprechaun existence is a matter of opinion. Literally, he just said that.
 
"A skeptic is one who prefers beliefs and conclusions that are reliable and valid to ones that are comforting or convenient . . ."


The preference for reliable conclusions is why one uses skepticism in the first place. It's not saying "a skeptic is one who makes conclusions". Making conclusions has nothing to do with skepticism.
 
Last edited:
"A skeptic is one who prefers beliefs and conclusions that are reliable and valid to ones that are comforting or convenient . . ."


The preference for reliable conclusions is why one uses skepticism in the first place. It's not saying "a skeptic is one who makes conclusions". Making conclusions has nothing to do with skepticism.

And the evidence for BigFoot is still lacking
 
"A skeptic is one who prefers beliefs and conclusions that are reliable and valid to ones that are comforting or convenient . . ."


The preference for reliable conclusions is why one uses skepticism in the first place. It's not saying "a skeptic is one who makes conclusions". Making conclusions has nothing to do with skepticism.


Making conclusions has everything to do with skepticism, which you've been told numerous times.

Are you saying that skeptics never make decisions regarding anything, or are you saying that there are really no true skeptics?
 
"A skeptic is one who prefers beliefs and conclusions that are reliable and valid to ones that are comforting or convenient . . ."


The preference for reliable conclusions is why one uses skepticism in the first place.
No, skepticism is a process by which you weigh evidence in order to make the best possible conclusion.
Dr. Steven Novella said:
A skeptic provisionally proportions acceptance of any claim to valid logic and a fair and thorough assessment of available evidence, and studies the pitfalls of human reason and the mechanisms of deception so as to avoid being deceived by others or themselves. Skepticism values method over any particular conclusion."
As demonstrated above, it's the method by which a skeptic apportions a provisional acceptance (belief/conclusion) of a claim.

It's not saying "a skeptic is one who makes conclusions".
Who said it did? It says that a skeptic may form a conclusion by assessing the evidence.
Making conclusions has nothing to do with skepticism.
Sure it does. An assessment of the evidence allows a judgement/conclusion even if that conclusion is "I dunno." Examining evidence demands such a thing, even if that demand is "better evidence please."
 
Making conclusions has everything to do with skepticism, which you've been told numerous times.

Are you saying that skeptics never make decisions regarding anything, or are you saying that there are really no true skeptics?

It's not logical or practical to be skeptical of everything. Letting of skepticism doesn't mean you're not a skeptic.

Example:

An artist is still considered to be an artist even when they aren't making art.

Similarly, skeptic is still a skeptic even when they aren't practicing skepticism.

How good of a skeptic you are is a matter of opinion.

Resume said:
skepticism is a process by which you weigh evidence in order to make the best possible conclusion.

That's not the definition of it at all. I posted the definition straight from multiple dictionaries, yet you deny it ;)
 
It's not logical or practical to be skeptical of everything. Letting of skepticism doesn't mean you're not a skeptic.

Example:

An artist is still considered to be an artist even when they aren't making art.

Similarly, skeptic is still a skeptic even when they aren't practicing skepticism.

How good of a skeptic you are is a matter of opinion.



That's not the definition of it at all. I posted the definition straight from multiple dictionaries, yet you deny it ;)

 
That's not the definition of it at all. I posted the definition straight from multiple dictionaries, yet you deny it ;)
Argument by dictionary: http://www.logicallyfallacious.com/index.php/logical-fallacies/27-appeal-to-definition
Dictionary meanings are usually concise, and lack the depth found in an encyclopedia; therefore, terms found in dictionaries are often incomplete when it comes to helping people to gain a full understanding of the term.
Your definitions of skepticism are shallow, as I've continually demonstrated both today, and previously. Sort of the way fringe believers abuse the term theory. This is sometimes referred to as a vulgar definition.

Moving forward, skepticism is a process by which claims are evaluated.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Scientific_skepticism
Scientific skeptics attempt to evaluate claims based on verifiability and falsifiability and discourage accepting claims on faith or anecdotal evidence . . .
We evaluate the claim in order to come to some sort of understanding, acceptance or conclusion, however provisional these might be.
 
Last edited:
If someone's conclusion is incorrect, it means the process of skepticism has failed them.

Denialism is when someone believes something isn't true either because the opposite belief being true is too uncomfortable or not knowing the answer is too uncomfortable.

If someone is in denial when it comes to a film being a hoax, it means either the truth about the film being fake is too uncomfortable for them to accept or not knowing the answer is too uncomfortable. Speaking for myself, the idea of BobH being Patty doesn't make me uncomfortable, so if I'm wrong about BobH not being Patty, it would mean that I was misinformed and that I didn't do enough research.
BH already confessed to wearing the costume. He's been a friend of Gimlin since way before the PGF. At this point, how would you possibly learn that the PGF is a hoax - and why is your default that it is authentic?
 
He has a reasonable chance of growing out of this and looking back to laugh. Good!
His belief is bundled as two.

1. Bigfoot exists.
2. Aliens exist and continually visit earth.

He can drop one but not the other if he chooses. Besides that, there could be no "new information" to inform a believer that either of those two is false.

Putting that aside, there is nothing really good (IMO) about a person who suddenly decides that Bigfoot doesn't exist but then doesn't also have a wholesale transformation of their rationality and reasoning processes. We have seen people switch their belief on Bigfoot and then proceed to believe other forms of woo with the same gusto as they previously had for Bigfoot.
 
BH already confessed to wearing the costume. He's been a friend of Gimlin since way before the PGF. At this point, how would you possibly learn that the PGF is a hoax - and why is your default that it is authentic?

The film being authentic was never a default for me. My determination of the PGF's authenticity stems from analysis of the film itself. For me to determine that the PGF is a hoax, I would have to see reliable evidence of a hoax.

Anyone can claim that they were "the man in the suit", but even if they were, they wouldn't be able to prove it. The only thing that they could make a case for is the film subject being a fake, but to do that they would need to demonstrate evidence of a hoax either within the film or outside the film by producing the costume itself.
 
Anyone can claim that they were "the man in the suit", but even if they were, they wouldn't be able to prove it.
Heironimus is the only person who has ever publicly claimed to be the person in the costume. His personal connection to Patterson & Gimlin is strong and he tells the story of how the hoax happened to his recollection. That should matter. That should matter a lot.

You somehow got past two things at the minimum...

1. No confirmatory evidence has ever been produced for Bigfoot.
2. A guy has confessed to wearing the costume in the PGF.
 
We evaluate the claim in order to come to some sort of understanding, acceptance or conclusion, however provisional these might be.

That's exactly the mentality of a pseudoskeptic/debunker. They're desperate to come to a conclusion if a question causes them cognitive dissonance.
 
The film being authentic was never a default for me. My determination of the PGF's authenticity stems from analysis of the film itself. For me to determine that the PGF is a hoax, I would have to see reliable evidence of a hoax.

Anyone can claim that they were "the man in the suit", but even if they were, they wouldn't be able to prove it. The only thing that they could make a case for is the film subject being a fake, but to do that they would need to demonstrate evidence of a hoax either within the film or outside the film by producing the costume itself.

 
That's exactly the mentality of a pseudoskeptic/debunker. They're desperate to come to a conclusion if a question causes them cognitive dissonance.

Let's just can the labels. You hold unjustified beliefs about a big monkey hiding out in North America for thousands of years without leaving any physical evidence.
 
That's exactly the mentality of a pseudoskeptic/debunker. They're desperate to come to a conclusion if a question causes them cognitive dissonance.

Still sounds like a load of this....and repetitive as well!

 
Last edited:
And your user name would be different.
We don't debate the existence of living Tyrannosaurs because there is no confirmatory evidence for that. Yet, we have the same lack of evidence for Bigfoot and still there are these believers hanging out in the fringes.

I frequently use the example of Tyrannosaurus rex because it illustrates the absurdity of believing in nonexistent creatures. Creatures like T-rex and Bigfoot are obviously nonexistent because there is no confirmatory evidence when we absolutely expect that there would be.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom