The Electric Comet Theory Part IV/SAFIRE

Status
Not open for further replies.
Resolution is unable to resolve microscopic spark erosion.

You still thinking giant lightning bolts from space or some version of it. That removes asteroid and comet from planetary surface not dust form comet surfaces.

The fakestream are not looking for this so remain ignorant.

Simple.

Lol. Sol's religious beliefs take him off into la-la land again. Go take your meds, and have a lie down. Leave science to those that have a reasonable understanding of it.
 
Charge separation and electric fields. :D

Do we charge separation at 67p?

Nope. Nothing beyond the Debye length. By definition. And how is that causing EDM (lol) woo? And non-existent discharges? And non-existent rock? Address your failures. I suggest psychiatric help. Science is not going to help, as you have clue zero about any of it. Just like your high priests. Eh?
 
So, steenkh, why not comets?

Why not what comets? You were asked about comets, and you answer about asteroids, and asteroids have practically no water, even they have more than expected (0.05%). Considering that you think that comets and asteroids are the same, one wonders why there is so much less water on asteroids?
 
Last edited:
You tell me why they are not found on comets. Or why the electric fields on asteroids do not cause asteroids to send out streams of ice like comets do.

He can't. Science really is not Sol's strong point. He needs to rely on other wooists to tell him what to say.
 
Why not what comets? You were asked about comets, and you answer about asteroids, and asteroids have practically no water, even they have more than expected (0.05%). Considering that you think that comets and asteroids are the same, one wonders why there is so much less water on asteroids?

Trust me, steenkh, you could go back at least a decade and a half, and none of these clowns have been able to answer that. They don't do science.
 
Trust me, steenkh, you could go back at least a decade and a half, and none of these clowns have been able to answer that. They don't do science.


Yawn...

Asteroids and comets are a continuum.

Dead comets are asteroids and active asteroids are comets.

Mainstream has no definition so can make up whatever they want.

This has been discussed a few pages back.

You have read Asteroid–comet continuum objects in the solarsystem?
 
Asteroids and comets are a continuum.



Dead comets are asteroids and active asteroids are comets.

It seems that asteroids that you claim are dead comets mainly have orbits where live comets are inactive. Did they die of boredom?


[/QUOTE]Mainstream has no definition so can make up whatever they want.[/QUOTE]

And Electric Comet has no physics, which allows you to make up whatever you want?
 
Short cut the whole argument.

The physics is charge seperation of the solar wind plasma and cometary plasma, including the charged dust.

The plasma process, more or less “zaps” the visually obvious rock to charged dust and releasing ALL the water trapped in side. Mainstream interpretation is sublimation, this has shown to quite inadequate.

Can’t believe how bleed’n simple the physics is, really.

Do you believe there is an ambipolar electric field at comet 67P?
 
Short cut the whole argument.

The physics is charge seperation of the solar wind plasma and cometary plasma, including the charged dust.
It has been my impression that there is no charge separation close to the surface where you need it. Care to explain?

Can’t believe how bleed’n simple the physics is, really.
Could it be your problem that you do not understand the complexities of real physics?
 
Short cut the whole argument.

The physics is charge seperation of the solar wind plasma and cometary plasma, including the charged dust.

The plasma process, more or less “zaps” the visually obvious rock to charged dust and releasing ALL the water trapped in side. Mainstream interpretation is sublimation, this has shown to quite inadequate.

Can’t believe how bleed’n simple the physics is, really.

Do you believe there is an ambipolar electric field at comet 67P?

Talking out of your backside is not going to alter the fact that your woo has failed. Is it? What have ambipolar fields got to do with anything? I keep asking, you keep avoiding. And how many times do you need to be told that you cannot release water from hydrated minerals without a large heat source, which you haven't got and which is not seen.
Stop making crap up.
 
The main problem here is that, by definition, anybody that believes this electric comet woo is scientifically illiterate. Trying to discuss science with such people is, therefore, a waste of time. They are too ignorant to realise how ignorant they are.
 
Was that your explanation of how non-existent charge separation at the surface level of the comet can provide the high energies needed for releasing water from hydrated minerals?

You weren't expecting any science, were you? :)
 
The usual lies, delusions, etc. already addressed over the last 10 years

The usual lies, delusions, etc. already addressed over the last 10 years. This post is one or more of
 
The usual lies, delusions, etc. already addressed over the last 10 years.

The usual lies, delusions, etc. already addressed over the last 10 years. This post is one or more of
For others: This is Sol88's persistent and irrelevant insanity about "Whipple's model" of the 1950's being the modern mainstream scientific model of comets. Scientific models (unlike the insane dogma of the electric comet) are continuously updated as more empirical evidence is gathered. 70 years of empirical evidence and scientific progress has resulted in a more complete and better working model.
The other rational posters here agree that as more empirical evidence is gathered the working mainstream model of comets will be updated.
 
The usual lies, delusions, etc. already addressed over the last 10 years

The usual lies, delusions, etc. already addressed over the last 10 years. This post is one or more of
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom