The Electric Comet Theory Part IV/SAFIRE

Status
Not open for further replies.
Nope, the scientifically illiterate loon said there would be no dust! The coma was actually a glow discharge! Lol. What a tool. Science isn't really his thing, is it?

He said it would be electrostaticaly cleaned and some dust may return.

The primary distinction between comet and asteroid surfaces is that electrical arcing and “electrostatic cleaning” of the comet nucleus will leave little or no dust or debris on the surface during the active phase, even if a shallow layer of dust may be attracted back to the nucleus electrostatically as the comet becomes dormant in its retreat to more remote regions.

What we should see is a nucleus that is MOSTLY ROCK, as stated by A'Hearn! His legacy.
:thumbsup:

(c) What are comets made of? At the simplest level, a very basic question is whether comets are mostly ice or mostly rock/dirt/refractory material. Whipple’s [2] model of the dirty snowball, the first quantitative model, envisioned cometary nuclei as mostly ice, although our understanding has been evolving more toward mostly rock, particularly for 67P/C-G for which refractory/volatile ratios as high as 6 have been cited [3,4]. Nevertheless, there is still considerable uncertainty about even this basic parameter, not least of which is that most measurements are subject to selection effects in removing refractories from the nucleus to the coma, where they are observed as dust.


Bang on the money!

A loon beat the mainstream, fancy that :D



Oh, I forgot sorry, is the dust charged? Are there electric fields? are there Birkeland currents!
 
Last edited:
It is this assertion that comets and asteroids have common genesis and will display common features and composition that is yet another experimentum crucis for the Electric Comet model. An experimentum crucis is defined by Wikipedia as:

Under the definition of a critical experiment (experimentum crucis), a prediction must be distinct from the predictions of other theories such that a clear test can be performed in order to distinguish which prediction is correct, and which prediction is incorrect.

To put it simply, the standard model expected comets to be the cold remnants of an “accretion disk,” or water and/or volatiles cemented together in or beyond the cold outer reaches of the solar system (in later revisions, the water and volatiles, not having been observed on the surface, were posited to exist below the surface, invisible and hidden out of the reach of our observational power).

The Electric Comet model, on the other hand, expects comets to display relatively homogeneous composition similar to that of meteorites. In fact, the Electric Comet model appears to say that they have common origin in catastrophic electrical discharges that literally electrically machined the surfaces of planets in our solar system in a relatively recent geological epoch, leaving identifiable electrical scars on those parent bodies and often on the comet / asteroid surfaces as well.

Asteroid–comet continuum objects in the solar system

Happy to keep discussing if you'd like?
 
He said it would be electrostaticaly cleaned and some dust may return.

Well, he was wrong, wasn't he?

What we should see is a nucleus that is MOSTLY ROCK, as stated by A'Hearn! His legacy.

Stop lying. There is no rock. Never, ever seen at a comet. If lying is all you've got left, why are you still here?
 
I’m sorry to have wasted your time mate. My apologies.

It's not my time you've wasted, it's your own.
32 years since H2O was definitively detected around Halley. And many other detections since then. 32 years since the detection of a diamagnetic cavity around Halley, and the magnetometer showing no discharge signatures within that cavity. And the detection of water vapour within a distance from the nucleus where the solar wind was not seen. 13 years since an impactor hit Tempel 1, and a bunch of ice came flying out. 7 years since the paper reporting the size of the crater. 7 years since there were pictures and reports of a veritable snowstorm around Hartley 2. And papers going all the way back to Hale-Bopp reporting ice grains. I could go on, but you get the point. You will find none of the above reported on Thunderdolts or Hollowscience. Why do you think that is? Seems to me the authors of that woo are not interested in actually dealing with the science, and are more interested in pushing a fairy tale in order to boost book sales. I would call it lying by omission. Which we can add to the more blatant lies, and general obfuscation, misrepresentation and scientific illiteracy of the aforementioned authors.
You were taken for a ride by unscrupulous, unqualified con artists.

For me, combatting this idiotic woo on various fora has increased my knowledge of comets considerably. I already knew enough to recognise the EC as nonsense the moment I first set eyes on it. The last 4 years or so have greatly added to that knowledge. When I first encountered these loons, it would take me considerable time to track down the necessary papers to refute their nonsense. Now it takes minutes, as I have those papers among a rather large collection. So, the electric comet woo has done some good! My only regret is that David Talbott's brief appearance on the forum predated my joining. IMHO he got away quite lightly. I'd have certainly been grilling him about the false claim that detections of H2O at comets were actually OH. That was one of the aforementioned blatant lies. And also the detection of ice grains at Tempel 1. And the claims of an electric discharge prior to the impact. Another blatant lie, as shown by the Chandra and SWIFT data.
To paraphrase a judge in a famous air crash investigation in NZ, the whole edifice of EC woo is based on "an orchestrated litany of lies."
 
Last edited:
“Science advances one funeral at a time.” Max Planck

I really enjoy your input but the latest raft of papers, 2018, throw some SERIOUS doubt on your dogmatic faith in comets are mostly ice and that it can only get come from in situ frozen leftovers from the presolar nebula.

And


I have a deep faith that science will advance to ultimately prove the electrical nature of not only comets by the Universe.

There are more than a few papers refuting your claims. I.e the diamagnetic cavity.


I feel exactly the same with regards to you (mainstream) wasting our time and money chasing farietales.

The Big Bang is wrong and the electric comet will prove this.

As above, so below and so below, as above.
 
Last edited:
“Science advances one funeral at a time.” Max Planck

I really enjoy your input but the latest raft of papers, 2018, throw some SERIOUS doubt on your dogmatic faith in comets are mostly ice and that it can only get come from in situ frozen leftovers from the presolar nebula.

No, as I have never said comets are mostly ice. That has not been believed for some time, as I have previously linked to. And no again, as there are no papers questioning the pre-solar nebula as the origin. Quite the opposite. So, that is just more lies and obfuscation.




I have a deep faith that science will advance to ultimately prove the electrical nature of not only comets by the Universe.

Nope, you have faith in a couple of scientifically illiterate clowns, who know Jack about comets. Or anything else.

There are more than a few papers refuting your claims. I.e the diamagnetic cavity.

No, there are not. Giotto saw what it saw, Rosetta saw what it saw. No solar wind within ~ 1500 km of the 67P in October 2015, more than a month after perihelion. No magnetic field within ~ 4500 km of Halley. End of story. Thornhill and his partner in crime lied to you, due to being clueless, and interested only in selling books and DVDs.

EDIT:
By the way, a diamagnetic cavity was also observed in the AMPTE artificial comet experiments, in 1984/5. Hardly breaking news. Predicted, observed, ignored by the idiot Wal.
 
Last edited:
A new scientific truth does not triumph by convincing its opponents and making them see the light, but rather because its opponents eventually die, and a new generation grows up that is familiar with it.”
Max Plank

Apossible mechanism for the formation of magnetic field dropouts in the coma of 67P/Churyumov–Gerasimenko

ABSTRACT The Rosetta Plasma Consortium MAGnetometer (RPC-MAG) has detected signatures of diamagnetic regions associated with comet 67P/Churyumov–Gerasimenko at distances from 30 to 400km at different heliocentric distances, which is larger than what has been predicted by numerical simulations of the cometary plasam environment. The physical mechanism behind these diamagnetic regions is still unknown. In this work, we use our newly developed multifluid plasma-neutral model to explore a possible physical mechanism that might create such regions. The model solves the governing multifluid magnetohydrodynamic equations for cometary and solar wind ions and electrons, and the Euler equations for the neutral gas fluid. Wefindthat a local increase of electron thermal pressure is capable of generating many of the observed features of the diamagnetic regions observed by RPC-MAG. The simulation results show that a magnetic field-free region is formed and the recovery phase of the magnetic field magnitude is faster than the declining phase.

Discuss?

Or


Are you of the belief still, the neutral “outgassing” from sublimation is causing the diamagnetic caivity?

Onthe ion-neutral coupling in cometary comae

ABSTRACT doi:10.1093/mnras/sty2869 In a cometary coma, the ion-neutral decoupling distance, sometimes referred to as the ion exobase or collisionopause, can be defined as the cometocentric distance, rin, where ions, initially moving with the neutral outgassing speed, have a probability of 1/e of not colliding with neutrals on their subsequent journey radially outwards. We present an analytical model for calculating this decoupling distance in the presence of a static radial electric field. We show that for a logarithmically decaying potential, the value of rin can even decrease to ∼15 percent of its field-free case value. Moreover, already at this distance, the effective ion speed can be expected to markedly exceed the neutral expansion velocity. These analytical results are in line with previous numerical calculations, adapting similar but not identical field profiles. The presence of a non-negligible ambipolar electric field and limited importance of ion-neutral collisional coupling are further supported by observations in the diamagnetic cavity of comet 67P/Churyumov–Gerasimenko by plasma instruments onboard Rosetta that reveal ion speeds several times higher than the neutral expansion velocity.

So....
 
Last edited:
Max Plank

Apossible mechanism for the formation of magnetic field dropouts in the coma of 67P/Churyumov–Gerasimenko



Discuss?

If that's the Huang paper, it has already been discussed. Tusenfem was not overly impressed. And it does not question the DC at Halley. 0 nT in that baby. Lots of 'discharges' that failed to register on the magnetometer. Your woo was dead before it was born. It is only due to the lies, omissions, obfuscations, misrepresentations and scientific illiteracy of T & T that this idiocy exists. Nobody with an IQ higher than a badger believes such nonsense.
 
No, as I have never said comets are mostly ice. That has not been believed for some time, as I have previously linked to.

It’s in my signature. :D

Comets are MOSTLY...vacuum. :boggled:

The refractory-to-ice mass ratio in comets
 
Last edited:
If that's the Huang paper, it has already been discussed. Tusenfem was not overly impressed. And it does not question the DC at Halley. 0 nT in that baby. Lots of 'discharges' that failed to register on the magnetometer. Your woo was dead before it was born. It is only due to the lies, omissions, obfuscations, misrepresentations and scientific illiteracy of T & T that this idiocy exists. Nobody with an IQ higher than a badger believes such nonsense.


Dynamic unmagnetized plasma in the diamagnetic cavity around comet 67P/Churyumov-Gerasimenko

ABSTRACT The Rosetta orbiter witnessed several hundred diamagnetic cavity crossings (unmagnetized regions) around comet 67P/Churyumov-Gerasimenko during its two year survey of the comet. The characteristics of the plasma environment inside these diamagnetic regions are studied using in situ measurements by the Rosetta Plasma Consortium instruments. While the unmagnetized plasma density has been observed to exhibit little dynamics compared to the very dynamical magnetized cometary plasma, we detected several localized dynamic plasma structures inside those diamagnetic regions. These plasma structures are not related to the direct ionization of local cometary neutrals. The structures are found to be steepened, asymmetric plasma enhancements with typical rising-todescending slope ratio of ∼2.8 (±1.9), skewness ∼0.43 (±0.36), mean duration of ∼2.7 (±0.9) min and relative density variation ∆N/N of ∼0.5 (±0.2), observed close to the electron exobase. Similar steepened plasma density enhancements were detected at the magnetized boundaries of the diamagnetic cavity as well as outside the diamagnetic region. The plausible scale length and propagation direction of the structures are estimated from simple plasma dynamics considerations. It is suggested that they are large-scale unmagnetized plasma enhancements, transmitted from the very dynamical outer magnetized region to the inner magnetic field-free cavity region.

Happy to discuss.
 
It’s in my signature. :D

Comets are MOSTLY...vacuum. :boggled:

Of course they are. What does ~ 75% porosity mean in la-la land? As far as mass goes, that mostly comes from the compact dust. Which is not there, according to the idiot Thornhill. How much further down the rabbit hole do you want to go?
 
Dynamic unmagnetized plasma in the diamagnetic cavity around comet 67P/Churyumov-Gerasimenko



Happy to discuss.

Nothing to discuss. No solar wind, no IMF. As seen at Halley, 67P, and in the AMPTE experiments. And 20 years after Halley and AMPTE, the idiot Thornhill is calling on solar wind H+ to create OH, when we already knew, definitively, that it was H2O. And his mechanism was impossible, anyways.
You see what listening to liars has done here, Sol? You're up **** creek without a paddle. Yes? Idiots relying on idiots. Never going to end well, is it?
 
OK, Sol, here is some of the stuff the idiot Thornhill didn't tell you in his crap poster from 2006;

The Kuiper Airborne Observatory observed H2O around Halley in 1985. Paper published early 1986. Vega observed it in-situ, a bit later. And still he lied. Numerous other definitive detections of water vapour occurred between 1986 and 2006. Many of them by Odin.

So, Sol; why was he lying? What is his problem? Or was he not aware of the detections? Or too thick to understand the science? Whichever way you go, he doesn't look good, does he?
 
Of course they are. What does ~ 75% porosity mean in la-la land? As far as mass goes, that mostly comes from the compact dust. Which is not there, according to the idiot Thornhill. How much further down the rabbit hole do you want to go?



The Nucleus of comet 67P/Churyumov–Gerasimenko – Part I: The global view – nucleus mass, mass-loss, porosity, and implications
7. The nucleus is thus a highly porous very dusty body with very little ice.

That’s as had a rock says MUPUS. :thumbsup:
 
OK, Sol, here is some of the stuff the idiot Thornhill didn't tell you in his crap poster from 2006;

The Kuiper Airborne Observatory observed H2O around Halley in 1985. Paper published early 1986. Vega observed it in-situ, a bit later. And still he lied. Numerous other definitive detections of water vapour occurred between 1986 and 2006. Many of them by Odin.

So, Sol; why was he lying? What is his problem? Or was he not aware of the detections? Or too thick to understand the science? Whichever way you go, he doesn't look good, does he?

Dude ice is every where except in your comets!

See The Nucleus of comet 67P/Churyumov–Gerasimenko – Part I: The global view – nucleus mass, mass-loss, porosity, and implications

Ice in the make up of cometary nuclei is insignificant, as stated by A’Hearn.
 
Last edited:
The Nucleus of comet 67P/Churyumov–Gerasimenko – Part I: The global view – nucleus mass, mass-loss, porosity, and implications


That’s as had a rock says MUPUS. :thumbsup:

Lie. Nowhere near as hard as rock. Quit with the lies, woo boy.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom