The Electric Comet Theory Part IV/SAFIRE

Status
Not open for further replies.
Here is a post from David Talbott that just goes to show how ill-informed the EU high priests are about previous cometary missions;


Okay, hold the presses again. Are the reports reading surface chemistry or the chemistry of the coma?
If there's water ice on the surface, I'll be the first to say that my prediction, along with those of several others, was DEAD WRONG. Our critics would have good cause to celebrate such a miscalculation on our part.

http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showpost.php?p=10359403&postcount=2439

This is 9 years after solid ice grains were blasted out of Tempel 1, and 7-8 years after the papers reporting it were published. And 4 years after this story about the copious ice around Hartley 2 appeared in the sort of press release usually used by the EUists, where scientists express surprise;

https://science.nasa.gov/science-news/science-at-nasa/2010/18nov_cometsnowstorm

"We've never seen anything like this before," says University of Maryland professor Mike A'Hearn, principal investigator of Deep Impact's EPOXI mission. "It really took us by surprise."

Strange how they didn't pick up on this particular scientist being surprised! Accident or design?
 
Last edited:
And this post by a certain Sol88 hasn't stood the test of time particularly well;

Ummm... the shiny stuff is NOT ice!!! And the "shiny" stuff seen at the base of the jets is the EDM we bang on about.

Any clearer, JeanTate??

Mainstream contradicted themselves on this occasion more than once to save face and the snowydirtball paradigm.

And now have gone into lock down mode with the OSIRIS images, Why?


http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showpost.php?p=10406813&postcount=3576

And what did the shiny stuff turn out to be when they looked at it spectroscopically? Ice!
 
Last edited:
So, you are happy to state that 67P has no ambipolar electric field?

Or do you believe 67P has an ambipolar electric field?

Your very cryptic jonesdave116.
 
So, you are happy to state that 67P has no ambipolar electric field?

Or do you believe 67P has an ambipolar electric field?

Your very cryptic jonesdave116.

It may. However, it is irrelevant to the complete failure of your woo. If it had any relevancy, you'd have told us what it was by now. This is just a diversionary tactic to avoid addressing the complete failures, as listed.
 
The purpose of this section is to describe the chemistry-emission coupled model for 67P. We use the spherically symmetric expansion model of Haser [1957] to estimate the number densities ni(r) of the ith parent species at a cometocentric distance r from the nucleus. The water production rate from the surface of 67P near perihelion has been estimated at 4 × 1027 s−1 for July 2015, while the velocity of the escaping volatiles has been measured to be700ms−1 usingthedataoftheCometPressure Sensor, part of the ROSINA experiment. Weconsidertheprimaryvolatile elements detected by the ROSINA/DFMSspectrometer, H2O, CO2,CO, andO2.
Photochemistry of forbidden oxygen lines in the inner comaof67P/Churyumov-Gerasimenko

And there is the biggest error in cometary science, the Haser model used to get Q!

Comets are mostly REFRACTORY
This constraint confirms that comets can be defined as “mineral organices” (Fulle et al. 2016b), i.e. a mixture of minerals and organics with a minor mass fraction of ices mixed among them, and provides a disentangling test for all models describing the (probably common) origin of comets and KBOs.
The Refractory-to-Ice Mass Ratio in Comets

Ice? Not looking good at all for your model, jonesdave116, not good at all.

You are using the incorrect assumptions to promote and outdated model.

The electric wind of Venus: A global and persistent “polar wind”-like ambipolar electric field sufficient for the direct escape of heavy ionospheric ions
Understanding what processes govern atmospheric escape and the loss of planetary water is of paramount importance for understanding how life in the universe can exist. One mechanism thought to be important at all planets is an “ambipolar” electric field that helps ions overcome gravity. We report the discovery and first quantitative extraterrestrial measurements of such a field at the planet Venus. Unexpectedly, despite comparable gravity, we show the field to be five times stronger than in Earth’s similar ionosphere. Contrary to our understanding, Venus would still lose heavy ions (including oxygen and all water-group species) to space, even if there were no stripping by the solar wind. We therefore find that it is possible for planets to lose heavy ions to space entirely through electric forces in their ionospheres and such an “electric wind” must be considered when studying the evolution and potential habitability of any planet in any star system.
applicable at comets if you believe there is an ambipolar electric field in operation at 67P

Do you believe there is an ambipolar electric field at comet 67P, jonesdave116?

Seems the mainstream have a conundrum...Molecular oxygen in comet's atmosphere not created on its surface
Scientists have found that molecular oxygen around comet 67P is not produced on its surface, as some suggested, but may be from its body.

Electrochemistry anyone? Electric fields rule the roost at the rocky cometary nuclei!

This can ideally help setting constraints on roughly what electric field strengths that may be present along the local plasma density gradient and, given an extended data set with statistically significant trends, justify the use of some specific potential profile for calculating ion-neutral collision probabilities and effective ion speeds. However, we have also raised concerns about the fact that our model is based on a time-stationary electric field profile. Such a scenario is unrealistic (if not dissociative recombination is very efficient) as it would cause a build-up of cold electrons incapable of escaping the potential barrier associated with the ambipolar field. This leads us to speculate on a periodically varying potential structure.

The potential drops found at at 1P were huge, to big for someone like tusenfem and his ilk to believe, as H.Laakso found but was poo pooed. Electric Fields and Cold Electrons in the Vicinity of Comet Halley

The dc electric field ex- hibits a large gradient (the total potential drop over the layer is -135 kV),

Now that can do some work!

Comets are an ELECTRICAL DISCHARGE PHENOMENON
 
Last edited:
It may. However, it is irrelevant to the complete failure of your woo. If it had any relevancy, you'd have told us what it was by now. This is just a diversionary tactic to avoid addressing the complete failures, as listed.

It may for you, most definitely does for the electric comet. :D

Which part are you struggling to comprehend, jonesdave116?

The fact that your outdated model is no longer relevant, e.g the massively overestimated water production? The fact that the dust is charged and responding to the ambipolar electric field, polarisation electric field to eventually swept tailward by the solar wind motional electric field, as per...
The three electric field are summarised in the schematic of Figure 7. Above the nucleus (zCSE > 0), Emotional and Eambipolar are essentially aligned. Towards the inner tail region, Eambipolar gives a tailward component to the total field compared to Emotional and eventually along the comet–Sun line, EHall adds up to the tailward acceleration of the cometary ions. Overall, the cometary ion acceleration ends up being mostly radial from the combination of the three terms in the generalised Ohm’s law.

The root of a comet tail - Rosetta ion observations at comet 67P/Churyumov--Gerasimenko

Do you believe there is an ambipolar electric field at comet 67P, jonesdave116?
 
It may. However, it is irrelevant to the complete failure of your woo. If it had any relevancy, you'd have told us what it was by now. This is just a diversionary tactic to avoid addressing the complete failures, as listed.

The diversionary tatic is commonly used by those that refuse to acknowledge an ambipolar electric field is in operation at comets, asteroids, planets, KBO, dwarf planets...and stars.

The Universe is Electric.:D

Comet are just foreign bodies seeking equilibrium with their direct plasma environment.
 
Thanks.


I am very happy to try to answer any questions you have on the topic of this thread, the EC (and SAFIRE)! :)

However, everything I've learned about your version of the EC is from what you have posted here, so I'm not sure what help I could be.

So, back to the EC:

What, other than the Sun's radial electric field, causes ROCK/mostly rock/rock objects, in elliptical orbits around the Sun, to exhibit comet features, such as a coma, and tails?

The strength of the ambipolar and polarisation electric fields, for one.

How’d we go with those questions you were getting back to me on?
 
Last edited:
And there is the biggest error in cometary science, the Haser model used to get Q!

No, it is not, and that is not what MIRO used anyway. I linked to the paper. Try understasnding it, instead of making up crap to try to get out of the failure of your model.
Hundreds of litres per second, whichever model you use. Thousands at Halley. Hundreds of thousands at Hale-Bopp.
 
applicable at comets if you believe there is an ambipolar electric field in operation at 67P

No, it is not. And there is an ambipolar field at asteroids. What is it doing? Your model failed completely. Get over it.
 
Scientists have found that molecular oxygen around comet 67P is not produced on its surface, as some suggested, but may be from its body.

Try to understand what you read.

The new analysis is consistent with team’s original conclusion, that molecular oxygen is most likely primordial.
https://www.imperial.ac.uk/news/187056/molecular-oxygen-comets-atmosphere-created-surface/

Electrochemistry anyone?

Not happening.

Ice? Not looking good at all for your model, jonesdave116, not good at all.

Stop lying. 8 - 18 000 tonnes ejected at Tempel 1. Therby falsifying the idiotic EC woo. It is dead.


Comets are an ELECTRICAL DISCHARGE PHENOMENON

And only an idiot would believe such crap. No discharges detected. Ever.
 
Last edited:
The fact that your outdated model is no longer relevant, e.g the massively overestimated water production?

Stop lying. The water production is not overestimeted. You are lying. It is all you've got left.
 
The diversionary tatic is commonly used by those that refuse to acknowledge an ambipolar electric field is in operation at comets, asteroids, planets, KBO, dwarf planets...and stars.

The Universe is Electric.

Comet are just foreign bodies seeking equilibrium with their direct plasma environment.

Complete and utter crap.
 
The strength of the ambipolar and polarisation electric fields, for one.

How’d we go with those questions you were getting back to me on?

Which are piss weak. What is the surface charge at an asteroid? Or a comet that isn't active? What is it when it is active? Where is all the dust coming from? According to the idiot Thornhill, we are not seeing dust. There isn't any. It is a glow discharge! Lol. Which Rosetta was within for 2 years without detecting it. Your stupid model failed. Get over it.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom