The Electric Comet Theory Part IV/SAFIRE

Status
Not open for further replies.
A stupid "these asteroids and comets" question to derail from electric comet insanity

What's the difference between these asteroids and comets?
A stupid "these asteroids and comets" question to derail from his electric comet insanity.

He conceded that comets are made of ices and dust. Asteroids are actual rock :eye-poppi! There is some evidence that a few asteroids have water ice on their surface.

Sol88's electric comet insanity:
Sol88's comet delusions include comets are rocks; these rocks were blasted from the Earth including recently; blasting was by electrical discharges between Earth and Venus; an imaginary solar electric field charges up comets; the charge causes never detected electrical discharges; comet jets are electrical discharges; images show that comets are rocks; Birkeland currents in comets and their tails with no appropriate magnetic field; papers using bedrock to describe layers of ices support his comet are rock delusion, imaginary double layers do magic; many years of lying that ices have not been detected on comets, a "hard shell of refractory +material on the outside" lie, insanity of consolidated ices and dust in papers being rock, an insane spate of lies about ices and dust papers.
Totally inane delusions about charge separation doing magic. Stupidly thinks that a ambipolar electric field is a double layer.
Insanity of dust removal from the surface changing measured comet density
Electrical discharge machining insanity.
A repeated insane insult of Michael A’Hearn.
 
"water from hydrated minerals" idiocy emphasizes his electric comet insanity

but, yes they are still ROCK (Hydrated silicates etc), unequivical the estimated "outgassing" is wrong and water from hydrated minerals is more than enough to supply the coma
"outgassing" delusion and "water from hydrated minerals" idiocy emphasizes his electric comet insanity.

Back to his insanity of actual ROCK rather then rock (ices and dust).
Added his delusion that the estimates of outgassing form ices are wrong.
Added his "water from hydrated minerals" idiocy.

Sol88's electric comet insanity:
Sol88's comet delusions include comets are rocks; these rocks were blasted from the Earth including recently; blasting was by electrical discharges between Earth and Venus; an imaginary solar electric field charges up comets; the charge causes never detected electrical discharges; comet jets are electrical discharges; images show that comets are rocks; Birkeland currents in comets and their tails with no appropriate magnetic field; papers using bedrock to describe layers of ices support his comet are rock delusion, imaginary double layers do magic; many years of lying that ices have not been detected on comets, a "hard shell of refractory +material on the outside" lie, insanity of consolidated ices and dust in papers being rock, an insane spate of lies about ices and dust papers.
Totally inane delusions about charge separation doing magic. Stupidly thinks that a ambipolar electric field is a double layer.
Insanity of dust removal from the surface changing measured comet density
Electrical discharge machining insanity.
A repeated insane insult of Michael A’Hearn.
A delusion that the estimates of outgassing form ices are wrong.
"water from hydrated minerals" idiocy.
 
The EC mob have never numerically modeled the plasma because as you state PLASMA is JUST PLASMA!

Mainstream take the same approach as gravity only mathamajiks and mmmmmmm..... the plasma does not do as the maths says it should!

This argument goes back some 50-60yrs.

My bold;
And there you are sooooooo wrong.
Plasma physics is one of the most elegant (imho) parts of physics, just because plasmas do actually adhere to the plasma physics math. Just write down the dielectric tensor for a plasma, and the wave modes just roll out, exactly as they are observed in the plasma.

The EC mob never numerically modeled plasma, because they don't have the physical or mathematical knowledge to do something like that.
 
So now the cats out of the bag, are you willing to discuss in what context might circuit theory come into play at comets, or at least 67P?

Or is that getting a bit close?

Not sure what "getting a bit close" means, but anywho:

I told that the terms that Jesper Lindkvist wrote down soundet circuit theory-ish, with the emphasis on "ish". Because he does not have a circuit, he has a hybrid numerical model, where he can calculate the properties of the interactino around a comet. These properties include particle densities, electric currents, magnetic and electric fields, etc.
Now there are regions where one can calculate the dot product of the electric field and the current, which might be positive or negative, which if one considers an electrical circuit would be corresponding to a generator or a load.

If you look over large scales (intergrate), and that would be over larger scales than MHD(!) then you can try to reduce what is seen in the hybrid model into an equivalent circuit, but of course you lose a lot of the actual plasma physics that is happening, and in fact is is even worse that your abhorred MHD>

Your above response will have a bearing on discussing further “electrified dusty plasma” and the “ion” tail and its implication on cometary displays!

What the frak is an "electrified" dusty plasma

For instance could this dusty plasma be able to carry a significant current? We see FAC mention in relation to to comet tail.

Plasmas can carry currents, whether they are dusty or not.
Do we see "FAC mention in relation to to comet tail"?
Cometary ion tails, just like the Earth magnetotail are mainly characterized to current perpendicular to the magnetic field.
 
Just like to add for clarity, the Kinetic Plasma Processes are that are important, are part of a larger circuit.

Any kinetic plasma modeling will be integrated out if you want to describe the comet with a circuit model.
 
<snip>
EDM is turning said hydrated ROCK in to refractory dust and H2O, CO2, CO,......
<snip>
Of course it isn't. As no radio (etc) signal from any EDM in comets has ever been detected (you have evidence - quantitative, independently verifiable evidence - that says otherwise? Let's see it then!).

But as I'm pretty sure you really struggle with plasma physics (do you know what the dielectric tensor for a plasma is? wave modes?), I'll tell you an optical (can see with one's own eyes) story.

Once upon a time, there was a great scientist, named Birkeland. He did some pioneering work on plasmas (as we call them today), and among his publications is a report of a discharge, in his lab, which sorta resembles Saturn's rings. He proposed that something like this discharge was, in fact, the cause of said rings.

While Birkeland was, without any doubt, a great scientist, he was quite unfamiliar with the literature in astronomy (can't really blame him, before the days of the internet becoming familiar was very time-consuming). Had he been, he'd have realized that his proposal was inconsistent with observation.

How?

In his discharge proposal, the rings would have to be self-luminous (i.e. they'd shine by their own light, not needing the Sun (or Saturn) to create reflected light). Yet they were observed - a few decades earlier - to not be self-luminous.

Huh?

As the Earth and Saturn orbit in planes that are a few degrees different, it is possible - ~once or twice every Saturn period - for us here on Earth to see the "unlit" side of the rings. If the rings were self-luminous they'd be ~as visible when unlit as when lit (assuming a similar Sun angle). Yet they were observed to be clearly very different ... hence convincing evidence that Birkeland's idea is inconsistent with observation.

Which brings me to EDM being what comets' jets are about (per your Electric Comet Idea).

In your EDM idea, the jets will be screamingly self-luminous. Yet no one has observed them to be like that. Hence convincing evidence that your EDM/jets idea is inconsistent with observation. Unless, that is, you have evidence - quantitative, independently verifiable evidence - that says otherwise? Do you?
 
In your EDM idea, the jets will be screamingly self-luminous. Yet no one has observed them to be like that. Hence convincing evidence that your EDM/jets idea is inconsistent with observation. Unless, that is, you have evidence - quantitative, independently verifiable evidence - that says otherwise? Do you?

This reminds me of something else; there was a discussion on BAUT/ CQ some years ago which I wasn't involved in. I only read it in the last couple of years, as I went through the various EU discussions on there. One poster (VanderL, iirc) was pushing the observed jets on Wild 2 as some sort of electric woo. I laughred when I read it, as I'm sure I saw those images, and there was an obvious shadow! Which obviously wouldn't be there were the jet self-luminous. Sadly, I wasn't around on that forum back then, otherwise I'd have pointed out the obvious!
The same goes for a discharge that Sol has been prattling on about, and was featured on the Thunderdolts boobtube channel. It was this one;

https://www.space.com/38590-frozen-comet-fart-caught-on-camera.html

Spot the shadow, anybody? Lol.
 
Talking of BAUT/ CQ, here is a post from 23 Feb 2007, by a certain 'starboy', who was a sock puppet of Sol88, after he got his sorry arse banned off of there;

In reply to this question by PhantonWolf;

And besides, aren't you pinning a lot on the MS being wrong? You willing to admit you are wrong when they find large amounts of ice under the surface of a comet?

.....starboy said;

Totally willing to admit that what I believe is wrong, with no reservations!

Are you willing to do the same when none or very little ice is found?

I hope you are, the house of cards is resting very precariously at the moment! And ice's on/in a comet nucleus is what the cards are resting on.

Not long afterwards we had the papers from the Tempel 1 impact which showed ice in the ejecta! Seen by the DI spacecraft, and also others. Quite a lot of it, as it happens.
And yet here we are, nearly 12 years on, and Sol is still in denial. His faith must be strong (read 'brainwashed').

https://forum.cosmoquest.org/showthread.php?41761-Electric-Comets&p=932834#post932834
 
Last edited:
And yet here we are, nearly 12 years on, and Sol is still in denial. His faith must be strong (read 'brainwashed').
To be charitable, there is a slight chance that 12 years later Sol88's "brainwashing" may have conceded to the real world. Lately he seems to have realized that comets are actually made of ices and dust. I call this chance slight because
  • There has been no clear statement from him that comets are made of ices and dust.
  • He is persisting with delusions about the dust ("rock") such as impossible electrical discharge machining doing magic.
  • There is still an obsession with the use of geological terms to describe comet features.
  • He is lying about/in denial of the reality of having ices on comets.
Consider 67P which may have a dust/ices ratio of up to 6. The surface of 67P surface is a mixture of mostly dust and some ices. When 67P got close to the Sun, conditions were such that the ices must sublimate. There must be gas emitted. That is the source of the gas in the comet coma and tail.
Now add the observed terrain which include pits and fractured cliffs. Sublimating ices inside pits and fractures will create jets! We have images of jets from inside pits. We have traced jets back to their origins.
 
We had Matt Taylor on the 'Rosetta Blog' addressing some of the EU wooists claims about the jets. At the time there was no indication of anything even remotely self-luminous. The vast majority of jets were less luminous than the nucleus. Which has an albedo of ~ 4%! A few were brighter than the nucleus. Spectroscopy of those jets shows us that it is sunlight reflected from dust.
 
Last edited:
To be charitable, there is a slight chance that 12 years later Sol88's "brainwashing" may have conceded to the real world. Lately he seems to have realized that comets are actually made of ices and dust.

Ahhh, he is saying that Wal and Dave got it wrong regarding these things being blasted off of rocky planets by electric woo? I guess we can call that progress. Of a sort.
 
Well at least we've advanced to MINERAL ORGANICES

This constraint confirms that comets can be defined as “mineral organices”
(Fulle et al. 2016b), i.e. a mixture of minerals and organics with a minor mass fraction of ices mixed among them,

Which is close enough to jd116 refractory dust.

So, A'Hearn says "our" understanding is evolving toward mostly rock!

So comets are now rockydirt balls?

One things for sure the dirtysnowball is dead!
 
Last edited:
Well at least we've advanced to MINERAL ORGANICES



Which is close enough to jd116 refractory dust.

So, A'Hearn says "our" understanding is evolving toward mostly rock!

So comets are now rockydirt balls?

One things for sure the dirtysnowball is dead!

Nope, no rock ever detected at a comet. End of story.
 
So, given the previous, I think that we can safely conclude the following;

ELECTRIC COMET = EPIC FAILURE
 
Well at least we've advanced to MINERAL ORGANICES



Which is close enough to jd116 refractory dust.

So, A'Hearn says "our" understanding is evolving toward mostly rock!

So comets are now rockydirt balls?

One things for sure the dirtysnowball is dead!
And this pertains to the Electric Comet Theory (or Model) - you know, the topic of this thread - how, exactly?

Don't you think it's time for the trolling to stop, Sol88?
 
MINERAL ORGANICES gibberish to derail from his electric comet insanity

Well at least we've advanced to MINERAL ORGANICES
MINERAL ORGANICES idiocy and gibberish to derail from his electric comet insanity.

The Refractory-to-Ice Mass Ratio in Comets
We review the complex relationship between the dust-to-gas mass ratio usually estimated in the material lost by comets, and the refractory-to-ice mass ratio inside the nucleus, which constrains the origin of comets.
...
Therefore, comets and KBOs may have less water than CI-chondrites, as predicted by models of comet formation by the gravitational collapse of cm-sized pebbles driven by streaming instabilities in the protoplanetary disc.
Usual idiocy of citing a mainstream ices and dust comet paper.

"a mixture of minerals and organics with a minor mass fraction of ices mixed among them" is not just refractory dust as anyone can read. “mineral organics” is
  • Refractory dust and
  • Organics and
  • ices
This is the origin of comets in the early Solar System (ices and dust) and well known chemistry of sunlight acting on the surface ices.

A'Hearn said that our understanding of the composition of comets was evolving to more dust ("mostly rock").

Sol88's electric comet insanity:
Sol88's comet delusions include comets are rocks; these rocks were blasted from the Earth including recently; blasting was by electrical discharges between Earth and Venus; an imaginary solar electric field charges up comets; the charge causes never detected electrical discharges; comet jets are electrical discharges; images show that comets are rocks; Birkeland currents in comets and their tails with no appropriate magnetic field; papers using bedrock to describe layers of ices support his comet are rock delusion, imaginary double layers do magic; many years of lying that ices have not been detected on comets, a "hard shell of refractory +material on the outside" lie, insanity of consolidated ices and dust in papers being rock, an insane spate of lies about ices and dust papers.
Totally inane delusions about charge separation doing magic. Stupidly thinks that a ambipolar electric field is a double layer.
Insanity of dust removal from the surface changing measured comet density
Electrical discharge machining insanity.
A repeated insane insult of Michael A’Hearn.
A delusion that the estimates of outgassing form ices are wrong.
"water from hydrated minerals" idiocy.
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom