The Electric Comet Theory Part IV/SAFIRE

Status
Not open for further replies.
Thank you

Just formulating a couple questions myself. Thanks for including your original questions for contex
 
Thank you

Just formulating a couple questions myself. Thanks for including your original questions for contex

Do not forget that it has never been shown, nor suggested (iirc), that electrostatic charging can lift sub-micron sized grains. The experiments that have been done are on particles of the order of tens of microns.
 
Do not forget that it has never been shown, nor suggested (iirc), that electrostatic charging can lift sub-micron sized grains. The experiments that have been done are on particles of the order of tens of microns.

Cheers.

Will be formulating the questions with some of the latest papers in mind.

These had not yet been published when you ask Skorov your question.
 
Cheers.

Will be formulating the questions with some of the latest papers in mind.

These had not yet been published when you ask Skorov your question.

I don't see any recent papers that have any relevance to electrostatic effects on nucleus material.
 
That’s obvious. :o

Yes, it is. Because there haven't been any. The nucleus is at its most charged when it is accessed by the solar wind. That is the time when dust emission is lowest. It is also the case at asteroids, which, from what we are seeing, do not have dust comas.
 
Yes, it is. Because there haven't been any. The nucleus is at its most charged when it is accessed by the solar wind. That is the time when dust emission is lowest. It is also the case at asteroids, which, from what we are seeing, do not have dust comas.

What makes you still think the solar wind is needed?

Horányi Experiments suggest UV to be a key driver as well? Along with his work on lunar dust charging suggesting the interplay between many competing forces having a greater effect than sputtering.

Such a shadowed regions becoming highly negatively charged via UV.

So I’ll just keep plodding down the line of the jets are an electrical phenomena. If you don’t believe there is any merit in this line of reasoning, then no wucken furries. Your free to have faith in anything you like. :cool:
 
Last edited:
Such a shadowed regions becoming highly negatively charged via UV.

Wrong. Nobody is suggesting such a thing! UV is from sunlight. Sunlight, by definition, is not reaching shadowed areas. You need the solar wind accessing the surface to build high negative charge on the dark side.


So I’ll just keep plodding down the line of the jets are an electrical phenomena.

Which is demonstrably wrong, so you're wasting your time.
 
In addition to cohesion, grains on small bodies will be influenced by electrostatic forces. Asteroids typically do not have magnetic fields. Thus, the surface of an asteroid interacts directly with the solar wind plasma and the solar UV radiation. The solar wind plasma tends to charge surfaces negatively. However, the solar UV radiation causes the regolith to photoemit, producing a net positive charge on the day-lit surfaces of the asteroid. The positively charged surface attracts electrons, resulting in a region of increased electron density near the surface called the plasma sheath.

Electrostatic forces on grains near asteroids and comets

The dust is charged. :D
 
Electrostatic forces on grains near asteroids and comets

The dust is charged. :D

So why aren't asteroids behaving as comets? It is a stupid argument, and you simply do not understand the science. Feel free to email Horanyi, who will also tell you that you are deluded.
 
Experimental Methods of Dust Charging and Mobilization on Surfaces with
Exposure to Ultraviolet Radiation or Plasmas
doi:10.3791/57072



Also top notch.
 
Experimental Methods of Dust Charging and Mobilization on Surfaces with
Exposure to Ultraviolet Radiation or Plasmas
doi:10.3791/57072



Also top notch.

And not relevant to an active comet. As any of these scientists would tell you, but you are too chicken to ask them.
 
So why aren't asteroids behaving as comets? It is a stupid argument, and you simply do not understand the science. Feel free to email Horanyi, who will also tell you that you are deluded.


Don’t know, something to do with their electric field I’d guess.

But we have probes at Bennu and Ryugu, unfortunately no Langmuir probes on either craft.

So who know what strength the electric fields or the charge of the asteroid may or may not be??? ;)
 
Don’t know, something to do with their electric field I’d guess.

But we have probes at Bennu and Ryugu, unfortunately no Langmuir probes on either craft.

So who know what strength the electric fields or the charge of the asteroid may or may not be??? ;)

Cop out, and a non-answer. Why would this not affect dust on airless asteroids, copping the full brunt of the solar wind, and the associated high negative charging, and yet somehow throw up jets of dust on a comet with a much lower charge, due to the solar wind not reaching the surface? You are making crap up, as usual, because the science is beyond you. Go ask one of the many authors who have written papers on this. We know you won't, and we know why you won't. You want to continue spamming this impossible nonsense on here. Due to your faith. It is dead. Gone. Finished. Only fruitloops ever believed it in the first place.
 
Last edited:
Cop out, and a non-answer. Why would this not affect dust on airless asteroids, copping the full brunt of the solar wind, and the associated high negative charging, and yet somehow throw up jets of dust on a comet with a much lower charge, due to the solar wind not reaching the surface? You are making crap up, as usual, because the science is beyond you. Go ask one of the many authors who have written papers on this. We know you won't, and we know why you won't. You want to continue spamming this impossible nonsense on here. Due to your faith. It is dead. Gone. Finished. Only fruitloops ever believed it in the first place.

Sometimes asteroids become active and all you have is gas light physics to try and explain it... impacts, spin up and sublimation.

Not really interested at this time on speculation, just concentrating on the data returned from 67P.

The dust is charged and there are electric fields at comet 67P, or are you still in the river de nile?
 
Do not forget that it has never been shown, nor suggested (iirc), that electrostatic charging can lift sub-micron sized grains. The experiments that have been done are on particles of the order of tens of microns.



Negatively charged nano-grains at 67P/Churyumov-Gerasimenko


The fact that the beam of negatively charged “outbound” particles is in
termittent and nearly mono-energetic is probably associated with a local peak in the grain size distribution.

Beams, collimated????

The effects of dust outbursts on the anomalistic features observed by Rosetta Alice around 67P/Churyumov-Gerasimenko

This comparison showed that simulations performed using nanograins entering the slit would created similar shapes as seen on February 19th, evidence that the most common appearance of the AF is caused by dust. For future UVS missions to unique and extreme environments in terms of dust, ions, and electrons, more research into this AF will determine if there are possible instrument enhancements that could mitigate the intensity
or even appearance of the AF, an ion repeller grid for example.
 
Last edited:
The dust is charged and there are electric fields at comet 67P, or are you still in the river de nile?

And the dust is charged at asteroids, and there is an electric field. Fail. No mechanism, no evidence, no science. As usual.
 
Do you think it’s happening at comet 67P, though?

This is the bit you’ve been looking for as the mechanism to release the dust from rock...


Mihály Horányi

The man is onto it!


This dust is the under the influence of the electric field and ......dust jets!
 
Last edited:
Do you think it’s happening at comet 67P, though?

This is the bit you’ve been looking for as the mechanism to release the dust from rock...



Mihály Horányi

The man is onto it!


This dust is the under the influence of the electric field and ......dust jets!

Lies. He is saying nothing of the sort. Quit lying and making crap up.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom