On the other hand, you've offered nothing to show why increased market provision of health care services in the UK, paid for by the NHS,
would move us to the American model. I shall consider that idea dropped for now
The claim is not that increased market provision would move us to the american model, its that it would move us closer. Increased choice for patients and a reduction in pay and funds for doctors who can't attract patients will result in doctors making more populist and less practical moves, such as prescribing homeopathy. As big pharma see that popular opinion will have a greater effect on doctors prescriptions, they will press harder with their dirty tactics such as
medical ghostwriters, as they realise that the amount of money they spend on this and lobbying will result in greater returns from the british populace.
If the tories decide to add more steps on to this, such as legalising the advertising of prescription medicine to the general public, abolishing NICE (which they have talked about), or increasing the extent to which people must pay for the most expensive treatments themselves, then we see ourselves moving more towards the american model. Without the increased marketisation of the NHS, these steps would be less effective, but combined, they push us closer towards partial coverage.
Furthermore, by the process of richer people travelling further to better funded GPs while the poor and infirm are stuck with whatever is close, we will see a widening gap between quality provided to the rich and poor, again pushing us closer to the american model.
Lastly, by allowing private hospitals to provide NHS patients with the cheapest types of care only while NHS hospitals have to provide everything, the tories and the right wing can strike a propaganda coup by pointing to private hospitals and showing their lower expenses and higher numbers of patients treated, while the factors of more expensive treatments in NHS hospitals will be conveniently ignored. This will convince certain elements of the british public that private healthcare is cheaper and more efficient.
My worry is not that this specific change will take us to the american model alone, but that combined with other changes that fit quite happily into tory doctrine and in some cases appear to already be on the cards, we will eventually get pushed so close to the american model that the tories can strike a finishing blow. I hope that I am wrong and this is just paranoia, or even that if i'm right the more left-wing libdems can curb it before its too late, but combine the above worries with the expense of the transition itself and the lack of evidence of actual gains resulting from the change, and you can probably understand why I oppose these reforms.