The Electric Comet Theory Part IV/SAFIRE

Status
Not open for further replies.
You claim that electric energies at the surface of comets release huge amounts of water from hydrated minerals. Please state the level of energy necessary, and then point to the study where it has been found.

No, your model says huge amounts of water. Our model say pittance.

We’ve been here and done that but for the slow of learning, how do you get Q?

:rolleyes:

Beginners....:blush:
 
No, your model says huge amounts of water. Our model say pittance.

We’ve been here and done that but for the slow of learning, how do you get Q?

:rolleyes:

Beginners....:blush:

And you are lying. Again. The levels of water outgassed are way beyond what your idiotic woo predicts. You cannot explain its presence. Nor that of ice. You failed. Get over it, and stop clogging up this thread with your inane drivel.
 
Oh, you want the peer reviewed ELECTRIC COMET paper, I see.

:rolleyes:

No mainstream peer reviewed paper means no intense surface electric fields, right got it now.

Means something written by people with half a clue about the relevant science. You are not one of those people. Neither are T & T.
 
You claim that electric energies at the surface of comets release huge amounts of water from hydrated minerals. Please state the level of energy necessary, and then point to the study where it has been found.

The expansion velocity is assumed to be constant in the coma, and the radial gas density profile for water was obtained using the standard spherically symmetric Haser distribution.

outgassing rate of the main-belt comet 176P/LINEAR observed with Herschel/HIFI⋆

Generally that’s how you KNOW comets are mostly ice....


Good one that :(
 
How do you measure an electric field in space?

The most brilliant mathamagicians can’t do it.

But there still there...
Is that your claim - that the Electric Comet cannot be proven because electric fields cannot be measured? I thought you had quoted tons of articles claiming to measure exactly that - but far away from the comet.

What about the plasma you wrote about before. That should show up in the presence of a strong electric field, right?

To sum up, you evade direct answers, then you refer to irrelevant articles (I haven't read them, but you did not defend them, so I guess I am right), and finally you claim that anyway, nobody can measure such a field.
 
It looks pretty bad for the Electric comet that there is apparently no electric discharges to free the water from the minerals, but never mind, as you point out, there could pink bunnies intense magical fields that we will never know about. But how do you explain that asteroids on elliptical orbits close to the Sun do not become comets, and a huge number of asteroids that you claim are burnt-out comets come nowhere near the Sun where they could have become comets?

I expect you to come up with some interesting explanation that the present asteroids were previously in elliptical orbits bringing them close to the Sun, and another piece of unmeasurable magic moved them into more circular orbits away from the Sun.
 
No, your model says huge amounts of water. Our model say pittance.
So your model is not in accordance with what has been measured? That is just too bad.

We’ve been here and done that but for the slow of learning, how do you get Q?
I admit I am rather slow in just accepting your words at face value. After all, you have a bad track record here: just look at the ever-growing list of errors and lies that Reality Check is maintaining.

Beginners....:blush:
Yeah, right.
 
outgassing rate of the main-belt comet 176P/LINEAR observed with Herschel/HIFI⋆

Generally that’s how you KNOW comets are mostly ice....


Good one that :(

Liar. Nobody is saying comets are mostly ice. That is a strawman of your own making. You are a pathological liar, as this lie has been pointed out to you several times as being a lie, with references to the literature. Stop lying.
 
So your model is not in accordance with what has been measured? That is just too bad.


I admit I am rather slow in just accepting your words at face value. After all, you have a bad track record here: just look at the ever-growing list of errors and lies that Reality Check is maintaining.


Yeah, right.


Don’t let me tell you, go read a peer reviewed paper...

From the discussion above it seems to be clear that the lost gas mass was strongly overestimated by the gas instruments and these teams work all on more realistic estimates.

The Nucleus of Comet 67P/ChuryumovGerasimenko - Part I: The Global View – nucleus mass, mass loss, porosity and implications

and, not so unrealistically, the nucleus would be a highly porous stony agglomerate, essentially devoid of volitiles.

But it seems posters here don’t like this paper. :blush:
 
Liar. Nobody is saying comets are mostly ice. That is a strawman of your own making. You are a pathological liar, as this lie has been pointed out to you several times as being a lie, with references to the literature. Stop lying.


Comets are mostly what, jonesdave116?

See my signature and the paper The Nucleus of Comet 67P/ChuryumovGerasimenko - Part I: The Global View – nucleus mass, mass loss, porosity and implications

The implications are comets are NOT mostly ice!

Comets are
not so unrealistically, the nucleus would be a highly porous stony agglomerate, essentially devoid of volitiles.


So I’m agreeing with you and Martin Pätzold.

Comets are mostly NOT ice!
:D
 
Last edited:
We’ve been here and done that but for the slow of learning, how do you get Q?
I admit I am rather slow in just accepting your words at face value.
I admit that I misunderstood your comment here, because I thought that you meant "cue", and it did not make sense.

I had forgotten that Q is part of the Haser model. The right answer is that Q is the production rate of the parent, in other words it is measured.
 
outgassing rate of the main-belt comet 176P/LINEAR observed with Herschel/HIFI⋆

Generally that’s how you KNOW comets are mostly ice....


Good one that :(
Why the sad smiley? I think it is good that we have a model that fits well with observed outgassing.
 
I admit that I misunderstood your comment here, because I thought that you meant "cue", and it did not make sense.

I had forgotten that Q is part of the Haser model. The right answer is that Q is the production rate of the parent, in other words it is measured.

Modeled not measured.

Does the nucleus outgass spherically?

:rolleyes:
 
Don’t let me tell you, go read a peer reviewed paper...

The Nucleus of Comet 67P/ChuryumovGerasimenko - Part I: The Global View – nucleus mass, mass loss, porosity and implications

But it seems posters here don’t like this paper. :blush:
I do not mind that paper. New insights are always interesting. But I also cannot see any reference in it to intense electrical fields that produce the observed gases. How come?

As I have said many times before, a failure of conventional theories does not imply a success for your ideas.
 
Comets are mostly what, jonesdave116?

See my signature and the paper The Nucleus of Comet 67P/ChuryumovGerasimenko - Part I: The Global View – nucleus mass, mass loss, porosity and implications

The implications are comets are NOT mostly ice!

Comets are


So I’m agreeing with you and Martin Pätzold.

Comets are mostly NOT ice!
:D

You are lying again. He said that was unrealistic in the case of 67P. Why do you lie so much?
 
Modeled not measured.
No, that is not how I have read it. Q is put into the model, and out comes an estimate of how the comet behaves at different distances. this apparently fits well with what we can observe with comets that happen to be at different distances.

Does the nucleus outgass spherically?

:rolleyes:
Does it have to? The model is not concerned with the nucleus. If the observed production rate, Q, is produced by isolated spots on the planet, they will just produce more than if the production was uniform. And it seems that this is what happens, because the Haser model fits a lot of different comets.
 
I do not mind that paper. New insights are always interesting. But I also cannot see any reference in it to intense electrical fields that produce the observed gases. How come?

As I have said many times before, a failure of conventional theories does not imply a success for your ideas.

The problem with that paper is that it fails to address how several instruments, using various models, including Earth-based observations, could all be wrong. Neither does it address the success of using those outgassing rates to model the changing rotation period, and the non-gravitational acceleration. Either Patzold et al have underestimated the mass loss, or they are failing to reproduce the amount of dust fallback onto the nucleus. I expect that will be addressed in the future, as various instrument teams look at their data.
 
No, that is not how I have read it. Q is put into the model, and out comes an estimate of how the comet behaves at different distances. this apparently fits well with what we can observe with comets that happen to be at different distances.


Does it have to? The model is not concerned with the nucleus. If the observed production rate, Q, is produced by isolated spots on the planet, they will just produce more than if the production was uniform. And it seems that this is what happens, because the Haser model fits a lot of different comets.

The Haser model is fine when viewing the whole coma, such as from Earth-based observation. However, Sol likes to lie about the models being used in the case of 67P;

Comet 67P/CG's water coma exhibits a complex, non-uniform distribution that varies in time due to both the rotation of the comet as well as the orbital motion of the comet. While Rosetta presents a large step forward in sampling that distribution, it cannot measure the water distribution at all locations at all times. For this reason, the interpretation of Rosetta measurements requires the use of models. These models can be as simple as assuming a spherically symmetric, uniformly expanding coma (Haser 1957) or as sophisticated as Direct Simulation Monte Carlo (DSMC) models of the 3D neutral gas coma using an accurate shape model (Bieler et al. 2015; Fougere et al. 2016a,b). The value of a simple, analytic model such as Haser (1957) is both its ease of application as well as the ease with which intuition can be applied to its use. However, with a shape as complex as that of the nucleus of 67P/CG, it is clear that a simple spherical model is not sufficient. The DSMC models of Bieler et al. (2015) and Fougere et al. (2016a,b) are a major step forward because they model the water production of 67P/CG using an accurate shape model, accurately calculated solar illumination (including shadowing) and physically meaningful modelling techniques.

From section 2 of;

Evolution of water production of 67P/Churyumov–Gerasimenko: an empirical model and a multi-instrument study
Hansen, K. C. et al.
https://academic.oup.com/mnras/article/462/Suppl_1/S491/2672995
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom