What's the difference between these asteroids and comets?
Aaaaannnnddd another refusal to answer the question. According to the idiot Thornhill, comets are just asteroids on elliptical orbits. Indagator supplied a list (certainly not exhaustive) of numerous asteroids, on comet-like elliptical orbits that do not behave as comets. Why are they not behaving as comets? You indicated that it was some idiocy about hydrated minerals. Lol. Leaving aside how the hell you are getting various volatiles out of the minerals, I have shown that many of those asteroids will have more hydrated minerals than comets. So, that cannot be the answer, can it?
So, we have ruled out ellipticity, and we have ruled out hydrated minerals as having anything to do with the outgassing volatiles. We have previously ruled out the solar wind as a contributor, given that it isn't reaching the area where volatiles are detected for many months. We can rule out any electric woo, as that would show up in the mag data.
So, what is left, Sol? It couldn't possibly be the ices revealed by spectroscopy on the surface and, by a dirty great impact, below the surface, could it?
If you'd stop doing a song and dance for long enough to realise even you can NOT give a clear definitive answer to what a comet and asteroid are made of.
I am not making a song and dance about anything. You are spamming this forum with an idiotic idea which has been well and truly debunked, is unscientific, and has zero evidence to support it. One of the idiots who invented this idiocy claimed that comets are just asteroids on eccentric orbits. I am pointing out that that is just plain wrong. And yes, I can tell you what comets are made of - dust, of which there are two basic types; fluffy (~ 1 kg/m
3), and compact (~ 3000 kg/m
3). There are also volatiles in the form of various ices. In addition to that, there are organics on the surface. All of this dust and ice is in a very porous mix, with ~ 75% porosity overall. This results in a density of ~ 500 kg/m
3.
Asteroids, generally, are rocky bodies, with densities around 2000 - 3000 kg/m
3. This implies that they are composed of rock. The sort of rock you might find on a planet or moon. Some of them are rubble piles, some, such as Lutetia, appear to be more compact. With very few exceptions, they do not outgas. Even the ones on highly elliptical orbits. Which may make them extinct comets, as it happens, but I digress. Of the only one whose date we have tested from sample return, they are commensurate in age with the solar system (4.64 Ga, iirc). As, no doubt, are comets.
This is clear from your refusal to debate about Omuamua and I fear refusal to answer why the "asteroids that have been shown to have water-ice on their surfaces" are not comets by standard mainstream 1+1=2 mentality.
I am not going to get sidetracked by a discussion on an irrelevant extrasolar object, about which we know sod all. There are plenty of asteroids in our own system to observe. This thread is about the electric comet, and the complete lack of evidence for it. And the complete lack of a mechanism that would explain why comets are actually just asteroids, but suddenly light up like the 4th of July when they approach the Sun.
So far, we have no viable explanation for this that matches observation and evidence. Zilch. It is dead. It was never alive. It is the brainchild of two neo-Velikovskian loons, who were possibly drugged up when they wrote it. I can think of no other explanation for grown men to conceive of something so wretchedly unscientific. Hopefully they are getting help. They need it.