The Electric Comet Theory Part IV/SAFIRE

Status
Not open for further replies.
1. Cut out the charges of lying and ignorance - be civil and polite.

2. Do not alter usernames in order to insult, or where a user has requested that you use their unaltered username.

3. Do not attack the arguers; concentrate solely on their arguments.
Replying to this modbox in thread will be off topic  Posted By: Agatha


Apologies. It gets frustrating when the arguments have been addressed multiple times.
 
Oh and the EDM you looking for has been called the “Patched Charge” model by Horanyi.

Look it up and educate yourself.

I've read the relevant papers, and they have nothing to do with discharges. They also have nothing to do with the non-existent EDM (lol).

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Electrical_discharge_machining


The mechanism proposed is mostly about dust transport, with only a small amount of lofting. There was nothing observed when UV exposure alone was was tested. And UV alone is what the surface of 67P is receiving when at its most active. There is a reason that Nordheim used the words "low activity" in the title of his paper. The only plasma within the diamagnetic cavity is of cometary origin. That will come from photo-dissociation of the neutrals (mostly water). The time against ionisation for water molecules is ~ 106 seconds. The cavity boundary may be around 170 km. At the velocity that the molecules are travelling (~ 600 m/s) it should take them ~ 300s to reach the cavity boundary. So, what is the proportion of ions to neutrals, given the aforementioned?
The process proposed is only applicable to airless bodies. This does not include comets at high activity levels. Asteroids are the obvious test of how much dust is actually lofted, and it is obviously not very much. Transport is certainly a possibility, and there is indirect evidence that it may happen.
Any claims that this model is proposing discharges, or collimated beams of dust, is a serious misunderstanding and/or a blatant misrepresentation of the papers.

The charge state of electrostatically transported dust on regolith surfaces
Schwan, J. et al.
https://agupubs.onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/abs/10.1002/2017GL072909
 
Last edited:
The only plasma within the diamagnetic cavity is of cometary origin. That will come from photo-dissociation of the neutrals (mostly water). The time against ionisation for water molecules is ~ 106 seconds. The cavity boundary may be around 170 km. At the velocity that the molecules are travelling (~ 600 m/s) it should take them ~ 300s to reach the cavity boundary. So, what is the proportion of ions to neutrals, given the aforementioned?


This paper cast serious doubt on that assertion, jd116

ABSTRACT doi:10.1093/mnras/sty2869 In a cometary coma, the ion-neutral decoupling distance, sometimes referred to as the ion exobase or collisionopause, can be defined as the cometocentric distance, rin, where ions, initially moving with the neutral outgassing speed, have a probability of 1/e of not colliding with neutrals on their subsequent journey radially outwards. We present an analytical model for calculating this decoupling distance in the presence of a static radial electric field. We show that for a logarithmically decaying potential, the value of rin can even decrease to ∼15 percent of its field-free case value. Moreover, already at this distance, the effective ion speed can be expected to markedly exceed the neutral expansion velocity. These analytical results are in line with previous numerical calculations, adapting similar but not identical field profiles. The presence of a non-negligible ambipolar electric field and limited importance of ion-neutral collisional coupling are further supported by observations in the diamagnetic cavity of comet 67P/Churyumov–Gerasimenko by plasma instruments onboard Rosetta that reveal ion speeds several times higher than the neutral expansion velocity.

Onthe ion-neutral coupling in cometary comae

Neutral gas drag is not responsible.


What say ye, Jonesdave116?
 
Further

Unless effectively removed via dissociative recombination (a process which is more efficient the slower the electrons are), the cold electron population grows and continues to do so up to a point where the resulting reduced electron temperature leads to a diminishing (or even reversal) of the ambipolar electric field that then can allow the cold electrons to escape outwards. This in turn leads back to an outward-pointing ambipolar electric field. Such a scenario would be qualitatively consistent with the time-varying cavity boundary observed on Rosetta (Goetz et al. 2016).

This is the diamagnetic cavity, a plasma double layer.

However, we have also raised concerns about the fact that our model is based on a time-stationary electric field profile. Such a scenario is unrealistic (if not dissociative recombination is very efficient) as it would cause a build-up of cold electrons incapable of escaping the potential barrier associated with the ambipolar field. This leads us to speculate on a periodically varying potential structure.

Please note, the paper does not mention the negatively charged nano-grains. This would complicate the situation somewhat.

So the long and the short, jd116 is, the model your using is a little to simplistic, unrealistic and now outdated.

This is no fault of anyone, as this has only come to light because of Rosetta’s data.
 
Last edited:
This is slowly leading to the realisation that the nucleus itself is a charged object.

As the ELECTRIC COMET has stated for some time.

On ya Wal!
 
. As shown in the previous experiment [Wang et al., 2016b], even though the initial dust sample in the crater was sieved to include particles only in the range of 38–45 μm in diameter, the lofted particles were observed to be composed of single-sized particles (38–45 μm), small residues (< 38 μm) adhered to the single-sized particles due to the dust production processes and large aggregates (up to 140 μm) as a result of theefficient clumping of single particles due to cohesion. The sizes of the electrostatically lofted Mars simulants had distributions of 20.3 ± 13.1 μm (under the UV radiation) and 44.9 ± 30.1 μm (under the electron beam) in diameter. Similar aggregation is also expected to occur for silica microspheres, leading to the formation of larger particulates with a broad size distribution. These aggregates can form complex microcavities with variable shapes and sizes. The cohesive force can vary over several orders of magnitude, depending on how dust particles contact each other [Cooper et al., 2001]. One possible scenario could be that the cohesive forces between the aggregates are smaller than the repulsive forces between them while the cohesive forces between the single particles are large enough to hold them together, resulting in the lofted aggregates instead of single particles.

The charge state of electrostatically transported dust on regolith surfaces


Fluffy dust anyone?
 
Last edited:
This paper cast serious doubt on that assertion, jd116



Onthe ion-neutral coupling in cometary comae

Neutral gas drag is not responsible.


What say ye, Jonesdave116?

A total irrelevance to what is being discussed. The only plasma within the cavity is of cometary origin, and they are saying nothing to the contrary. I have no idea why you think this paper has any relevance to your failed model.
 
The charge state of electrostatically transported dust on regolith surfaces


Fluffy dust anyone?

Another reference to something that is totally irrelevant to the failed EC woo. Will you please stop doing this. Address the failure of your model, and stop linking to irrelevant papers that have nothing to do with the idiocy written by the idiot Thornhill. Everything in that paper applies to asteroids. They are not surrounded by dust. Fail.
 
This is slowly leading to the realisation that the nucleus itself is a charged object.

As the ELECTRIC COMET has stated for some time.

On ya Wal!

No, it is not. Asteroids are more charged than comets, as you have repeatedly been told. So, why are asteroids not behaving as comets? Stop fabricating utter nonsense, it is getting tiresome.
 
This is the diamagnetic cavity, a plasma double layer

No, it is not a double layer, you haven't got a clue what you are talking about. Stop making things up, it is getting tiresome.
 
water). The time against ionisation for water molecules is ~ 106 seconds. The cavity boundary may be around 170 km. At the velocity that the molecules are travelling (~ 600 m/s) it should take them ~ 300s to reach the cavity boundary. So, what is the proportion of ions to neutrals, given the aforementioned?

We’re did you get this information from?
 
Further



This is the diamagnetic cavity, a plasma double layer.



Please note, the paper does not mention the negatively charged nano-grains. This would complicate the situation somewhat.

So the long and the short, jd116 is, the model your using is a little to simplistic, unrealistic and now outdated.

This is no fault of anyone, as this has only come to light because of Rosetta’s data.

And is completely irrelevant to the EC woo. Stop going off on irrelevant tangents. Discuss the complete failure of the EC woo, or stop posting. Zero evidence, zero mechanisms, zero science. You are still batting zero.
 
And is completely irrelevant to the EC woo. Stop going off on irrelevant tangents. Discuss the complete failure of the EC woo, or stop posting. Zero evidence, zero mechanisms, zero science. You are still batting zero.


Ok let’s break it down some more.

Where are the ions coming from?
 
So, where are we now with the electric comet 'model'? What have we learned after over a decade of this woo being spammed around various fora on the internet? Let's break it down to its most fundamental claims, as per the Thornhill & Talbott poster from 2006;

Comets are rocks, blasted from planets by unknown electric woo.
Leaving aside the scientifically impossible mechanisms described to achieve this, we need only look at the composition of planets and moons, and at the composition of comets, and do a comparison. Earth, Mars, Mercury and Venus; all rock with high density. Comets; highly porous mixture of dust (fluffy and compact), ice and organics, with very low density.
Therefore the electric comet model fails.

Comets are merely asteroids on elliptical orbits.
Any cursory examination of the many asteroids on elliptical orbits shows this to be wrong.
Therefore the electric comet model fails.

The jets observed are electric discharges to (from?) the nucleus.
Electric discharges would show up in the magnetometer data. There was nothing. The jets are observed to be gas, dust and, sometimes, ice.
Therefore the electric comet model fails.

There is little to no ice, and the water observed is actually OH.
Water has been definitively detected at comets since 1986. So that was a lie.
Therefore the electric comet model fails.

The OH (H2O?) that is observed is due to solar wind H+ combining with O-.
Impossible. The H+ ions are far too energetic to combine with anything.
There is nowhere near enough H+ to explain even 1 litre of water per second.
There is little to no O-.
The solar wind is getting nowhere near the nucleus for about 8 months around perihelion.
Therefore the electric comet model fails.

Those are the fundamental building blocks underlying the electric comet model. Verdict? It fails. Horribly, and indisputably. The electric comet model was stillborn. It was never alive, and nobody has come close to zapping its stinking corpse with 50 000 volts to bring it to life. It is a miserable, neo-Velikovskian heap of trash, dreamed up by unqualified woo merchants. It is a joke. It isn't worthy of our attention.

Still waiting. Deal with the complete failure of the EC woo, as outlined above.
 
Cometary neutrals. As you have been told. Stop going off on tangents. It is tiresome, and completely irrelevant to your failed model.

Its on topic.

You are ignoring the evidence.

Why?

These analytical results are in line with previous numerical calculations, adapting similar but not identical field profiles. The presence of a non-negligible ambipolar electric field and limited importance of ion-neutral collisional coupling are further supported by observations in the diamagnetic cavity of comet 67P/Churyumov–Gerasimenko by plasma instruments onboard Rosetta that reveal ion speeds several times higher than the neutral expansion velocity.
 
Last edited:
I've read the relevant papers, and they have nothing to do with discharges. They also have nothing to do with the non-existent EDM (lol).

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Electrical_discharge_machining


The mechanism proposed is mostly about dust transport, with only a small amount of lofting. There was nothing observed when UV exposure alone was was tested. And UV alone is what the surface of 67P is receiving when at its most active. There is a reason that Nordheim used the words "low activity" in the title of his paper. The only plasma within the diamagnetic cavity is of cometary origin. That will come from photo-dissociation of the neutrals (mostly water). The time against ionisation for water molecules is ~ 106 seconds. The cavity boundary may be around 170 km. At the velocity that the molecules are travelling (~ 600 m/s) it should take them ~ 300s to reach the cavity boundary. So, what is the proportion of ions to neutrals, given the aforementioned?
The process proposed is only applicable to airless bodies. This does not include comets at high activity levels. Asteroids are the obvious test of how much dust is actually lofted, and it is obviously not very much. Transport is certainly a possibility, and there is indirect evidence that it may happen.
Any claims that this model is proposing discharges, or collimated beams of dust, is a serious misunderstanding and/or a blatant misrepresentation of the papers.

The charge state of electrostatically transported dust on regolith surfaces
Schwan, J. et al.
https://agupubs.onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/abs/10.1002/2017GL072909


No mention of the ambipolar electric field in your example, jd116?

So how can we discuss? You don’t believe there is an electric field at comets.
 
Its on topic.

You are ignoring the evidence.

Why?

I am not ignoring any evidence. It is off-topic, as it has nothing to do with the failed EC woo. The ions are of cometary origin, and there is nobody saying differently.
 
No mention of the ambipolar electric field in your example, jd116?

So how can we discuss? You don’t believe there is an electric field at comets.

There is nothing to discuss. It is irrelevant to your failed woo. The solar wind is getting nowhere near the comet at periods of high activity. Therefore your model fails. There is no EDM, therefore your model fails. You cannot explain the vapour or the ice. Therefore your model fails. Et cetera. Deal with it, and stop posting irrelevancies.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom