The Mentality of Skeptics

If someone's conclusion is incorrect, it means the process of skepticism has failed them.

Denialism is when someone believes something isn't true either because the opposite belief being true is too uncomfortable or not knowing the answer is too uncomfortable.

If someone is in denial when it comes to a film being a hoax, it means either the truth about the film being fake is too uncomfortable for them to accept or not knowing the answer is too uncomfortable. Speaking for myself, the idea of BobH being Patty doesn't make me uncomfortable, so if I'm wrong about BobH not being Patty, it would mean that I was misinformed and that I didn't do enough research.

Yeah you might want to have a rethink and do more research about the whole apeman thing. Your skepticism has failed you on the topic.
 
The idea is to get to the truth and to avoid making a wrong conclusion. False evidence is still false evidence, even if you thought it was the best at the time.
Yes, that's why you rely on the best evidence. Science isn't about absolute truths or absolute proofs anyway; there is simply no way to avoid false conclusions, especially when using poor evidence. That is why we call them provisional.


ETA: In regard to the highlighted in your post, best evidence at the time means evidence that has been vetted, reproduced and tested, often generating a consensus. You can plainly see why footie evidence has failed so far.
 
Last edited:
there is simply no way to avoid false conclusions,

There is and it's called skepticism. Being skeptical means you're doubting and being neutral. You can never be wrong for saying "I don't know".

Scientists will inevitably make mistakes and that's because they are human. The process of skepticism fails them from time to time just like everyone else.
 
There is and it's called skepticism. Being skeptical means you're doubting and being neutral. You can never be wrong for saying "I don't know".
Nonsense. Skepticism helps inform your reality, and you make positive decisions based on that information every single day. I don't know is perfectly acceptable as long as you're proceeding on the best information, and not using it as a cop-out.

Scientists will inevitably make mistakes and that's because they are human. The process of skepticism fails them from time to time just like everyone else.
It's not a "failure" when you proceed on the best available evidence. Being "wrong" occassionally often reveals the proper path; it leads to better decision making, innovation, and intellectual integrity.

ETA:BTW, if a person says "I don't know" in regards to bigfoot/bigfoot evidence, that person is not a bigfoot believer by default.
 
Last edited:
Skepticism helps inform your reality, and you make positive decisions based on that information every single day.


Here is the definition:

noun skep·ti·cism \ˈskep-tə-ˌsi-zəm\
: an attitude of doubting the truth of something (such as a claim or statement)
http://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/skepticism

It doesn't inform you of what's true and what isn't. All it does is guarantee that you aren't making the wrong conclusion. By forming a conclusion on something, you have let go of skepticism, but that's not necessarily wrong. For instance, no one here needs to be skeptical of the existence of bears.
 
Here is the definition:


http://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/skepticism

It doesn't inform you of what's true and what isn't. All it does is guarantee that you aren't making the wrong conclusion. By forming a conclusion on something, you have let go of skepticism, but that's not necessarily wrong. For instance, no one here needs to be skeptical of the existence of bears.

Projection is a form of defense in which unwanted feelings are displaced onto another person, where they then appear as a threat from the external world. A common form of projection occurs when an individual, threatened by his own angry feelings, accuses another of harbouring hostile thoughts.

Cheers :thumbsup:
 
Here is the definition


http://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/skepticism

It doesn't inform you of what's true and what isn't. All it does is guarantee that you aren't making the wrong conclusion.
No, it's not about absolute truth but informed decision making. It also guarantees nothing. There are none of those in reality.
By forming a conclusion on something, you have let go of skepticism, but that's not necessarily wrong.
Wrong again. Skepticism informs decisions, allowing provisional conclusions. You skepticism remains.
For instance, no one here needs to be skeptical of the existence of bears.
That all depends now, doesn't it?

The bear in your closet. Atlas Bears, Mexican Grizzlies, etc.
 
Last edited:
Skepticism informs decisions, allowing provisional conclusions.

It does no such thing.

Here is the definition again : "an attitude of doubting the truth of something (such as a claim or statement)"

From another dictionary

adjective
1.
inclined to skepticism; having an attitude of doubt:

2.
doubtful about a particular thing:

3.
showing doubt:

4.
denying or questioning the tenets of a religion:

5.
(initial capital letter) of or relating to Skeptics or Skepticism.

http://dictionary.reference.com/browse/skeptical

Forming conclusions is the complete opposite of skepticism.
 
It does no such thing.
Of course it does. Unless you're doing it wrong, which is certainly within the realm of possibility.
Forming conclusions is the complete opposite of skepticism.
Argument by assertion. Scientific skeptics come to provisional conclusions all the time. How they proceed.


https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Scientific_skepticism

Dr. Steven Novella said:
"A skeptic is one who prefers beliefs and conclusions that are reliable and valid to ones that are comforting or convenient . . .
 
Last edited:
The dude already said he doesn't think leprechauns don't exist.

LEPRECHAUNS!

Is there any point to this whatsoever?

I also said that I don't think they do exist. In other words, I don't have an opinion on leprechauns.

OS, how does one ever determine if something is not true?

A lot of times it's impossible to determine, but in theory it can be determined by the complete absence of any evidence.
 
pterodactyl said:
The dude already said he doesn't think leprechauns don't exist.

LEPRECHAUNS!

Is there any point to this whatsoever?

From his point of view or ours?

He engages us for a little while then goes to the BFF and harps about how mean and inept we are.
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom