The Electric Comet Theory Part IV/SAFIRE

Status
Not open for further replies.
The usual lies, delusions, etc. already addressed over the last 10 years

The usual lies, delusions, etc. already addressed over the last 10 years. This post is one or more of
 
The usual lies, delusions, etc. already addressed over the last 10 years

Nothing to do with any post.
The usual lies, delusions, etc. already addressed over the last 10 years. This post is one or more of
 
Was that your explanation of how non-existent charge separation at the surface level of the comet can provide the high energies needed for releasing water from hydrated minerals?


Very much like here...New NASA model gives glimpse into the invisible world of electric asteroids

The model also can be used to predict interactions between an asteroid and the spacecraft itself. "One of the reasons we're visiting asteroids is because they are relatively pristine remnants from the formation of the solar system, so they give clues as to how the planets formed and life originated," says Farrell. "However, spacecraft release gases (like water) that ionize, and these spacecraft-emitted ions likely will contaminate the surfaces of the asteroids we want to study. This new asteroid model will allow us to estimate the degree of ion collection and contamination over various regions." Farrell is the Principal Investigator of one of SSERVI's nine teams called the Dynamic Response of the Environment at Asteroids, the Moon, and moons of Mars (DREAM2), which provided a portion of the funding to develop the model.

This is the physics you are looking for Steenkh!

Model has never been applied to comets by the mainstream because it's known that they are dirtysnowballs.

Mostly ice sublimating when they get close to the sun.


So what the ELECTRIC UNIVERSE is saying is the SAME physics is in play at comets, just FAR more intense.

Intense enough to cause microscopic EDM at the surface.
 
The usual lies, delusions, etc. already addressed over the last 10 years

Sol88 lies yet again about mainstream science. New NASA model gives glimpse into the invisible world of electric asteroids is not to do with his electric comet insanity. This is the known physics that airless bodes (moons and asteroids) - which does not include comets with their coma preventing the solar wind from reaching their surface - interact with the solar wind and become electrically charged.

Sol88 lies yet again about the electric comet insanity which is not interaction of the solar wind with airless bodies.
Sol88 lies yet again about real comets since he has been told many times that it is comet coma makes this model invalid for comets.
Sol88 lies yet again about real comets since he has cited many papers that state comets are not asteroids.
Sol88 lies yet again about the electric comet insanity which has no microscopic EDM. The deluded authors of the electric comet insanity have massive EDM blasting away the surface of comets and forming the macroscopic features that their demented imaginations make up.
Sol88 emphasizes the electric comet insanity yet again. This is a 2014 paper about improvement to previous models. If this was part of the electric comet insanity then the authors have been abysmally ignorant by not applying the model for maybe decades!

The usual lies, delusions, etc. already addressed over the last 10 years. This post is one or more of
 
Last edited:
Very much like here...New NASA model gives glimpse into the invisible world of electric asteroids



This is the physics you are looking for Steenkh!

Model has never been applied to comets by the mainstream because it's known that they are dirtysnowballs.

Mostly ice sublimating when they get close to the sun.


So what the ELECTRIC UNIVERSE is saying is the SAME physics is in play at comets, just FAR more intense.

Intense enough to cause microscopic EDM at the surface.

Another lie. Please point out where Thornhill states this.
 
Very much like here...New NASA model gives glimpse into the invisible world of electric asteroids



This is the physics you are looking for Steenkh!
Sorry, you lost me there. There is certainly physics, but about contamination, so it has nothing to do with the question I asked you. Would you care to try again?



So what the ELECTRIC UNIVERSE is saying is the SAME physics is in play at comets, just FAR more intense.



Intense enough to cause microscopic EDM at the surface.

Where did you find that in the quote? And why has these intense electric fields never been observed where they are needed, at the surface?
 
So the same process is involved for both comets and asteroids and it’s NOT sublimation.
 
The usual lies, delusions, etc. already addressed over the last 10 years

The usual lies, delusions, etc. already addressed over the last 10 years. This post is one or more of
 
The usual lies, delusions, etc. already addressed over the last 10 years

PHP:
An insane lie of no sublimation on comets when he acknowledges comets have ices which physics says has to sublimate and we observe the products of that sublimation.
An insane lie of no sublimation on asteroids when he has cited papers stating some of the extremely rare comet-like activity seen for asteroids can be ices sublimating.

The usual lies, delusions, etc. already addressed over the last 10 years. This post is one or more of
 
The usual lies, delusions, etc. already addressed over the last 10 years

Hope this is enough physics for you steenkh?
A deluded lie that Sol88 has presented any physics about the electric comet insanity.

The usual lies, delusions, etc. already addressed over the last 10 years. This post is one or more of
 
Some real science since the subject of `Oumuamua has popped up yet again.
At least 1 astronomer has doubts that the non-gravitational acceleration is as large as reported.
Evidence against non-gravitational acceleration of 1I/2017 U1 `Oumuamua
Micheli, et al. (2018) reported that a seven-parameter fit to the orbit of 1I/2017 U1 `Oumuamua indicated a non-gravitational acceleration in the anti-Solar direction, and attributed it to recoil from comet-like outgassing. The implied gas to dust ratio is at least 100 times greater than that of known Solar System comets. The reported collapse of the scatter of nearly contemporaneous coordinate residuals upon inclusion of the non-gravitational term in the orbital fits is difficult to understand. There are grounds for skepticism.

Another astronomer argues that the hypothesis of outgassing for the non-gravitational acceleration does not work. And gives evidence against the above paper.
Outgassing As Trigger of 1I/`Oumuamua's Nongravitational Acceleration: Could This Hypothesis Work at All?
The question of what triggered the nongravitational acceleration of 1I/`Oumuamua continues to attract researchers' attention. The absence of any signs of activity notwithstanding, the prevailing notion is that the acceleration of the stellar, cigar-like object was prompted by outgassing. However, the Spitzer Space Telescope's failure to detect `Oumuamua not only ruled out the CO_2 and/or CO driven activity (Trilling et al. 2018), but made the cigar shape incompatible with the optical observations. Choice of water ice as the source of outgassing is shown to be flawed as well: (i) the water sublimation law is demonstrably inconsistent with the observed variations in the nongravitational acceleration derived by Micheli et al. (2018), the point that should have been assertively highlighted; and (ii) an upper limit of the production rate of water is estimated at as low as 4 x 10^(23) molecules s^(-1), requiring that, at most, only a small area of the surface be active, in which case the conservation of momentum law is satisfied only when `Oumuamua's bulk density is extremely low, <0.001 g cm^(-3), reminiscent of the formerly proposed scenario with `Oumuamua as a fragment of a dwarf interstellar comet disintegrating near perihelion, with the acceleration driven by solar radiation pressure (Sekanina 2019a) and no need for activity at all. This conclusion is possible thanks to the high quality of astrometry and Micheli et al.'s orbital analysis, whose results were confirmed by the computations of other authors.
CO2 or CO ices sublimating is ruled out by the Spitzer Space Telescope's failure to detect `Oumuamua. The original detection of the non-gravitational acceleration by Micheli et al. (2018) has variations with heliocentric distance r that contradict the models for water ice sublimation. The paper has additional arguments against water ice outgassing. Add no activity seen and it is unlikely that outgassing caused the acceleration. A viable physical mechanism is then solar radiation pressure.
 
Intense surface electric fields, charged dust...etc etc.

I ask a fairly simple question, and you evade to answer, now for the second time. Are any of the bunch of papers that you threw at me addressing the question that was about measuring energies at the surface high enough to release water from hydrated minerals? I only see something about charged dust that in my layman's view involve much lower energies.

So the same process is involved for both comets and asteroids and it’s NOT sublimation.

What process? You have not presented evidence for any process.

Hope this is enough physics for you steenkh?

I'll tell you when I see it.
 
Oh, you want the peer reviewed ELECTRIC COMET paper, I see.

:rolleyes:

No mainstream peer reviewed paper means no intense surface electric fields, right got it now.
 
I ask a fairly simple question, and you evade to answer, now for the second time. Are any of the bunch of papers that you threw at me addressing the question that was about measuring energies at the surface high enough to release water from hydrated minerals? I only see something about charged dust that in my layman's view involve much lower energies.



What process? You have not presented evidence for any process.



I'll tell you when I see it.

What’s high energy for you?

10v 100v 1000v?

Couple volts positive bang up hard against ‘00kv negative?

You do know what plasma is, don’t you?
 
What’s high energy for you?



10v 100v 1000v?

You claim that electric energies at the surface of comets release huge amounts of water from hydrated minerals. Please state the level of energy necessary, and then point to the study where it has been found.
 
No mainstream peer reviewed paper means no intense surface electric fields, right got it now.
I was not aware that you felt that desperate.

time and again, people who know this stuff much better than me - and apparently you - have shown that these intense fields would have been measured, if they existed.

You could just as well have written "No mainstream peer reviewed paper means no pink bunnies, right got it now."
 
How do you measure an electric field in space?

The most brilliant mathamagicians can’t do it.

But there still there...
 

None of which has anything to do with your failed woo. If these impossible, high temperature EDM (lol) woo were happening, it would be seen. It isn't. Including from Philae, which detected water, but no electric woo. And every single asteroid would be outgassing like comets. They aren't. You are making stuff up in order not to admit that your religion has been shown to be a false belief.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom