The Electric Comet Theory Part IV/SAFIRE

Status
Not open for further replies.
Not real rock you goose, cometary rock. Special A’Hearn rock.

The stupid here hurts! The thermal inertia is nothing like any sort of rock. Or dust. Read the paper, even if you can't understand it.
although our understanding has been evolving more toward mostly rock,

Referenced by A'Hearn. No rock ever detected at a comet.
 
Last edited:
Wouldn’t really expect you to understand anything more complicated than the dirtysnowball model.

Made special for special people.
 
I’ve shown you the error in your linked paper, you ignore them.

That’s fine., but...

Do you believe in the ambipolar electric field at 67P, jonesdave116?

Yes or no?
 
The stupid here hurts! The thermal inertia is nothing like any sort of rock. Or dust. Read the paper, even if you can't understand it.


Referenced by A'Hearn. No rock ever detected at a comet.

Not real rock, comet rock.
 
Wouldn’t really expect you to understand anything more complicated than the dirtysnowball model.

Made special for special people.

At least I understand the papers I link well enough not to put my foot in my mouth by making dumb claims that are ruled out by the data in those papers. And you don't have a model. No evidence, no mechanisms, no science. Still batting zero.
 
Do you believe in the ambipolar electric field at 67P, jonesdave116?

Yes or no?

It is irrelevant what I believe. Your dumb model has failed 100%. Ambipolar fields are not changing that. 8-18 000 tonnes of ice excavated at Tempel 1. How has an ambipolar field got anything to do with that? You lost. Get over it.
 
You need to have a Bex and a little lay down, jonesdave116.


Others wise Mums going to tell you off.

18k tonnes of”ice” from a mostly rocky come? That’s a good one.
 
You need to have a Bex and a little lay down, jonesdave116.


Others wise Mums going to tell you off.

18k tonnes of”ice” from a mostly rocky come? That’s a good one.

Yes, 8-18 000 tonnes. As observed. And no rock. Crater was way too big. And a shed load of ice around Hartley 2. Entrained, along with dust, in carbon dioxide jets.
 
And the various ways of measuring the gas production rates;

http://blogs.esa.int/rosetta/2016/0...-production-of-water-at-comet-over-two-years/

And;

Evolution of water production of 67P/Churyumov–Gerasimenko: an empirical model and a multi-instrument study
Hansen, K. C. et al.
https://academic.oup.com/mnras/article/462/Suppl_1/S491/2672995

And;

Direct Simulation Monte Carlo modelling of the major species in the coma of comet 67P/Churyumov-Gerasimenko
Fougere, N. et al.
https://academic.oup.com/mnras/article/462/Suppl_1/S156/2633379
 
Yes, 8-18 000 tonnes. As observed. And no rock. Crater was way too big. And a shed load of ice around Hartley 2. Entrained, along with dust, in carbon dioxide jets.

Is the dust charged? :rolleyes:

Was Tempel 1’s ejecta mainly “ice” or “dust”?

What was he ambipolar electric field strength at Hartley 2, Tempel 1, Wild 2, Borrely?

Otherwise your blatherings about shiny stuff is just that irrelevant blatherings.
 
Last edited:
Is the dust charged? :rolleyes:

Was Tempel 1’s ejecta mainly “ice” or “dust”?

What was he ambipolar electric field strength at Hartley 2, Tempel 1, Wild 2, Borrely?

Otherwise your blatherings about shiny stuff is just that irrelevant blatherings.

What the hell is that supposed to mean? The shiny stuff is ice. As proven. The Tempel 1 ejecta includes dust, ice and vapour. I've linked to the Spitzer paper enough times. The ice and vapour killed your woo stone dead. 13 years ago. And what the hell has electric field strength got to do with ice? Try to make sense, just for once.
 
Just to reiterate; ice grains in the impact ejecta at Tempel 1 were detected by three separate observations - by the DI spacecraft itself; by XMM-Newton; and by Spitzer. That killed the EC woo. Ice plays no part in their fantasy. Nor does copious amounts of H2O and other gases. This rubbish was stillborn. No science, no evidence, no mechanisms.
 
And let's also mention the estimates of gas production from previous apparitions of 67P, before Rosetta reached it. These seem to range between 4-7 x 1027 mol/s.
This would have been using the Haser model. The reported rates from different instrument teams, using different models based on in-situ observations, range from ~ 1.4 - 3.5 x 1028 mol/s. Which tells me that the Haser-based estimates of cometary outgassing tend to underestimate the production rate. So, Hale-Bopp? 250 000 l/s? Maybe more. That's a lot of water.
 
And going back to a previous piece of obfuscation from Sol; MIRO measures water vapour. Among other things. It can distinguish different isotopes of H2O. It does not detect OH. Which has a totally different signature. This is the same method used by the Odin satellite, which made numerous definitive detections prior to Thornhill's lies in 2006.
 
Yep, EC rock is very strange stuff! ~75% porous. Weird rock.
Yeah.

And when it sublimates is blasted by EC EDM, it produces ... water! :jaw-dropp

Sometimes produces spectacular comas and tails (ion, dust, ...), sometimes nothing.

Can vanish without a trace (Sol88 can tell you which comet EC ROCK met this fate).

Etc. :p
 
Yeah.

And when it sublimates is blasted by EC EDM, it produces ... water! :jaw-dropp

Sometimes produces spectacular comas and tails (ion, dust, ...), sometimes nothing.

Can vanish without a trace (Sol88 can tell you which comet EC ROCK met this fate).

Etc. :p

Indeed. One has to wonder about the scientific credentials of the authors of the 'Electric Comet' poster. Evidently, one has a bachelor's degree in a physics related subject. Went on to do stuff related to computing. The other has no relevant qualifications. Wrote a bunch of crap about Earth orbiting Saturn.
A bit rubbish, really.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom