The Electric Comet Theory Part IV/SAFIRE

Status
Not open for further replies.
Which part of this was difficult to understand?

The bit where you can not comprehend that the mysterious ambipolar electric field is stopping the solar wind. charged particle flow.

But there is an electric field still along with strong localised surface electric fields.

The dust is charged.

You still seem a little bamboozeled.

Do you believe there is an ambipolar electric field at comet 67P, jonesdave116?
 
Last edited:
The bit where you can not comprehend that the mysterious ambipolar electric field is stopping the solar wind.

No, it bloody is not. Learn to read. Mass loading and deflection due to pick-up of cometary ions and electrons. It is plain as day in the paper. First you say the solar wind is hitting the nucleus due to some idiocy to do with an ambipolar field, now you have turned 180 degrees and are saying the field is stopping the solar wind! You haven't got a clue about any of this, have you? (rhetorical).

But there is an electric field still along with strong localised surface electric fields.

And is doing nothing relevant to your failed woo.

The dust is charged.

Just as it is at asteroids.

You still seem a little bamboozeled.

Errr, no. I haven't just flipped 180 degrees in the space of a couple of posts!

Do you believe there is an ambipolar electric field at comet 67P, jonesdave116?

Irrelevant. No solar wind = no water in la-la land. No water means no neutrals. Means no ions and electrons to cause the field. You lose again.
 
No 180 dude, you’re shadow boxing with your own strawman.

The solar wind is not being held back by collision with neutrals, only a complete duffer would think that.

Do you believe there is an ambipolar electric field at comet 67P, jonesdave116?

Do you know how it’s formed?

You do realise that the ions a decoupled from the mthe neutrals at the surface, by
In the absence of a magnetic field, the most plausible reason for ion acceleration would be the presence of an ambipolar electric field, set up to maintain charge quasi-neutrality in the presence of an electron pressure gradient

limited importance of ion-neutral collisional coupling are further supported by observations in the diamagnetic cavity of comet 67P/Churyumov–Gerasimenko by plasma instruments onboard Rosetta that reveal ion speeds several times higher than the neutral expansion velocity.

Mass loading is a crock.
 
No 180 dude, you’re shadow boxing with your own strawman.

The solar wind is not being held back by collision with neutrals, only a complete duffer would think that.

According to you, just a few posts back, the solar wind was hitting the surface! That is a 180. And it is not being held back by neutrals. Only an idiot would think that is the reason. It is mass loaded by cometary ions. Which come from cometary neutrals. The more outgassing, the more mass-loading, the greater the deflection. There are tonnes of papers on it. Go read some.


Do you believe there is an ambipolar electric field at comet 67P, jonesdave116?

Irrelevant.

Mass loading is a crock.

Really? Says who? Show me the paper.
 
This underscores that by neglecting the ambipolar electric field the ion-neutral decoupling distance may be severely overestimated.

As jonesdave116 actually does, says it’s irrelevant. :)
 
limited importance of ion-neutral collisional coupling are further supported by observations in the diamagnetic cavity of comet 67P/Churyumov–Gerasimenko by plasma instruments onboard Rosetta that reveal ion speeds several times higher than the neutral expansion velocity.

What the hell has that got to do with mass-loading of the solar wind? Those are cometary ions heading out. From whence they will eventually contribute more mass-loading to the solar wind. This stuff really is beyond you, isn't it? (rhetorical).
 
According to you, just a few posts back, the solar wind was hitting the surface! That is a 180. And it is not being held back by neutrals. Only an idiot would think that is the reason. It is mass loaded by cometary ions. Which come from cometary neutrals. The more outgassing, the more mass-loading, the greater the deflection. There are tonnes of papers on it. Go read some.




Irrelevant.



Really? Says who? Show me the paper.


None of those papers are relevant. None mention any electric fields or indeed the charge dust (the electron carriers) so they are completely useless. :D

No solar wind hitting the nucleus, jonesdave116

Did you not see the embarrassmed emoji? They don’t have are sarcastic emoji.

We both agree THE SOALR WIND IS NOWHERE NEAR THE NUCLEUS.

Where we do differ is the mechanism doing the work.

It’s the ambipolar electric field doing the stopping of the charged particles (solar wind) and the accelerating of the ions. It is also accelerating the dust from in colimated jets.
 
Last edited:
None of those papers are relevant. None mention any electric fields or indeed the charge dust (the electron carriers) so they are completely useless. :D

No, they are not useless. You are. The convective electric field is mentioned, and charged dust has been known about for decades. It is irrelevant to the mass loading.

No solar wind hitting the nucleus, jonesdave116

What the hell are you on about now? I have told you all along that the solar wind is not hitting the surface for long periods. It falsifies your woo.
 
Again- what the hell relevance is that to anything? These are cometary ions, decoupling from cometary neutrals. Heading out. It wasn't seen at Halley.


At the surface not some distance from it. You’ve used an incorrect and incomplete model, again :o

Still on The Dirtysnowball side, you are jonesdave116. :D
 
At the surface not some distance from it. You’ve used an incorrect and incomplete model, again :o

Still on The Dirtysnowball side, you are jonesdave116. :D

It is not at the surface. Stop lying. What the hell do you think exobase means? And what bloody relevance is it?
 
No, they are not useless. You are. The convective electric field is mentioned, and charged dust has been known about for decades. It is irrelevant to the mass loading.



What the hell are you on about now? I have told you all along that the solar wind is not hitting the surface for long periods. It falsifies your woo.

Not the convective electric field the ambipolar electric field!

:D

Do actually know anything about plasma physics and electrical engineering?

Or you’re more of a dark matter, black hole, impact sorta of loser, totally incompetent and unable to contend with reality?

Seems like it.
 
It is not at the surface. Stop lying. What the hell do you think exobase means? And what bloody relevance is it?

Exobase from the overestimation from using the outdated Haser model of cometary “outgassing” production rate.

There is a piddle amount of water released from the ionisation of hydrated cometary rock.

You do know asteroids have more water than comets? :jaw-dropp


Or did you let that one slip thru to the keeper?

Do try and keep up and stop lagging in the past.
 
Not the convective electric field the ambipolar electric field!

:D

Do actually know anything about plasma physics and electrical engineering?

Or you’re more of a dark matter, black hole, impact sorta of loser, totally incompetent and unable to contend with reality?

Seems like it.

The ambipolar field has nothing to do with mass-loading. Electrical engineering has nothing to do with plasma astrophysics. And you know squat about plasma physics. Nor does anybody else in your cult. Hence the complete failure of your model.
 
Exobase from the overestimation from using the outdated Haser model of cometary “outgassing” production rate.

There is a piddle amount of water released from the ionisation of hydrated cometary rock.

You do know asteroids have more water than comets? :jaw-dropp


Or did you let that one slip thru to the keeper?

Do try and keep up and stop lagging in the past.

Stop lying. The Haser model is not used in the later 67P estimates. And there is ~ 600 l/s. And you cannot get water out of hydrated minerals at the temperatures experienced by the comet. Stop making up unscientific crap. And the water was not supposed to be there in your failed woo. It was OH. And that cannot be formed by the idiot Thornhill's nonsense for various reasons, including the solar wind getting nowhere near the nucleus.
 
Last edited:
Perhaps you can help, do you believe that there is an ambipolar electric field at comet 67P, steenkh?

Honestly, I don't know. If one has been measured, I can believe it.

As far as I can gather here, it cannot support EC (even though electric fields figure in both), so I agree that it does not seem relevant here. Perhaps you could explain the possible relevance?
 
Not sure how we can proceed steenkh when jonesdave116 refuse to acknowledge there is an ambipolar electric field at comet 67P?

Even you are not stubborn enough to sit there with egg on your face.
 
Not sure how we can proceed steenkh when jonesdave116 refuse to acknowledge there is an ambipolar electric field at comet 67P?

Even you are not stubborn enough to sit there with egg on your face.

Why the hell do you need my acknowledgement? I have said at least twice before, "let's assume it does exist." So, proceed from there. It may exist at 67P. It may not be permanent. It may not form at all around much more active comets. Ions have the same speed as the neutrals in the cavity at Halley, for instance. It is of no relevance to your failed woo.
 
Honestly, I don't know. If one has been measured, I can believe it.

As far as I can gather here, it cannot support EC (even though electric fields figure in both), so I agree that it does not seem relevant here. Perhaps you could explain the possible relevance?

Indeed. And here is the irony; in 1986 Giotto, and a bunch of other spacecraft, encountered Halley at various cometocentric distances. Giotto got closest, to within ~ 500 km. It encountered a magnetic field-free cavity, as predicted by theory. Within that cavity were only cometary neutrals, and the ions and electrons from those neutrals. Overwhelmingly neutral though. The cavity boundary was located at ~ 4500 km from the nucleus. So, in 1986 we knew not just from theory, but from observation, that the solar wind was not reaching the nucleus at high activity levels.
Some little time previously, the Kuiper Airborne Observatory (a modified Lockheed airplane), had made the first definitive detection of H2O at a comet (Halley). This was in infrared, from the vibrational signatures that could only come from the water molecule. Previous attempts to find it were impossible from the ground, due to the water in our own atmosphere. So the plane got above most of it. This was later confirmed in-situ by one of the two Russian Vega craft that went to Halley.
So, 20 years, and another bunch of definitive detections of H2O around comets later, and the high priests of the Lightning Bolt cult come up with a pile of unscientific woo, including the solar wind creating OH, which dumb scientists were interpreting as a breakdown product of H2O!
The fact that it was definitively H2O, and that the solar wind was definitively not reaching the nucleus, had apparently passed them by. It was a busted flush from the get-go.
Now to the present - and the fact that the interaction of the solar wind with these cometary ions (mostly from water) and electrons, that shouldn't be there according to their woo, may well be creating an ambipolar field at times, is seen by Sol as a win for his failed woo!
Ironic, wouldn't you agree? :)
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom