The grand NHS shake-up

That they are individuals "contracted" instead of "employed" is an insignificant difference compared to the basic, usual definition of public sector vs private.
If you think there's no difference, then you ought not to have any issue with the UK government contracting out increased amounts of health care supply. And GPs are not contracted individually, their practice--which is effectively a private business--is contracted/paid.

My garbage man could be "contracted" on a day to day or month to month basis via a gov run temp agency, instead of being a literal gov employee, and it wouldn't change the fact that garbage collection in my city is publicly provided.
No it's publicly financed.
 
If you think there's no difference, then you ought not to have any issue with the UK government contracting out increased amounts of health care supply. And GPs are not contracted individually, their practice--which is effectively a private business--is contracted/paid.

<snip>

But critically, in the vast majority of cases the amount of money a GP practice makes at the moment is not directly linked to the medical treatment GPs advise for their patients. Therefore GPs have little to no conflict of interest being advocates for their patients healthcare needs.

Mr. Lansley's reforms will create a conflict of interest for GPs.
 
Adverse selection is a market failure, which means that voluntary actions don't bring about the most efficient outcome. In the case of health insurance, adverse selection arises if insurance enrolment is voluntary, or partly voluntary. It is compulsory in UHC systems and not in the US (the fact that it is paid for collectively by employers for some groups, and by the federal government for military and Medicaid/are prevents a worse failure than if it was completely voluntary. The links I gave are all over this.
I'd say adverse selection can be one of many mechanisms behind market failure. I'm also unconvinced that at present in the US, whatever effects are arising from adverse selection aren't being eclipsed by recissions, etc, leaving other factors to be responsible for the bloated costs in the US.

That's a separate issue (mentioned in the McKinsey report) and you are correct that things (including a lot of healthcare stuff, but not alal of it) are overconsumed if provided free-at-delivery. But that backfires on people when premiums soar afterwards. Hence statutory entitlements are, and should remain, the role of a public regulator. That does not, however, mean that the public sector needs to supply what patients are entitled to on a captive basis.
It's not just about overconsumption; it also involves the innovations that arise under classic market conditions.


IMO Medicare is an illustration that governments can screw this up too. Since Medicare is only relevant to a minority of the population in the US, then it falls prey to special interest lobbies which extract disproportionate gains for that group paid for by the working population.

What extra care are US seniors getting that UK senior aren't? If there's not much different in the health care being delivered to that age group in the US vs the UK, then you need to answer the question of where all the Medicare money is going in the US, and why we can't deliver the same care for the same price as the NHS does.
 
[ . . . ] I'm also unconvinced that at present in the US, whatever effects are arising from adverse selection aren't being eclipsed by recissions, etc, leaving other factors to be responsible for the bloated costs in the US. [ . . . ] What extra care are US seniors getting that UK senior aren't? If there's not much different in the health care being delivered to that age group in the US vs the UK, then you need to answer the question of where all the Medicare money is going in the US, and why we can't deliver the same care for the same price as the NHS does.
Erm, no I don't need to answer that question. You've been given enough information in this thread already, which you either are not bothered about reading (McKinsey elaborates at length about the trajectory of Medicare costs; namely its non-market pricing methods and decades of political give-aways to a clout-wielding part of the voting population) or you don't understand (You seem to think that the rescission problem lowers US health spending. It doesn't; it externalises it to individuals who either go without or end up paying more, or costing taxpayers more via emergency treatment. Your own House Energy/Commerce Subcommitee reported on this at length in 2009).

Again, in both cases, lack of universal mandate and statutory entitlements (for everybody, not a sub-group of taxpayers, many of whom don't pay tax anyway) are a large part of the problem.

On the other hand, you've offered nothing to show why increased market provision of health care services in the UK, paid for by the NHS, would move us to the American model. I shall consider that idea dropped for now :)
 
Last edited:
On the other hand, you've offered nothing to show why increased market provision of health care services in the UK, paid for by the NHS, would move us to the American model. I shall consider that idea dropped for now :)

The claim is not that increased market provision would move us to the american model, its that it would move us closer. Increased choice for patients and a reduction in pay and funds for doctors who can't attract patients will result in doctors making more populist and less practical moves, such as prescribing homeopathy. As big pharma see that popular opinion will have a greater effect on doctors prescriptions, they will press harder with their dirty tactics such as medical ghostwriters, as they realise that the amount of money they spend on this and lobbying will result in greater returns from the british populace.

If the tories decide to add more steps on to this, such as legalising the advertising of prescription medicine to the general public, abolishing NICE (which they have talked about), or increasing the extent to which people must pay for the most expensive treatments themselves, then we see ourselves moving more towards the american model. Without the increased marketisation of the NHS, these steps would be less effective, but combined, they push us closer towards partial coverage.

Furthermore, by the process of richer people travelling further to better funded GPs while the poor and infirm are stuck with whatever is close, we will see a widening gap between quality provided to the rich and poor, again pushing us closer to the american model.

Lastly, by allowing private hospitals to provide NHS patients with the cheapest types of care only while NHS hospitals have to provide everything, the tories and the right wing can strike a propaganda coup by pointing to private hospitals and showing their lower expenses and higher numbers of patients treated, while the factors of more expensive treatments in NHS hospitals will be conveniently ignored. This will convince certain elements of the british public that private healthcare is cheaper and more efficient.

My worry is not that this specific change will take us to the american model alone, but that combined with other changes that fit quite happily into tory doctrine and in some cases appear to already be on the cards, we will eventually get pushed so close to the american model that the tories can strike a finishing blow. I hope that I am wrong and this is just paranoia, or even that if i'm right the more left-wing libdems can curb it before its too late, but combine the above worries with the expense of the transition itself and the lack of evidence of actual gains resulting from the change, and you can probably understand why I oppose these reforms.
 
Why is there such a rush to throw the baby out with the bathwater?

Destroying the NHS will have two main benefits:

1) People can make a lot of money out of the privatisation process.
2) By removing the tax burden the NHS incurs, rich people can pay a lot less tax.

You can't go ahead and just say that though because there'd be an outcry, however if you can push it through on the back of "Gosh isn't the country in a terrible mess, we need to save lots of money by doing this!" then it's A-OK.
 
The reason the rich would have to deep-six NHS wasn't at issue, richard. I was more wondering why reasonable people who stand to lose the most buy into this bill of goods.

There's a phrase I seem to recall; something about history, forgetting and doom
 
It always astonishes me that what previous generations fought so hard to bring forward, myopia within a small timeframe can seem to so easily undo. Why is there such a rush to throw the baby out with the bathwater?

You can usually trust the Lords to hold up sweeping legislation like this. Consider the Parliamentary Voting and Constituencies Bill which is currently in Day 15 of the Committee stage, being filibustered by Labour peers.
 
We presently have a mook on Parliament Hill who'd like nothing better than to rid the country of such 'socialist' trappings as Universal Health Care. And said mook is busy stuffing the Senate with tame senators. So we don't at present can't guarantee that avenue of recourse.
 
The reason the rich would have to deep-six NHS wasn't at issue, richard. I was more wondering why reasonable people who stand to lose the most buy into this bill of goods.

Ah. Well, allow me then to have one last rash sweeping blast of cynical generalising: It's because they take The Mail and The Express and believe what they read.

I now return you to your reasoned arguments ;)
 
Ben Goldacres analysis of the evidence, or lack thereof, for the benefits these changes will bring:
http://www.guardian.co.uk/commentisfree/2011/feb/05/lansley-use-word-evidence

No, no no. That has to be all wrong. At Prime Minister's Questions today the PM himself assured us that since Lansley had been looking at the NHS for so long he was a total expert and knew all about it, and therefore his plans must be the best thing possible. And it's not just the NHS he's an expert on; before he got into power his office was funded by a private healthcare company so he knows all about that side too, although the PM didn't bother to mention that part for some reason.

Odd, that, you'd have thought he'd have dropped it in somewhere. If your Top Medical Man knows it all, you'd want to spell it out, surely?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom