The Electric Comet Theory Part IV/SAFIRE

Status
Not open for further replies.
The problem with that paper is that it fails to address how several instruments, using various models, including Earth-based observations, could all be wrong. Neither does it address the success of using those outgassing rates to model the changing rotation period, and the non-gravitational acceleration. Either Patzold et al have underestimated the mass loss, or they are failing to reproduce the amount of dust fallback onto the nucleus. I expect that will be addressed in the future, as various instrument teams look at their data.

The real problem with that paper is it does not gel with jonesdave116s world view.

You and steenkh should talk... :D
 
No, that is not how I have read it. Q is put into the model, and out comes an estimate of how the comet behaves at different distances. this apparently fits well with what we can observe with comets that happen to be at different distances.


Does it have to? The model is not concerned with the nucleus. If the observed production rate, Q, is produced by isolated spots on the planet, they will just produce more than if the production was uniform. And it seems that this is what happens, because the Haser model fits a lot of different comets.

See jonesy comments :thumbsup:

Is Q measured all modeled, steenkh?

:D
 
See jonesy comments :thumbsup:

Is Q measured all modeled, steenkh?

:D

What an idiotic comment! How the hell would you measure every single molecule of gas coming off the comet? Build a gigantic collector around the whole comet?
Give up. Your woo has failed miserably. It failed when thousands of tonnes of ice were ejected at Tempel 1. Not that it was ever scientifically possible, anyway.
 
So the models could be wrong?

Good one...steenkh thinks it’s measured.
 
See jonesy comments :thumbsup:



Is Q measured all modeled, steenkh?



:D

I still vote "measured". Q is the input to the Haser model, not the product. But of course you need some kind of model to tell you that if the coma is of a certain size, and has a certain spectrum and intensity, then it it means that so and so much gas has been produced. In that sense everything is modelled.

As jonesdave116 said, we are not collecting all of the gas to make the measurement.
 
How do you measure an electric field in space?

The most brilliant mathamagicians can’t do it.

But there still there...

Ah, this would be the magical electrical field that allows positive and negative ions to move in the same direction?
You know, the field you keep insisting is there, but that you refuse to explain?

You've found the maths that explain it then? By all means, present them.
 
Nope. They will be close to the mark. Otherwise it must be God providing the non-gravitational acceleration.


Ask steenkh about Omuamua and it’s non gravitational acceleration.

Outgassing ya reckon, righto then. :rolleyes:
 
Ah, this would be the magical electrical field that allows positive and negative ions to move in the same direction?
You know, the field you keep insisting is there, but that you refuse to explain?

You've found the maths that explain it then? By all means, present them.

Beams of electrons(dust)
 
Ask steenkh about Omuamua and it’s non gravitational acceleration.



Outgassing ya reckon, righto then. :rolleyes:

What relevance has Ouamuamua here? We know next to nothing about it. In particular, we do not know anything about its electric properties that could have supported your ideas. So this is a non-starter for you.
 
Beams of electrons(dust)

It is curious how you often reply with something irrelevant when asked a difficult question. In this case you were asked to explain something in your theory that goes against physics, and your reply is something that doesn't not explain how your theory overcomes this problem.

Dust is, by the way, not beams of electrons.
 
Oh but it is.

Arrives in showers or bursts and can be both - and +. Amazing stuff this plasma.

Omuamua, comet or asteroid?

Funny about the acceleration it experienced, ay?


Mainstream coming up donuts, again.
 
Last edited:
It is curious how you often reply with something irrelevant when asked a difficult question. In this case you were asked to explain something in your theory that goes against physics, and your reply is something that doesn't not explain how your theory overcomes this problem.

Dust is, by the way, not beams of electrons.

It’s all interrelated, ‘ol mate.
 
Ah, this would be the magical electrical field that allows positive and negative ions to move in the same direction?
You know, the field you keep insisting is there, but that you refuse to explain?

You've found the maths that explain it then? By all means, present them.

All in a peer reviewed mainstream paper.

Why not read up?

Size of a plasma cloud matters
The polarisation electric field of a small-scale comet ionosphere


Not so simple, is it sport. ;)

Ions, electrons, electric fields, field aligned currents....:thumbsup:
 
Oh but it is.

Arrives in showers or bursts and can be both - and +. Amazing stuff this plasma.

Omuamua, comet or asteroid?

Funny about the acceleration it experienced, ay?


Mainstream coming up donuts, again.

Complete gibberish.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom