The Electric Comet Theory Part IV/SAFIRE

Status
Not open for further replies.
Plasma physics in relation to comets superstition nonsense??

How? Maybe you’d could explain yourself a little better.

Why bother? You have little hope of understanding.

For myself, I am content to watch you embarrass yourself proposing and supporting such garbage.

To me, such flailing is entertainment.
 
When the electric field strength is high enough for the rocky nucleus to being emmiting dust.

Ceres has the same composition as Bennu...and Tempel 1

And, as I have pointed out before, this is a strike against the EC woo! Asteroids are permanently exposed to the solar wind. A comet will have its highest charges when the solar wind also has permanent access to the surface.
In the case of asteroids, this is not causing a dust coma, except in an infinitesimally small percentage, and that likely due to other mechanisms. This includes a shed load on eccentric orbits. A fact that you continually fail to address, and wrecks your EC woo. Strike one.
So, back to comets; the time when they have their highest charge, due to charging from the solar wind, is the time when they are least dusty! Strike two. And then, as the solar wind is excluded, and the only charging is tiny, and coming from the photoelectric effect, they become dustier! Strike three, you are out.
Don't like baseball? Prefer cricket? I'm sure I can come up with at least seven more fatal flaws in your woo to leave you all out for 0.
 
Time for some words of wisdom from Tim Thompson from nearly 15 years ago;


There is no honesty in the electric cosmos, it is dominated by preconception. You can see this clearly in the way they practice "science by exegesis", using literary techniques, and criticizing phrases & passages. But when they try to follow the form of "science", suggesting "scientific" explanations, like the simple circuit model for a solar flare, they can't even make their own model physically consistent with their own explanation! When do you finally decide that enough is enough? How many gross, simple factual errors do you think are OK, before you are willing to call something "stupid"? I actually have a pretty decent level of tolerance for error based on ignorance, but errors based on a fundamental dishonesty are intolerable when peddled as "science". At its core, the electric cosmos is based on dishonesty, not science, and you cannot ever tolerate that.

https://forum.cosmoquest.org/showthread.php?28596-Electric-Universe-Model&p=477320#post477320
 
Why bother? You have little hope of understanding.

For myself, I am content to watch you embarrass yourself proposing and supporting such garbage.

To me, such flailing is entertainment.
Sol88’s posts in this thread certainly do have considerable entertainment value! :p
 
Why bother? You have little hope of understanding.

For myself, I am content to watch you embarrass yourself proposing and supporting such garbage.

To me, such flailing is entertainment.


Grab the :popcorn1 sport and settle in, it’s just starting to get interesting!
 
Sol88’s posts in this thread certainly do have considerable entertainment value! :p


The dust is being emitted and accelerated form the comet via a complex interaction with surface electric fields, ambipolar electric fields, Hall electric field and the solar wind motional electric field.

Your job jt, is to prove me wrong.

Sublimation not needed. :D
 
These currents produced move in curcuits. The charged dust constitutes part of this current system.

Electrons go one way, ions the other.

All pretty mainstream. :)
 
The dust is being emitted and accelerated form the comet via a complex interaction with surface electric fields, ambipolar electric fields, Hall electric field and the solar wind motional electric field.

Your job jt, is to prove me wrong.

Sublimation not needed. :D

Wrong. Nobody is saying that that is how the dust is being accelerated. Only you, and you know Jack about the relevant science. Therefore it is not up to us to disprove this idiocy - that isn't how science works - it is up to you to prove it. And, for the umpteenth time - sublimation is OBSERVED. Therefore your woo is not required.
 
These currents produced move in curcuits. The charged dust constitutes part of this current system.

Electrons go one way, ions the other.

All pretty mainstream. :)

Which is not observed, and nor is anyone claiming such a thing. Fail.
 
Grab the :popcorn1 sport and settle in, it’s just starting to get interesting!

No, it is not getting interesting. The data is in. You lost. Your laughably silly 'model' failed miserably. Zero evidence, zero mechanisms, zero science.
 
No, it is not getting interesting. The data is in. You lost. Your laughably silly 'model' failed miserably. Zero evidence, zero mechanisms, zero science.


Such a tosser, jd116.

You are completely ignorant :(

Gave you a viable mechanism and you choose to ignore it.

What makes you think the ambipolar electric field is not accelerating NEGATIVELY CHARGED DUST of the nucleus?

The root of a comet tail - Rosetta ion observations at comet 67P/Churyumov--Gerasimenko

Onthe ion-neutral coupling in cometary comae

Size of a plasma cloud matters & Astrophysics The polarisation electric field of a small-scale comet ionosphere

Cometary Dust

Electron and Ion Dynamics of the Solar Wind Interaction with a Weakly Outgassing Comet

Energy conversion in cometary atmospheres Hybrid modeling of 67P/Churyumov–Gerasimenko

Spontaneous formation of nonspherical water ice grains in a plasma environment

Surface charging and electrostatic dust acceleration at the nucleus of comet 67P during periods of low activity

Is near-surface ice the driver of dust activity on 67P/Churyumov-Gerasimenko

Unexpected and significant findings in comet 67P/Churyumov–Gerasimenko: an interdisciplinary view

Possible observation of charged nanodust from comet 67P/Churyumov

We emphasize that the solar wind density is highly variable in time, accordingly the surface potential of the nucleus and the energy of the charged nanodust particles fluctuate as well.




Sublimation can not do it as quite a few papers have said.
 
Such a tosser, jd116.

You are completely ignorant :(

Gave you a viable mechanism and you choose to ignore it.

What makes you think the ambipolar electric field is not accelerating NEGATIVELY CHARGED DUST of the nucleus?

The root of a comet tail - Rosetta ion observations at comet 67P/Churyumov--Gerasimenko

Onthe ion-neutral coupling in cometary comae

Size of a plasma cloud matters & Astrophysics The polarisation electric field of a small-scale comet ionosphere

Cometary Dust

Electron and Ion Dynamics of the Solar Wind Interaction with a Weakly Outgassing Comet

Energy conversion in cometary atmospheres Hybrid modeling of 67P/Churyumov–Gerasimenko

Spontaneous formation of nonspherical water ice grains in a plasma environment

Surface charging and electrostatic dust acceleration at the nucleus of comet 67P during periods of low activity

Is near-surface ice the driver of dust activity on 67P/Churyumov-Gerasimenko

Unexpected and significant findings in comet 67P/Churyumov–Gerasimenko: an interdisciplinary view

Possible observation of charged nanodust from comet 67P/Churyumov






Sublimation can not do it as quite a few papers have said.

Sublimation is observed. Therefore your model is dead. The ambipolar field, if it exists, is not happening anywhere near the nucleus when the solar wind is nowhere near the nucleus. Fail. None of this has anything to do with EDM, or discharges, or asteroids on elliptical orbits failing to turn into comets. You failed. Totally. No evidence, no mechanism, no science.
 
What makes you think the ambipolar electric field is not accelerating NEGATIVELY CHARGED DUST of the nucleus?

Because any putative ambipolar field cannot occur until the cometary electrons and ions have been picked up by the solar wind. A solar wind that is getting nowhere near the nucleus for long periods when the comet is at its dustiest. Duh!
 
The dust is being emitted and accelerated form the comet via a complex interaction with surface electric fields, ambipolar electric fields, Hall electric field and the solar wind motional electric field.

Your job jt, is to prove me wrong.

Sublimation not needed. :D


Hey Sol, not so many buzzwords in one post, please. The game's no fun if we all get bingo at the same time. Seriously, can you explain the concept behind the Hall effect in your own words? No fair Googling! To be fair, maybe you can. I know for ****-sure you can't explain how it applies to your electric rock.
 
Sublimation is observed. Therefore your model is dead. The ambipolar field, if it exists, is not happening anywhere near the nucleus when the solar wind is nowhere near the nucleus. Fail. None of this has anything to do with EDM, or discharges, or asteroids on elliptical orbits failing to turn into comets. You failed. Totally. No evidence, no mechanism, no science.

We’re not talking transient frost patches, we’re talking about the nucleus being mostly ice.

There is no surface sublimation observed. Sublimation is not a viable mechanism to remove μm size dust, it’s a busted flush champ, according to the new papers

.
 
Hey Sol, not so many buzzwords in one post, please. The game's no fun if we all get bingo at the same time. Seriously, can you explain the concept behind the Hall effect in your own words? No fair Googling! To be fair, maybe you can. I know for ****-sure you can't explain how it applies to your electric rock.

Hello Freddie :w2:
 
Because any putative ambipolar field cannot occur until the cometary electrons and ions have been picked up by the solar wind. A solar wind that is getting nowhere near the nucleus for long periods when the comet is at its dustiest. Duh!

Oh...:o

I see you a still struggling to come to terms with Electron and Ion Dynamics of the Solar Wind Interaction with a Weakly Outgassing Comet

Identifying the origin of the suprathermal electron populationdeliverscluestothephysicalmechanismbehindtheir acceleration or heating in the collisionless coma. Two mechanisms have been discussed in literature thus far: (i) heating of electrons through wave particle interactions, such as the singing comet waves (understood as an ion Weibel instability [43,52]) or lower hybrid waves [45], and (ii) the acceleration of electrons along the ambipolar electric field [29]. In the second scenario, solar wind electrons traveling toward the comet fall into the potential well that is generated by the gradient in electron number density [53,54]. Electrons born inside, i.e., the cometary electrons, are trapped unless they carry enough energy to escape. The potential scales as the electron thermal energy [29]; hence, only suprathermal electrons will be able to escape the nearcomet environment. Note that this interpretation is valid on subion time scales only, as quasineutrality will act such that electrons must eventually leave the potential well. Without ruling out the influence of wave particle interactions, our simulation favors the ambipolar electric field model, though this may not be the case atotheractivityphasesofthecomet.


Grab a cup of coffee sit down and have a good read ‘ol mate. :D

Standard mainstream plasma physics, in a peer reviewed paper. :thumbsup:
 
Electron and Ion Dynamics of the Solar Wind Interaction with a Weakly Outgassing Comet

Has nothing to do with a comet when it is at its most active. As the authors pointed out for the hard of thinking in the title.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom