The Electric Comet Theory Part IV/SAFIRE

Status
Not open for further replies.
None of which is anything to do with your scientifically impossible, failed woo. No science, no mechanisms, no evidence.


Ok boss, whatever ya reckon. ;)

Context. The cometary ionosphere is immersed in fast flowing solar wind. A polarisation electric field may arise for comets much smaller than the gyroradius of pickup ions because ions and electrons respond differently to the solar wind electric field.

Aims. A situation similar to that found at a low activity comet has been modelled for barium releases in the Earth’s ionosphere. We aim to use such a model and apply it to the case of comet 67P Churyumov-Gerasimenko, the target of the Rosetta mission. We aim to explain the significant tailward acceleration of cometary ions through the modelled electric field.

Methods. We obtained analytical solutions for the polarisation electric field of the comet ionosphere using a simplified geometry. This geometry is applicable to the comet in the inner part of the coma as the plasma density integrated along the magnetic field line remains rather constant. We studied the range of parameters for which a significant tailward electric field is obtained and compare this with the parameter range observed.

Results. Observations of the local plasma density and magnetic field strength show that the parameter range of the observations agree very well with a significant polarisation electric field shielding the inner part of the coma from the solar wind electric field.

Conclusions. The same process gives rise to a tailward directed electric field with a strength of the order of 10% of the solar wind electric field.Using a simple cloud model we have shown that the polarisation electric field, which arises because of the small size of the comet ionosphere as compared to the pick up ion gyroradius, can explain the observed significant tailward acceleration of cometary ions and is consistent with the observed lack of influence of the solar wind electric field in the inner coma.

Tell me more, because I’m a numpty, about this polarisation electric field.

:boggled:

As a result, the surface gets positively charged. Above the nuclear surface a photoelectron plasma sheath forms in which the ejected dust grains collect electrostatic charges and become responsive to the electric field in the sheath

Is this ambipolar electric field or the polarisation electric field?
 
Last edited:
Oh but it is.
You live in a strange world where dust and electrons are the same ...

Arrives in showers or bursts and can be both - and +. Amazing stuff this plasma.
I am sure it is amazing, but I am equally sure that positive ions do not move towards a positive charge, whereas negative ions do, so you need to bring some evidence of this new physics if you want to convince me.

Omuamua, comet or asteroid?

Funny about the acceleration it experienced, ay?
Why?
 
What’s the difference between an active asteroid, comet, asteroid and extinct comet?

Good luck...:rolleyes:
I've got a better one: in what way are active asteroids, comets, and extinct comets the same?

In the context of this thread, the answer is "they all behave in ways that are inconsistent with The Electric Comet Model". :p
 
Ok boss, whatever ya reckon. ;)



Tell me more, because I’m a numpty, about this polarisation electric field.

:boggled:



Is this ambipolar electric field or the polarisation electric field?

It has nothing to do with your failed woo. If it had, you'd have explained it by now.
 
As a result, the surface gets positively charged. Above the nuclear surface a photoelectron plasma sheath forms in which the ejected dust grains collect electrostatic charges and become responsive to the electric field in the sheath

Is another deliberate piece of obfuscation, and lying by omission. That is from;

Charged dust dynamics above the surface of a comet far from the Sun
Juhasz, A. & Szego, K. (1998)
https://agupubs.onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/pdf/10.1029/97JA02991

In it, they clearly state;

We investigate the dynamics of small dust particles ejected from the sunlit side of the nucleus of a comet far from the Sun. The motion of these particles is determined by gravity, electromagnetic forces, and solar radiation pressure. The nucleus is not shielded from either the solar wind or the solar UV radiation; therefore the surface of the nucleus absorbs electrons and protons and emits photo-electrons. As a result, the surface gets positively charged.............................................................................. As the comet approaches the Sun, the solar wind does not reach the surface any more, and only the solar UV radiation charges both the surface and the dust particles. However, as the surface activity increases, this very likely washes away the more subtle effects of charging.

At closer distances from the Sun, the solar wind is not reaching the surface.

If you are going to lie and obfuscate, then don't make it so easy for others to discover your lies and obfuscation.
 
Last edited:
Yawn....


Do try and keep up champ...

Results. Observations of the local plasma density and magnetic field strength show that the parameter range of the observations agree very well with a significant polarisation electric field shielding the inner part of the coma from the solar wind electric field.

Conclusions. The same process gives rise to a tailward directed electric field with a strength of the order of 10% of the solar wind electric field.Using a simple cloud model we have shown that the polarisation electric field, which arises because of the small size of the comet ionosphere as compared to the pick up ion gyroradius, can explain the observed significant tailward acceleration of cometary ions and is consistent with the observed lack of influence of the solar wind electric field in the inner coma.

Size of a plasma cloud matters

The polarisation electric field of a small-scale comet ionosphere


Been there done that.

Diamagnetic cavity someone once said.

Next, please.
 
Last edited:
In summary, the simplistic model of dust production resulting from gas drag overcoming gravity is no longer tenable. However, the dominant mechanism is still unclear.

Cometary Dust

Wonder what it could be????
 
You live in a strange world where dust and electrons are the same ...


Your not reality check in n disguise?

The fundamental physics of charged cometary dust has been studied for a long time (Mendis and Horányi 2013). Dust charging is a delicate interplay between several currents, including electron and ion collection currents from the surrounding plasma, ultraviolet induced photoelectron currents, secondary electron emission (due to energetic ion and/or electron bombardment), thermo-ionic emission, field emission (due to large surface fields), etc. As arule of thumb,a dust particle collects about 700 extra electrons per unit particle volume equivalent radius (measured in µm) and unit electric potential difference between the particle surface and the surrounding plasma (measured in V).


You been taking confabulation lessons from reality check, steenkh?


You do know what plasma is? So I’m sure I don’t have to tell a smart cookie like you about dusty plasma, do I?

Where are all these electrons comming from, steenkh?

Before you shoot your mouth of in a confabulation of facts.
 
Last edited:
You live in a strange world where dust and electrons are the same ...


I am sure it is amazing, but I am equally sure that positive ions do not move towards a positive charge, whereas negative ions do, so you need to bring some evidence of this new physics if you want to convince me.


Why?

DUSTY PLASMA

We can think of dust particles as swimmers in a sea of electrons and ions – negative and positive charges, respectively. Electrons are so tiny compared to the dust that they easily stick to the particles’ surfaces. When that happens, a dust particle will become negatively charged.

Because like charges repel each other, that bit of dust will now feel a push from other negatively charged dust particles. Likewise, that same negatively charged dust particle will feel a pull by the positive ions in the plasma, because charges of opposite signs attract each other. The net result is that dust particles will be pushed and pulled in many different directions, making them move in complex and fascinating ways.
LINK


:D


How many extra electrons is the charged dust from the nucleus of 67P carrying?

:thumbsup:
 
Your not reality check in n disguise?
You flatter me.


You do know what plasma is? So I’m sure I don’t have to tell a smart cookie like you about dusty plasma, do I?
Absolutely fascinating, but I cannot see anything related to your claim that an electron stream and charged dust is the same.

Where are all these electrons comming from, steenkh?

No. Can you tell me?
 
How many different types of electric field are in play at comets?

Probably a lot, but are they were they should be, and at the right strength to support the Electric Comet?

This has always been your Achilles heel, that electromagnetism exists, and can do wonderful things, but still does not appear to support your ideas.
 
Probably a lot, but are they were they should be, and at the right strength to support the Electric Comet?

This has always been your Achilles heel, that electromagnetism exists, and can do wonderful things, but still does not appear to support your ideas.

Absolutely nailed cobber!

Not my Achilles heel, mainstreams. :D

You should stick with sublimation, safer.

Find me a paper we’re the preeminent scientist up till Rosetta and very unfortunately after his passing, mentions electric fields and charged dust.

Then read them and get back to me when you can, cheers
 
Interesting stuff, but is it relevant for the Electric Comet?


Ummmmmm...... lord stone the flipping crows!

You not real learned, ya cob?

They are charged,fragmented,and decelerated by the spacecraft negative potential and enter GIADA in showers off fragments at speeds<1ms−1(Fulleetal.,2015a).

The analysis of compact particle speeds versus cometocentric distance shows that in the dust acceleration region, the dust speed increases from 2.5 ± 0.8 ms−1 at 10 km to 4.3 ± 0.9 ms−1 at 30 km.

GIADA: shining a light on the monitoring of the comet dust production from the nucleus of 67P/Churyumov-Gerasimenko


And you are having trouble interpreting the data?
 
Maybe you should then bone up on, The root of a comet tail –Rosetta ion observations at comet 67P/Churyumov–Gerasimenko

Skip straight to
Fig.7
Schematics of the three terms of the total electric field

We could keep going?

But if you are looking for the paper where they put that all together, you’d be disappointed. Sorry.

Seems pretty straight forward to me.

But I’m a simpleton obviously. :blush:
 
Maybe you should then bone up on, The root of a comet tail –Rosetta ion observations at comet 67P/Churyumov–Gerasimenko

Skip straight to
Fig.7
Schematics of the three terms of the total electric field

We could keep going?

But if you are looking for the paper where they put that all together, you’d be disappointed. Sorry.

Seems pretty straight forward to me.

But I’m a simpleton obviously. :blush:
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom