The Electric Comet Theory Part IV/SAFIRE

Status
Not open for further replies.
Well, I feel like we've made some progress in the last couple of post!

tusenfems help on confirming comet plasma processes maybe circuit theory-ish along with electric fields, violation of quasi-neutrality is :thumbsup:

and me 'ol mate jd116 over here now says A'Hearne really meant refractory dust not rock even though jd116 goes on to explain that get enough of it together heat it and voila ROCK.

So me thinks to me self, the STARDUST mission bought back cometary samples that indeed showed this very fact.

Coupled with the fact that the CONSOLIDATED terrain displays scarps, fractures, over hangs, boulders, rocks.

You are still prepared to stand toe to toe and argue if the comet is real rock or "comet rock"?

Although it is evolving toward mainly rock.

Now, as for your challenge
Asteroids are rock. They don't behave like comets. Why not?
hows 'bout we work on a mutual problem?

Oumuamua.


The way i read it because the mainstream REFUSE to entertain the notion that any sort of EM effects are excluded they're willing to entertain it may be extraterrestrial in nature?

What do you think jd116, asteroid? (then why the
These very careful observations showed that 'Oumuamua accelerated as it left the solar system, revealing the existence of "non-gravitational forces". This means that the trajectory of the object could not be explained just by the gravity of the sun and other major objects in our solar system.

Read more at: https://phys.org/news/2018-11-evidence-aliens-oumuamua-visitor-space.html#jCp
or a comet because of this same effect but wheres the ice?

or

its an alien spaceship because what else could it be?
 
You are still prepared to stand toe to toe and argue if the comet is real rock or "comet rock"?

Although it is evolving toward mainly rock.

Nope, rock has never been detected at a comet. Show the detection if you think otherwise. No rock, no discharges. EC is dead.
 
or a comet because of this same effect but wheres the ice?

or

its an alien spaceship because what else could it be?

Not interested. Answer indagator's question. Stop avoiding it. Why are a shed load of rocky asteroids behaving as asteroids and not comets? For the squillionth time.
 
even though jd116 goes on to explain that get enough of it together heat it and voila ROCK.

And if you heat sand you get glass. So what? Is your local beach a white glass beach, or a black glass beach? Or do you call it sand?
 
Trollin trollin trollin Sol just keeps on trollin
And why shouldn’t he?

Look at how much attention he gets ... for a few minutes’ typing on his keyboard, he gets long, sometimes detailed and well-researched, responses!

To be clear, there is ~zero scientific content in his posts, and there seems no intent to ever post any; trolling is an apt description.
 
And if you heat sand you get glass. So what? Is your local beach a white glass beach, or a black glass beach? Or do you call it sand?

Can we call the rock
This constraint confirms that comets can be defined as “mineral organices” (Fulle et al. 2016b), i.e. a mixture of minerals and organics with a minor mass fraction of ices mixed among them, and provides a disentangling test for all models describing the (probably common) origin of comets and KBOs.
The Refractory-to-Ice Mass Ratio in Comets

Minor mass fraction from ice :relieved:

So A’Hearn was on the money, mainstreams understanding of what comets are made from is evolving toward mainly rock or mineral organices! :D
 
Last edited:
And why shouldn’t he?

Look at how much attention he gets ... for a few minutes’ typing on his keyboard, he gets long, sometimes detailed and well-researched, responses!

To be clear, there is ~zero scientific content in his posts, and there seems no intent to ever post any; trolling is an apt description.

Oi, jt.

What are comets made of?

:D

Trolling trolling trolling rawhide! ;)

This is mainstream science “catching up” to the ELECTRIC COMET!
 
Not interested. Answer indagator's question. Stop avoiding it. Why are a shed load of rocky asteroids behaving as asteroids and not comets? For the squillionth time.

I don’t know and neither does the mainstream! :D

Though I suspect, at least for “outgassing”, it will be composition related.

More hydrated minerals more “outgassing”. ;) :thumbsup:
 
And prithee, what shalt the conductivity of "kinetic" plasmas be?

You hopefully do know that there is no such thing as a "kinetic" or a "fluid" plasma. These are two ways of numerically, that is in computer simulations, to deal with the development of plasmas. So it is the "fluid" or "kinetic" approach, the plasma is just plasma.

The EC mob have never numerically modeled the plasma because as you state PLASMA is JUST PLASMA!

Mainstream take the same approach as gravity only mathamajiks and mmmmmmm..... the plasma does not do as the maths says it should!

This argument goes back some 50-60yrs.
 
Oh yeah, I am feel very threatened.
I think you probably have an inferiority complex.
Isn't life wonderful?



No, it sounds very circuit theory-ish.
Ic cannot sound like an electric comet, because there is no electric comet model to check it with, so fail there.



What is "electrified dusty plasma" supposed to mean?



If that is what you got from Jesper's paper, one has to say "the confusion works deeply in this one" as it has absolutely, but really absolutely nothing to do with whether or not the nucleus of a comet is a "sublimating ice ball". There is a source term in the simulations and that is that. Jesper makes NO claims at all, about what the nucleus is composed of.


So now the cats out of the bag, are you willing to discuss in what context might circuit theory come into play at comets, or at least 67P?

Or is that getting a bit close?

Your above response will have a bearing on discussing further “electrified dusty plasma” and the “ion” tail and its implication on cometary displays!

For instance could this dusty plasma be able to carry a significant current? We see FAC mention in relation to to comet tail.

Keen?
 
Last edited:
So A’Hearn was on the money, mainstreams understanding of what comets are made from is evolving toward mainly rock or mineral organices!

Bore off. There is no rock.
 
I don’t know and neither does the mainstream! :D

Though I suspect, at least for “outgassing”, it will be composition related.

More hydrated minerals more “outgassing”. ;) :thumbsup:

Typical crap response. Hydrated minerals do not outgas. Volatiles outgas. Quit with the lying.
 
So now the cats out of the bag, are you willing to discuss in what context might circuit theory come into play at comets, or at least 67P?

Or is that getting a bit close?

Your above response will have a bearing on discussing further “electrified dusty plasma” and the “ion” tail and its implication on cometary displays!

For instance could this dusty plasma be able to carry a significant current? We see FAC mention in relation to to comet tail.

Keen?

I think I'll take the word of a plasma astrophysicist over an unqualified Velikovskian loon any day of the week. Remember Sol - you are not a plasma physicist, and understand vanishingly little about the subject. And that goes for the rest of the idiots involved with electric universe non-science.
 
Your above response will have a bearing on discussing further “electrified dusty plasma” and the “ion” tail and its implication on cometary displays!

No it won't. There is no such discussion taking place............ Yep, just checked on Google Scholar, and a bunch of conference abstracts. Zilch.
Nothing written on here by ignorant, scientifically illiterate laymen has any bearing whatsoever on real science. Just saying.
 
I don’t know and neither does the mainstream! :D

Though I suspect, at least for “outgassing”, it will be composition related.

More hydrated minerals more “outgassing”. ;) :thumbsup:

You "suspect"? Based on a complete lack of knowledge of which particular aspect of astrophysics this time? Why don't you extract your head from your rectum and actually learn some science? Hmmm? Instead of all this unscientific faith-based crap that you adhere to?

Hydrated Minerals on Asteroids: The Astronomical Record
Rivkin, A. S. et al.
https://ntrs.nasa.gov/archive/nasa/casi.ntrs.nasa.gov/20020046797.pdf

And;

Water in the early solar system: Mid-infrared studies of aqueous alteration on asteroids.
McAdam, M. M. et al.
http://adsabs.harvard.edu/abs/2017DPS....4920811M

This work investigates the distribution of water in the early Solar System by connecting asteroids to carbonaceous chondrite meteorites using spectroscopy...............The mid-infrared spectral region has been shown to be a tool for estimating the degree of alteration of asteroids and meteorites remotely (McAdam et al., 2015)...............We present the estimated degrees of alteration for 73 main belt asteroids using these results. Hydrated minerals appear to be widespread in the main belt and asteroids have variable degrees of alteration. There does not appear to be any relationship between the estimated degree of alteration and size, albedo or heliocentric distance ....... Furthermore, local heterogeneities of water-ice were likely common since asteroids of all sizes and heliocentric distances may exhibit any degree from anhydrous to highly altered. Additionally, asteroids that have been shown to have water-ice on their surfaces (e.g., Takir and Emery, 2012) appear to have hydrated minerals. This indicates that while these asteroids have water-ice, its presence did not prevent aqueous alteration.

^^^And plenty more where they came from.

So, it would appear that asteroids actually have more hydrated minerals than comets.

Now, go back to indagator's question, and tell us why those asteroids are not comets. After all, the chief morons of EU tell us that comets are just "asteroids on elliptical orbits."
 
Last edited:
Two (of many) notable quotes that I have built and sustained my career around ...!

"Mathematics is the key and door to the sciences." --- Galileo Galilei

"Count what is countable, measure what is measurable, and what is not measurable, make measurable." --- Galileo Galilei

FYI - I have been known to change my position on a subject! Not with words, but with NUMBERS! Now, I really do hope those members of the "eu" community that choose to discuss their "ec" and "es" models with me will not disappoint the fine gentleman from Florence, Master Galilei!

Whilst waiting for "20 answers to 20 questions" from Sol88, and anyone else from the "eu" community, I would like to open some holes in a claim made by the "eu brain trust" regarding orbital eccentricity, and the physical mechanism responsible for the charging and discharging of a comet nucleus (my Question #16).

Eccentricity and the electric comet: "It's your model! You fix it!"

Sol88 (or any brave individual from the "eu" community), my understanding, according to "eu" doctrine, is that eccentricity is somehow responsible for building and dissipating charge on the nucleus of a comet. If eccentricity is at all important, please explain the following tabulated discrepancies ....!

Object ID a e i q Q
Astrd: 2001 KD55 3.344 0.6235 9.98 1.26 5.43
Astrd: 2014 LS26 3.364 0.6289 10.86 1.25 5.48
Astrd: 2000 DQ110 3.361 0.6297 58.28 1.25 5.48
Astrd: 2016 RP33 3.334 0.6343 23.04 1.22 5.45
Astrd: 2014 XN40 3.381 0.6349 14.20 1.24 5.53
Astrd: 1986 RA 3.327 0.6358 19.13 1.21 5.44
Comet: 67P/C-G 3.463 0.6414 7.05 1.24 5.69
Astrd: 2014 HW177 3.302 0.6437 13.00 1.18 5.43
Astrd: 1995 QN3 3.300 0.6450 14.79 1.17 5.43
Astrd: 2014 HY196 3.526 0.6561 42.29 1.21 5.84
Astrd: 2016 WX8 3.529 0.6572 13.29 1.21 5.85
Astrd: 2016 LA2 3.565 0.6748 17.43 1.16 5.97
Astrd: 2011 YY28 3.388 0.6765 7.35 1.10 5.68


Columns: a = Semi-major axis (AU), e = Eccentricity, i = Inclination, q = Perihelion (AU), Q = Aphelion (AU). All data extracted from the JPL SBDB. Please note, the tabulated data, above, is a trivial subset of a greater whole.

Sol88? Please explain, in mathematical terms, how eccentricity is physically involved in the charging and discharging of an electric asteroid ... I mean comet? You'll note, I've bracketed a known comet (67P) with 12 randomly selected mainstream asteroids! Help me out here! What "electrical" mechanisms are missing in your eccentricity calculations? Why is only one of 13 objects in this list deemed to be a comet? Why are the 12 mainstream asteroids inert in the same solar e-field as that surrounding 67P?

CONCLUSION: Based on simple observation, eccentricity is NOT involved in the electric comet model!!!

Prove me wrong!!! Present a mathematical model that can predict when a celestial object will become an electric comet!!! This mathematical model must use the 13 data points provided. You may also reference the JPL SBDB and any other sources to gather additional physical parameters and data that may be needed to complete your calculations! Good luck!

Sol88! Can we declare the electric comet dead yet?

Just a reminder of the question (one of many) that Sol deliberately avoids, because he can't answer it.
 
Last edited:
Oi, jt.

What are comets made of?

:D

Trolling trolling trolling rawhide! ;)

This is mainstream science “catching up” to the ELECTRIC COMET!
Thanks Sol88, your post can be used to test what I said.

What is the scientific content of your post? I submit that it is zero.

So what is the point of your post? I submit that is to troll, nothing more.
 
Just a reminder of the question (one of many) that Sol deliberately avoids, because he can't answer it.
I think this is a misunderstanding of what Sol88 is, these days, about.

He is no longer interested in the Talbott/Thornhill Electric Comet model; instead his ELECTRIC COMET MODEL is both very simple and very much nonsense: comets are ROCK, and Kinetic Plasma Processes are important. He’s somewhat equivocal on where the observed water comes from, and occasionally still thinks comet jets are EDM. But that’s pretty much it.

So most of those questions are irrelevant to his highly idiosyncratic idea.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom