The Electric Comet Theory Part IV/SAFIRE

Status
Not open for further replies.
Another spate of ~336 items of ignorance, idiocy (citing irrelevant mainstream papers), delusion, derails, insults, and lies from 27 July 2018 to 14 November 2018
Another spate of ~366 items of ignorance, idiocy (citing irrelevant mainstream papers), delusion, derails, insults, and lies from 27 July 2018 to 21 November 2018

18 November 2010: The lies, failures and successes of Thunderbolts Deep Impact predictions by Wal Thornhill
10th April 2015: The ignorance, delusions and lies in the Thunderbolts web site, videos, etc.
13 April 2018: A couple of the delusions in Scott's Birkeland current paper.

The electric comet delusion has at least 45 years without a scientific electric comet model or observations to support it!

Over 3 years of the fear of doing basic physics: 25 June 2015 Sol88: Use a impact calculator to calculate the size of the crater on a comet made of rock by the Deep Impact impactor.
 
Last edited:
MINERAL ORGANICES idiocy and gibberish to derail from his electric comet insanity.

The Refractory-to-Ice Mass Ratio in Comets

Usual idiocy of citing a mainstream ices and dust comet paper.

"a mixture of minerals and organics with a minor mass fraction of ices mixed among them" is not just refractory dust as anyone can read. “mineral organics” is
  • Refractory dust and
  • Organics and
  • ices
This is the origin of comets in the early Solar System (ices and dust) and well known chemistry of sunlight acting on the surface ices.

A'Hearn said that our understanding of the composition of comets was evolving to more dust ("mostly rock").




A quote from M.A'Hearn
(c) What are comets made of?
At the simplest level, a very basic question is whether comets are mostly ice or mostly rock/dirt/refractory material. Whipple’s [2] model of the dirty snowball, the first quantitative model, envisioned cometary nuclei as mostly ice, although our understanding has been evolving more toward mostly rock, particularly for 67P/C-G for which refractory/volatile ratios as high as 6 have been cited [3,4].


Brand new latest paper from hard in situ data. The Refractory-to-Ice Mass Ratio in Comets
This constraint confirms that comets can be defined as “mineral organices” (Fulle et al. 2016b), i.e. a mixture of minerals and organics with a minor mass fraction of ices mixed among them

So you tell me on thing and the "experts" say another? :confused:

You aslo complete ignored the hard truth that asteroids and comets are a CONTINUUM! Not distinct separate objects.
4. Conclusion
In summary, the population of small bodies in our solar system today, including both minor planets and classical comets, is far less well-delineated into distinct groups of objects than the classical paradigm might have led one to believe in the past. These objects instead appear to occupy a continuum spanning the full range of observational, physical and dynamical properties classically attributed solely either to asteroids or comets

So that nullifies any song and dance jd16 and indagator would like to preform wrt eccentricity being the ONLY variable in the equation. Seems a bit simplistic.


So what's going on?
 
Last edited:
Not sure what "getting a bit close" means, but anywho:

I told that the terms that Jesper Lindkvist wrote down soundet circuit theory-ish, with the emphasis on "ish". Because he does not have a circuit, he has a hybrid numerical model, where he can calculate the properties of the interactino around a comet. These properties include particle densities, electric currents, magnetic and electric fields, etc.
Now there are regions where one can calculate the dot product of the electric field and the current, which might be positive or negative, which if one considers an electrical circuit would be corresponding to a generator or a load.

If you look over large scales (intergrate), and that would be over larger scales than MHD(!) then you can try to reduce what is seen in the hybrid model into an equivalent circuit, but of course you lose a lot of the actual plasma physics that is happening, and in fact is is even worse that your abhorred MHD>



What the frak is an "electrified" dusty plasma



Plasmas can carry currents, whether they are dusty or not.
Do we see "FAC mention in relation to to comet tail"?
Cometary ion tails, just like the Earth magnetotail are mainly characterized to current perpendicular to the magnetic field.

Except where they dont these are called BIRKELAND CURRENTS

Plasmas can carry currents, whether they are dusty or not.
Great do you think the tail structure from a comet constitutes part of Jesper Lindkvist "missing" circuit?
 
Not sure what "getting a bit close" means, but anywho:

I told that the terms that Jesper Lindkvist wrote down soundet circuit theory-ish, with the emphasis on "ish". Because he does not have a circuit, he has a hybrid numerical model, where he can calculate the properties of the interactino around a comet. These properties include particle densities, electric currents, magnetic and electric fields, etc.
Now there are regions where one can calculate the dot product of the electric field and the current, which might be positive or negative, which if one considers an electrical circuit would be corresponding to a generator or a load.

If you look over large scales (intergrate), and that would be over larger scales than MHD(!) then you can try to reduce what is seen in the hybrid model into an equivalent circuit, but of course you lose a lot of the actual plasma physics that is happening, and in fact is is even worse that your abhorred MHD>


How big's this circuit tusenfem?
 
So, given the previous, I think that we can safely conclude the following;

ELECTRIC COMET = EPIC FAILURE

At the simplest level, a very basic question is whether comets are mostly ice or mostly rock/dirt/refractory material.

Whipple’s [2] model of the dirty snowball, the first quantitative model, envisioned cometary nuclei as mostly ice.


This constraint confirms that comets can be defined as “mineral organices” (Fulle et al. 2016b), i.e. a mixture of minerals and organics with a minor mass fraction of ices mixed among them

Therefore, comets and KBOs may have less water than CI-chondrites, as predicted by models of comet formation by the gravitational collapse of cm-sized pebbles driven by streaming instabilities in the protoplanetary disc.

Ok, so a comet is...
A comet is an icy small Solar System body that, when passing close to the Sun, warms and begins to release gases, a process called outgassing.


Right, so comets are icy small Solar System bodies that outguess when passing close to the Sun.

So anything that "outgasses" is a comet all the others are asteroids/ meteoroid?

Except that is for ACTIVE ASTEROIDS. These are just like comets but do not have ice.

So I hope that clears up what is a comet and an asteroid are. :thumbsup:


So, given the previous, I think that we can safely conclude the following;

DIRTYSNOWBALL = EPIC FAILURE a very basic question is whether comets are mostly ice or mostly rock/dirt/refractory material.
 
Last edited:
Any kinetic plasma modeling will be integrated out if you want to describe the comet with a circuit model.


No it will not!

You will only uncover the circuit hierarchy! :D

You do not have enough supercomputer power to crunch those numbers, you struggle on just a lowly comet.
 
Because the internet never forgets, I thought I would step back a few days to address and correct a number of critical errors committed by our resident 'ec' expert ....

Told you MHD was not applicable at comets. That there was charge separation and the violation of quasi-neutrality!

Seems we have to PIC and there goes the MHD fantasy!

So i'm 100% confident "Double Layers" will be "discovered" at comets.

[size=+2]WRONG!!! And LAUGHABLE![/size]

First! MHD IS applicable at comets! You, Sol88, are WRONG! Yet again!

Second! MHD is not a fantasy! It is a very real horror for you and your 'electric universe' buddies (along with modeled and observed plasma physics involving 'frozen-in' magnetic fields and magnetic reconnection)!

Third! If you don't know what you're doing, both MHD and PIC models can, and will, FAIL at comets!

A hammer is only as good as the carpenter who swings it!

A mathematical model is only as good as the scientist who codes it!

Sol88! As it turns out, no one in your 'eu/es/ec' community has a clue about science, physics, chemistry, geology, mathematics, or modelling and simulation! Of course, MHD is applicable at comets! The real questions to ask are; What properties of a comet are you really trying to investigate? And how might the discovery of double layers 'AT' comets salvage your failed electric rock?

FACT! 'MHD' is a mathematical modelling tool based on Maxwell's equations and the dynamic (i.e., ballistic) movement of fluids. It is applicable to numerous practical problems in plasma physics, including comets. Assumptions must be made, and clearly stated, in order for this modelling technique to work!

FACT! 'Plasma Particle-In-Cell' is a mathematical modelling tool based on Maxwell's equations and the dynamic (i.e., ballistic) movement of particles. It is applicable to numerous practical problems in plasma physics, including comets. Assumptions must be made, and clearly stated, in order for this modelling technique to work!

What's the real difference, Sol88? Desparation! Someone does not care about science! Someone only seems to care about their religion being RIGHT! What happens to your world, Sol88, when you "discover" that you have been WRONG all along?

This next point is important for you and your 'electric universe' buddies to grok! None of you seem to understand the scientific method, mathematics, physics, astrophysics, plasma physics, and of course, electrical engineering!!! Because of this fundamental deficit in scientific understanding, no one in the 'electric universe' will ever build a predictive model of an electric comet! Because of this fundamental deficit in scientific understanding, no one in the 'electric universe' will ever build a predictive model of an electric star! Sadly, because the electric comet and electric star violate fundamental laws of physics, mainstream science cannot help you!

To conclude, double layers will 'NOT' be found 'AT' comets! **** :D Period! End of story!

And are you really 100% confident? Your confidence is exactly that of a priest!

A priest has 'absolute' confidence that 'gwad' exists, and one day, they will get to meet her!

You, Sol88, have absolute confidence that 'double layers' exist, and one day, they will be discovered at comets!

By the way, could you give me a quantitative description of the word 'AT' ...?

I see 'absolutely' no difference between you and a priest!

I see 'absolutely' no difference between your 'electric universe' and a religion!

Religion requires no science! Just faith! Religion requires no mathematics! Just faith! Religion requires no evidence or proof! Just faith!

Sol88! I would like to plant a seed in your brain (and the brains of any 'eu/es/ec' lurkers too scared and scarred to step forward).

I don't want to lie to you! Thornhill, Talbott, and Scott do!
I don't want your money! Thornhill, Talbott, and Scott do!
I don't want your blind obedience! Thornhill, Talbott, and Scott do!
I want you to think about science and mathematics! I want you to question ... everything! I want you to learn! Thornhill, Talbott, and Scott don't want you to do anything that upsets their income stream!

The folks at Thudderbutts need people like you to keep recruiting and sending them money!

The folks at Thudderbutts don't want you to think! They have put you inside a box and told you what to think, do, and say regarding astronomy and astrophysics, to name but two! The more you learn about the real world, the less appealing your 'electric religion' will appear. Be genuinely skeptical! Think about your own model's lack of evidence and it's violations of fundamental physics! Think about why I say there is no evidence! Think about why I say the 'eu/es/ec' violates fundamental physics (maybe I'm right and Sol88 is wrong)! Think about why I have come here and what my motives are.

PostScript ---

[size=+2]Using electrostatics, electrodynamics, and orbital mechanics, show how eccentricity is responsible for the charging and discharging of your electric comet![/size]

Tis an IMPOSSIBLE task, Sol88! Eccentricity has nothing to do with the charging and discharging of an electric rock! One of the foundational elements of the electric comet is observationally WRONG!

What do you do? Double down? Or wonder if the whole house of cards is about to collapse?
 
Last edited:
At the simplest level, a very basic question is whether comets are mostly ice or mostly rock/dirt/refractory material.

Whipple’s [2] model of the dirty snowball, the first quantitative model, envisioned cometary nuclei as mostly ice.


This constraint confirms that comets can be defined as “mineral organices” (Fulle et al. 2016b), i.e. a mixture of minerals and organics with a minor mass fraction of ices mixed among them

Therefore, comets and KBOs may have less water than CI-chondrites, as predicted by models of comet formation by the gravitational collapse of cm-sized pebbles driven by streaming instabilities in the protoplanetary disc.

Ok, so a comet is...


Right, so comets are icy small Solar System bodies that outguess when passing close to the Sun.

So anything that "outgasses" is a comet all the others are asteroids/ meteoroid?

Except that is for ACTIVE ASTEROIDS. These are just like comets but do not have ice.

So I hope that clears up what is a comet and an asteroid are. :thumbsup:


So, given the previous, I think that we can safely conclude the following;

DIRTYSNOWBALL = EPIC FAILURE a very basic question is whether comets are mostly ice or mostly rock/dirt/refractory material.

Nope, there is ice and dust. As proven. They are not rock. As proven. There is no electrical woo. As proven. Your religion is a failure. As proven. T & T have never got a single thing right about comets, due to being scientifically illiterate. As proven. Give it up. Your fantasy is dead. It was never alive. It is pure woo. It relies on impossible lightning bolts blasting rock off of planets. Only a six year old could believe such idiocy. Are you an idiot, Sol? Are you six years old? What other excuse do you have for believing this puerile woo?
 
Except where they dont these are called BIRKELAND CURRENTS

But field aligned currents only happen seldomly in the cometary tail, basically only when there is a tail detachment event happening.

Great do you think the tail structure from a comet constitutes part of Jesper Lindkvist "missing" circuit?

You would have a very hard job trying to put Lindkvist's model into a circuit theory, which apparently you still do not understand.
You hear terms, start using them, but you totally do not understand what they mean.
 
How'd you calculate the 250 000l/s from Hale-Bopp? The Haser model?

It doesn't matter. The Haser model underestimates the outgassing at 67P, so this may be a lower estimate. What you can't explain, is that 9 years after its apparition, Thornhill and Talbott lied to you about there being water detected at comets. Pretended it was only OH. Why did they lie, and why did you fall for it?
Gullible six year olds spring to mind again.
 
So that nullifies any song and dance jd16 and indagator would like to preform wrt eccentricity being the ONLY variable in the equation. Seems a bit simplistic.


So what's going on?

Nope, the vast majority of asteroids DO NOT outgas. Some that do are in circular orbits. Some comets in circular orbits outgas. Many asteroids in elliptical orbits DO NOT outgas. Comets outgas because they have ice close to the surface, which gets heated. Asteroids generally don't. Ergo, eccentricity has nothing to do with it. There is no radial electric field, no discharges and no electric sun (lol). You have there a busted flush, don't you?
 
How big's this circuit tusenfem?

How would I know, probably very small, because you are talking about a circuit representation of plasma physics, which means that you average everything to get bulk parameters like total resistivity, total capacitance, total current, etc. and then you put those components into a circuit and then ... you have a circuit which may (or may not depending on how you build the circuit) describe the large scale bulk properties of the system that you are looking at.

You basically loose all the plasma physics that is happening, as Walter Heikkila writes in the introduction:

WH said:
Circuit analysis is not a full description of the physics, being a scalar relationship.

(you might like him, because he did not approve of MRX)
 
Tis an IMPOSSIBLE task, Sol88! Eccentricity has nothing to do with the charging and discharging of an electric rock! One of the foundational elements of the electric comet is observationally WRONG!

What do you do? Double down? Or wonder if the whole house of cards is about to collapse?[/QUOTE]

So whats the difference between a asteroid and a comet?

it a very basic question
a very basic question is whether comets are mostly ice or mostly rock/dirt/refractory material.

So what are they Indagator, mostly ice or mostly rock?

:D

MHD at comets, that was a good one! :)

PS

How much $$$ did i pay again?

PSS

Eccentricity has nothing to do with the charging and discharging of an electric rock! Omuamua the alien spaceship because what else could it be!



Oh dear, it's most defiantly NOT em effects!
 
Last edited:
So what are they Indagator, mostly ice or mostly rock?

Definitely not rock. No rock ever detected at comets. The density alone should make that obvious, even to a gullible six year old.
 
How would I know, probably very small, because you are talking about a circuit representation of plasma physics, which means that you average everything to get bulk parameters like total resistivity, total capacitance, total current, etc. and then you put those components into a circuit and then ... you have a circuit which may (or may not depending on how you build the circuit) describe the large scale bulk properties of the system that you are looking at.

You basically loose all the plasma physics that is happening, as Walter Heikkila writes in the introduction:



(you might like him, because he did not approve of MRX)

Ok thought so, thanks anyway
 
Definitely not rock. No rock ever detected at comets. The density alone should make that obvious, even to a gullible six year old.

Oh so A'Hearn is wrong! :rolleyes:

Comets are mostly ice even poor Marco Fulle got it wrong he thinks comets are mostly refractory dust!

Ahhh comet density!
 
because the electric comet and electric star violate fundamental laws of physics, mainstream science cannot help you!

Standard plasma physics!

Nothing is being violated except the illusion you know what comets are!
 
Oh so A'Hearn is wrong! :rolleyes:

Comets are mostly ice even poor Marco Fulle got it wrong he thinks comets are mostly refractory dust!

Ahhh comet density!

No rock. As proven. Just dust, ice and organics. As opposed to actual rock, which is obviously what the asteroids Steins and Lutetia are composed of, as confirmed by Rosetta density measurements at those bodies. Which were not outgassing.
 
Nope, the vast majority of asteroids DO NOT outgas. Some that do are in circular orbits. Some comets in circular orbits outgas. Many asteroids in elliptical orbits DO NOT outgas. Comets outgas because they have ice close to the surface, which gets heated. Asteroids generally don't. Ergo, eccentricity has nothing to do with it. There is no radial electric field, no discharges and no electric sun (lol). You have there a busted flush, don't you?

So Henry H. Hsieh's paper Asteroid–comet continuum objects in the solar system

Address's your very concerns sport!

Remember the only tools you have to explain everything about these objects is random impact and "spin up".

So with just those tools explain Oumuamua's
"excess acceleration,"

You cant do it, neither could I!
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom