The Electric Comet Theory Part IV/SAFIRE

Status
Not open for further replies.
jd116, what happens when a charged particle (Dust, Ion or electron) encounters an electric field?

:D
 
jd116, what happens when a charged particle (Dust, Ion or electron) encounters an electric field?

:D

Irrelevant. Why is this not happening at asteroids? Why is not a single scientist saying that jets of dust and gas and ice at comets are due to electric woo? Fail.
 
Irrelevant. Why is this not happening at asteroids? Why is not a single scientist saying that jets of dust and gas and ice at comets are due to electric woo? Fail.

Ummmmm, because Whipple may have misinterpreted the data at the time and then peoples spending the next 60 odd years trying to prove him right.


The new data is pointing to something other than sublimation and infrared radiation as the key driver for the dust jets.

My money’s on the electric force!

You know, electric fields powered via Birkeland currents, acting on “rock”.

How many probes with Rosetta’s dust instruments have orbited an asteroid?

The Dawn mission was probably the longest and Ceres has been observed to be active at times...at times it’s a COMET. :jaw-dropp

So, it HAS to be sublimation...or impact...or “spin up”...but, only the crap fed to the non knowing and the gullible,.

Comets me ‘ol mate are electric, plugged into a socket and all!
 
Last edited:
What do you reckon ‘s going on at the moon?

Dust wise.

Irrelevant...:rolleyes: sure... whatever tickles your toes.
 
Ummmmm, because Whipple may have misinterpreted the data at the time and then peoples spending the next 60 odd years trying to prove him right.


The new data is pointing to something other than sublimation and infrared radiation as the key driver for the dust jets.

My money’s on the electric force!

You know, electric fields powered via Birkeland currents, acting on “rock”.

How many probes with Rosetta’s dust instruments have orbited an asteroid?

The Dawn mission was probably the longest and Ceres has been observed to be active at times...at times it’s a COMET. :jaw-dropp

So, it HAS to be sublimation...or impact...or “spin up”...but, only the crap fed to the non knowing and the gullible,.

Comets me ‘ol mate are electric, plugged into a socket and all!

Complete crap. And Rosetta visited two asteroids. You are making stuff up again, due to having zero evidence, zero mechanism and zero science. It is complete and utter drivel.
 
How many probes with Rosetta’s dust instruments have orbited an asteroid?

Errr, all you need is a camera to see the dust. They don't see any. Stupid comment. Not unexpectedly.
 
Complete crap. And Rosetta visited two asteroids. You are making stuff up again, due to having zero evidence, zero mechanism and zero science. It is complete and utter drivel.

How long did Rosetta spend orbiting just these two asteroids?

Long enough to seal the deal?

No Rosetta didn’t spend very long at all and it raised a few more questions than answers as far as I remember about it’s size and density.

Funny that. :D

Jonesy me ‘ol mate.
 
Last edited:
Nope. Zero evidence, zero mechanism, zero science. Total drivel.

What’s powering the variable ambipolar electric field at 67P again jd116?

Oh, and how many amps over what distance are the Birkeland (force free) field aligned electric currents in operation at 67P?

So no gravity, sublimationy, little gas rockets fariedust dark magic needed really but like I said whatever blows the wind through your hair dude.
 
Last edited:
No Rosetta didn’t spend very long at all and it raised a few more questions than answers as far as I remember about it’s size and density.

No, it didn't. The density is well constrained. And the spacecraft had cameras. No dust. Fail. Stop talking nonsense.
 
Apollo objects have eccentric orbits no comas...
Sol88 has ignored that for year

4015 Wilson–Harrington
2P/Encke


What was your point again, sorry dd?


What’s the difference between comets and asteroids again dancing david?

There are only seven other objects that are cross-listed as both comets and asteroids: 2060 Chiron (95P/Chiron), 7968 Elst–Pizarro (133P/Elst–Pizarro), 60558 Echeclus (174P/Echeclus), 118401 LINEAR (176P/LINEAR), (323137) 2003 BM80 (282P/2003 BM80), (300163) 2006 VW139 (288P/2006 VW139), and (457175) 2008 GO98 (362P/2008 GO98).[3] As a dual status object, astrometric observations of 4015 Wilson–Harrington should be reported under the minor planet designation.[3]

Where’s the line in the sand, I don’t know, do you. ;)
 
Last edited:
4015 Wilson–Harrington
2P/Encke


What was your point again, sorry dd?


What’s the difference between comets and asteroids again dancing david?



Where’s the line in the sand, I don’t know, do you. ;)

Do you know how many asteroids there are? Quit being silly. Your cult claims comets are just asteroids on elliptical orbits. Indagator gave you a shed load of asteroids on elliptical orbits that do not outgas. And a number of the ones you list are not on particularly eccentric orbits, further disproving your claim. Therefore your claim fails. Trivially. You have painted yourself into a corner. You don't even have a reason why an elliptical orbit would cause outgassing. Pure lunacy. 100% debunked. Nothing to do with science.
 
Do you know how many asteroids there are? Quit being silly. Your cult claims comets are just asteroids on elliptical orbits. Indagator gave you a shed load of asteroids on elliptical orbits that do not outgas. And a number of the ones you list are not on particularly eccentric orbits, further disproving your claim. Therefore your claim fails. Trivially. You have painted yourself into a corner. You don't even have a reason why an elliptical orbit would cause outgassing. Pure lunacy. 100% debunked. Nothing to do with science.

Cool, maybe you could write a peer reviewed paper on it and we could discuss? Other it’s irrelevant, as you say.

But in the mean time back to 67P and Rosetta’s data.

The dust is charged and there are electric fields, my question, with this data in mind is could this produce the visible dust jets?

I believe it does, from the papers I’ve linked to recently.

Others with to have complete faith in an outdated model, regardless of the latest data and papers.
 
Cool, maybe you could write a peer reviewed paper on it and we could discuss? Other it’s irrelevant, as you say.

But in the mean time back to 67P and Rosetta’s data.

The dust is charged and there are electric fields, my question, with this data in mind is could this produce the visible dust jets?

I believe it does, from the papers I’ve linked to recently.

Others with to have complete faith in an outdated model, regardless of the latest data and papers.

Nope, not a single scientist is suggesting electric woo can cause dust jets. Possible levitation, particularly at the Moon, and asteroids. Possible transport, even on comets at low activity levels. No jets. Really dumb suggestion. Go email Horanyi. He'll tell you how dumb it is. Like I said - you are making crap up in the absence of any evidence or viable science.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom