The grand NHS shake-up

Aren't those dire projections only based on the state of the country as it exists today, I.e. the current tax system?
 
But the debate is too routinely hijacked by less than useful posturing about denying care and profiting etc etc. This thread isn't an exception.

When it is a bunch of millionaire toffs pushing it, from a party who nearly destroyed it before, then one can see why people are a tad worried.
 
But health care and its cost (which is the other side of the same thing) should not and can not be kept separate, other than in imaginary utopias. The UK cannot sustain the rate of cost increase that the Labour government gave to the NHS budget between 2000 and 2009 (and this is true regardless of whether you view that as "correcting prior under-funding" or as expanding the service, or as waste). And Labour would not have been able to sustain it if it had retained power either.

I've never claimed nor suggested that healthcare can be kept seperate from its costs. My opinion is that if costs of healthcare are increasing, we either need to find cheaper ways to care for the elderly, or increase taxation to keep up with the ageing population, or both. I've never seen anything to suggest that the private sector can provide the same healthcare to the same demographic for reduced costs, and see no reason to believe that private healthcare is the solution to an ageing population.

Labour - or anyone - could have funded increasing healthcare costs by reclaiming more of the money spent on bailing out the banks. Considering the uk provided ~£850bn in bailouts to the banks, and the deficit still only ended up at ~£170bn, its quite clear that government overspending on public services is not the issue. The issue is the lack of banking regulations that forced us to pay out hundreds of billions in preventing their collapse.
 
I've never claimed nor suggested that healthcare can be kept seperate from its costs.
Yes you did. If you want profit motivation kept away from health care then you want cost/benefit considerations to be ignored which means you elect to be indifferent about costs. That you don't realise it is your error.

My opinion is that if costs of healthcare are increasing, we either need to find cheaper ways to care for the elderly, or increase taxation to keep up with the ageing population, or both.
Finding cheaper ways involves cost versus benefit motivation which contradicts what you already said. Alternatively, increasing tax does nothing to affect costs.

I've never seen anything to suggest that the private sector can provide the same healthcare to the same demographic for reduced costs
Apparently you are not aware of how much of the health care sector is private (Hint: Almost all of it including GP practices. The government only insures the population and regulates the sector. This is what "universal health system" means).

and see no reason to believe that private healthcare is the solution to an ageing population.
That would fit with your view that cost isn't important perhaps. But more logically, if demand for something can be confidently expected to rise steeply, expanding the supply of it and incentivising cost reduction per unit appears to be a better response. That is, unless you just want to tax for taxation's sake.
 
No universal health insurer can sustain itself; it has to be supported by government compulsion (if that's what you mean)

As far as the ongoing cost of health insurance for a population like the UK, I don't recall seeing any projections that it will do anything other than rise in real terms. That can stil be sustained, but for it to rise almost three times as fast as GDP (which was the 2000-2009 effect, IIRC) it would overwhelm the economy within a generation or two.

IMO the major positive about private provision of med services (which provokes recoil from most people even if they occupy the political centre ground) is to increase the supply of health care services.

Why is that a positive?

We already know that the demand is going to soar. Mushrooming demand with unchanged supply needs to violate commonly accepted economics in order not to result in spiralling costs.

<snip>

Explain how introducing private companies will lower healthcare inflation compared to a state controlled system when (as you stated above) demand constantly outstrips supply?
 
Yes you did. If you want profit motivation kept away from health care then you want cost/benefit considerations to be ignored which means you elect to be indifferent about costs. That you don't realise it is your error.

Profit motivation =/= consideration of cost/benefit.

<snip>

Apparently you are not aware of how much of the health care sector is private (Hint: Almost all of it including GP practices. The government only insures the population and regulates the sector. This is what "universal health system" means).

<snip>

Are PCTs private? How about SHAs?
 
Why is that a positive?
Failure to increase supply if demand increases results in a higher price than otherwise.
Explain how introducing private companies will lower healthcare inflation compared to a state controlled system when (as you stated above) demand constantly outstrips supply?
?? Private companies are already introduced. Costs are already lower (and service better) than if the government actually ran the health care sector IMO.
 
Incorrect.

No Franscesca, you are incorrect and don't understand the terms you are using. There is a significant difference between deciding what treatment to provide based on profit motive and what treatment to provide based on cost benefit analysis.

I can explain it further if you still don't understand what the difference is.

They are buyers and administrators respectively. They don't provide health care services.

Exactly. They have no interest in making a profit from funding or not funding treatment and healthcare services.
 
Yes you did. If you want profit motivation kept away from health care then you want cost/benefit considerations to be ignored which means you elect to be indifferent about costs. That you don't realise it is your error.

Wrong. It is entirely possible to consider the cost of something, without considering the profit. If the healthcare costs of the NHS are ~£100bn a year, and you funnel ~£100bn of taxes into them, you have funded the NHS without involving profit.

Finding cheaper ways involves cost versus benefit motivation which contradicts what you already said. Alternatively, increasing tax does nothing to affect costs.

Increasing taxes does nothing to affect costs, but it provides more money with which to pay those costs. You appear to have determined that any situation where an attempt to determine the cheapest method of doing something can be described by the word "profit". That is not my understanding of the term. I use it to describe the excess money returned from an investment.

Apparently you are not aware of how much of the health care sector is private (Hint: Almost all of it including GP practices. The government only insures the population and regulates the sector. This is what "universal health system" means).

Sure, the entire NHS is a private company owned by glaxosmithkline, whatever.

That would fit with your view that cost isn't important perhaps. But more logically, if demand for something can be confidently expected to rise steeply, expanding the supply of it and incentivising cost reduction per unit appears to be a better response. That is, unless you just want to tax for taxation's sake.

I've never said that cost isn't important, I have said that I do not believe the NHS should be run for profit. The cost is important, and reducing costs should be a priority. But I disagree that in order to determine the cheapest method of doing something, you have to employ people who will themselves profit from discovering these cheaper methods. I would rather see these factors determined by government employees, paid a wage funded by taxes.

I don't want to tax for taxations sake, nor do I accept that that phrase even means anything. I want to tax for the sake of better public services and less inequality.
 
Wrong. It is entirely possible to consider the cost of something, without considering the profit.
But in seeking to minimise costs and maximise profit the same motivation is involved. And it has a beneficial--make that necessary--place in the provision of health care.

If the healthcare costs of the NHS are ~£100bn a year, and you funnel ~£100bn of taxes into them, you have funded the NHS without involving profit.
Not relevant to what you're trying to argue, although this statement appears to be devoid of cost consideration also, other than: "Charge whatever, and just send us the bill".

Increasing taxes does nothing to affect costs, but it provides more money with which to pay those costs.
Correct, so if your only response to a spike in costs is "Raise more tax!", you're going to be rather impotent to prevent costs exploding (unless you impose widespread below-market price controls centrally, which would be likely to merely result in quality degradation instead).

You appear to have determined that any situation where an attempt to determine the cheapest method of doing something can be described by the word "profit". That is not my understanding of the term. I use it to describe the excess money returned from an investment.
I mean revenue minus cost. Even if the profit is zero, when the revenue is fixed, profit motivation is what is applied to bring costs lower and thereby minimise rationing. You might like the budget for the NHS to be higher, but it would then just be fixed at a higher level. What are you going to do then? I am afraid that the numbers simply do not allow you to increase real health spending much more rapidly than national output on a sustained basis, even at a theoretical 99% tax rate.

Sure, the entire NHS is a private company owned by glaxosmithkline, whatever.
The NHS is the state owned provider of health insurance--in other words, the payer and guarantor of payment. That isn't private, nor will it be under any coalition plans. So that's a red herring. Health care, on the other hand, is overwhelmingly privately provided. Few people in the health care business work for the state. You are apparently not aware of this, given your comment that the private sector can't provide the service for reduced costs.

I've never said that cost isn't important, I have said that I do not believe the NHS should be run for profit.
The NHS isn't and probably never will be, as above. Many GP surgeries are already and have been for years.

I disagree that in order to determine the cheapest method of doing something, you have to employ people who will themselves profit from discovering these cheaper methods. I would rather see these factors determined by government employees, paid a wage funded by taxes.
OK but you're at odds with the present system in that case. Not to mention most of the non-government economy.

I don't want to tax for taxations sake, nor do I accept that that phrase even means anything. I want to tax for the sake of better public services and less inequality.
Then I'm not sure why you brought tax up. The discussion was about costs of health care. Your mention of tax seemed to come from a relative disinterest in the cost (because we can, like, just tax banks some more whenever the cost of anything rises) coupled with my impression that you appear to want to find a reason to do that anyway (from the frequency with which it enters your posts in other topics).
 
Last edited:
But in seeking to minimise costs and maximise profit the same motivation is involved. And it has a beneficial--make that necessary--place in the provision of health care.

I disagree.

Not relevant to what you're trying to argue, although this statement appears to be devoid of cost consideration also, other than: "Charge whatever, and just send us the bill".

I am all in favour of the NHS employing people whose job is to find out which forms of healthcare are cheapest and which give the best outcome, and believe that these employees should be charged a wage funded by tax. I do not agree with your apparent belief that the only way to acquire such staff is to tell them that if they find better value healthcare, they will personally profit from much higher wages.

Correct, so if your only response to a spike in costs is "Raise more tax!", you're going to be rather impotent to prevent costs exploding (unless you impose widespread below-market price controls centrally, which would be likely to merely result in quality degradation instead).


That's not my only response at all. I quite clearly stated that the NHS should emply people whose job is to determine the best value healthcare, and frankly i'm not sure why you have ignored this. One of my family friends works for the NHS, and is currently exploring webcam GPs for the elderly, allowing them to talk to their GP by webcam without automatically requiring a house visit or GP surgery visit. He is on a fixed wage, and the process involves no profit beyond what I have described, but it is still a method of reducing costs. As you can see, the two are not mutually exclusive.

I mean revenue minus cost. Even if the profit is zero, when the revenue is fixed, profit motivation is what is applied to bring costs lower and thereby minimise rationing. You might like the budget for the NHS to be higher, but it would then just be fixed at a higher level. What are you going to do then? I am afraid that the numbers simply do not allow you to increase real health spending much more rapidly than national output on a sustained basis, even at a theoretical 99% tax rate.

I disagree that profit motivation is the only way to bring costs down, and have outlined an example of this not being true above. I challenge you to show that privatised healthcare does result in cheaper costs for the same quality of healthcare to the same demographic. It seems to me as though you simply want to transfer payment for healthcare from society to individuals, and expect the free market to come up with magical cost saving solutions.

My view of the result of privatising healthcare is that administrative costs would rise in the form of advertising and other causes outlined in the large thread one subforum down, costs would rise further from fatcats creaming off the top, and the only savings would be made from reduced staff wages and clever clauses allowing private companies to refuse healthcare.

The NHS is the state owned provider of health insurance--in other words, the payer and guarantor of payment. That isn't private, nor will it be under any coalition plans. So that's a red herring. Health care, on the other hand, is overwhelmingly privately provided. Few people in the health care business work for the state. You are apparently not aware of this, given your comment that the private sector can't provide the service for reduced costs.

The money that pays these staff comes from the government, and the government money comes from taxes. If you want to show me that when I walk into the Heath Hospital in cardiff, the nurse or doctor who sees me is somehow being paid by coca-cola, i'm all ears. In my understanding, the staff are paid by the government.

OK but you're at odds with the present system in that case. Not to mention most of the non-government economy.

I should clarify - this is my belief in the areas of healthcare and education, and you have yet to provide any evidence to the contrary. I am all in favour of allowing the consumer goods economy to be run by the private sector, because their experiments to reduce cost such as a drop in t-shirt quality is an acceptable risk. A drop in healthcare quality to save costs is not, and neither is a drop in education quality.

Then I'm not sure why you brought tax up. The discussion was about costs of health care. Your mention of tax seemed to come from a relative disinterest in the cost (because we can, like, just tax banks some more whenever the cost of anything rises) coupled with my impression that you appear to want to find a reason to do that anyway (from the frequency with which it enters your posts in other topics).

I am not disinterested in the cost. The link between taxes which fund the NHS, and the funding of the NHS, should really be obvious. My point is that if healthcare costs are rising, we should attempt to reduce costs using inventive techniques such as the anecdote I gave further up. I do not believe that the free market has magical solutions to rising healthcare costs, nor that the transfer of costs from society to individuals genuinely qualifies as a reduction in costs.
 
Francesca R said:
Wrong. It is entirely possible to consider the cost of something, without considering the profit.
But in seeking to minimise costs and maximise profit the same motivation is involved. And it has a beneficial--make that necessary--place in the provision of health care.

<snip>

No, the motivation is different. The desire to maximise profit is motivated by greed. Lowering costs is motivated by a desire to use resources more efficiently. That the former can be achieved by the latter does not make them the same thing.
 
<snip>

The NHS is the state owned provider of health insurance--in other words, the payer and guarantor of payment. That isn't private, nor will it be under any coalition plans. So that's a red herring. Health care, on the other hand, is overwhelmingly privately provided. Few people in the health care business work for the state. You are apparently not aware of this, given your comment that the private sector can't provide the service for reduced costs.

<snip>

What sources of information you are using?
 
No, the motivation is different. The desire to maximise profit is motivated by greed. Lowering costs is motivated by a desire to use resources more efficiently. That the former can be achieved by the latter does not make them the same thing.
What incentivises the desire to use resources more efficiently?
 
What incentivises the desire to use resources more efficiently?

Quite a few things, some will be from the "objective side" some from the "subjective side" for example from the objective side accurate analysis of costs and identification of inefficiencies and from the subjective side personal ambition.
 
I am all in favour of the NHS employing people whose job is to find out which forms of healthcare are cheapest and which give the best outcome, and believe that these employees should be charged a wage funded by tax. I do not agree with your apparent belief that the only way to acquire such staff is to tell them that if they find better value healthcare, they will personally profit
No-one said it was "the only way". However it is a way that aligns incentives. You're silent on how your alternative does that

It seems to me as though you simply want to transfer payment for healthcare from society to individuals
Nonsense. You have just not spent long enough on this forum to have come across the many posts I have made in health care topics, all of which advocate for universal state provided coverage.

The money that pays these staff comes from the government, and the government money comes from taxes.
That has no bearing on whether they work for state agencies or private profit-seeking concerns
 
for example from the objective side accurate analysis of costs and identification of inefficiencies
In what way is what you describe an incentive?

and from the subjective side personal ambition.
This is nothing to do with policy "aligning incentives" and would likely be present to the same extent with the addition of policy (such as financial) incentives.
 
What incentivises the desire to use resources more efficiently?

Many different motivations exist. With respect to healthcare, the desire to help more people with their medical problems.

<Ivor waits for the usual meaning of the phrase 'profit motive' to be tortured to fit that description.>
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom