Honestly, I don't know. If one has been measured, I can believe it.
As far as I can gather here, it cannot support EC (even though electric fields figure in both), so I agree that it does not seem relevant here. Perhaps you could explain the possible relevance?
Indeed. And here is the irony; in 1986 Giotto, and a bunch of other spacecraft, encountered Halley at various cometocentric distances. Giotto got closest, to within ~ 500 km. It encountered a magnetic field-free cavity, as predicted by theory. Within that cavity were only cometary neutrals, and the ions and electrons from those neutrals. Overwhelmingly neutral though. The cavity boundary was located at ~ 4500 km from the nucleus. So, in 1986 we knew not just from theory, but from observation, that the solar wind was not reaching the nucleus at high activity levels.
Some little time previously, the Kuiper Airborne Observatory (a modified Lockheed airplane), had made the first definitive detection of H
2O at a comet (Halley). This was in infrared, from the vibrational signatures that could only come from the water molecule. Previous attempts to find it were impossible from the ground, due to the water in our own atmosphere. So the plane got above most of it. This was later confirmed in-situ by one of the two Russian Vega craft that went to Halley.
So, 20 years, and another bunch of definitive detections of H
2O around comets later, and the high priests of the Lightning Bolt cult come up with a pile of unscientific woo, including the solar wind creating OH, which dumb scientists were interpreting as a breakdown product of H
2O!
The fact that it was definitively H
2O, and that the solar wind was definitively not reaching the nucleus, had apparently passed them by. It was a busted flush from the get-go.
Now to the present - and the fact that the interaction of the solar wind with these cometary ions (mostly from water) and electrons, that shouldn't be there according to their woo, may well be creating an ambipolar field at times, is seen by Sol as a win for his failed woo!
Ironic, wouldn't you agree?
