The Electric Comet Theory Part IV/SAFIRE

Status
Not open for further replies.
Dude ice is every where except in your comets!

See The Nucleus of comet 67P/Churyumov–Gerasimenko – Part I: The global view – nucleus mass, mass-loss, porosity, and implications

Ice in the make up of cometary nuclei is insignificant, as stated by A’Hearn.

Lol. The tosser Thornhill invoked impossible woo to do away with ice. We see ice. We see the volatiles sublimated from this ice. He lied. Get it through your thick head. You were conned. He is a liar.
 
No ice on the surface, no ice in the coma, where is the ice jd116?

The electric comet only needs water vapour to spontaneously form ice

Question is where does the water vapour come from?

Hydrated minerals, same as asteroids
 
Last edited:
Lie. Nowhere near as hard as rock. Quit with the lies, woo boy.

Did you not invoke a sintered ice layer? Because you know comets are mostly vacuum. :D

MUPUS could not penetrate the layer it encountered.
 
Last edited:
Let’s dig out some more old papers...

The most important result of this study is that the nucleus surface footprints of the dust particle trajectories that could populate the jet are concentrated outside of the maximum gas production area, which is located close to the terminator line, as suggested by Fougere et al. (2016). The locations of these footprints are shown in Fig. 7. This suggests that there is no simple proportionality relation between gas and dust production rates, which raises the question of the nature of the dust-release mechanism that produces jets in a region outside of the area with the highest gas production rate. The inferred footprint location area is consistent with that of the active pits in the Seth region, as determined by Vincent et al. (2015).

Sublimation questioned was back then...:rolleyes:

There is however a falsifiable theory that jonesy chooses to remain ignorant about.

This was suggested by W.Thornhill before the comet Tempel 1 encounter.

Jonesdave116 ignores the effect of the non negligible electric field effects in play at comets, asteroids, planets and suns and chooses to remain in the gas light era physics.


Sol88 also has a large collection of papers that raise serious concerns on the standard 1950’s Whipple’s model as comets as mostly ice.

Is a war of how many papers provide evidence for the standard model of comets or the electrical nature of comets a scientific method?

Tusenfem was a goose who liked to play games whilst he confirmed the dominant electric nature of comets....

Expect to see he’s next paper saying this
 
Last edited by a moderator:
It is interesting that the submicron particle flux coming from the solar direction exceeds that from the direction to the comet's nucleus by a factor of 3 (Della Corte et al. 2015). It suggests that charging, and the Lorentz force, may have a significant effect on dust particle dynamics, which can be especially important for small particles.

Analysis of the dust jet imaged by Rosetta VIRTIS-M in the coma of comet 67P/Churyumov–Gerasimenko on 2015 April 12

They then go on to completely ignore that the dust is charaged in their assumption and calculations...why?

Interesting for sure, except for jonesy the inquisitor!
 
Found a paper right up jonesy, defender of the mainstream model of comets will cream his pants over!

Comet 67P/Churyumov-Gerasimenko rotation changes derived from sublimation induced torques.


ABSTRACT
Context. The change of the rotation period and the orientation of the rotation axis of comet 67P/Churyumov-Gerasimenko (67P/C- G) is deducible from images taken by the scientific imaging instruments on-board the Rosetta mission with high precision. Non gravitational forces are a natural explanation for these data.
Aims. We describe observed changes for the orientation of the rotation axis and the rotation period of 67P/C-G. For these changes we give an explanation based on a sublimation model with a best-fit for the surface active fraction (model P). Torque effects of periodically changing gas emissions on the surface are considered.
Methods. We solve the equation of state for the angular momentum in the inertial and the body-fixed frames and provide an analytic theory of the rotation changes in terms of Fourier coefficients, generally applicable to periodically forced rigid body dynamics. Results. The torque induced changes of the rotation state constrain the physical properties of the surface, the sublimation rate and the local active fraction of the surface.
Conclusions. We determine a distribution of the local surface active fraction in agreement with the rotation properties, period and orientation, of 67P/C-G. The torque movement confirms that the sublimation increases faster than the insolation towards perihelion. The derived relatively uniform activity pattern is discussed in terms of related surface features.

Ice everywhere, jonesy, everywhere.

Shhhhhh...don’t tell them the dust is charged....shhhh
 
Last edited:
Do not forget that it has never been shown, nor suggested (iirc), that electrostatic charging can lift sub-micron sized grains. The experiments that have been done are on particles of the order of tens of microns.


Some mainstream scientists are

Other interesting observations concern electrically charged nanograins in the inner coma, indicating a possible connection between dust at the surface of the nucleus and the comet’s plasma environment [53]. Aeolian ripples (figure 20) on the surface of the nucleus of 67P/Churyumov–Gerasimenko [54] may be another hint of a pronounced impact of the plasma environment on the nucleus morphology. The ripples observed exhibit a wavelength of about 10 m, which is comparable to the wavelength of ion acoustic waves in that environment [55]. Such ‘plasmaeolian’ structures would demonstrate the importance of a deeper understanding of the cometary plasma environment, if the conjectured relation can be confirmed.

Interaction of the solar wind with comets: a Rosetta perspective
Karl-Heinz Glassmeier
 
No ice on the surface, no ice in the coma, where is the ice jd116?

The electric comet only needs water vapour to spontaneously form ice

Question is where does the water vapour come from?

Hydrated minerals, same as asteroids

Will you quit lying? What the hell is the matter with you? Is your faith that engrained? There is ice on the surface. There is ice in the coma. There is ice beneath the surface. I have provided links to those detections umpteen times, and I am getting sick to death of your idiocy. Go away. You lost. Get over it, you sad person.
 
Did you not invoke a sintered ice layer? Because you know comets are mostly vacuum. :D

MUPUS could not penetrate the layer it encountered.

And I have provided links to show that the strength of that layer is nowhere near that of rock. Just quit the lying, you sad person. Get help.
 
Let’s dig out some more old papers...



Sublimation questioned was back then...:rolleyes:

There is however a falsifiable theory that jonesy chooses to remain ignorant about.

This was suggested by W.Thornhill before the comet Tempel 1 encounter.

Jonesdumb ignores the effect of the non negligible electric field effects in play at comets, asteroids, planets and suns and chooses to remain in the gas light era physics.


Sol88 also has a large collection of papers that raise serious concerns on the standard 1950’s Whipple’s model as comets as mostly ice.

Is a war of how many papers provide evidence for the standard model of comets or the electrical nature of comets a scientific method?

Tusenfem was a goose who liked to play games whilst he confirmed the dominant electric nature of comets....

Expect to see he’s next paper saying this

Complete crap. No evidence, no mechanism, no science. Just word salad. Not a single scientist supports your idiotic crap. Go away.
 
Found a paper right up jonesy, defender of the mainstream model of comets will cream his pants over!

Comet 67P/Churyumov-Gerasimenko rotation changes derived from sublimation induced torques.




Ice everywhere, jonesy, everywhere.

Shhhhhh...don’t tell them the dust is charged....shhhh

And the dust is charged at asteroids, you idiot. Why aren't asteroids outgassing? Go away, you are boring, and talking crap. As usual. Get an education.
 
Some mainstream scientists are



Interaction of the solar wind with comets: a Rosetta perspective
Karl-Heinz Glassmeier

Nothing to do with the failed EC woo. The plasma is not reaching the surface for long periods. Fail.
 
Nothing to do with the failed EC woo. The plasma is not reaching the surface for long periods. Fail.

And there it is folks, jonesy going down the river de Nile.


Other interesting concern electrically charged nanograins in the inner coma, indicating a possible connection between dust at the surface of the nucleus and the comet’s plasma environment [53]. Aeolian ripples (figure 20) on the surface of the nucleus of 67P/Churyumov–Gerasimenko [54] may be another hint of a pronounced impact of the plasma environment on the nucleus morphology. The ripples observed exhibit a wavelength of about 10 m, which is comparable to the wavelength of ion acoustic waves in that environment [55]. Such ‘plasmaeolian’ structures would demonstrate the importance of a deeper understanding of the cometary plasma environment, if the conjectured relation can be confirmed.

Interaction of the solar wind with comets: a Rosetta perspective


Poor jonesy. That’s pure electric comet woo right there.
 
Last edited:
And there it is folks, jonesy going down the river de Nile.




Interaction of the solar wind with comets: a Rosetta perspective


Poor jonesy. That’s pure electric comet woo right there.


No, it has nothing to do with the electric comet woo. There is no dust on the surface in the EC woo. Plasma reaching the surface at times of low activity is nothing to do with the EC woo. The same thing happens at asteroids. Permanently. They are not outgassing. How many times do you need the same things explained to you? Just quit this idiocy. No evidence, no mechanisms, no science. No point.
 
No, it has nothing to do with the electric comet woo. There is no dust on the surface in the EC woo. Plasma reaching the surface at times of low activity is nothing to do with the EC woo. The same thing happens at asteroids. Permanently. They are not outgassing. How many times do you need the same things explained to you? Just quit this idiocy. No evidence, no mechanisms, no science. No point.

No Wal said comets would be electrostaticly cleaned I.e there is dust being electrostaticly removed from the surface in jets...

And when pointed to the same mechanism happening on dwarf planet, your tactic is to ignore contradictory information.


Moot point anyway, the dust is charged, there are Birkeland currents and electric fields( double layers.

Comets are an electrical discharge phenomena... cheers Wal :thumbsup:

Sublimation...:blush:


Not a viable mechanism jd116, you lose.

Charged dust eats sublimation for breakfast.
 
Last edited:
Wal said comets would be electrostaticly cleaned I.e there is dust being electrostaticly removed from the surface in jets...

No, he did not say that, you liar. He said;


• The primary distinction between comet and asteroid surfaces is that electrical
arcing and “electrostatic cleaning” of the comet nucleus will leave little or no
dust or debris on the surface during the active phase, even if a shallow layer
of dust may be attracted back to the nucleus electrostatically as the comet
becomes dormant in its retreat to more remote regions.

And the idiot was wrong, wasn't he? Not surprising from a scientifically illiterate Velikovskian.
So, the idiot is saying that there will be no dust in the most active phase. Fail. There is more dust in the coma at active times than at lower activity times. And the idiot also said;

• The observed jets of comets are electric arc discharges to the nucleus, pro-
ducing “electrical discharge machining” (EDM) of the surface. The exca-
vated material is accelerated into space along the jets’ observed filamentary
arcs.

EDM! Lol. What a loon! So, where is this EDM in the mag data?




And when pointed to the same mechanism happening on dwarf planet, your tactic is to ignore contradictory information.

I ignored it because it is irrelevant.

Moot point anyway, the dust is charged, there are Birkeland currents and electric fields( double layers.

The dust on a bloody asteroid is charged! What the hell is wrong with you? And there are no Birkeland currents, and no double layers, that is just more lying from someone who has lying as his main tactic to deal with the complete failure of his idiotic belief system.

Sublimation...


Not a viable mechanism jd116, you lose.

Charged dust eats sublimation for breakfast.

Yes it is a viable mechanism, as observed. And you don't have one. Fail. And I keep explaining to the hard of thinking, that asteroid dust is charged. Nothing is happening of any note. You fail again.
 
Last edited:
And there it is folks, jonesy going down the river de Nile.

No, that is you deliberately lying again. It is a bad habit, and does your credibility (such as it is!) no good at all. Want me to quote the relevant passage from the paper?


Instead, a most detailed investigation of plasma physical processes in the inner coma is possible. Here, we concentrate on the physics of the interaction during the low- and intermediate-activity phase of the comet.

So, quit the lying.
 
Ha ha ha good one jonesy.

Unless the paper contains the words “sublimation” and “ice” they are all irrelevant.


Does Ceres have an exosphere? Does Tempel 1’s composition contain the same material as Ceres and asteroid Bennu? Does the Moon emit dust? Why is the OH reading the highest on the sunlit side of the moon?

Irrelevant for a no hoper I ‘ spose..

It a proven fact, Birkeland currents and electric fields are in play at comets, you choose to make irrelevant... why?

Because it is not in the mainstream playbook?

Or you’re just to dim witted to see the evidence before you.

If you look closely you can see the discharge in the MAG data.
 
Last edited:
Oh and the EDM you looking for has been called the “Patched Charge” model by Horanyi.

Look it up and educate yourself.


The observed energy range of 200−500eV correspondsto the kinetic energy of nano-dust particles with radii in the approximate range of 3−4 nm. The fact that the beam of negatively charged “outbound” particles is intermittent and nearly mono-energeticis probablyassociated with a local peak in the grain size distribution.

Negatively charged nano-grains at 67P/Churyumov-Gerasimenko
 
Last edited:
It a proven fact, Birkeland currents and electric fields are in play at comets, you choose to make irrelevant... why?

No Birkeland currents. Fail. And what the hell have electric fields got to do with the trash written by the idiot Thornhill?

Because it is not in the mainstream playbook?

Because it has sod all to do with any viable science, and no scientist supports your idiotic woo.

Or you’re just to dim witted to see the evidence before you.

Lol! I'm not the idiot that believes in a stupid model that has no evidence. no mechanisms, and no science to back it up.

If you look closely you can see the discharge in the MAG data.

Which is a another barefaced lie. You are pathetic.
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom