The grand NHS shake-up

The problem with the profit motive in the provision of healthcare is that it generally misaligns the incentives of providers from both the payer(s) and consumers.

A profit motivated provider of healthcare will try to maximise the amount they are paid to provide healthcare and minimise the cost of supplying healthcare to consumers. Because of the unique nature of the healthcare market (i.e. information asymmetry, consumers unable to shop around, virtually unlimited demand, etc.), suppliers are in a very strong position to price gouge and supply unnecessary healthcare to maximise profit.
 
The problem with the profit motive in the provision of healthcare is that it generally misaligns the incentives of providers from both the payer(s) and consumers.
The virtue of the profit motive in the provision of health care is that it generally aligns the incentives of the providers with those of the consumers and the payers.

By relying on desire to help medically you are not doing anything to align incentives in any way.
 
No-one said it was "the only way". However it is a way that aligns incentives. You're silent on how your alternative does that

As Ivor says, it is entirely possible for people to be motivated to provide good healthcare on a decent wage, simply because they want to help people. This applies also to cost-cutting in the NHS, as I explained above with an anecdote.

Nonsense. You have just not spent long enough on this forum to have come across the many posts I have made in health care topics, all of which advocate for universal state provided coverage.

Well, good. Perhaps I overestimated the extent to which you were following the shifting libdem doctrine. But the cynic in me says that the aim of the condem government in promoting market values in the NHS is to allow private companies to provide the cheapest, easiest healthcare, force the state to provide the expensive healthcare to the unhealthiest demographic and the elderly, and then attempt to use this to show that the market provides healthcare more cheaply, and abolish the NHS. This is another reason I oppose the reforms.

That has no bearing on whether they work for state agencies or private profit-seeking concerns

Can you show evidence that the majority of healthcare in britain is now provided by private companies?
 
The virtue of the profit motive in the provision of health care is that it generally aligns the incentives of the providers with those of the consumers and the payers.

Like in america, where healthcare providers always seek to provide the cheapest possible healthcare and never overcharge, nobody is ever refused treatment on grounds of profit motive, and absolutely no americans are leaving their illnesses to get worse over time out of fear of costs?
 
Last edited:
Like in america
No, not like in America, where the absence of a universal mandate coupled with the market failure of adverse selection completely rips apart the ability of their system to provide viable health care to the population.

The bogeyman that every market-influenced reform of health care "moves us to America" is false and born of ignorance of how health care markets work.
 
No, not like in America, where the absence of a universal mandate coupled with the market failure of adverse selection completely rips apart the ability of their system to provide viable health care to the population.

The bogeyman that every market-influenced reform of health care "moves us to America" is false and born of ignorance of how health care markets work.

Bogeyman? It's the logical conclusion of handing control of your healthcare system over to the market.

Put it this way - if you could show me that allowing more private control of the market would reduce costs for everyone, would never result in rich people getting better healthcare on the NHS than poor people, and would never result in the dismantling of the NHS in favour of the american system, i'd be far less confrontational. I don't mind private systems where they benefit society equally, rather than the rich more than the poor.

I would still have trouble with the increased private lobbying, sure to result in more power for big pharma over the NHS, and I would still be wary of rising costs through administrative fees, advertising, and price gouging, but I would be happy to have the debate.

Can you show that private companies provide the same healthcare to the same demographic at a cheaper cost?
 
The virtue of the profit motive in the provision of health care is that it generally aligns the incentives of the providers with those of the consumers and the payers.

Stating something as a fact does not make it true. Please provide an explanation of how the incentives of a profit motivated provider of healthcare are aligned to the payer(s) for that healthcare or the consumers of it.

The payer wants to pay the minimum amount for healthcare of an appropriate quality and quantity.

The consumer wants to have the appropriate quantity of the best healthcare possible.

The providers want to supply lots of high-profit healthcare (and no loss-making healthcare) irrespective of how appropriate it is.

In a state funded and run system, the incentives of the payer and consumers are slightly misaligned. But at least the consumers can change the payer if they don't like the healthcare they're getting.

In a profit-driven provider system the incentives of the providers are in total opposition to those of the payer and more misaligned to those of the consumers than in a state run system, where providers are advocates for patients' healthcare needs. In a profit driven system, providers have no incentive to supply the appropriate amount of healthcare if supplying more or less will increase profit.

How do you suggest supplying the right amount of appropriate healthcare results in the maximum remuneration (i.e. greatest incentive) for profit-driven providers?

By relying on desire to help medically you are not doing anything to align incentives in any way.

Incorrect. You are selecting providers of healthcare who are less interested in profit and more interested in helping people.
 
Last edited:
In what way is what you describe an incentive?

You really don't know?



This is nothing to do with policy "aligning incentives" and would likely be present to the same extent with the addition of policy (such as financial) incentives.

First part of your sentence - no idea what you are on about, and the second part is a "so?"
 
Bogeyman? It's the logical conclusion of handing control of your healthcare system over to the market.
Except that is not what it is. Provision is handed over to the market. Statutory entitlements remain. This type of system is the norm in many continental European countries, as well as Japan and New Zealand. Your scaremongering fear that it leads to US style partial provision is indeed a bogeyman.

Put it this way - if you could show me that allowing more private control of the market would reduce costs for everyone, would never result in rich people getting better healthcare on the NHS than poor people, and would never result in the dismantling of the NHS in favour of the american system, i'd be far less confrontational. I don't mind private systems where they benefit society equally, rather than the rich more than the poor.
I'm not going to do that. I have experienced the state-financed uniiversal systems in France, Spain and Switzerland first hand and my view is the standard of care is higher. Their public spending on health care is about the same as the UK's (OECD data [.xls, sixth table in]). They contract out more of the provision than the UK does. What health systems have you tried?

Can you show that private companies provide the same healthcare to the same demographic at a cheaper cost?
See above. Can you show that they can't?
 
Last edited:
Stating something as a fact does not make it true.
Then don't do it, as you did in what I quoted and threw back at you.

The payer wants to pay the minimum amount for healthcare of an appropriate quality and quantity.

The consumer wants to have the appropriate quantity of the best healthcare possible.

The providers want to supply lots of high-profit healthcare (and no loss-making healthcare) irrespective of how appropriate it is.
You missed out the effect of competition. Ignorance or deception? In any case your incentive structure lacks a rather crucial element and is invalid.

In a state funded and run system, the incentives of the payer and consumers are slightly misaligned. But at least the consumers can change the payer if they don't like the healthcare they're getting.
?? The payer is the NHS, and that would be the same under any proposed UK system and is nothing to do with this discussion.

In a profit-driven provider system the incentives of the providers are in total opposition to those of the payer
Incorrect again (and I think you know this). Competition means they can not be.

and more misaligned to those of the consumers than in a state run system, where providers are advocates for patients' healthcare needs.
Rejected, providers are advocates for those needs equally under either approach. If you disagree, show that this is the case.

You are selecting providers of healthcare who are less interested in profit and more interested in helping people.
You are asserting that they are in some way exclusive of each other. You have not shown this to be a valid assumption.
 
Except that is not what it is. Provision is handed over to the market. Statutory entitlements remain. This type of system is the norm in many continental European countries, as well as Japan and New Zealand. Your scaremongering fear that it leads to US style partial provision is indeed a bogeyman.

It doesn't need to lead to partial provision to be a step backwards. Liberal economics promotes a society where individuals only pay for services they themselves use. The end goal of the tory party is going to be a transition to a state where the rich get better healthcare than the poor, and this is a step in that direction.

Basically, if the tories move us a step towards more market control, there is no reason for them to stop there. They will move us incrementally further towards partial provision, and they will reduce regulation on big pharma allowing them to add their weight to the shift in policy. You may argue that the liberals will curb this shift, but given that the liberals appear to have roughly zero influence in this government, I am planning to oppose every shift towards market healthcare that the tories implement.

I'm not going to do that. I have experienced the state-financed uniiversal systems in France, Spain and Switzerland first hand and my view is the standard of care is higher. Their public spending on health care is about the same as the UK's (OECD data [.xls, sixth table in]). They contract out more of the provision than the UK does. What health systems have you tried?

Except of course we have literally no way of knowing whether your experience was typical for the system as a whole.

See above. Can you show that they can't?

I don't need to show that they can't, because your side is the only one that has added expense to it. If neither of us show whether or not our side will result in cheaper or better quality healthcare in the long run, then the only factor left in the debate is the expense of a transition to a new system, and that expense quite clearly promotes my viewpoint as being the better choice.
 
No and I have no idea if that's even true. But more of it is provided by a combination of private companies, self-employed and partnerships than by NHS/PCT employees. (Table 4(1) and Table 6, PDF)

Table 4 shows ~1.6 million public sector workers in the NHS. Table 6 says that there are ~4 million "human health and social workers" employed in britain, and the explanations under the table say that some of those are private workers. I fail to see how this backs up your claim that "almost all of the healthcare system is provided by the private sector".
 
I am planning to oppose every shift towards market healthcare that the tories implement.
You should reconsider because that's ideological blindness on your part.

I don't need to show that they can't, because your side is the only one that has added expense to it.
Justification via inertia is not very convincing. And you are wrong, continuation of Labour NHS spending increases (above 6% after inflation) are neither cheaper nor affordable indefinitely.
 
Last edited:
The virtue of the profit motive in the provision of health care is that it generally aligns the incentives of the providers with those of the consumers and the payers.

By relying on desire to help medically you are not doing anything to align incentives in any way.

I haven't finished reading this thread, I skimmed but didn't see where this was specifically responded to...but I just have to respond right here.


When I go see a Dr as a consumer, I sure as **** want medical help because, let's face it, I don't care how much the Dr profits, I care how my medical problem is resolved.

For instance (personal anecdote), I just had arthroscopic knee surgery. The Dr, if he were profit motivated (as you suggest he should be), could have easily decided on different course of treatment that would not have as easily corrected my problem, but would have increased his profit margins (increased office visits, increased testing, longer/more invasive surgical procedure) and, at the end, left my knee almost just as ********** as it was before we started and encouraged me to have a second surgery or whatever. Because that increases his profit.

A different, but possibly related, problem I have bursitis on the top of my knee cap. The Dr has two options for treatment - a cortisone shot or open knee surgery. Which is more profitable for the doctor? The surgery. Which is better for me, the patient in a medical/cost sense? The cortisone shot, with only the possibility of surgery if the shot doesn't fix it. Me getting better faster decreases his profit because there are less visits/procedures for him to charge me for.



How anyone can make the claim that "helping people" as a motivating factor for a Dr does not align with the consumer/patient's motivations is beyond me, but it certainly hurts (colors) any further arguments you present, whether right or wrong.
 
Francesca R said:
Stating something as a fact does not make it true.
Then don't do it, as you did in what I quoted and threw back at you.

You will note I provided more than the statement you quoted to support my reasoning.

The payer wants to pay the minimum amount for healthcare of an appropriate quality and quantity.

The consumer wants to have the appropriate quantity of the best healthcare possible.

The providers want to supply lots of high-profit healthcare (and no loss-making healthcare) irrespective of how appropriate it is.
You missed out the effect of competition. Ignorance or deception? In any case your incentive structure lacks a rather crucial element and is invalid.

Competition doesn't work very well in healthcare markets. Patients tend to be not as well informed as the providers of healthcare and are frequently unwilling or unable to shop around.

In a state funded and run system, the incentives of the payer and consumers are slightly misaligned. But at least the consumers can change the payer if they don't like the healthcare they're getting.
?? The payer is the NHS, and that would be the same under any proposed UK system and is nothing to do with this discussion.

Try reading the whole sentence. I said 'state funded and run system'. Under the new plans GPs (realistically profit-driven companies) will be replacing PCTs. How are consumers of healthcare supposed to get rid of UnitedHealth et al if they don't like the healthcare they're getting?

In a profit-driven provider system the incentives of the providers are in total opposition to those of the payer
Incorrect again (and I think you know this). Competition means they can not be.

How big and well funded do you think the regulator is going to be? Are you aware EU competition rules will have to be followed by GPs? What impact do you think that will have on quality of healthcare, particularly continuity of care?

and more misaligned to those of the consumers than in a state run system, where providers are advocates for patients' healthcare needs.
Rejected, providers are advocates for those needs equally under either approach. If you disagree, show that this is the case.

Under the proposed reforms GP practices and any private companies they employ to handle the commissioning can increase the amount of profit they make by changing the advice given to patients. Currently GPs are relatively impartial advocates for their patients healthcare needs because the profit they make is mostly independent of the advice they provide.

Example: My private dentist is constantly trying to flog me stuff such as tooth whitening treatment, high fluoride toothpaste and electric tooth brushes.

You are selecting providers of healthcare who are less interested in profit and more interested in helping people.
You are asserting that they are in some way exclusive of each other. You have not shown this to be a valid assumption.

No I'm not. The two don't have to be exclusive for a change in incentives to alter how people behave.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom