The grand NHS shake-up

You should reconsider because that's ideological blindness on your part.

No, it's ideological sense. The tories have always been opposed to the NHS, and have always favoured individuals funding services over society funding them. By allowing the tories to hand control of the NHS over to the market, you allow them to take further steps towards privatising the national healthcare system.

Justification via inertia is not very convincing. And you are wrong, continuation of Labour NHS spending increases (above 6% after inflation) are neither cheaper nor affordable indefinitely.

Costs of healthcare are rising. Labour were planning to meet the rising costs of healthcare with higher funding for healthcare. Would you care to explain how handing the NHS to the market is going to conjure up extra funding? Or does the condem government simply not have to deal with the ageing population?
 
No, not like in America, where the absence of a universal mandate coupled with the market failure of adverse selection completely rips apart the ability of their system to provide viable health care to the population.

The bogeyman that every market-influenced reform of health care "moves us to America" is false and born of ignorance of how health care markets work.

The US costs are twice (!!!) as high as the UK's.
The idea that a lack of a mandate is a significant part of the bloated costs is a really extraordinary claim.

Regarding "market failure of adverse selection", what do you mean?
 
Stating something as a fact does not make it true. Please provide an explanation of how the incentives of a profit motivated provider of healthcare are aligned to the payer(s) for that healthcare or the consumers of it.

The payer wants to pay the minimum amount for healthcare of an appropriate quality and quantity.
The consumer wants to have the appropriate quantity of the best healthcare possible.

The providers want to supply lots of high-profit healthcare (and no loss-making healthcare) irrespective of how appropriate it is.

You're being mighty generous to profit-motivated third party payers there. Caring about "appropriate" quality and quantity isn't even on the motivation table, really.
 
You're being mighty generous to profit-motivated third party payers there. Caring about "appropriate" quality and quantity isn't even on the motivation table, really.

Yeah. I should have made clear I was referring to a benevolent third party, such as the government. Even then interference from powerful special interest groups has to be guarded against.

In the private insurance sector it's only through severe regulation or high levels of competition between the payers (requiring movement of consumers between payers to be easy) that market failure can be mitigated.
 
Going by wiki:
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Market_failure

Market failure is a concept within economic theory wherein the allocation of goods and services by a free market is not efficient. That is, there exists another conceivable outcome where market participants' overall gains from that outcome would outweigh their losses (even if some participants lose under the new arrangement).

I'm not sure essential for-profit health care isn't by nature a de facto market failure compared to nationalized health care.
 
What qualifies as "market failure" in health care?

Well technically market failure is when the overall gains from a market are less than some other allocation of goods and services.

In the case of a market in healthcare, failure could be something like lots of highly profitable healthcare being provided to those who can afford it at the expense of no healthcare being provided to others who need it but can't.

E.g., it might be more efficient to reduce the number of MRI scans and Colonoscopies and increase the coverage of FOB tests to detect bowl cancer.
 
...snip...

I'm not going to do that. I have experienced the state-financed uniiversal systems in France, Spain and Switzerland first hand and my view is the standard of care is higher. Their public spending on health care is about the same as the UK's (OECD data [.xls, sixth table in]). They contract out more of the provision than the UK does. What health systems have you tried?

See above. Can you show that they can't?

Can you show from the bill itself how it will improve the UK health system so that it provides the better standard of care that you are claiming it will do?
 
Just a quick democratic question: Can anyone get a vote on a proposed ammendment to these bills?
 
How do you (MP) get a vote on your ammendment?

At the second reading (the first reading is really just the announcement of the bill, it doesn't usually get debated), any MP can try to put forward a "Reasoned Amendment" which can actually go forward to a vote. After the second reading it goes to committee stage, which is when most of the amendments are put into the bill - but are then voted on only by the committee members. Each day the committee stands, amendments proposed by MPs will be published on a marshalling list and discussed by the committee who can also take advice from experts and suchlike.
 
Last edited:
Not only this they now want to sell the rest of our nations forests to the private sector.

Is there anything these toffee nosed twats wont sell?
 
I fail to see how this backs up your claim that "almost all of the healthcare system is provided by the private sector".
Which wasn't my claim. "Health care is overwhelmingly privately provided" was. GPs are part of the private provision of health care.
 
I haven't finished reading this thread [ . . . ]

How anyone can make the claim that "helping people" as a motivating factor for a Dr does not align with the consumer/patient's motivations is beyond me, but it certainly hurts (colors) any further arguments you present, whether right or wrong.
That's beyond me too. I certainly didn't claim it. Maybe read the thread more carefully (including what you quoted which does not make the claim you allege)
 
Competition doesn't work very well in healthcare markets. Patients tend to be not as well informed as the providers of healthcare and are frequently unwilling or unable to shop around.
Patients are quite able to "shop around" (exercise choice) already but not to a great extent (DH National Patient Choice Survey, England - January 2008), and not to the extent that they want to (Kings Fund Patient Choice survey 2009, updated Dec 2010).

The Labour government substantially increased competition and choice and most people think the NHS improved under Labour (NatCen British Social Attitudes Survey, Dec 2010). Competion works fine in the provision of health care services.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom