The Electric Comet Theory Part IV/SAFIRE

Status
Not open for further replies.
Why the hell do you need my acknowledgement? I have said at least twice before, "let's assume it does exist." So, proceed from there. It may exist at 67P. It may not be permanent. It may not form at all around much more active comets. Ions have the same speed as the neutrals in the cavity at Halley, for instance. It is of no relevance to your failed woo.

So let’s assume it does is about the closet we are going to get to an acknowledgement that an ambipolar electric field is in operation at comet 67P?
 
Indeed. And here is the irony; in 1986 Giotto, and a bunch of other spacecraft, encountered Halley at various cometocentric distances. Giotto got closest, to within ~ 500 km. It encountered a magnetic field-free cavity, as predicted by theory. Within that cavity were only cometary neutrals, and the ions and electrons from those neutrals. Overwhelmingly neutral though. The cavity boundary was located at ~ 4500 km from the nucleus. So, in 1986 we knew not just from theory, but from observation, that the solar wind was not reaching the nucleus at high activity levels.
Some little time previously, the Kuiper Airborne Observatory (a modified Lockheed airplane), had made the first definitive detection of H2O at a comet (Halley). This was in infrared, from the vibrational signatures that could only come from the water molecule. Previous attempts to find it were impossible from the ground, due to the water in our own atmosphere. So the plane got above most of it. This was later confirmed in-situ by one of the two Russian Vega craft that went to Halley.
So, 20 years, and another bunch of definitive detections of H2O around comets later, and the high priests of the Lightning Bolt cult come up with a pile of unscientific woo, including the solar wind creating OH, which dumb scientists were interpreting as a breakdown product of H2O!
The fact that it was definitively H2O, and that the solar wind was definitively not reaching the nucleus, had apparently passed them by. It was a busted flush from the get-go.
Now to the present - and the fact that the interaction of the solar wind with these cometary ions (mostly from water) and electrons, that shouldn't be there according to their woo, may well be creating an ambipolar field at times, is seen by Sol as a win for his failed woo!
Ironic, wouldn't you agree? :)


Do you agree jonesdave116, this how you model the formation of the diamagnetic cavity?
The existence of a diamagnetic cavity could not be proven until the Giotto flyby at comet 1P/Halley in 1986. Neubauer et al. (1986) and Neubauer (1988) presented magnetometer data in which a field-free region was detected at a distance of 4760 km inbound and 3840 km outbound. This distance was greater than expected for a simple balance between magnetic pressure up- stream and dynamic pressure downstream of the boundary. This led Cravens (1987) and Ip & Axford (1987) to the conclusion that the cavity must be sustained by an ion-neutral friction force.

Is this your belief on the formation of cometary diamagnetic cavitys?
 
Do you agree jonesdave116, this how you model the formation of the diamagnetic cavity?

Is this your belief on the formation of cometary diamagnetic cavitys?

I'm not sure what the current thinking is. A while since I read the DC papers. That it exists is indisputable. As the Halley data showed, 20 years before the EC woo that Thornhill wrote. Not to mention AMPTE in 84/85. He should have known the solar wind was not reaching the nucleus. That's what you get when you rely on press releases to do your 'science'. I guess DCs aren't very sexy, and didn't make the headlines back in the day, and therefore the Grand Poobah of The Lightning Bolt Cult failed to notice. Just like he failed to notice thousands of tonnes of ice coming out of Tempel 1. And shed loads of the stuff floating around Hartley 2. Although the latter certainly did make the press. Can't imagine why he didn't report it on Hollowscience! And that the Dunderdolts crew also missed it! Passing strange, no?

EDIT:
It would seem that the current thinking is that it is due to both ion-neutral and electron-neutral collisions;

Structure and dynamics of the umagnetized plasma around comet 67P/CG
Henri, P. et al.
http://adsabs.harvard.edu/abs/2016AGUFM.P43A2095H
 
Last edited:
So, let us venture further into the science-free zone of EU woo! What is the 'bright' coma of a comet? Well, observation tells us that it is sunlight reflected from dust. Easily proven from spectrometry. What does the idiot Thornhill think it is? Strap in, unscientific crap upcoming!

Most of the voltage difference between the comet and the solar plasma
is taken up in a double layer of charge, called a plasma sheath, that sur-
rounds the comet. When the electrical stress is great enough, the sheath
glows and appears as the typical cometary coma and tail. Diffuse electrical
discharges occur in the sheath and at the nucleus, radiating a variety of
frequencies, including x-rays.

Oh God, the stupid here hurts! It isn't reflected sunlight from dust, as proven, but some sort of plasma woo glow! What did this guy qualify in? Idiocy?

http://thunderbolts.info/pdf/ElectricComet.pdf

The problem for these people, apart from being thick, is that they look at a picture and say 'ooh look at the bright jet', and start making up woo based on that. Not realising that those images are contrast adjusted to hell and back, to make these jets show up, mostly. The surface has an incredibly low albedo of ~ 4%. The jets are rarely brighter than that. They are darker than bloody coal!
This is what happens when you listen to unqualified, neo-Velikovskian wooists, with books and DVDs to sell. If you are thicker than they are (which takes some doing!) you will never see through their idiocy.
 
So arguing with someone who’s not even sure how the diamagnetic cavity is formed and maintained, giving me jip about the solar wind not reaching the surface.

We both agree the solar wind is not reaching the the surface. What we are arguing about is the how and why.

Again from the LATEST PAPER...
The presence of a non-negligible ambipolar electric field and limited importance of ion-neutral collisional coupling are further supported by observations in the diamagnetic cavity of comet 67P/Churyumov–Gerasimenko by plasma instruments onboard Rosetta that reveal ion speeds several times higher than the neutral expansion velocity.
On the ion-neutral coupling in cometary comae

Go read it.

It’s the AMBIPOLAR ELECTRIC FIELD doing the work. So how is the ambipolar electric field field formed and sustained?

The third term, the ambipolar electric field Eambipolar , is expected to be significant close to the nucleus. At zero order, this electric field points radially outward from the nucleus. It might be one of the reasons why close to the nucleus the modelled proton trajectories in Figure 7 depart from the observed velocity vectors. Another effect arising from the ambipolar term is a polarisation electric field due to the different motion of the cometary new-born electrons and ions. The gyroradius of the cometary ions can be much larger than the interaction region, itself larger than the cometary electron gyroradius, which induces a charge separation, and in turn a polarisation electric field. This electric field contribution is explored in the analytical work of Nilsson et al. (2018), and results in one additional acceleration of the cometary ions with an anti-sunward component.
The root of a comet tail - Rosetta ion observations at comet 67P/Churyumov--Gerasimenko

Colliding neutrals :o have no part in it.

You lose champ!

The are not enough “neutrals” this was an assumption based on an incorrect model. The Haser model to quests at Q.

Sorry mate, it’s Electric all the way down.

But I ‘spose we will here some sob story that water has been observed. I’m also agreeing with you just not in the tremendous amounts put forth by the Haser model.

It’s a piddly little dribble of h20 and the so called “daughter” products ARE being electrochemical made in the electric field and voltage potential at cometary nuclei.

Evidence of Electrical Activity on Comet 67P: Towards an Electrochemical Framework for Cometary Phenomena
 
So arguing with someone who’s not even sure how the diamagnetic cavity is formed and maintained, giving me jip about the solar wind not reaching the surface.

We both agree the solar wind is not reaching the the surface. What we are arguing about is the how and why.

No, you liar. Not many posts back you were making out that the ambipolar field meant the SW was reaching the nucleus! Quit with the lying. You are too easy to catch out. The idiot Thornhill requires the SW to reach the surface, to combine with the non-existent O- from the non-existent EDM (lol). Fail.

The rest of your post is the usual scientifically illiterate woo we have come to expect. Go away. Get an education.
 
Last edited:
The are not enough “neutrals” this was an assumption based on an incorrect model. The Haser model to quests at Q.

Idiot. There are obviously enough to prevent the solar wind reaching the nucleus. Eh? As measured, as observed. Go peddle your crap somewhere where the average IQ is that of a badger. Try Thunderdolts.
 
No, you liar. Not many posts back you were making out that the ambipolar field meant the SW was reaching the nucleus! Quit with the lying. You are too easy to catch out. The idiot Thornhill requires the SW to reach the surface, to combine with the non-existent O- from the non-existent EDM (lol). Fail.

The rest of your post is the usual scientifically illiterate woo we have come to expect. Go away. Get an education.

Go dig it and show me up. :p

You confabulation of a strawman is hilarious.

The ambipolar electric field is stopping the solar wind.

Put that in your signature line so we don’t keep going over the same ground. :D

It’s all el electric.
 
But I ‘spose we will here some sob story that water has been observed. I’m also agreeing with you just not in the tremendous amounts put forth by the Haser model.

And they are not using that model, you liar. They are using a modified local version of it, you idiot. Impossible with fly-bys, and Earthbound observations, where it gives a good estimate over the whole coma. You are just too thick to understand it. Or anything else, you brainwashed loon.
 
The ambipolar electric field is stopping the solar wind.

Oh Jesus. What an idiot! How the hell is it doing that? Where are the neutrals that produce the water ions that cause the field coming from, you clown? Seriously, go away, get an education.
 
Last edited:
Oh Jesus. What an idiot! How the hell is it doing that? Where are the neutrals that produce the water ions that cause the field coming from, you clown? Seriously, go away, get an education.


Wow, absolutely wow.

You do know what an electric field is and how it effects charged particles?


This is basic primary school stuff old mate, basic.

You don’t really seem to have a grasp on it do you.

Fair dinkum champ you are nearly as bad as rc for confabulation of basic arguments. You are becoming, like Whipple’s Dirtysnowball model, increasingly irrelevant.

Do you believe there is an ambipolar electric field at comet 67P?


Otherwise, do try and catch up. :thumbsup:
 
Last edited:
And they are not using that model, you liar. They are using a modified local version of it, you idiot. Impossible with fly-bys, and Earthbound observations, where it gives a good estimate over the whole coma. You are just too thick to understand it. Or anything else, you brainwashed loon.

You don’t even know what model your supposed to be using....:confused:

How do they guesstimate the the outgassing of cometary “neutrals”.

If you don’t know just say and I can point you to a few papers so you can see the assumptions made and how they are not valid.

Really jonesdave116, you are just a strawman building confabulator. :blush:
 
So, to reiterate, do you believe there is an ambipolar electric field at comet 67P, jonedave116?
 
Wow, absolutely wow.

You do know what an electric field is and how it effects charged particles?


This is basic primary school stuff old mate, basic.

You don’t really seem to have a grasp on it do you.

Fair dinkum champ you are nearly as bad as rc for confabulation of basic arguments. You are becoming, like Whipple’s Dirtysnowball model, increasingly irrelevant.

Do you believe there is an ambipolar electric field at comet 67P?


Otherwise, do try and catch up. :thumbsup:

And another avoidance. Where are the ions and electrons coming from to make Deca's four fluid model? Can't answer, can you? Because it falsifies your woo.
 
If you don’t know just say and I can point you to a few papers so you can see the assumptions made and how they are not valid.

No you can't, due to being scientifically illiterate.
 
So, to reiterate, do you believe there is an ambipolar electric field at comet 67P, jonedave116?

Possibly, but possibly not at Halley. Either way, its existence is another strike against your already failed woo. Want to address those failures? Want me to list them again?
 
Really jonesdave116, you are just a strawman building confabulator.

Really? So what strawmen are these? The density of the comet? The ice excavated at Tempel 1? The vapour seen in the coma? The total lack of any discharge woo? The impossibility of the idiot Thornhill's method of making OH? His lies about water not being detected? Etc. Do specify.
 
If you don’t know just say and I can point you to a few papers so you can see the assumptions made and how they are not valid.

The very existence of neutrals falsifies your model. Particularly in the quantities detected. You lose again.

3-D Retrieval of Global Outgassing Rate for Comet 67P/Churyumov-Gerasimenko from Microwave Instrument on the Rosetta Orbiter (MIRO) Spectroscopic Data
von Allmen, P. & Seungwon, L.
http://adsabs.harvard.edu/abs/2017EGUGA..1911583V

Spatially resolved evolution of the local H2O production rates of comet 67P/Churyumov-Gerasimenko from the MIRO instrument on Rosetta
Marshall, D. W. et al.
https://www.aanda.org/articles/aa/pdf/2017/07/aa30502-17.pdf
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom